StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Just War/Military Ethics - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The theory of just war dates back to the works of early Greek and Roman philosophers, Aristotle and Cicero who brought about the discussion on…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
Just War/Military Ethics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Just War/Military Ethics"

Just War Just War Just war in the criteria by which nations lawfully and ethically qualify war to be a correct of action for particular reasons. The theory of just war dates back to the works of early Greek and Roman philosophers, Aristotle and Cicero who brought about the discussion on justifiable reasons to take life or go to war with proper rules of conduct. the idea have deep roots in the religious doctrines of Abrahamic origin (Islam, Judaism and Christianity) which tries to harmonize the fact that killing is sin but at some cases it may be purposeful to take human life (Walzer, 2008). . This paper seek to harmonize the different principles that qualifies a war to be just.

Just war as a theory have open boundaries of interpretation, there exist as many understanding of the concept of the concept as there are philosophers pursuing the same. not everyone have the same view towards the fruits of just war, some argue that killing is wrong no matter the purpose for which life is taken, they believe that force and killing is one way a government can enforce its interest (Orend, 2009) .The first principle considered in many ancient literature to justify a war is the just ad bellum (justifications for war to be begin); it deals with what it takes for one to go into war.

The second principle is just in bello (justice in the cause of war), which concern itself with conduct of two parties at war. The third principle of just war is just post bellum (justice after an event of war), which considers what is just to be done after the war has ended (Walzer, 2008).According to early Christians, killing was treated as a sin and as such, no Christians were allowed to kill, but as more Romans converted to Christianity, the question arose whether is it possible for a Roman soldier to be a Christian considering their chances of taking lives.

This issue was addressed by early Christina theologies; Augustine of Hope wrote several articles trying to explore the fate of roman soldiers. His ideas were synthesized by St. Thomas of Catholic Church and he come up with guidelines to qualify war to be just (Walzer, 2008). . Today, these principles are widely used to judge wars, they include:1. Good intention- a just war only exists when one fights to make a wrong right or in the event of self-defense against an armed attacker. 2. War as a last resort- for war to be just, it must be the last option when all other peaceful methods have been exhausted to the point that war becomes a solution.3. Chances of success- there must be possibilities that war will solve all the problems, a war that leads to loss of lives and injuries for no fruitful results cannot be considered ethical.4. Beneficial results- a war that results in better conditions than when the war would have not taken place is just, otherwise it is unjust.5. The violence and suffering should be proportional to victory gained for war to be justifiable.

Some argue that this theory have some shortcomings, for instance, they believe that taking life for any purpose is unjust before God and humanity. They also argue that war should waste the minimum time possible and therefore any method that brings victory at the earliest opportunity should be used, including interfering with civilians, this is way against human rights (Robinson, 2013).The discussion details main facts about the theory of just war, the benefits and problems that it brings. The theory bridges theoretical and applied ethics, since it demands an adherence, or at least a consideration of meta-ethical conditions and models, as well as prompting concern for the practicalities of war, a few of those practicalities have been mentioned here (Robinson, 2013) .

References.Orend, B (2009). War and International Justice. Wilfrid Laurier Press.Robinson, P (2013) Just War in a Comparative Perspective. Ashgate.Walzer, (2008). Just and Unjust Wars. Basic Books.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Just War/Military Ethics Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1638117-just-warmilitary-ethics
(Just War/Military Ethics Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1638117-just-warmilitary-ethics.
“Just War/Military Ethics Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1638117-just-warmilitary-ethics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Just War/Military Ethics

Differences among Assassination, Tyrannicide, and Targeted Killing

Collateral damage can be described as civilian casualties due to bombings of allied military forces.... By describing losses of civilian lives and properties, the officials redirect the criticism against the military for a high death count of common people (Hashmi 125-127).... Though the phrase has its roots in the military background, it has also been interchangeably used in common language.... Many experts believe that focussing only on the deaths of common people as a way of accessing a military operation is not a flawless approach....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Jus in Bello or the Doctrine of Just War

JUS IN BELLO Introduction Jus in bello or the docrine of just- war has originated from ‘Christian Realism', the cornerstone of morals and ethics.... Thus, the principle of proportionality demands the war commanders not to chase unattainable objectives or which were relatively unimportant by paying with lives of their own military troops.... Irrespective of war objectives, under no circumstances the military is supposed to make the civilian population a permissible target....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

American Military Conflicts: The Theory of Just War

The current writing investigates the just war theory in regard to the USA participation war events.... The just war theory does imply the humanitarian laws where justification of the moral tactics plays a vital role in determining the nature of the warfare.... The historical feature, or the "just war ritual" deals with the chronological body of regulations or accords applied (or in any case existing) in a variety of wars across the eons.... Under the theory of just war, Jus ad Bellum is (Latin word for "Justice to War) are an array of criteria that are referred to prior engaging in war, so as to decide whether entering into war is correct or not....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Action Taking during Military Operations

This is the time when he considers some issues like Moral reasoning, Proper leadership, Personal ethics, Constitutional ethics, Moral virtues, Utilitarianism, Justice.... The military of any country often face such incidents of hostile situations.... … In this paper I've basically tried to answer the question: when to fire and when to protect during hostile situations viewed as a military officer.... If we can for a moment forget the military men as armed forces only, and try to look beyond their armored uniform and heavy weapons they use to protect themselves and the people and welfare of their country, we see that they are similar in almost every way to the young boy or girl his age next door....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Ethics and the Hiroshima Bomb

This paper "ethics and the Hiroshima Bomb" will attempt to support the belief of the writer which is no, it was not ethical.... He feels that ethics are not futile or irrelevant but may be a hopeless pursuit.... Gradualist ethics is defined by going along with the policy even when we believe it is wrong.... In the deontological point of view, it is difficult to support the idea that ethics works differently for the State than for the individual....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

US Intel Community

Traditionally, the military have been accountable for interior security and homeland defense.... The National Security Act of 1947 regrouped the leadership of the armed forces following Second World war, validating a Defense Department (DOD) with a Secretary of Defense (SECDEF) that content directly to the Commander-in-Chief.... The organization has been of help in identification of individuals disputes and always alerted the States on any prevailing measures needs to be taken just on time....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Ethics and Moral Reasoning

The author of this essay "ethics and Moral Reasoning"  describes ethics and military use of drones.... This paper outlines the uses of predator drones by the US military offers them any satisfaction, theory of utilitarianism, the three ethical theories.... Is the use of drones by the US military for targeted killings of individuals and members of militant groups justified?... his paragraph seeks to evaluate if the use of predator drones by the US military offers them any satisfaction....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Ethical Justification of War

The just war theory gives the criteria for justifying the war; the criteria for the justification of war can be either ethical or historical.... This paper seeks to answer these questions by applying three main theories of ethics to the phenomenon of war; the three theories of ethics are the utilitarian theory of ethics (Consequentialism), the Kantian Deontology, and the Aristotelian Virtue ethics.... A critical look at applying the three theories of ethics to the phenomenon of war shows that the Aristotelian Virtue ethics is the ethical theory that provides the most satisfactory moral answer to the ethical question that this paper seeks to answer....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us