Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Violation of Patient Consent - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
In the article “Breach of Confidentiality: Did the Patient Have a Case?”, a medical case was brought up in which the working patient with ulcer was the plaintiff and her doctor was the defendant under trial. On the one hand, the patient argued that no discourse took place…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
Violation of Patient Consent
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Violation of Patient Consent"

Violation of Patient Consent In the article “Breach of Confidentiality: Did the Patient Have a Case?”, a medical case was brought up in which the working patient with ulcer was the plaintiff and her doctor was the defendant under trial. On the one hand, the patient argued that no discourse took place between her and the doctor regarding her problem with peptic ulcer yet contradictory to this, the defendant doctor claimed that the patient expressed full consent for the medical examination to be carried out for the sake of the plaintiff’s employer aiming to obtain a medical record of the employee based on the prevailing health conditions of the latter at the time. Though the meeting at the doctor’s office was held in dispute being the point of divergence from the two statements, the hearing managed to establish that at least both the doctor and the patient accurately identified each other due to recollected encounters at the hospital’s ER.
Apparently, the violation indicated that no authorization to examine was given to the defendant by the plaintiff such that factual details of results may not be divulged to the third party – company or employer of the patient – unless her full consent was granted. To help settle the issue, it was found that a form from the side of the third party had been signed by the patient worker and it particularly reflected that “she understood her medical record would form part of the company’s permanent record of her employment (Can. Fam. Physician, 790).” Her decision to have done so by signing was taken into account as a proper authorization and as an additional relief to the direction of the case, the doctor presented evidence wherein the medical documents handed over to the employer merely consisted of the information on the normal x-ray which the patient herself supplied the physician with. Moreover, the defending party proved innocence toward the alleged breach of confidentiality by showing the court an available note which manifested the patient’s written compliance to be examined by the physician. A portion of the defendant’s query about “indigestion” was responded to with “not now” by the plaintiff and this served another indispensable proof of the event of their conference within the doctor’s premise (Can. Fam. Physician).
The judge, accordingly, recognized that there emerged a cause of action when the plaintiff conveyed upset feelings on the basis of her misguided understanding of the breach of trust which she suspected to have occurred between her and the defendant. After supporting evidences from either side were thoroughly analyzed and carefully weighed, however, it turned out that indeed a discussion of the patient’s concern with ulcer transpired in the office of the attending physician who was also the defendant. Furthermore, the court perceived evasiveness in the attitude of the plaintiff whose expectation rested upon the hope that the doctor would provide false evaluation of her situation with ulcer to the company in third party by which she was employed.
Through the verdict and with fair considerations over the initial findings, the conflict could have been resolved had the doctor thought more seriously about the value of confidentiality in the patient’s point of view. Even if the College of Physicians and Surgeons did not necessitate any disciplinary action to cover the matter, it was pointed out that the doctor should have exercised more prudence in the decision to examine the patient much as he ought to have regarded with deeper interest the delicate task of specifying exactly which details can be disclosed and the extent of such disclosure to the third party.
Can. Fam. Physician. “Breach of Confidentiality: Did the Patient Have a Case?” CFP-MFC. Vol. 28: Apr 1962. Retrieved from on May 24, 2012. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Violation of Patient Consent Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Violation of Patient Consent Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“Violation of Patient Consent Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Violation of Patient Consent

Patient Autonomy and Consent

...? PATIENT AUTONOMY AND CONSENT Task Outline I. Introduction II. Patient autonomy, consent and interprofessional team work. III. Maintaining autonomy by gaining consent and working as team member in professional healthcare IV. conclusion Patient Autonomy and Consent I. Introduction Healthcare practice entails the provision of medical services to individuals in order to maintain their wellbeing. Usually, professionals referred to as healthcare practitioners carry out this exercise in accordance to the requirements of the law (Leino-Kilpi 2000). In most circumstances, these professionals are trained individuals who have acquired the skills required in the delivery of medical services. While on duty, medics usually conduct procedures... that...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Health Care Incident Reported in the News

...? Health Care Incident in the News of Health Care Incident in the News Chad Terhune’s article within the Los Angeles Times on May 5th 2012 reported State Regulators’ verdict on Redding Hospital which violated the confidentiality of its patient. The hospital is owned by the Prime Healthcare Services Inc. and is said to have shared the medical files of their patient Darlene Courtois with journalists. Moreover, the hospital disclosed the patient’s treatment though email to more than 780 hospital workers (Terhune, 2012). Courtois is a diabetic patient who was treated in Redding Hospital in 2010 did not consent to the decision of the hospital’s chief executive and medical officer in disclosing her treatment information. This followed... . It is in...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay


