StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Error Described by Socrates, Menos Paradox - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Error Described by Socrates, Meno’s Paradox" it is clear that Socrates argues that is vital for him to pursue his mission even in the event of death occurring. According to Socrates, he would rather give the wrongdoers his deserts than remain a burden on the earth…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Error Described by Socrates, Menos Paradox
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Error Described by Socrates, Menos Paradox"

Question 1
Explain the error described by Socrates and provide an example of the error which is depicted in the modern-day world.
According to Socrates the craftsmen in Athens also made errors, just like the poets. They were knowledgeable in numerous areas and to an extent, Socrates states that he was not aware they were wiser than him (Plato 27). Socrates’ view was that they had this error because each one of the assumed they were wiser in their pursuits because of their success. This error thus contributed to the overshadowing of their wisdom.
An example of this error in the modern-day world is when people draw superstitious conclusions about future events through shows, movies or in writing such as in the movie 2012.
Question 2: Explain on Socrates argument in regard to the logical structure of the text and the argument that can be identified.
Socrates states that if a man is in a position that he deems as the best when placed by his leader, then such a man has to face danger willingly without any thoughts of death crossing in his mind. In Socrates’ arguments, it would be dreadful if a man did not face danger as he should have in the eyes of god and men due to his fear of death. No one is sure of whether death brings blessings to a man or if it is the root of evil (Plato 33). People fear it with the assumption that it is the greatest of evils yet there is no proof. Therefore, Socrates views himself as a wise man than the rest because he has no fear for what is unknown to man especially the underworld. However, he stresses the fact that despite his claim to be wiser than other people, he still believes that it is wicked to disobey God or his human superiors.
Question 3: Capture the logic and structural aspects in each of these arguments. Indicate the respective premises and conclusions in the arguments.
The wise men and women gave this talk on a divine intervention based on what they practised on a daily basis. The wise men and women indicated that the soul is usually immortal but comes to an end at one time when an individual dies (Plato 33). The wise men and women called it dying though the soul is regarded to be still alive. Since the soul never dies with the body, the individual has to lead a life that is pious.
Question 4:
a) Highlight on Meno’s paradox?
Meno’s paradox is why human beings may call learning a recollection; He also questions why there would be a need for people to search what they already know.
b) Explain the doctrine of recollection.
In the doctrine, of recollection, an individual’s soul is immortal, and it has the capability of recollecting about the things that were committed when the individual was not dead (Plato 49).
c) How is this doctrine of recollection supposed to change Meno’s paradox?
The doctrine of recollection can change Meno’s paradox if he understands that in the process of the soul learning a lot when an individual is not dead can also become energetic in the search for answers.
Question 5: Is the argument between the Meno and Socrates sound in a logical sense?
Yes, the two are arguing about an issue that exists even in this modern-day society. Most people today have various questions related to death and life after death. There are so many myths that surround these questions. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Error Described by Socrates, Menos Paradox Assignment - 14, n.d.)
Error Described by Socrates, Menos Paradox Assignment - 14. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1592381-philosophy
(Error Described by Socrates, Menos Paradox Assignment - 14)
Error Described by Socrates, Menos Paradox Assignment - 14. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1592381-philosophy.
“Error Described by Socrates, Menos Paradox Assignment - 14”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1592381-philosophy.
  • Cited: 1 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Error Described by Socrates, Menos Paradox

Gibbs Paradox

... This paper contains a deeply analyzed report about Gibbs Paradox along with its relationship with different theories like Information theory and thermodynamic entropy. A Brief Introduction of Gibbs Paradox:- In statistical mechanics, a simple derivation of the entropy of an ideal gas based on the Boltzmann distribution yields an expression for the entropy which is not extensive (is not proportional to the amount of gas in question). This leads to an apparent paradox known as the Gibbs paradox, allowing, for instance, the entropy of closed systems to decrease, violating the second law of thermodynamics. The paradox is averted by recognizing that the identity of the particles does not influence the entropy. In the conventional explanation...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Socrates

