StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Descartes' Argument from Illusion - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
As the paper "Descartes' Argument from Illusion" outlines, Descartes argued that real knowledge rested in the mind and not in the senses. There was no definite difference between what happens when one dreams and when he is awake. In the present, it is possible that he is dreaming, yet he is awake. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
Descartes Argument from Illusion
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Descartes' Argument from Illusion"

Epistemology relates to the theory or study of nature and grounds of knowledge with reference to its limits and validity. Empiricism denotes a practice of basing ideas and theories on testing and experience. Empiricists believe that, when it comes to the nature of the world beyond one’s minds, the experience is the sole source of information (Dancy, Ernest, and Matthias 38). They define every concept by the use of reason and fact. The main argument is on the basis that dreams and reality are very similar.

Epistemology reiterates the fact that most of the human knowledge comes from their senses, and through perception. It argues that the way individuals perceive the world is determined by their understanding of things around them. It points out the importance of considering the evidence before believing anything.Descartes argues with the question asking how many times, when fast asleep, he is convinced that he is sitting by the fire when in reality he was lying undressed in bed. He argues that there are no signs to distinguish the difference between being asleep from being awake.

He says that dreams can be vivid and very convincing. Moreover, he says that one may be dazed, and at that time believing that he is asleep. There is the argument that many times human senses deceive them, and, in fact, those things that they may believe to recognize may be false. There is the notion that dreams borrow from the real world. Descartes argues that though we do not experience these dreams with our real body parts, eyes, limbs, and mouths, they still contain elements that are indeed real.

Some of the elements in question are substance, shape, number, and time. He urges us not to be skeptical of our reasoning of dreams because it may cause us to doubt the world and how we view it, including everything around us.Sometimes it is indeed confusing when trying to differentiate dreams from reality. This is why we experience countless déjà vu moments in our lifetimes. It has also been strongly argued by many who have dreamt about certain situations or occurrences which eventually have come to pass.

It is difficult to determine sometimes how many illusions we had which, in fact, real situations were occurring in actual time. It must be argued again that many times one could have undergone situations where he thought he was dreaming, but abruptly he snaps out of the daze and realize that it was indeed a reality and not an illusion. This goes on to validate Descartes's theory. Many times it is indeed very difficult to distinguish between dreams and illusions. In addition, it is indeed difficult to validate whether or not certain occurrences happened or whether they were part of a fantasy that we encountered.

Descartes’ argument has much emphasis when we connect it to many human experiences.The hero in the movie déjà vu illustrates the fact that we use only a fraction of our brain’s potential when we are awake. He goes further to explain that when we are asleep, our mind can do almost anything. He explains how when dreaming, we create and perceive our world simultaneously, and that our mind does this so well that we are not even aware that it is happening. The mind takes over this whole process by taking over the creative part.

Dreams feel real when we are in them when we wake up, this is when we feel that there is something strange. He goes on to assert that we never remember the beginning of a dream; however, we get ourselves trapped in the middle of it. The director used slow-motion technology as real-life occurred within the dream. There were explosions occurring in slow motion, still time, as both of them were busy in conversation.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(ESSAY ON Descartes' Argument from Illusion, n.d.)
ESSAY ON Descartes' Argument from Illusion. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1870871-essay-on-descartesapos-argument-from-illusion
(ESSAY ON Descartes&Apos; Argument from Illusion)
ESSAY ON Descartes&Apos; Argument from Illusion. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1870871-essay-on-descartesapos-argument-from-illusion.
“ESSAY ON Descartes&Apos; Argument from Illusion”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1870871-essay-on-descartesapos-argument-from-illusion.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Descartes' Argument from Illusion

Pholosophy Questions

Q: Is descartes' argument against trusting the senses a good one?... The fact that Descartes takes the degree of doubt to another level stems from his idea to even doubt one's basic senses of perception upon which all knowledge is based.... Dreams feel real until we are woken up from them so who is to decide if the present situation is not a dream but in fact reality.... This is the argument upon which Descartes doubts the authenticity of his senses; However, Rene further presents another side of the picture by drawing an analogy from a painting....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

First Term Paper - Why I know I am not in the Matrix

However, rather than letting this be a determination for the fact that all reality is subjective and could possibly be a clever illusion on the part of a twisted higher power, Descartes determined that the best approach to this question of reality was the famous quote, “I think therefore I am”....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

The Comparison of the Matrix with the Readings from Plato and Descartes

hellip; “In "Matrix," on the other hand, there aren't flesh-and-blood creatures behind the illusion--only a computer program that can think, and learn” In the same way, the Descartes also poses the question regarding the question as to the illusion of the existence of the world which is the theme in the Movie “Matrix”.... Which is better: the harshness of reality or the “ignorance is bliss” of illusion?... Reality is good, but when the harshness comes into play it is better to resort to the “ignorance of bliss” illusion....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Human Life and the Basic Human Values

It matters a lot if the world does not exist and everything becomes an illusion.... Von Horton gained from his ignorance and confusion the insight that man can seek himself.... The author of the following essay entitled 'Human Life and the Basic Human Values' focuses on the formulation of appropriate premises which is important in philosophy....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Evaluate an argument from the Bouwsma reading

Thus, if we are able to detect deception through the five senses, we are not deceived about the world around us, but if we are not able to detect Evaluate an argument from the Bouwsma Reading The first argument s that if we are deceived about the world around us, either we are able to detect the deception through the five senses, or we are not able to detect the deception through the five senses.... Bouwsma (144) gives an example of Tom, who experiences the illusion that everything around him is just paper....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Describe and contrast two psychological/cognitive models of consciousness with supporting evidence

Phenomenal consciousness is a raw idiosyncratic feeling or visual illusion while access consciousness characterizes reason and available information.... Shoemaker (1982) presents a similar argument, spelling out that different human consciousness determines naïve perceptions that arise from colour.... 2005, Consciousness: converging insights from connectionist modelling and neuroscience.... Jackson (1986) presents an interesting argument that one cannot sense a colour if they have not seen the colour before....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Short Paper on Descartes

Retrieved from http://www.... Although Descartes explanation manages to relate the happenings in the dream land with those in the actual world, it is apparent his argument against the pinch test does not rule out the pinch test as the best test for the awake of a person.... In conclusion, Descartes double standard argument for the pinch test is in relation to his association of the dream land incidents with the real incidents....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Paradoxes of Philosophy

To pass for that, then the mythical self should be stemming from one impression that gives rise to every real idea and the impression should manifest consistency in our lives.... It is from this background that Hume concludes that there is no self because the impressions prevalent in life are not at all consistent.... He observes that we are able to divert our attention from the things that we do and focus that attention on watching ourselves do the same things....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us