Free

The world I live in - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Capital punishment or death penalty is a punishment awarded to persons convicted of capital offences, whereby an individual is sentenced to death by the state as a penalty for a heinous crime. Murders, serial killings, rape and murder etc, where a perpetrator metes out…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
The world I live in
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The world I live in"

13 July An Analysis of Ethical Issues Involved in a Recent Event of Capital Punishment Introduction: Capital punishment or death penalty is a punishment awarded to persons convicted of capital offences, whereby an individual is sentenced to death by the state as a penalty for a heinous crime. Murders, serial killings, rape and murder etc, where a perpetrator metes out extreme cruelty to the victim as well as crimes against the state such as treason, can attract capital punishment. One of the most recent capital punishments in the US relates to the execution by “lethal injection” (Prentice, para. 12) on June 6 2012 awarded to Richard A Leavitt who has brutally murdered Danette Elg, a 31-year-old lady. The punishment by death, awarded in this case, corresponds to Aristotle’s ethical philosophy, which suggests that justice takes place when “all agents deserve equal concern of justice, in the quest to ensure that all agents get what they deserve and agents do not get what they do not deserve” (Aikin, para.34). It only appears ethically reasonable that a person who inflicts severe pain on another human being and takes away her life, deserves to die for that crime because such individuals may repeat the crime and become a threat to the society, if not dealt with severely.
Analysis of the Punishment and the Ethical Issues Involved in the Case:
Danette Elg, a 31 year old lady was cruelly murdered in her residence during July 1984 by Richard A Leavitt. The offender had stabbed her multiple times and cut off her sexual organs. The victim’s body was discovered days after her murder and was identified for police by her murderer. He was not arrested until December 1984, for the crime. Leavitts trial started on September 12, 1985 and Seventh District Judge, H Reynold George sentenced him to death, considering the extreme cruelty inflicted to the victim. The judge noted that the crime was monstrous, dreadful and cruel. Leavitt’s death warrant was issued and executed on June 6, 2012 by lethal injection, 28 years after committing the murder.
There can be both ethical and unethical issue involved in punishing an offender by the award of death penalty. In most cases, sometimes the judge may tend to ignore some of the ethical aspects and punish the offender without properly taking into consideration all the circumstances that led to the culmination of the crime. However, in the instant case, the Judge’s decision to execute Richard Leavitt appears ethical as the crime he had committed is gruesome, barbaric and extremely threatening to women as a whole. He wounded Danette Jean Elg “repeatedly with exceptional force, and had cut out her sexual organs” (Boone, para. 16). The extreme pain the perpetrator has meted out to the victim and the horrific violence, with which he carried out the crime, are so bizarre as to torment the human conscience. The court, in this instance, seems to have considered the ethical principles by showing fairness and justice to Danette Jean Elg. The ethics involved here concerns respecting the dignity, diversity and rights of individuals. Any person in his right sense will admit that this is an inhuman act that challenged the victim’s dignity and honor, apart from causing her enormous physical pain and mental agony. Thus, awarding any punishment less than death would not have served the purpose of justice in this case.
According to the view of the jury and the public, termination of the culprit’s life is the only justice that befits the case. However, despite the fact that the capital punishment given to the culprit is justified and falls within the framework of ethics, the emotional as well as the psychological torture that convict has undergone seems unethical. The first verdict to execute him was pronounced on December 19, 1985. However, the death sentence was carried out as late as June 6 2012 after 28 years because the case went on multiple appeals and none of the judges found a reason to overturn the death sentence. The culprit, no doubt, deserves the punishment, in a physical context. But when one considers the psychological aspects of human beings, it appears to be cruel to make the person languish in prison, waiting for his death to be carried out. Though the ethical issue does not directly relate to any of the courts, it still becomes relevant that it is the inadequacy of the law enforcement system. The system should have been able to expedite the execution by speeding up the disposal of appeals, without making the culprit wait for his death in such a state of agony and mental stress.
On another premise, the case of Leavitt can be perceived in the Utilitarian concept which suggests that the consequences of one’s action will maximize one’s well-being. Thus, on the flipside, it can be construed that the consequences of one’s negative action will maximize his agony. Since Richards Leavitt has committed such extreme cruelty to a woman, natural justice may have found its course in putting him through a similar trauma. Kant believes that the rights of humans can be classified into positive and negative. Positive right applies when a person does a good deed and negative right applies when one harms another. As Richard has committed such a heinous crime, he cannot claim any rights and his actions have led to his suffering, even though it may have entailed from the unethical conduct of others in the society.
Conclusion:
Capital punishment is a legal process, which sentences an individual to death by the state as a punishment for a heinous crime. While considering the ethical and non ethical aspects of capital punishment by examining the case of Richard A Leavitt, who has brutally killed Danette, one can conclude that the court has imparted justice to the family of Elg by following the ethical principles of utilitarian concept. As a human being, Leavitt has no right to take the life of Elg in such a brutal manner and he deserves the maximum punishment. The unethical aspect of the execution taking a long 28 years, causing him such mental trauma, can be construed as a limitation of the law enforcement system on one hand and a dramatic serving of natural justice by payback on the other.
Works Cited
Aikin, Sarah Tischler. Just Violence: Aristotelian Justification of Capital Punishment. California State University at Chico. n.d. Web. 2 June 2012. Boone, Rebecca. Richard Leavitt Executed For Murdering Danette Elg in Idaho in 1984. Huff Post Crime. 2012. Web. 2 June 2012. Prentice, George. Did You Stab Danette Elg? Death Row Inmate Undergoes Polygraph On Gruesome Murder. BIOSE Weekly. 2012. Web. 2 June 2012. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The world I live in Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
The world I live in Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1600063-the-world-i-live-in
(The World I Live in Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
The World I Live in Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1600063-the-world-i-live-in.
“The World I Live in Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1600063-the-world-i-live-in.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The world I live in

