Family-based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The reporter states that it is no simple matter to determine how best to take care of an individual who is suffering from dementia. The two main alternatives consist of whether the individual is cared for through family-based care or through a nursing home…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
Family-based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Family-based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia"

Outline: Introduction Economical cost of family-based care Emotional cost of family-based care Conclusion Works Cited Family-based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia
It is no simple matter to determine how best to take care of an individual who is suffering from dementia. The two main alternatives consist of whether the individual is cared for through family-based care or through a nursing home. There are two important aspects when it comes to deciding between these alternative. The first is the financial cost and the second is the emotional costs on those involved. Both in terms of the emotional and the physical cost of caring for dementia patients, it is often better that dementia patients, particularly those suffering severely from the disease, are cared for through nursing home care rather than family-based care.
Dementia is a collective term used to refer to a range of diseases that involve the deterioration of cognitive function over time. For those suffering dementia, their quality of life can substantially decrease, and they quickly become dependent on others to help them with even their most basic needs. The prevalence of dementia increases dramatically with age, as a consequence the number of people suffering from dementia at a given time is likely to rise as our population in general ages. As a consequence of this, the government is increasingly interested in determining what method of care is of lower cost.
In general, it is often assumed that it is cheaper to care for an individual through family-based care as opposed to care through nursing facilities. However, this does not take into account costs that are incurred by family members in terms of finances or time. This is an important factor, as dementia patients frequently require full time care, thus when dementia patients are being cared for through family-based care it is likely that at least one member of the family has reduced hours at work compared to under normal circumstances. When labor and costs are taken into account, studies have shown that for patients with severe levels of dependence it was more economically viable for them to be cared for through nursing home care than through family-based care . Thus, despite the financial costs of nursing home care, it is still equal in cost, or cheaper than family-based care.
Financial cost is not the only consideration in regards to deciding the best type of care for those suffering dementia. Dementia is progressive and destroys mental function. When it is a family member or loved one that this is occurring to, the process can be very painful to watch and can cause feelings of helplessness and mental trauma. There are many reports of caregivers of dementia patients suffering from severe depression as a consequence of watching the progression of the disease . As a consequence caring for an individual with dementia exerts significant mental pressure on those responsible.
How does one determine what to choose when taking care of a family member with dementia? Placing a mother, a father, or any relative in a nursing home incites the sensation of injustice and abandonment. Yet, the costs of taking care of a dementia patient at home are considerable, especially as the disease progresses. Not only are the financial costs considerable, but the emotional toll can be severe. Taking care of an individual with dementia is a social issue that is increasing in prevalence as the population ages, and those who face the decision with family members or relatives need to take all the aspects into consideration to ensure they make a fully informed decision.
Works Cited
Chiu, L., Tang, K.Y., Liu, Y.H., Shyu, W.C., and Chang, T.P. "Cost comparisons between family based care and nursing home care for dementia", Journal of Advanced Nursing 29.4, (1999) pp. 1005-12.
Eisdorfer, C., Czaja, S.J., Loewenstein, D.A., Rubert, M.P., Argüelles, S., Mitrani, V.B., and Szapocznik, J. "The effect of a family therapy and technology-based intervention on caregiver depression", The Gerontologist 43.4, (2003) 521.
 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Family-based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia Essay”, n.d.)
Family-based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia Essay. Retrieved from
(Family-Based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia Essay)
Family-Based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia Essay.
“Family-Based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Family-based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia

CHN: Family Nursing Care Plan

...?Running head: FAMILY NURSING CARE PLAN CHN: Family Nursing Care Plan (school) CHN Project: Family Nursing Care Plan Assessment Profileof selected family The Smith family (pseudonym) is made up of Mr. and Mrs. Todd (52 years old) and Evelyn (45 years old) Smith, parents to four children: Susan, living at home, (20 years old), Todd, Jr. (17), Adriana (12), and Roger (7 years old). Todd is an office worker at a government agency and Evelyn is a housewife. Todd’s elderly mother, Rose (88 years old), also lives with them. The father is the primary breadwinner, decision-maker, and authority figure in the home. In his absence, the mother Evelyn has more or less similar functions for the family. The family is Caucasian and belongs... York: Nova...
14 Pages(3500 words)Research Paper

Advance Dementia Care

... care. This same value which propounds the need to stick to empiricism is also underscored by this approach’s insistence on the notion that medicine should help develop technological solutions for everything, and that medicine is the only credible and valid perspective and approach for understanding illnesses and diseases. One can therefore wax poignantly that the biomedical model has extensively played a pivotal role in setting the path for the observation of evidence-based practice in the treatment of dementia. According to Whitman (2009, 66), the downside of the biomedical model is that its insistence on the notion that medicine is the only credible and authentic perspective that can help bring about understanding on illnesses... of...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Nursing Home Care

