StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Plato's Arguments for Rationalism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Plato's Arguments for Rationalism"  informs that rationalism is regarded as the view in which specific items focused on knowledge are known independent of the sense of experience. According to Plato he argues that the sense of experience often fails to provide us with a guarantee…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Platos Arguments for Rationalism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Plato's Arguments for Rationalism"

Plato's Arguments for Rationalism Rationalism is simply regarded as the view in which specific items focused on knowledge are known independent of the sense of experience. According to Plato he argues that the sense of experience often fails to provide us with a guarantee that implies that what we do experience is, in fact true. Any information that we receive by relying on the sense of experience is frequently changing and quite unreliable (88). Such information can only be corrected and evaluated with regards to dependability based on certain principles which do not change at all. The unchanging principles are what are referred to as forms and they are the bases of reasoning and thinking in the first place. Therefore, if we can be able to show that a belief or an opinion we hold true is based on these forms of thought that are undoubtable, then we have a strong foundation for the opinion. It is that strong foundation that allows us to be able to think of a belief more often than simply an opinion: that is what allows us to be able to identify that specific belief as justified as well as true, and that is what is referred to as knowledge. In order to possess a justified true belief, there is need to surpass the flux of the physical world that is ever changing and also grasp the permanent order of rational that is behind the flux, that is an order which will illustrate the universal in particular. The grasping aspect is simply an intellectual act that is in its manifestation point in the mind (91). In short, Plato’s arguments can be summarised in the following contest: a) Justification is simply by reason instead of senses. This means that there is need to move away from that world of cave that is explored by our sensory experience and move outside the cave to discover the world of forms by means of reason. b) Objects of knowledge such as forms are necessary, unchanging and external. Therefore, we are looking for the permanent order which underlies the flux. c) The most basic and important knowledge is priori that means that it does not rely on sensory information. Thus this is true knowledge of goodness, of mathematics, of justice and many others. d) Mathematics is simply like a model for the entire knowledge process. This implies that the easiest way that an individual can think of forms is by thinking of mathematical objects being the perfect circle. The theory of form is regarded to as one of Plato’s most powerful theory. It proposes that on top of the physical world that we sense in our midst, there is also another realm based on reality. This kind of realm is intelligible instead of being an observable sphere in existence; it is made up of absolute, unchanging, external, perfect forms that define that which exists imperfectly and fleetingly in our world of senses (95). The forms therefore provide knowledge regarding the objective truth. The theory of forms assists Plato’s epistemological theories in a number of ways. According to Plato, epistemological theories are based on the account of what is meant by knowledge. Through these theories Plato assumes that knowledge is present or it is possible to achieve it and thus he focuses on revealing the conditions that make it possible. The conditions implied in this context which are conceived, concern the rational capacities of humans as well as the object of knowledge themselves (111). With regards to the objects referred to in the epistemological theories, forms are simply regarded as objects of knowledge and thus this is one of the reasons as to how the theory of forms is highly referred to in this context. Plato states that before even we were born our souls simply live according to the realms of the forms and thus they tend to have complete knowledge about the forms (98). Immediately we are born we still retain it but we often do not realise that we have it. The recollection of such knowledge demands that we face some difficulty before we can fully recover that knowledge in our minds. The theory of forms is applied in this context based on the fact that the realm of forms is highly regarded. The realm allows the use of intelligence where there is unchanging, absolute and external, perfect forms that is used to identify that which occurs imperfectly and fleetingly in our world of senses. Therefore, in understanding what is meant by knowledge based on the application of the epistemological theories, the theory of forms greatly supports it due to the realm of forms that addresses knowledge effectively. In the Allegory of the cave Plato focusses on the objects that are outside of the cave and references them to different kind of forms. In this allegory the physical objects illustrate the various forms of the physical objects. For instance, the objects that are seen at night in the sky that is the stars and the moon represent different forms of abstractions such as logic, beauty, justice and numbers (120). The object sun simply represents a form of good that is regarded as the highest among all other forms. It is hence the major organizing principle in which every other form participates. Thus through application of abstraction as well as unchanging principles knowledge is able to be understood. Epistemological theories are able to study source, nature, validity of knowledge and limits by relying on some form of help from the theory of forms (118). In accordance, to that the interest it raises in developing a method that attempts to evaluate the claims that individual know something. The world is viewed based on the aspect of changing objects. Plato claims that the objects can still remain intelligible without having to change their forms. In summary the epistemological theories are focused on knowledge and opinion. Knowledge is focussed on understanding and supported by various concepts of the theory of forms. Opinion is focussed on sense of experience, belief, imagination and hearsay and is supported by particular sensible objects, images, reflection and shadows which are given by the theory of forms. In my view Plato, provides enough support with respect to the concept of rationalism. This is because he clearly develops his ways in this concept based on the set rule of rationalism. Plato argues his cases that tend to strip the information that is received from sense of experience. He efficiently embraces the theory of forms as well as the epistemological theories in order to bring out what is meant by knowledge from an intriguing perspective. Secondly, he is able to construct accounts on how reason in some form tends to provide more information about the world. I strongly believe that based on the requirements that a rationalism concept requires Plato has been able to provide the relevant support for his arguments regarded on rationalism. Reference Melchert, Norman. The Great Conversation: A Historical Introduction to philosophy. New York: Oxford University Press, 2010. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Plato's Arguments for Rationalism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Plato's Arguments for Rationalism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1631813-platos-arguments-for-rationalism
(Plato'S Arguments for Rationalism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Plato'S Arguments for Rationalism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1631813-platos-arguments-for-rationalism.
“Plato'S Arguments for Rationalism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1631813-platos-arguments-for-rationalism.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Plato's Arguments for Rationalism

