StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Mandated Staffing & Working Hours for RN's - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Mandated Staffing & Working Hours for RN's" discusses mandated staffing of nurses that requires establishing the minimum number of nurses for a particular floor or department, for each shift. This is sometimes referred to as the nurse-to-patient ratio…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
Mandated Staffing & Working Hours for RNs
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Mandated Staffing & Working Hours for RN's"

 Fewer medication errors and other mistakes are made when nurses are not overtired or when facilities are not understaffed.

      This would appear to be an advantage for many nurses.  Younger health care workers value time with their own children and families.  There is said to be less incidence of burn-out and mental fatigue that is so common in the nursing profession. “Proposed minimum, nurse-to-patient staffing ratios, such as those enacted in many U.S. States, are intended to address a growing concern that patients are being harmed by inadequate staffing related to increasing severity of illness and complexity of care” (Welton, 2008).  This initially seems an appropriate solution for both staff and patients, in terms of health and well-being.

       However, mandated nursing staff minimums increase administrative costs to many facilities,

with little or no additional reimbursement from insurance companies and managed care.  Without additional funds, facilities are limited in spending.  This can affect the pay rates of nurses, who may forego raises and bonuses.  Other areas of the budget may be affected as well.  New equipment and areas such as Information Technology may be affected as well.  Nurses and other staff may work harder to accomplish the same goals, as there is little money for updating patient record systems and for adding new diagnostic tools.  “Mandatory ratios, if imposed nationally, may result in increased overall costs of care with no guarantees for improvement in quality or positive outcomes of hospitalization” (Welton).  Patients may not get the best care with outdated

equipment such as monitors and IV pumps in use.  Outdated equipment may need more frequent

repair and is more likely to fail.

      Outdated patient charting or records systems require more time to be spent on documentation, taking time away from patient care.  In order to cut costs, facilities may cut back on other staff as well.  Nurses aides and orderlies, transportation workers, housekeeping, and unit clerks are often vital to keeping each shift running smoothly, helping nurses to care for patients on schedule.  With less support staff, nurses must perform many of their tasks as well as their own.  Again, nurses feel the brunt of the mandates as they must balance more responsibility.  Patients lose out with less contact from nursing staff, who may have to mop a floor or order supplies for their unit.

      When mandated or regulated nurse staffing occurs, often the nurses are the ones to suffer, not only in workload but in salary as well.  In order to remain competitive, facilities may go ahead and invest in more modern equipment or newer systems, reducing the budget for salaries. over time, this results in nursing shortages and high nursing staff turnover. Patient care is again lost in the turmoil.  Most anyone would agree that they would rather see a loved one cared for in a hospital where nurses are more plentiful, well-paid and happy, than overworked, tired, and fearful that a mistake will be made.  The New Mexico Organization of Nurse Executives (NMONE) “recognizes recent research that demonstrates a positive relationship between appropriate nurse staffing and its impact on patient outcomes, safety of patients and nurses, nurse physical and psychological health, and nurse satisfaction” (NMONE).  The organization also indicates that there is a concern for nursing errors, due to fatigue.  It believes that mandated ratios are not the only solution to staffing. 

      In a 2004 to 2006 study of mandatory nurse staffing ratios in California, results indicate that mandates did not improve patient care.  “Anticipated improvements in nursing-sensitive patient outcomes were not observed” (Bolton, et al, 2007).  The study mentioned above, along with other examples, reinforces the view of the NMONE, that mandated staffing ratios is not the solution to better working conditions and better patient care.  Neither is mandated overtime.  However, as the risk of staffing shortages occurs, combined with mandated ratios, the likelihood that nurses will be required to work overtime increases.  As budget cuts are often made in support staff, the increased workloads of nurses require additional time for completion of all duties within a shift.

      While each facility or state government may dictate the number of staff, this solution can only work if nurses are compensated competitively and facilities are not forced to make choices in which important services to cut.  A better solution is to develop a separate billing for nursing hours, rather than for hospital rooms or facilities.  A system that bills the patient based on the level of care required, separately from other services, may allow the mandatory staffing ratios to improve conditions for patients and nurses alike.  The NMONE recommends “a planning process that takes into account the number, skill mix and experience of nursing personnel, the acuity of patients and the complexity of their care, the availability of support staff, available technology, and the physical environment of a given nursing unit.”