The Portrait Of Christ

...Each of the Gospels offers a portrait of Christ, and each portrait is distinct, reflecting that their audiences were distinct. As Barton points out,it is important to examine the Bible in both its historical cultural context and also in the context of our modern dayi. This essay will focus on the portrait that John has left us, and will explore the meaning of that portrait for today’s society, especially for Americans. It is the intention of this essay to show the special relevance of that portrait for the world I live in, and especially for women. Mark’s gospel was written earlier than the others, prior to 70 AD. Next came Matthew’s, then Luke’s. John’s gospel account was...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

How Should I live

...How Should I Live Many aspects of life affect how an individual should live. These include a community’s social-cultural, economic, biological and psychological aspects (Monroe 8). Socio-cultural aspects are those that involve a person’s inner being like, family’s wealth background, gender, religion, occupation, education, and even political views. Psychological aspects affect much about how an individual lives. For example, factors like socialization, sympathy, and recognition contribute much to one’s life. A person will live their life according to how they relate with other people. On the other hand, sympathy tells much about how a person...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

The Life I Want to Live

...The Life I Want to Live Registration Number Module Number and of Assignment Growing up, I was oblivious to the problems of the world. Like any other kid, I worried about not receiving the toys of my choice or getting scolded for my poor results at school. Life in Sao Paulo, the capital city of Brazil, was simple, yet comfortable. However, having been sent away from home to Switzerland has made me realize that life is not always a bed of roses. Although my initial feelings of being sent away greatly upset me, I was soon able to make friends from different parts of the world in the boarding school where I stayed and was gradually introduced to many different cultures. I also received the opportunity to learn about technology... the chance to...
2 Pages(500 words)Personal Statement

I Want To Live by Thom Jones

...“Will to Live, to Love and to be Loved Meaning of Life Introduction Thom Jones’s story “I Want to Live” puts significant effort in search of ‘what life is’. Meanwhile it deals with some subsidiary themes such as the meaning of life, compatibility between love and duty, etc. The author wants to tell his readers that life is essentially the will to live, to love and to be loved, while being to true to the ultimate reality, death. The narrative style along with some literary tools like symbolism, alliteration, metaphor, personification, etc. greatly contributes to the development of the story’s plot while working out the projected theme. From the beginning of illness, Mrs....
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The world we live in

...The World We Live In of Intersectionality In the human species, there are different types of individuals spread across the globe. People exist in diverse domains ranging from their ecosystems, character, looks, gender, believes to age. The diversity is so wide that it eventually covers all aspects of humanity. Everyone belongs to one group or another, and nobody is left out of the intersectionality web. Actually, intersectionality applies to everyone and not just some minority group or groups. Every individual represents one identity or another. Intersectionality is always not just how we see ourselves, but more of how the world itself sees us. The world tends to see...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Helen Keller

...26 June Helen Keller I) Introduction There is no shortage of generous adjectives used to describe Helen Keller; she was stoic, eager, diligent, brave, intelligent and committed to affecting the world. The author is mostly remembered as an advocate for the visually impaired, yet her influence in the literary world deserves just as much attention, if not more. The paper will explore the author’s early life, later political and social events and the world’s reactions to Keller’s work. Through an analysis of “The world I live in” it will be possible to determine why Keller is still one of the most influential writers of...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

A Place I Would Like to Live

...A Place I Would Like to Live Apparently, everyone has a dream of having a number of things in life. These dreams are individualistic in nature although at times there might have some similarity depending on the general perception of different persons. In light of this, I would like to settle down in the capital city of Finland known as Helsinki. It is defined as one of the global gateways to Finland, with the highest number of immigrant from other parts of the world such as Russia, Estonia, and Germany among other countries for its geographical position and rich culture. Firstly, its geographical feature is believed to be approximately 20,000 people per square...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The House I Live In

...The House I Live In Just as any other in America, war on drugs in my continues to target the poor who are the minority with nobody to defend them. More and more young people who could contribute positively to growth and development are being arrested almost on a daily basis for drug-related offenses. There are issues of unemployment, poor access to quality health services and education. Most of the people who are arrested and serve jail terms are the breadwinners in their families and so when they are arrested such families are left stranded. Domestic violence and family conflicts is a common problem. The initial step in addressing the drug abuse and drug trafficking problem is to engage the community....
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The House I Live In

...The House I Live in al Affiliation) The war against the use of drugs in the has led to a transition in the operational activities of drug traffickers. The operations have developed appropriately in response to the policies implemented to curb drug abuse. For instance, the drug traffickers have developed strong networks within the political networks (Sempruch, 2004). The drug trade occurs with the knowledge of the responsible authorities who controls the sector. The relevant agencies should focus on the need to have economic relations with the sources of finance on the war on drugs. This is to ensure that the sources of finance have the ability to be in a position to provide further funding on consequent drug wars. There needs... House I...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Sociological Theories: The House I Live In

...“The House I Live In”, it is apparent that this country sinks in highest degree of racism with the main race using war on drug policies to eliminate certain races in their midst. In other words, this society is using failed policies in fighting the drug within the society as machineries of conducting inhuman acts (Ritzer, 2014). It is only in the same society that citizens are happy and feel safe being in prisons and jails than rooming the streets freely; according to the, the outside world is unsafe for them. For instance, in the film, an inmate (Larry) admits that prison is the best place he will ever want to be (Bershen, 2012). According to him, it frees drug users from the underlying...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic The world I live in for FREE!

Contact Us