Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker - Term Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Find a newspaper article or scholarly journal article (from 2008 to present date) that illustrates an ethical discussion that involves allocation of health care resources such as challenges that fall within the category of distributive justice. The article by Atul Gawande (2009) in published in the New Yorker raises fundamental issues about the way American citizens receive their health care from their local hospitals and doctors…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker"

Download file to see previous pages Some scholars suggest that the system has drifted out of control: “Through no planned design or evil intent, our health care system has evolved in ways that better serve a myriad of economic, professional, and political interests than those of patients and families, and the larger public” (Mechanic, 2006, p. ix). Gawande, however, sees a much bleaker picture, and suggests that there are areas in America where doctors and administrators are financially tied into provision, and that this encourages massive amounts of over-treatment, with no benefit to patients. Gawande’s article describes a huge discrepancy in the per capita costs of medical care in two comparable districts, McAllen and El Paso, Texas, while there is no evidence that the higher cost location (McAllen) offers better care or achieves better results. This gives rise to a serious ethical problem: in El Paso patients have much lower rates of access to all kinds of tests and treatments, while in McAllen, they have much higher rates. The variation is due to doctor behavior, and not down to the demographics of the citizens, since the two regions are very similar. This is the kind of situation that led to the passing of the 2010 Health Care Reform bill which aims to extend health coverage to from 83% to 95% of the legally resident population. (Tumulty, 2010, p. 1) Unfortunately, however, huge variation in the way that this money is spent will mean that a fair and equal service is not likely to happen. From the point of view of justice, or fairness, such unequal practices cannot be defended, since all American citizens should have equal access to the benefits of our modern technologies. From a utilitarian point of view, there is a deviation from best practice, since in the McAllen hospitals there is little effort to gain the greatest benefit to patients for the lowest cost. Increasing the amount of testing in order to maximise revenue is the very opposite of ethical behaviour on the part of institutions where doctors earn more for ordering more procedures and tests. Gawande suggests that the problem lies with the structures of delivery, and describes the McAllen healthcare model as “as system that has no brakes” (Gawanda, p. 14). He cites the example of the Mayo clinic, where doctors receive a fixed salary, as a potential solution. Fewer scans are done, and more discussion between doctors takes place to minimize unnecessary treatments, all of which come with risks as well as benefits, and to try to ensure that patients have what they need, rather than what can be sold to them for profit. There is little incentive to cherry pick patients in this kind of system, and hospitals which follow this style find that overall costs are lower, and quality of care goes up. This analysis takes a refreshing look at the way the whole system is set up, and this gives the reader an overview of things rather than just the view of an economist, or a health professional, or an administrator. It highlights the error that patients, and some doctors, often make, in thinking that more testing is always good. The point is to do what is the best for the patient, and not what sustains the system. If there was more of this kind of benchmarking across hospitals with comparable patient characteristics, then perhaps more could be done to eliminate wasteful ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker Term Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker Term Paper)
“The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker Term Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker

Adventist Hospital gains a new face

...Press Release FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Work telephone Home telephone Fax number Adventist Hospital gains a new face! August 2006, Hong Kong To help Adventist Hospital promote their advanced services, the board of directors has just announced the addition of Student name to the newly created position of Director of Public Relations and Development effective immediately. According to Peter Jones, president of Adventist Hospital’s board of directors, student last name was selected out of 100 candidates for this position based on a very impressive educational career. “We also felt that student name handled him/herself in a very mature manner in the interviews. The job is a new position and calls for someone capable not merely of handling...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Running a Small Business in Papua New Guinea

...Running a Small Business in Papua New Guinea Introduction Running a small business in Papua New Guinea is often expected to be broke because of the revenue and instability of cash that are usually redirected to the native non- market economy of the country. A lot of businesses are built in order to supervise exchanging gifts and developing the social status of the investors and business owners. Hence, this will be apparent to the motivation of the subordinates to get through the objectives of the business. Indeed this is one technique seen in most of businesses today is building public relations in order to acquire brand loyalty and to position the business in the market. In a narrower sense, developing strategies on how to market...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

Creative Actors of the Third Age - When Old Is New by Jennie Keith

... Creative Actors of the Third Age - When Old Is New by Jennie Keith Contrary to the stereotypes among old people being portrayed as “frail, forgetful, shabby, out-of-date and on the edge of senility and death”, [1] not all of them exhibit such commonly stereotyped characteristics. Based from an interview conducted on two (2) people who are in the so-called “third age” (between 60 and older), the subjects were as active and productive as someone in their 30s. In her article entiteled “When Old is New” Jennie Keith points out that “Older people have been creative actors in the shaping of new life stages and cultural spaces.” [2] From the two separate interviews conducted, we can say that the subjects’ focus vary as they age...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