To put it in simple words, Protagoras views the principle of morality as a valuable aspect that facilitates social cooperation. On the other hand, Socrates holds a vision about the principle of morality as a matter of an individuals’ interrelation towards his/her own soul which cannot be taught based on certain defined theories or assumptions contradicting Protagoras’ views that a person learns virtue from his early age recently when he/she starts speaking (Plato 5-25). Thesis Statement This study intends to analyze the arguments made by Socrates questioning the dialogues in Protagoras regarding the teachability of virtue and education humans regarding wisdom. Protagoras’ acclamations with reference to the viewpoints of Socrates...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Socrates

Socrates uses himself as an example when he teaches that beauty does not guarantee happiness. True beauty is inner beauty, the beauty of one’s spirit and character. In conjunction with happiness, which was also a construct that Socrates discussed, he denotes that one cannot tell if a person is happy or not based on his external appearance, but happiness, like kindness, is a matter of inner qualities. His famous motto: “An unexamined life is not worth living” is a testimony to how much he values thinking and philosophy and the perennial introspection of why we exist. Constantly reflecting about one’s life and impact on others creates meaning for a person and Socrates encourages that we indulge in deep, critical thinking ourselves...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Socrates

...-existent, and the law would never be changed. To sum up the dialogue with Crito, Socrates appeals to him stating that he does not intend to be rescue, leaving him speechless. Socrates finalizes this dialogue by claiming, “Let it be then, Crito, and let us act in this way since this is the way the god is leading us” (Plato 57). In Socrates dialogue with Meno, Socrates makes a conversation about the nature of virtue, using it to justify why he should accept his judgment. The two of them discuss whether virtue is teachable or not, or whether virtue is an inherent knowledge that all people have and need to remember simply. The two discuss back and forth in their attempt to define virtue, and Socrates seems more interested in posturing rather...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Error

...It's the fact of common knowledge; beta-coefficient shows that while increasing average market profitability on pct, this share profitability will increase on beta pct. Look at sorted table on the Sheet 2. You see that 7 companies have Beta<1. It means that their shares are less sensitive to market fluctuations than other 8, who have Beta>1. Also we have C-coefficient values In our CAPM-model in perfect case we have C=0. For each company C values are small enough, what approves the adequacy of our model. Besides, we have Standard Errors of the Beta and C means. In fact, Standard Error of the mean quantifies how accurately we know the true mean of the population. In our case Standard Errors are very small - a good confirmation of correct C...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Socrates

...Like with most ancient figures, Socrates is a man whose life is one part mystery, one part historical and biographical spectacle. He was, in his lifetime, a true enigma—a puzzle for the entire span of the Athens city-state to solve. And like most ancient figures, we should not seek to avoid separating Socrates the man from Socrates the philosopher, for the two are not so easily differentiated. It seems, according to most sources, that Socrates’ whole life consisted of philosophy and the search for truth; it is this overriding commitment to the love of wisdom which led to Socrates’ ultimate downfall at the hands of his fellow citizens. Socrates was truly one of the few philosophers in history to make a significant attempt to question...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Socrates

... the Socrates’ argument of rejecting the language altogether. Hence, it can be said that the name of a thing may not be as important as the thing itself but a thing without any apparent identity of its own makes it hard to describe. In fact, the plot of the argument shows a contrast between what Socrates is defending in the beginning and what he is maintaining at the end of it. Kirk (1951, pp.225). A thing continues to be what it is regardless of the name it is given. Different names are attributed to the things by the humans themselves, based purely on their instincts, for their own ease otherwise it would have been difficult to identify one thing from the other. Even in our everyday life, we name things without giving much thought to them...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Socrates

