StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Preventing a Brave New World by Leon Kass - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper 'Preventing a Brave New World by Leon Kass' states that in the work “Preventing a Brave New World” by Leon Kass, the author argues against the cloning of the human being. He finds it unethical and immoral. Kass argues on ethical grounds and he exposes the reader to the adverse impact of the cloning system…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
Preventing a Brave New World by Leon Kass
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Preventing a Brave New World by Leon Kass"

?In "Preventing a Brave New World" Leon Kass concludes that reproductive and therapeutic cloning of human embryos is unethical. What are the exact steps in Kass's argument for this conclusion? What is your assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of this argument? In the work “Preventing a Brave New World” by Leon Kass, the author argues against the cloning of the human being. He finds it unethical and immoral. Kass argues on the ethical grounds and he exposes the reader to the adverse impact of the cloning system. He points out that “revulsion” (Kass, 2001) is not the basis of his argument as he points out that “repugnance” (Kass, 2001) of the past is silently accepted in the present. He moreover observes that disgust is not something that is emotional and hence he is not being emotional when he criticizes the cloning of the human embryos but it is a deep thought into the matter makes him talk against the mechanism. He compares cloning with the incest relationships and other unethical activities like disfigurement of corpse or feeding on human flesh. Kass observes that as murder, rape or bestiality cannot be ethically justified, in the same manner reproductive and therapeutic cloning of human embryos stands unjustified on the ground of ethics. Kass (2001), in his composition, says that cloning is resisted not only because it is strange to take up something like this but because he “intuit” that it is not novel and cloning for him is the violation of things that he dearly holds. In the book he criticizes cloning on the grounds of unethical experimentation, threatening the identity of human being and his or her individuality, transforming the essence of procreation into manufacturing. He also argues against it on the ground of despotism that it heralds on the children, thereby becoming the harbinger of parenthood perversion. He makes sure he is not misinterpreted when he is arguing against cloning. He points out that he is against the creation of reproductive cloning and not against the cloning that is used for the research work (Kass, 2001). On ethical grounds Kass argues that the cloning experiment has an adverse and unethical effect on the child to be born. Its not that they would be only affected adversely on the ethical grounds there can serious dangers to their life, as the experiment of cloning has failed mostly among the animals. Incidents of fetal deaths and the deaths of the stillborn infants cannot be avoided in the process of cloning. He also points out that the so called proclaimed successes are actually failure. It has also been revealed very recently that there remains a high chance of disability and deformity among the cloned animals that lives after birth. He justifies his argument by citing examples of clone crows which has heart and lungs problems and cloned mice which develops pathological obesity later on in its life span. It has been also observed that a cloned animal fails in attaining normal development milestones. Though he argues on the ethical grounds of relationships and the associated problem that would arise from cloning he actually argues on a strong scientific and logical terms. His argument against cloning stands justified on the basis of the facts and figures that have been provided by him (Kass, 2001). He also puts forward an argument on the basis of identity and individuality crisis. It will be like a dilemma for the person who has been cloned, as not only will he have concerns about his distinguishing characteristics but also that he will have an identical appearance as his father or mother. This would lead to serious identity crisis. He indicates the adverse effect that a homey case can have if engaged in infra familial cloning. Cloning of the husband and the wife gives birth to a twin parent child relation. Eventually no parent will be competent to take care of the clone of himself or herself as one treats his or her own child. This creates a series of perplexity in the relationship, the way they are perceived. Like if the daughter is the clone of the mother, it really becomes difficult for the father and the daughter, as the face of the daughter reminds the father of the woman with whom he had fell in love. And when the divorces comes a pertinent question that arises is will the spouse be able to love their cloned off springs as they cannot stand each other. The faces of the children will always make them remember of the person whom he or she hates and that would bring a mental turmoil for both the parents and the children. Kass argues that the decision of cloning is one sided and nobody cares about what the child will think about it (Kass, 2001). Kass points out in his argument that human cloning is that giant step that has been taken forward in the “transformation of begetting into making” (Kass, 2001). The very essence of the procreation gets changed into the manufacturing where in general terms human beings are able to hand make their off springs. It gives rises to a situation of tailor made products where one even gets the child made according to his or her own sweet wish. Kass makes it clear that he is not simply arguing on the basis of “nature knows best” (Kass, 2001). He points on the fact that the child whose features and characteristics exists as per the human design does not necessarily stands on the same surface as its creators. He compares cloned child with manufactured products by saying as the products have attributes that are more perfect than the original ones, the child will also be expected to par-excellent. He observes that the desired product can be perfect and more efficient but that is more of artifacts than human. Finally he ends up his argument by saying that the cloning of human being will result in the aggravation of insightful misapprehensions as there would be a incomprehension in the parent child relationships. When a child is pro created the parents gets ready to accept whatever the child turns out to be, but when it is tailor made and designed the expectation soars high and the acceptance changes accordingly (Kass, 2001). Conclusion Kass strongly argues against the cloning of the human embryos and provides factual evidence against it. His arguments are justified on strong ethical grounds. Again, the argument that has been stated in the work of Kass is not based on the non acceptance of the modern technology by the prior generation. He bases his arguments on the scientific and social adversities that the process of cloning will result into. He bases his arguments on ethical grounds but puts a logical explanation to it when he talks about the incidence of identity crisis and relationships confusion that people will undergo as a result of cloning. References 1. Kass, L. (2001), “Preventing a Brave new world”, retrieved on June 20, 2011, from: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:A7k16m1TTbkJ:www.csus.edu/indiv/g/gaskilld/ethics/BanCloning.doc+preventing+a+brave+new+world&hl=en&gl=in Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“In Preventing a Brave New World (pp. 317-329), Leon Kass concludes Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1425930-in-preventing-a-brave-new-world-pp
(In Preventing a Brave New World (pp. 317-329), Leon Kass Concludes Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1425930-in-preventing-a-brave-new-world-pp.
“In Preventing a Brave New World (pp. 317-329), Leon Kass Concludes Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1425930-in-preventing-a-brave-new-world-pp.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Preventing a Brave New World by Leon Kass