The Battle of New Orleans

...The Battle of New Orleans The War of 1812 pitted the British and the Americans against one another, and one of the battlegrounds came to be in what would later become the state of Louisiana. Movements began on the night of January 7th, 1815, and the battle itself took place on January 8th. The city of New Orleans, on the coast of the Gulf of Mexico, was invaded by British troops under Pakenham. Meanwhile, American troops under Jackson moved to confront the British. The British Army was planning to cross the Mississippi River in order to make a surprise attack, with two sections of the force planning to attack the American forces while another section remained in reserve. Trouble with the canals they had dug, as well as a general slow...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

Analysis of Early Childhood Education in New Zealand

... Analysis of Early Childhood Education in New Zealand Early childhood education in New Zealand includes education of the child from birth until entry into school. National curriculum reforms started in New Zealand in 1980s to improve the quality of education and lay a stronger foundation thereby ensuring a future successful participation by young people, the economy, and in New Zealand society (Brewerton, 1996). The development of the guidelines for the national curriculum to improve the quality of early education was a part of this process. New Zealand is the first country in the world to have introduced national Early Childhood Curriculum called Te Whariki or the woven mat. The developers of Te Whariki ensured a high degree...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article

Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the New World Order

This study deals with the challenge of social integration in France with respect to adoption of the assimilation model as well as the issues in integration, associations of paradigms to those of other countries in Europe. Sam et al define integration as the process of inclusion in which the immigrants have the ability to incorporate positive qualities of the other groups while maintaining their cultural self. In assimilation, a group of people only maintains good relations with the host population (Sam and Berry 168). The two approaches differ in the degree of identification, whereby integration upholds dual identity that is of the adopted and original culture. On the other hand, assimilation abets keen identification with the...

15 Pages(3750 words)Article

The Safety of a New Amide Local Anesthetic

... section is to underline the theoretical framework and the need to study a subject. Therefore a critical reader should spot three constituents, which are a description of the topic, research problem statement, and a review of the background literature. The research problem is the part that attracts the reader’s attention to the scope, impact and the status of the problem studied (Fawcett and Garity 2009). Further, the standard of best evidence attainment compels randomization of patients to evaluate alternative treatments or comparing known treatment strategies to newly developing ones. Apart from ethical issues, getting a balanced state of what is established, and what a new study suggests or the uncertainty level in results links strongly...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article

New Clues to Genetics of Type 2 Diabetes

The difference between this and type 1 diabetes is that, according to the WebMD page “Type 2 diabetes Overview” in the latter condition no insulin is produced. Diabetes is the most frequent cause of chronic renal failure as well as blindness in adults and the necessity for the amputation of limbs because of circulation problems, and it is also a major risk factor in cardiac disease, strokes, and can cause birth defects. It is important that the causes, whether genetic or otherwise, are known as this will help with the education of both medical personnel and their patients as to the best way to deal with the condition.
The hypoglycemia associated with the condition, when the body’s cells don’t receive eno...
15 Pages(3750 words)Article

New Knowledge and Innovation of RLK Media

These challenges can easily be overcome if outsourcing is taken as a tool to meet the corporate goals. It should be aligned with the company’s missions and then it can help to create more value from the same internal resources of the company. Besides, the company gains on time and benefits from the added knowledge of the new partner. Synergies also generate new knowledge and innovation is enhanced. The CEO has to convince the technical head of the benefits and involve him in every step of the decision-making process. This is necessary because the middle management tends to feel insecure when outsourcing decisions are taken. Outsourcing the R&D is the best option for the company and this will reap benefits.
In the comp...
12 Pages(3000 words)Article

Effect of Immigration on New York City

... and South America relative to the nation, which has been more likely to get immigrants from Asia and Mexico. The Caribbean comprised 33 percent of the flow of immigrants to the city, but only 12 percent of the flow to the nation in the 2005-2009 periods. (Gelfand, 03) Similarly, while South Americans comprised twelve percent of the citys flow, their share of the nations flow was only six percent. On the other hand, just one percent of the citys flow was comprised of Mexicans (Other North America), compared to thirteen percent of the nations immigrant flow. Likewise, Asians were 26 percent of the citys flow but comprised 42 percent of entering immigrants to the nation. (Martin, 5) The 2000s marked resurgence in European immigration to New...
10 Pages(2500 words)Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Term Paper on topic The Article by Atul Gawande (2009) New Yorker for FREE!

Contact Us