     Additionally, when nurses are compensated fairly, it is less likely that a facility will be forced to impose mandatory staffing minimums.  Less attrition of nursing staff will occur.  Many will be more likely to work voluntary overtime, within limits.  Facilities will be able to maintain adequate levels of support staff as well, allowing nurses to concentrate on the duties and skills for which they are trained.  Facilities receive a much better value for the money spent when nurses use more of their highly developed skills.  Patients are also likely to fare much better, receiving at least a minimum standard of care.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Mandated staffing & working hours for RN's Essay, n.d.)
Mandated staffing & working hours for RN's Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1712504-mandated-staffing-working-hours-for-rns
(Mandated Staffing & Working Hours for RN'S Essay)
Mandated Staffing & Working Hours for RN'S Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1712504-mandated-staffing-working-hours-for-rns.
“Mandated Staffing & Working Hours for RN'S Essay”. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1712504-mandated-staffing-working-hours-for-rns.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Mandated Staffing & Working Hours for RN's

Fifteen Questions on Nursing

The cost of losing one nurse has been estimated at twice the annual salary of one nurse.... All in all, cost to healthcare for nursing turnovers registers at about $15 million a year … The cost of losing one nurse has been estimated at twice the annual salary of one nurse.... All in all, cost to healthcare for nursing turnovers registers at about $15 million a year (Hunt, 2009, p....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Procedure Working - Organic Farming

Procedure working of the product chosen As has been the trend observed over the past several decades, the third world countries are introduced to a new product when some time has been elapsed after the introduction of the same product in the markets of the first world countries.... PEST Analysis Author's Name Institution Overview With the modernization taking over the world, every field of life has taken the toll of devastating human practices....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

My Own Use of Language

This essay "My Own Use of Language" examines different samples of text written in different styles.... The writer of this essay analyzes language in both general and professional academic contexts, showing both differences and similarities of the language.... hellip; Endnotes usually appear at the end of the text....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Justification of Humanitarian Intervention: Studying the Case of Rwanda

Many working in the political arena - National Security Advisor Anthony Lake, State Department employee Prudence Bushnell, who was at the time acting deputy assistant secretary of state for African affairs and John Shattuck, who was U.... In theory, governments exist to protect the interests of their people....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Mandated Staffing Ratios

mandated staffing Ratios (Name) (Institution) mandated staffing ratios Introduction Different hospitals have been adopting different nurse staffing systems depending on different factors.... A controversy arose regarding the effectiveness of the mandated staffing ratios legislation.... This essay analyses the merits and demerits of mandated staffing ratios compared to acuity-based, flexible matrices established, through collaborative governance processes....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Analysis of the Economic Torts

However, in general, a tort is a legal wrong, whereby a Plaintiff has suffered damages due to the negligence or wrongful conduct of another person and must therefore be… What must be established is that the Plaintiff has suffered harm caused by the direct negligence or omission of the defendant and that there is a violation of a duty of care....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Drivers Working Hours Directive

The essay 'Drivers' working hours Directive' is devoted to the Council Directive 2000/XXX on the 'working hours of drivers of inner-city public transport' (the Directive) by all the Member States was 31st December 2003, which determines the daily routine of the urban public transport driver.... There was to be no overtime and drivers could request their employers to provide them with flexible working hours.... Workers cannot request flexible working hours....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

How Have Mandated Nurse Staffing Ratios Affected Hospitals

Overtime and long working hours have also been blamed for leading to nurses' job-related burnout and job dissatisfaction, which in turn result in a low nurse retention rate (Sanford, 2010).... Current literature demonstrates that the finance representative's argument is correct as the “time worked, overtime, and total hours worked per week have significant effects on errors” (Martin, 2015, p.... have already begun legislation on the regulation of mandatory nurse overtime by introducing laws that “either ban nurse mandatory overtime or limit the total number of hours nurses may work” (Bae, 2012, p....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us