A comparative analysis on treatments for heart failure patients

Heart failure is included in the group of cardiovascular diseases, which is the leading cause of death all over the globe.... wo of the many options of treating HF are the use of pharmacologic therapy,andthe use of an implanted cardiac resynchronization device .... ... ... A Comparative Analysis on Treatments Available for Heart Failure Patients Heart failure (HF) is included in the group of cardiovascular diseases, which is the leading cause of death not just in the United States but all over the globe....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Proposal

Personal Management Framework

The paper "Personal Management Framework" concludes that the management framework may lean in a more humanistic slant, utilizing teams and manager listening skills, but the overall productivity could be constrained by the organizational structure and mixed messages of senior leadership.... ... ... ...
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Preventing a Brave New World

In the paper 'preventing a brave new world' the author analyzes Dr.... Leon Kass's assumptions regarding the novel brave new world by Aldous Huxley.... Dealing with Ethical issues, Kass is extremely concerned with the brave new world as presented by Aldous Huxley in the 1932 novel.... Moreover, he is concerned with the notion of humanity interested with saying 'yes' to the principles that lead to dehumanized brave new world.... According to the paper, kass abrasively states that there is that need due to nature that compel the humanity to decide on the issues not less than whether humanity procreation is to be terminated or it should remain....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Preventing a brave New World WK5 assignment

preventing a brave new world Name Institution Date Introduction The current world has advanced in technology and thought to an extent that some unethical acts are either not recognized as unethical, or are accepted in the society in the name of freedom, modernity, preserving life and so many other reasons.... kass is against the idea of using human embryos for therapeutic purposes indicating that it is an act of disrespect for human life.... He argues that whatever scientists call ‘therapeutic cloning', is the use of embryos as a font of tissues (kass, 2001, p....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Analysis of Dantes Inferno

The people here live in a contemplative world so that they can reflect on the fact that they were not baptized.... From the paper "Analysis of Dantes Inferno" it is clear that The seventh circle of Hell is reserved for those who were unduly violent in their life.... This circle of Hell is divided into three rings....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Effective Use of Conflict and Control in Reinforcing the Dangers of Technocracy in Brave New World

The paper "Effective Use of Conflict and Control in Reinforcing the Dangers of Technocracy in brave new world" discusses that in the phenomenological reality that we call nature, new conundrums are raised when mass entertainment and technology push individual experience into virtual worlds.... One of the constant undercurrents in brave new world is the dehumanizing effects of technological progress.... In fact, at the time of the writing of brave new world, they were seen as progressive ideas....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Brave New World by Aldous Huxley

Indeed, the author has explored various themes in the novel using diverse characterization as well as key elements that have shaped the course and meaning The novel details the community as cemented through stability in its beliefs and cultures, which guide the thinking in the world.... This is a utopian perspective, with abstract goals that the world hopes to meet through its defined identity.... Indeed, the characters mostly identify the subject of stability, whose craving desire to achieve this state make bio-engineers design ways that would see the same kind of individuals produced in the world without any distinctions....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Relevance of Key Contributors

This paper describes a proposed Personal Management Framework based on readings, outside research, and experiences.... By presenting a working management framework, the manager can benchmark the history and theories of the past to avoid repeating mistakes and benefit from lessons learned.... ....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us