...and their families. This was achieved by identifying the experience that participants had with pneumonia and what locus of care would be preferred. The research also sought to find the differences that these participants perceived between hospital-based care and LTCF care and what would be the criteria for good care. Methods of study: In this study, qualitative descriptive study was employed. The participants involved members of families of LTFC residents and the residents themselves who had previously been treated for pneumonia. Members of staff in these nursing homes were asked to...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Practical Dementia Care

...?Clinical Reasoning Case Study The Case Mrs. Archer has been admitted to your facility for respite care while her daughter (her primary carer) has a 6 week holiday. She weighs 45 kilograms and has paper thin skin. She is in the early stages of dementia and you notice she does not eat very much food or drink very much. Her daughter tells you she often gets very red and sore genitalia because she sometimes has urinary tract infections. She also tells you Mrs. Archer is very unsteady on her feet and tends to pull back on her walking frame. Identification of Nursing Care Problems In the given situation, several problems regarding Mrs. Archer’s health status arise. The height...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Nursing Care Plan for Dementia and Analysis

...the condition of the patient is more accurately evaluated as Alzheimer’s Disease. This is the most common cause of Dementia (Korvath et al, 1989; Adams and Moyle, 2007; ACCESS, 2006). After the assessment of the real condition of the patient, the nursing care plan developed will directly target the person’s needs as an Alzheimer’s patient with dementia. Based on literature, there are various approaches to deal with demented people. Person-centred care by Kirtwood (1997), highlights the inner subjective needs of the patients with Dementia, implying their sense of personhood. Other approach deals with the complex roles...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Dementia Nursing Care Plan and Analysis

.... Dettmore, Diane, Kolanowski, Ann & Boustani, Malaz. (2009). Aggression in Persons with Dementia: Use of Nursing Theory to Guide Clinical Practice. Geriatric Nursing. 30 (1), 1-11. Dijkstra, Ate. (2007).FAMILY PARTICIPATION in Care Plan Meetings: Promoting a Collaborative Organizational Culture in Nursing Homes. Journal of Gerontological Nursing. 33, Iss. 4, 22-29. First, Michael & Tasman, Allan. (2004). Mental Disorders: Diagnosis, Etiology and Treatment. Chichester, England: J. Wiley. Floetke, Amanda, Horgas, Ann, & Marsiske, Michael.  (2008). Nurses’ Role in Identifying Mild Cognitive Impairment in Older Adults. Geriatric Nursing. 29 (1), 1-12. Kim, Jennifer. (2007).Nutritional Assessment in Elderly Clients. Journal for Nurse... or take...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Population based nursing care

.../definition/Community Dalzell, M. D. (1998). Just What the Devil Is Population-Based Care? Retrieved from Hart, M. (1998). How do you define a community? Retrieved from Maurer, F. A., & Smith, C. M. (2005). Community/public health nursing practice: health for families and populations (3rd ed.). Elsevier Health Sciences. Population-Based Public Health Practice. (2003). Retrieved from Population-based nursing care Population-based nursing care What is...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Music & Dementia Care

...) of the patient appeared to increase. This result was particularly strong during the singing condition, suggesting that there may be a significant role for the human voice in dementia care. Hammar et al (2011) presented results based upon the ‘normal’ morning-care routine and the MTC-based morning-care routine to allow for a direct comparison of the results. It was felt that without MTC, there was a lack of communication between the patients and the caregivers which hampered the ability of the caregiver to administer the care that the patient required. Another theme of this condition was that there is a physical and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Countryside Care Nursing Home/Case Study

...workplace (Spellman & Whiting, 2005). The current situation that Craig is facing is similar to the one that he dealt with before in most ways such as being a nursing home that is facing similar problems as the previous one. In addition, the Countryside Care Center also has the issue of injuries that are related to lifting of residents. Therefore, implementation of the no-lift program would be effective especially if this nursing home could ask the employees for input with regard to how the program could be implemented for maximal outcome. This program would be very effective in reducing the compensation expenses because...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Dementia Patient Care Plan

...). The patient could also visit different specialists such as geriatricians, neurologists, psychiatrists, neuropsychologists, and psychiatrists, who have more knowledge concerning issues of behaviour and memory changes related to dementia. Such individuals could also arrange for or perform detailed assessments, blood tests, and brain scans. Another option for Peter is the Aged Care Assessment Teams (ACATs) that involve multi-disciplinary teams comprising of occupational therapists, social workers, doctors, and nurses based in community health centres or hospitals such as the Alaska Native Medical Centre (Australian Government, 2012; Alaska Native Medical Center , 2015)....
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Family-based Care or Nursing Home Care in the Face of Dementia for FREE!

Contact Us