StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Critical reading - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Here we must begin by the tricky question, should shared credit be given to Samuel Morse’s predecessors for invention of long distance communication? The reader’s end up concluding that - Morse is the one who made the telegraph…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Critical reading
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critical reading"

Critical Reading HSTC 1800 Assignment 5: Peer Review What was your first impression of the paper? Reading the research paper cultivate new ideas. Here we must begin by the tricky question, should shared credit be given to Samuel Morse’s predecessors for invention of long distance communication? The reader’s end up concluding that - Morse is the one who made the telegraph available to the general public, making communication- faster, easier and more convenient.
The concept of a telegraph was once established. But people never knew how accessible it could become until Morse. Things aren’t simpler as it seemed since he introduced it to the general public leading to a borderless world.
On the other hand it leads the reader to consider the knowledge that had been known to shape Morse’s telegraph. And this eventually drives them to question who should be credited for that.
It could be concluded that this paper is more analytical than argumentative, leaving the judgment to the reader. It is on a non-rational mode, analyzing two stands.
Identification and evaluation of the thesis
The paper has two thesis statements. One is that society should accept Samuel Morse’s declaration of his invention of the telegraph. And the second is shared credit should be given to his predecessors paving the road for long distance communication.
The thesis was clearly stated. Arguments to support both stands were presented but it was not balanced. The latter side was more substantiated, failing to lay down stronger arguments on why society should accept Morse’s claim.
The writer could have discussed about how Morse came up with the invention from his artistic background: how Morse had this device on his own design and how he developed this telegraph despite lacking the technical knowledge. The writer could also answer the question regarding what inspires him to do this demonstration.
Is the author presenting enough objections to his/her argument?
The writer had a good choice of information that were helpful to the development of the paper but is should improve the opposition of the two stands.
The outline was strategic and logical. The opening statements claim how important telegraph is, arousing the reader’s interest. The valuable contribution of Morse’s predecessors, especially Chappe’s was explained. It was written clearly, and because of the absence of jargons, it could be easily understood. The statement about how the telegraph changed the society is very necessary. However, the distinctness of Morse’s telegraph could be explained further.
Two strong oppositions have more potential to employ sound reasoning. In order to arrive at a good judgment, the reader must be provided with complete history.
Nevertheless, the research paper was well written.

References:
Johnsons M. (2008). Reading the American Past: Bedford/St. Martins.
MacKenna G. (2007). The Puritan Origins of American Patriotism. Yale University Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical reading Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 2”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1608799-critical-reading
(Critical Reading Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 2)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1608799-critical-reading.
“Critical Reading Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 2”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1608799-critical-reading.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critical reading

Critical reading response

...Questionnaire to determine the learning style of an individual. A person may either be a visual learner, and auditory learner, or a tactile learner. Aside from VARK, these are still several learning theories that demonstrate how the traditional school set-up may not be the only way to learn. School set-up is more of visual education, where everyone is asked to read most of the time. This puts the auditory and tactile learners at a disadvantage, as it is possible that they may learn as much if the teaching method is appropriate to their learning styles (Lujan 13). This says a lot if linked to Holt’s article on education. However, it requires a lot of restructuring of the current system. Personally, Holt’s ideas, no matter...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Critical Reading Reflection

...? CRITICAL READING REFLECTION OF THE BOOK LIVES ON THE BOUNDARY Introduction This essay will discuss the issues dealt with in the book Lives on the Boundary by Mike Rose and will include some direct references to Mike Rose’s story, and the stories of his students. There will also be a critical reflection about my own experiences that connect to the themes in Rose’s text, focussing on some of my experiences in school and in my family. In the book Lives on the Boundary, the author explores the challenges and successes associated with literacy within the American educational system. The author starts by stating that “this is a hopeful book about those who fail.” (Rose, M., 2005 p. xi) and...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Critical Reading Reflection

...?Other (s) Critical Reading Reflection Introduction The book “The mind at work” by Mike Rose is an interesting piece of work that offers a critical analysis of the contemporary American physical labor drawing on both cognitive psychology and current researches in social sciences. Born in 1944, Mike Rose is one of the greatest American literary scholars widely recognized for his insights into the struggles and challenges of working class Americans. Drawing from his personal experience, interviews, family memory and observational data, the author has effectively conveyed intellectual and emotional forces that are often associated with any form of physical work. Throughout his book, Rose...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Critical Reading assignment