...The cause for this requirement of accomplishment comprise: a partial view of consent, bewilderment over what constitutes "informing," the techniques of achieving consent, the lack of a comprehensive theoretical base for consent, and reluctance by researchers. The imaginary view that individuals have the right to make assessment for themselves forms the root for well-versed consent. Nevertheless, this philosophy was included into consent guidelines only after frequent subject and patient mistreatment. Changes in consent processes have often been reason by political view rather than empirical study of informed...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay


...). For example, these may be as follows. Who can be considered as fully competent to give consent Who can be considered as fully competent to receive such consent From these two specificities, the research questions generated by the review, it is disclosed that one of the most sensitive issues surrounding retrieval of such information in the present day is the retrieval of such information for research. The principal ethics concerning retrieval for research purposes is acquiring consent of a competent authority in particular context to who can actually retrieve it - whether it is the patient him/herself or any other that is deemed competent The research may now...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Informed Consent

...related to the care and treatment that will be delivered to him/her by the health care professionals. (Mental Health Act 2005, 2005) On the other hand, patients below the age of 18 years old requires a parental guidance prior to the delivery of a specific treatment or care. (DOH, 2001a: p.4; DOH, 2001b: p. 7) For this study, the researcher will discuss about the pros and cons of informed consent and parents rights to access a child's medical records. In the process, the researcher will provide several cases to allow the readers to easily understand the subject of discussion. To enable the readers to have a better understanding with regards to the limitations of parents' rights to access a child's...
5 Pages(1250 words)Case Study

U08d1 Patient Consent and Health Care Ethics

...Running Head: U08D1 PATIENT CONSENT AND HEALTH CARE ETHICS u08d1 Patient Consent and Health Care Ethics Submitted by: XXXXXX Number: XXXXXX University of XXXXXXX The treatment of an individual is dependent not only on the need basis but also on a consent basis. Every individual as a patient has the rights to provide the doctors with a consent to go on with the medication that they will provide. There are a number of different consents that are generally needed for different types of activities. Consent simply implies that the person is aware of all of the procedures and agrees to let the doctor perform the same on them. These include express consent, implied consent, statutory consent and many more. In the health care industry... it is...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Patient Rights and Informed Consent

...Informed Consent vs. Educated Consent Informed consent or the right of every patient to understand the risks and liabilities of the procedure that they face is absolute and must be followed through by every physician. However, evidence has shown that patients do not understand the risks and liabilities of the procedures that they are undergoing. In essence, they are putting their lives in the hands of their medical professionals without those professionals making sure that their patients are properly educated about the risk involved. Three components exist in informed consent: first, that the patient...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Informed Consent

...28 November Informed consent Psychological healing of a sexually abused adolescent Purpose We are asking you to participate in a counseling program. This counseling program will psychologically heal a traumatized individual, especially when one has been sexually abused. People who participate in the counseling program will expose their feelings, experiences, and identify the abusers. More than 1000 people have benefitted from similar counseling program in the United States. In this counseling program, only one client is attended at a time during counseling. The counselor will use the information and identify the reasons to why the trauma keeps disturbing you now and then. You will need to visit our office three times per...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Patient Information Sheet and consent form

.... In 2014, all the patients, who participate in pulmonary rehabilitation at the Repatriation General Hospital, will be asked to do this maximal exercise cycle test as part of the standard pre pulmonary rehabilitation assessment. Data of this test will be used to further adjust your pulmonary rehabilitation exercises. If you participate in this research project, there is a 50% chance that you will and a 50% chance that you will not get this maximal exercise cycle test (we will decide this with the help of a computer program). If you will not be asked to do the maximal exercise cycle test, you will be offered the same pulmonary rehabilitation program that has been offered in the Repatriation General Hospital until the end...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Patient Consent/Patient Rights & Responsiblities/End of Life (SLP)

..., before it is performed (Torrey, 2014). This right requires patients to sign a document that states their doctors have provided that information. Patients are also entitled to a right of deciding how their lives can be terminated especially when that merciful killing is the only available option remaining. In the provided case study, Sparza’s (patient) rights were violated in a number of ways. First, she was made to sign the general admission forms and the surgical consent form that were all written in English and as mentioned she had little skills in English language. This means that her right to Understanding Informed Consent was...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Violation of Patient Consent for FREE!

Contact Us