... Socrates Introduction Socrates was a religious man and was ready to undergo anything to defend his religion. Socrates adored his religion although the government did not want it. In the Apology, Socrates explains to the July that his religion was very important, and it was mandatory act according to what the gods said. His love for obedience to the gods made him continue practicing philosophy despite the great resistance from the government. In another occasion, the Crito, Socrates stated that it was of importance to comply to the laws of Athens it is very clear that he is patriotic, and he values the laws of the land. All through the book Socrates proves his respect for the law as well as his deep desire to continue studying philosophy...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Socrates

... Teacher 24th January 2051 Socrates’ View of evil actions, its validity and Philosophy “There is only one good, knowledge, and one evil, ignorance.” Socrates All sages and philosophers have differing views on evil actions related questions. Some philosophers say evil actions are not in our extinct but some say the contrary. It is a very long discussion to prove these both concepts. Socrates’ view about evil actions is based on realistic thinking. Socrates believed that nobody deliberately chooses to do wrong. He also believed that nobody wants to harm his or herself. And he maintained that if a person does anything wrong to himself or herself, then he or she will harm himself or herself. Moreover, as per Socrates, people do evil act...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Socrates

... Socrates Socrates Biography Socrates was one of the famous Greek Philosophers and a main source of Western thought. Although quite little is known about his earlier life. Part of his biography was recorded by his students among whom included Plato, another Greek philosopher. From these notes, Socrates was born in Athens in 470 BC, as a son of Sophroniscus a Greek Mason and stone sculptor (Cohen, 23). Being from a rather poor family, Socrates must have received basic Greek education besides learning his father’s art from an early age. He is therefore believed to have worked as a mason for many years before engaging in a life of philosophy. It is however not well known how Socrates supported himself. Whereas some contemporaries point out...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Aristotle, Simmias, Cebes and Socrates' Main Ideas Regarding Philosophy

... principle is known actually (deduction) and the particular case (induction or demonstration) is known potentially. (ontruth.com/aristotle.html) He wrote, And this [deduction] evidently belongs to all animals; for they have a connate discriminatory capacity, which is called perception, in some animals retention of the percept comes about and from experience, or from the whole universal that has come to rest in the soul there comes a principle of skill and of understanding [induction, demonstration]. Where as According to Socrates, the right practice of philosophy is practicing for death and dying, and only this way can the soul be still exist with reason. Socrates bases his logic on the reasoning that death is the separation of the soul...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Left and Right Marker Error by a Reporting Radiographer: Whose Legal Responsibility

...Left and Right Marker Error By A Reporting Radiographer: Whose Legal Responsibility? Not all errors are negligent in medicine1 because doctors are expected to make mistakes during the course of their careers.2 While malpractice suits attach liability when doctors depart from the ordinary level of care expected of their peers,3 exactly how juries evaluate manifest errors remains unclear. Obvious errors, however, tend to move juries even further towards finding for a plaintiff. This problem of evaluating error is particularly acute in the specialty of Radiology.4 The ease with which a plaintiff can have films taken later in time invokes a variation of hindsight bias, to which the radiologist must answer why he or she did not identify...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study

Socrates in Platos Apology

... know many things of which I was ignorant, and in this they certainly were wiser than I was. But I observed that even the good artisans fell into the same error as the poets; because they were good workmen they thought that they also knew all sorts of high matters, and this defect in them overshadowed their wisdom” (Apology: 947). The second charge brought against Socrates was that he was associated with the hated Sophists who frequently played the role of devil’s advocate for the simple purpose of creating chaos and confusion. After being told by the oracle that he was the wisest man alive, Socrates did not allow this distinction to go to his head and immediately begin profiting from this prophecy. Instead, he went to the streets...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Socrates and Taoism

...Socrates and Taoism Introduction Philosophy is a wider than the sea and more complex than anything humanly derivable. Great understanding is broad and unhurried, little understanding is cramped and busy. (28). It is no surprise that are different beliefs, different theories and individuals involved in it, some having beliefs conflicting that of others. The theory of immortality, afterlife and the soul are often the subjects that are most debated and viewed from different angles. Socrates had a theory on the immortality of the soul and divided his argument into four clear parts. Taoism, one of the most popular beliefs among the Chinese has a different view on the subject. This paper analyses the philosophical theory suggested by Socrates...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Error Correction in Language Teaching and Learning

