Carnavelis Decision Making Model - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Doris Carnevali’s model of clinical judgment and decision making postulates that an integration of critical thinking is important for effective diagnostic reasoning (Carnevali, 2003, p. 45). …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Carnavelis Decision Making Model
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Carnavelis Decision Making Model"

Download file to see previous pages The effectiveness of a nurse’s role is achieved through the assessment of the social, physical, mental, and spiritual and health factors which define the needs of the patient. This paper is based on a clinical case study where the roles of nurses in assessment of the patient and related factors and decision making and practice are discussed. The discussion is based on Carnevali’s model of clinical judgment and decision making which evaluated in terms of its effectiveness and impact on the execution of nursing roles in patient assessment and decision making. The assessment of Jack’s physical, social, mental, spiritual and health care needs will be based on an integration of critical thinking and observation. Wolf (2012, p. 20) explains that the ability of a nurse to identify the needs of the patient during the assessment process is effectively achieved through keen observation and application of higher cognitive processes of thought. Kearney and Penque (2012, p. 32) adds that the legal and ethical standards of nursing and evidence based practice should also be included in trying to identify the needs of the patient. In Jack’s case, his symptoms are used to assess his health care needs. For example his dehydration is identified through the nurse’s observation. This leads to a critical thinking process through which the nurse will make a decision of the nursing intervention and therapy which is relevant for his condition. The significance of Carnevali’s model of clinical judgment and decision making is disclosed in this case because effectiveness in assessment of the health care needs of the patient would only be achieved through observation of his symptoms. Carnival’s model presents the first stage of diagnostic reasoning process as the collection of information and data on the patient and the family (Carnevali, 2003, p. 45). Aitken, Marshall, Elliott and McKinley (2009, p. 38), add that the roles of nurses in patient diagnosis are guided by collection of patient data on the social and cultural aspects and applying them in the prescription of relevant intervention and therapy. Jack for example is affected by social factors such as lack of appropriate support and care from the parents. This is disclosed by the fact that the parents want to leave him in the hospital with a neighbor. Nonetheless, critical thinking and prioritization must be applied in nursing care to ensure that the health care needs of the patient are provided before further assessment achieved. Jack’s dehydration and weakness requires immediate nursing intervention even before a complete analysis of all factors surrounding his condition are ascertained. Huiqin and Thompson (2010, p. 2752) points out that nurses play a critical role in meeting the needs of patients for care with due consideration of the standards of care and maintenance of high standards in practice. However Carnevali’s model of clinical judgment and decision making fails to show emphasis on the role of ethical and evidence based nursing practice. In accordance to Carnaveli’s model of clinical judgment and decision making, the second stage in diagnostic reasoning process is entry into the patient assessment (Carnevali, 2003, p. 45). This includes priority setting. Jack’s health care needs are prioritized by the nurse because of his weak condition and continuous crying. This is the reason why the nurse must prioritize the health care needs of the patient. Sutcliffe (2011, p. 35) emphasizes that the Nursing and ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Carnavelis Decision Making Model Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Carnavelis Decision Making Model Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 Words)
“Carnavelis Decision Making Model Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3000 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 1 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Carnavelis Decision Making Model

Decision-Making: The Administrative Model

.... Finally, one needs to confirm whether the chosen alternative resolves the problem successfully and efficiently (Baker, Bridges, Hunter, Johnson, Krupa, Murphy, & Sorenson, 2001). Models of Decision-Making The two popular models of decision-making are the rational economic model as well as the administrative model. The rational economic model of decision-making is a prescriptive model based on a normative approach. The rational economic model recommends how an individual or an organization should make...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Decision making

...). This underscores the importance of mediation as a tool for diplomats to solve conflicts and tensions between nations and states. I see high importance in understanding the perspective role of international mediation as a future conflict resolution tool. Since the demands of each side of the conflict must be heard in mediation, the method with which parties come up with decisions on the demands they put forward is important in determining the success of the process. Thus, each party might need to come up with decisions on the condition to present in the mediation. A simple decision making model involves diagnosis of the problem, search for options and...
12 Pages(3000 words)Research Paper