...elections in the beginning of the century. Demonstrations and strikes also played a part in the initial reform processes. Such strikes and boycotts are ideal strategies in communicating information to the relevant authorities. The new system was a proposal to the public following recommendations by the Citizen’s Assembly. A critical evaluation of the system reveals its similarities with the STV electro systems around the world. This is where authorities fail to meet the needs of the public for self-interests. In relation with the STV use in Australia’s Senate, voters are not expected to rank candidates. This is to prevent voters from ranking unknown candidates or those that they do not opt to elect. Such considerations...
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review

Critical reading assignment

...Critical reading It is hard to believe today, that there was a period in history when Christian Jews and Muslims coexisted peacefully, or better saying in harmony. We are talking now about the period called “Golden Age”. In general it refers to the medieval Christian Spain. The position of the Jews is the most interesting (Cohen 3). Those, who live in the Ashkenazic lands, and those who live in Reconquista Spain had different rights and opportunities. Mark Cohen in his article “The Convivencia of Jews and Muslims in the High Middle age” described different sides of this problem. The scientist argued that the Jews-Muslim convivencia had contrasting political motives or goals. Some state that Jews and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Critical Reading

...Critical Reading & Comparison of Three Articles on Distance Education of the of the Article Graduate Preferences in Online Instruction Livengood, K. & Glamery, M. (2011): Graduate Students Preferences in Online Instruction. In M. Koehler & P. Mishra (Eds.), Proceedings of Society for Information Technology & Teacher Education International Conference 2011 (pp. 471-475). Chesapeake, VA: AACE. Knowledge List the main ideas in the piece The authors of this article purported to find out what were the most preferred methods of online instruction used by students. Define six terms from the piece Education: Knowledge than can be taught. Online: Using internet and web technologies. Website: collection of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

Critical Reading

...Eddie Zhu English 111 Merging Dreams of Lovers with Leftover Pizza: A Critical Analysis What is the true meaning of a poem? If someone asked you whatthe essence of a poem was, what would you say? If you were asked to write a poem, how would you go about doing so? In my view, a poem is a form of creative writing that is used to express thoughts, emotions, and events. A poem can sometimes convey a principle or a paradigm of a campaign or dreams that are yet to come true. There are many renowned poets, such as E.E.Cummings, T.S. Eliot, Robert Frost, Joyce Kilmer, and Amy Levy, who have made their mark on history. Besides these famous poems, there are plenty of people who write poems as a hobby or use it simply as a venue to...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Critical reading, thinking or writing;

...Critical Reading, Thinking, Writing AFFILIATION: Critical Reading, Thinking or Writing In today’s time, IT companies are seeking individuals who can give them competitive edge over their competitors. This can only be achieved if the employees of a company have good analytical skills. Hence, such companies will hire individuals who have the ability to critically read, write and think because only then these individuals can apply analytical skills. Critical thinking can be regarded as thinking which is achieved by means of certain tactics and skills. The use of these tactics and skills increases the likelihood of a desired...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Critical reading exercise

...and their limited chances for the protection against the abuses, neglects and poor health from the protection agencies. It views that several families in the areas suffer serious trauma considered as generational, grief caused by their endless problems and losses. The chapter also discusses vividly the different types of Trauma faced by women and children that may lead to the death of their babies (Plummer & Macionis 2000). Lessons learnt From the chapter reading I have learnt the dangers of taking alcohol and other drugs most especially to the pregnant mothers as it may lead to the early death of the child, giving birth to unhealthy child. It also illustrates the importance of child protection from the unfair treatments...
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review

Critical Reading and Critical Thinking

...Reflective Essay In academics, the value of critical reading and critical thinking is impossible to undermine. Critical reading implies a careful and analytical approach, with attention to minute details lest anything be overlooked. In order to establish an epistemic proportion about one’s own manner of rationalization at the time of reading, it is imperative that one should be able to clearly analyze what is written. It is the mind that makes and at the same time, it is only human to make errors. The apparent contradiction of this statement calls for special attention while reading. Ideally, it is to be done in full...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critical reading for FREE!

Contact Us