..., 1992: p. 151). Gass and Selinker (2001: 92) eventually described errors as ‘red flags’ that give confirmation of the student’s understanding of the second language. Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) As argued by the proponents of the communicative language teaching (CLT), acquisition of language is facilitated through communication rather than through explicit teaching of the system’s patterns (Pussel, 2005: 32). Meaning is viewed as the most important aspect and communicative competence is the intended outcome. CLT proponents assume that learners can gain higher communicative abilities through a normal setting and that if they are rigorously exposed to the language, they can gain proficiency of the TL in much the same way...
21 Pages(5250 words)Research Proposal

Dealing With Consequences of Medical Error

...Is a no fault regime better than a negligence rule as a way of dealing with the causes and consequences of medical error? The law, and allied legal institutions, is responsible for the allocation of ownership rights and responsibilities, particularly when there is a dispute on resource allocation (Dnes 1996). The role of the medical malpractice liability system is classified into two main aspects. One is concerned with redressing individuals who are victims of negligence, while the other aspect deals with the creation of incentives for doctors to give appropriate level of care (Kessler & McClellan 1996). In terms of insurance, medical malpractice insurance is dependent on community ratings (Quinn 1998). The provision of health care...
13 Pages(3250 words)Research Paper

El Cantar de Mio Cid - How Reliable Are the Described Events

..., Cantar de mio Cid can be considered an exception to the discrepancy that is rife in epic poems. There are many portions in the poem, particularly the first third of the poem, where there is a striking similarity of the events described to real life events; the initial parts of the poem accurately describe many of the deeds that Cid did in his life without any undue exaggeration or distortion of the truth. Since the poem is the only existing epic narrative that is relatively intact, it has been the subject of many studies based on Spanish epic prose and literature. Most of the aspects of the poem have been the topic of debate amongst scholars. There are different views regarding the differences between the text and the original events...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

The Potential Influence of Environmental Factors on Human Error

... The Potential Influence of Environmental Factors on Human Error Introduction The scientific study of people in the workplace has a long history of its own. It has been identified since ages that there is a potential influence of environmental factors on human error. This study aims to understand a specific work set up, its environment and the resources needed for its execution. This study will also help in evaluating the overall impact of the external factors involved and propose a solution to effectively address these concerns. This study involves identifying and controlling the risks from environmental factors in the working environment. Various factors affect worker’s potential and their productivity that are being described below...
12 Pages(3000 words)Dissertation

With What Justification Can Italian Architecture of the Period Be Described as Gothic

...With what justification can Italian architecture of the period be described as Gothic? Introduction Gothic architecture is an architectural style that dominated in most European countries during, the medieval period. During the development of Gothic architecture, Italy separated itself from the rest of Europe. Books Llc (2010: p.134) states that unlike other European country artists, Italian artists did not imitate the architectural styles from Northern France probably due to geologic and geographic factors. However, Gothic architecture first appeared in Italy in the 12th century, and it became indispensable just like in other European countries. The influence came from Northern European Gothic architecture and contained strong regional...
12 Pages(3000 words)Research Paper

Threat and Error Management

... focusing on what it needs to accomplish as far as TRM in the aviation industry is concerned. Chapter 2 covers various problems that led to development of TRM, including aviation accidents, elements of TRM, the role of ATC, its tasks and operations. Chapter 3 describes the importance of the development of TRM in aviation, focusing on the training as well as the devices of TRM, TRM and CAR OPS 2, threat and error management as well as TRM effectiveness evaluation. Chapter 4 provides the information on opportunities and advantages of the development of TRM within the aviation industry. It also focuses on the advantages and the core elements of TRM, the S.M model as well as the SHELL model. Chapter 5 focuses on the challenges and constraints...
44 Pages(11000 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Error Described by Socrates, Menos Paradox for FREE!

Contact Us