Making decision

...? MAKING DECISION BY PRESENTED Making decisions In a couple of sentences outline why it is difficult to distinguish between clinical-decision making errors solely due to intuitive judgement or analytical judgement Hammond (1996) explains that intuition is a cognitive process that provides answers and idea solutions without using any conscience, or logically defensible processes. In other words, intuition cannot be made explicit while an analysis can be made explicit. As Bendal & Morrison (2009) assert, nurses are called to hold on the highest degree of professionalism in making any decision. As Bendal & Morrison (2009) elaborate, nurses in most cases have to apply evidence based practices to alive at any decision where a patient... is...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Rational Decision-Making Model

...Rational Decision-Making ModelDecision making is required in every field whether it is business or routine life activities. It is required to make effective decisions in limited time by formulating policies through proper planning. Rational decision creation representation is referred to a controlled and chronological strategy for resolution making which is intended towards attaining precise solutions to well-defined problems making use of defined methods. The decision maker can gather necessary information through observations and statistical analysis. Moreover it also requires modelling and a systematic analysis of real quantitative data for analysis for making selections through alternative course of actions (Lunenburg, 2010... )....
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Decision Making Model

...Decision-Making DECISION-MAKING MODEL School Decision-Making Model Making decisions is common to all people. Everybody at myriad points in their lives is confronted with various decisions needed to be made. In doing so, people opt for different methods that they are comfortable with and prove to be effective for them. It should also be noted that a person may resort not only to one particular style but to different ways of making decisions ("Wikipedia", 2005). The decision-making...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Describe the decision making model

...The Decision Making Model It has been the practice of the people involved in the management of businesses to engage in decision making. There is usually limited time and resources in formulating business policies and addressing of public issues. Therefore public and business administrators must practice a certain degree of discretion in planning, revising and implementation of public policies (Gianakis 2004). They must participate in making decisions. Decision making is the process of evaluating the various options available, benefits and costs related to them, and selecting one for...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Assignment #1 Making a Decision Using the Decision - Making Model

...Decision Making Process Decision Making Process Introduction Making decisions that can have a huge impact on one’s life is a notan easy task. While going back to school was one of the major steps in life, graduate education has taken a toll on my life. Before enrolling for graduate school, I was excited about the chance to gain further skills for my future and professional life. I was looking forward to the programs and units I enrolled in several weeks to the commencement of my class work. However, the huge amount of class work has made me depressed and I find myself procrastinating from time to time. Due to my ability to...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

MANAGEMENT DECISION-MAKING business model assignment the surrounding community. 2 4.3 How are they integrated with the rest of our business model? Customer relationship is an integral part of the business. They are ultimate consumers of our products and therefore without them, there will be no sales and therefore no need of production (Liebenberg, 2004). 2 Sec 5 Customer Segments Leave this side of the document Blank for Comments / Corrections 5.1 For whom are we creating value? Why? We are creating value for the mass market and a market segment. Our major target market is both male and female youths. Why? The reason behind aiming at this target market is the fact that, they are young and therefore spend much of their cash on beauty products in an attempt to look...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Decision-Making Model

...Decision-Making Model Introduction The case study is based on 6 years of age child having fever and the explanation of the decision of the parents of the child for the treatment. It has been identified that the parents of child are divorced and the mother is not a biological parent, but the father is a biological parent. Based on the difference in religion, the decisions of the parents are recognized to be different from each other related to the treatment of the child because the mother is a Christian Scientist and insisted that the child should be provided with treatment and on the other hand, the father insisted that treatment should be offered along...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Discussion of Decision Making Model

...Discussion of Decision Making Model Uustal formulated a model that is useful in making effective ethical decisions. The model ensures the transformation of ethical dilemma into a morally appropriate solution (David, 2001). I usually encounter ethical dilemmas in the clinical environment. One such dilemma is initiation of abortion. A doctor requested me to help in abortion. I declined the request because I strongly oppose abortion. I subscribe to a religion that believes that human life starts at conception. The religious teachings hence strongly oppose abortion. The decision making...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Carnavelis Decision Making Model for FREE!

Contact Us