Comparing Two Pathways to Tolerance and World Peace

Comparing Two Pathways to Tolerance and World Peace Your Name Subject Name Date Martha.... C.... Nussbaum begins her treatise on “Patriotism and Cosmopolitanism” with a citation of Rabindranath Tagore's novel, The Home and The World, in which the hero exclaims “I am willing to serve my country; but my worship I reserve for Right which is far greater than my country....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Explain Plato's Method of Finding True Knowledge in Meno

Descartes proposes three arguments- perceptual argument, dream argument and the evil genius argument.... plato's and Descartes' methods both stress on non-dualist theories to find the true knowledge; however, plato's methods revolve around soul-body dualism and Descartes methods progresses through mind-body dualism.... There are several things that can be gained from plato's insights and ideas....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Platos Perspectives

Even though the modern philosophers have been opposed to the contribution of Plato, his arguments are still considered to be in context in the 21st century.... This paper ''plato's Perspectives'' tells that Plato is one of the ancient greatest philosophers in Greece, who besides philosophy, did mathematics and science....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

What Does Plato See as the Relation Between Experience and Knowledge of the Forms

plato's theory of forms and his view therein is based on two key components: knowledge cannot be acquired via a person's senses and people do hold knowledge - for example, people can know mathematics.... Their true forms, in plato's mind, are permanent, eternal, and nonphysical.... After taking plato's views and descriptions of Forms, true knowledge is an attainable trait.... These views resulted in plato's.... t to plato's certain view of knowledge, Plato believed that those propositions derived through sensory experience have a high degree of probability; and as such, this experience cannot be certain....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Platos Epistemological Position

rationalism is one of the epistemological positions that dominate philosophy.... 3), rationalism is viewing knowledge as a product of rational reflection.... Plato's general rationalism is the basis of Plato's epistemological position.... According to this rationalism, knowledge is an awareness of absolute, universal ideas or forms that exist independent of subject (Heylighen par.... This rationalism identifies what could be philosophically regarded as knowledge according to Plato....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Rationalism empiricism

Formalize the following arguments from the article.... What is the doctrine of knowledge by recollection, in plato's Meno?... In this thesis, the empiricists agree that they know by intuition that their concept of God includes their concept of eternal existence.... This thesis assumes that some… This thesis argues that some truths that we know are through our rational nature....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Platos Theory of Human Nature

Socrates refutes Thrasymachus view and the opinions of the other interlocutors by claiming that the interest of every individual is plato's Theory of Human Nature plato's Theory of Human Nature plato's defense of justice portrays his perception of the human nature.... The paper describes plato's theory of human nature and describes how he succeed and ways he failed.... It then tries to relate plato's theory of human nature with his theory of politics....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Theory of Knowledge

The first example in this regard comes from Plato himself and Cornford (2003) explains plato's ideas about the value of knowledge by saying that while knowledge itself is valuable, opinions and beliefs may affect the manner in which knowledge is valued.... This work called "Theory of Knowledge" describes beliefs and opinions as so important as the rational justifications given to assigning value to knowledge....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us