Peer Review and credibility assessment - Essay Example

Peer Review and Credibility Assessment No: Peer Review and Credibility Assessment Organization TheMaterial of the paper discusses the Department of the Homeland security and the various functionalities that are performed to help maintain a higher level of security in the region of United States. It looks like the material well describes the ideas that the essay is based on. The order of the paragraphs is quite formal and creates an interest of the reader in the writing. However, the paper lacks the logical explanations of facts about the 9/11 and corresponding situations.

Considering the length of the paper, it seems that the information on the paper is not in an adequate amount. Generally, the paper is in perfect flow, while the writer sometimes disrupted the sequence.CitationThere is a need to utilize the similar writing style and font throughout the paper except main headings and subheading. The font as well as the writing style in the citation and paper is not the same that look informal. Spacing between the lines is not same in the whole paper. However, the format of the citation is correct and according to the APA writing standards.

IntroductionThe introduction in the paper quite well introduces the paper and the content in the paper. The important factor of the introduction is the length of the introduction that makes it not only introducing the content but also discussing a bit of content. The writer quite well presented the facts in the introduction and clearly expressed the thesis statement that is “The value of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security is best understood by examining its genesis and the events that prompted its creation, evaluating its mission to understand the department’s goals, and analyzing its effectiveness as measured by a variety of matrices.

”BodyThe body of the paper is quite well distributed in paragraphs. Each point is well described in the writing; however, one paragraph has not adequate number of words that led to reduce the credibility of the point given in the paragraph. The points given in the paper have deep association with the thesis statement as each point tends to prove the statement. There is no unnecessary information given in the paper that is irrelevant to the topic.ConclusionThe conclusion in the paper summarizes the points in the paper and the concluding ideas that are derived from the content of the paper.

The conclusion proves the thesis statement to be correct.ContentThe content of the paper is well distributed in paragraphs. The title of the paper seems to be confusing and there is a need to write the notation of the words in the title of the paper. The writer employed his thought but supported then with proper citation.Credibility of the SourcesBooks are considered as the most credible sources to be considered as a source for the writing. However, government sites and other renowned websites and journal can also be considered as credible.

Few things can be considered in determining the credibility of the sources; through which regions the site belongs, does the site or the author published many journals or it is the first journal he published, etc. The sources related to the government department can be considered as credible sources. Thus the sources the writer employed are credible as only departmental article and news paper articles are sourced.