Nobody downloaded yet

African Athena Controversy - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Author Martin Bernal, exposits that it is from the feelings of nationalism and racism that the Greek historians rejected the ancient view that the cultural diffusion of the Greeks from the…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
African Athena Controversy
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "African Athena Controversy"

Download file to see previous pages In his first volume, “The Fabrication of Ancient Greece”, the author has attacked the nineteenth century notion that Greeks were basically Aryans from the North and he proposes to dissolve his ideas from the Aryan Model to Ancient Model and stated that the religion of the Greeks were derived from the East with Egypt in particular. The controversy is that the western ideological thinkers have criticized Bernal’s views of the Greek’s influence (p.1). Bernal argues that the widely influential books like Flaubert’s Salambô (1862) suggested that the African cultures were pugnacious and uncivilized than that of the Greeks or the Romans. Bernal describes that Flaubert had originally meant to elucidate a historical novel about Egypt but later on fixed on ancient Carthage as his subject because the Egyptians were not sufficiently degenerated for his purposes. Bernal describes the authors’ work as a typical reflection of the western hypocrisy. “Flaubert implied that Europeans-with the possible exception of the English-were incapable of such things. In fact, the Romans outdid the Carthaginians in virtually every luxury and outrage while the Macedonians [i.e., Greeks] were not far behind” (p. 2). The paper focuses on the influence of the Greeks and the Phoenicians on the Greek society on the lines of Bernal’s elucidation in his “Black Athena” but at the same time criticizes his views and highlights the area of loopholes of his findings.
From the initial findings of the book Black Athena project, Bernal saw the competition between the Aryan and the revised models in terms of competitive plausibility from the documents of the Late Bronze Age in terms of archaeology, language, culture and religious rituals and historical analogy and topology (p.3). In terms of the archaeology and documents the evidence hardly points out to the Revised Ancient Model but in terms of cult and language the evidence supports the very dominance of the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“African Athena Controversy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
African Athena Controversy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1596604-african-athena-controversy
(African Athena Controversy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
African Athena Controversy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1596604-african-athena-controversy.
“African Athena Controversy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1596604-african-athena-controversy.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF African Athena Controversy

Abortion controversy

...Topic: Abortion Lecturer: Presentation: Introduction Abortion is one of the controversial issues in the contemporary society. It is the willful termination of pregnancy before giving birth leading to the death of the fetus. Elective abortion is the intended termination of pregnancy to satisfy personal interests of the pregnant woman. On the other hand, abortion that is recommended by the physician is usually meant to save the pregnant woman from the dangers she might be exposed to as a result of the pregnancy. In the philosophical perspective, abortion is evaluated on the moral status of the fetus. Despite the fetus having a moral right to life, it develops in the body of another person and therefore infringes the rights...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The Great Athena

... The Great Athena The Great Athena is a gold leafed statue in Nashville, Parthenon in Tennessee. This statue has been described as the true, unique and significant center piece in Nashville. The Athena is a statue of the ancient Goddess, Athena of Greece. The building where the statue is built is designed and constructed as an exact replica of the Greek Athena and Parthenon, the original structures in Athens. The Athena which stands 41 feet and 10 inches in height is approximately 12 tons heavy (Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County 1). Alan LeQuire was the sculptor behind the design and construction of the Great Athena. In his research, LeQuire found out that the original sculptor, Pheidias, built the Athena... on with...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Black Athena

...in the Greek culture. They hold the belief that any other kind of claim should be ignored as not having any foundational background. Another important aspect in the Black Athena is how Bermal failed to correctly identify the ethnic content of the Egyptians. He said in the Black Athena book that there was a mixture of South West European, African and Mediterenean racial groups. He did not clearly state the reasons why he could not classify Egyptians as the main source of civilization from the African context. He repeatedly alluded that Egyptians were black people but other critiques argued that these were people of Mediterranean origin and had the opportunity to adapt to...
3 Pages(750 words)Book Report/Review

The Hope Athena

...The Hope Athena For many artists, the inspiration for their works stems from the things that they know or have experience with. This is not only true for modern-day artists but was true for the ancients as well. The Italian Renaissance was spurred by a renewed interest in the sculptural achievements of ancient Rome just as the ancient Romans learned many of their techniques and ideas of expression from the Greeks. An example of this type of copying can be found in the Hope Athena, a Roman sculpture dating from the 2nd century AD. This statue is marble, more than 7 feet tall and has experienced some damage, but still provides us with a great deal of information about the society that produced it. ...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Odysseus's Relationship with Athena

...Odysseus's Relationship with Athena Prompt 1: Compare and contrast Odysseus's relationship with Athena to Job's relationship with God in an effort to define each respective culture's conception of a model relationship with the godhead. Athena was the patron goddess of Odysseus, which in some cases have been viewed as Penelope’s rival when it comes to his attention. While the notion that the gods, goddesses and demigods in Greek mythology coexists without insomuch as a dispute regarding their judgment, for the divinities have set the destiny of everyone—a destiny which they cannot run away from—the Christian relationship of the God and of mortals is a different case. Even from the setting that the two civilizations root... , which had...
4 Pages(1000 words)Admission/Application Essay

Controversy

...Controversy: Environment: Global Warming Summary An article by Boycoff in the open exchange forum ‘CounterSpin’ studies the patterns in the global temperature. Boycoff discusses how climate change remains a highly relevant issue at the end of the ‘00s. The role of the media is very much important in the public’s understanding of climate change because they often translate technical and often alienating terminologies for the people (Boycoff, 2010). They also influence citizens and how these citizens value the world. From the years 2000 to 2009, media coverage of climate change in five US newspapers has pointed out an outward path, with some major spikes (Boycoff, 2010). The increased attention on global warming seen in 2007... Environment:...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The African Athena Controversy

...by itself, by which Bernal is proud to articulate due to infinite possibilities with regards to the real origin of the ancient Greek culture. Another is that the parallel ideas present within the Semitic and the Hellenistic as with the Egyptian cultures can also draw other inferences with regards to the real relationship between the cultures, and ultimately, the initial influential body with regards to ancient Greek and Hellenistic civilizations. Works Cited Berlinerblau, Jacques. “The Aryan Models.” Berlinerblau, Jacques. Heresy in the University: The Black Athena Controversy and the Responsibilities of American Intellectuals. New Brunswick, New Jersey and London: Rutgers University Press, 1999....
5 Pages(1250 words)Thesis

The Great Athena

...Mohammed Hani English 1010 Chery Flanigan August, 6th, The Great Athena The Great Athena is a gold leafed statue in Nashville, Parthenon in Tennessee. This statue has been described as the true, unique and significant center piece in Nashville. The Athena is a statue of the ancient Goddess, Athena of Greece. The building where the statue is built is designed and constructed as an exact replica of the Greek Athena and Parthenon, the original structures in Athens. The Athena which stands 41 feet and 10 inches in height is approximately 12 tons heavy. Alan LeQuire was the sculptor behind the design and construction of the Great...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Controversy

...Proposed Solutions to Controversies Surrounding Healthcare in the United s Proposed Solutions to Controversies Surrounding Healthcare in the United States The overall fundamental problem with the healthcare system in the United States is the ever-rising cost of healthcare. It is important for the United States to carefully formulate and proceed to implement policies that will help the country reduce the over 17% of gross domestic product, or about $ 2.5 trillion that the country uses on healthcare each year (Francis, 2008). At present there are a number of solutions that can be implemented so as to resolve the current controversy surround the provision of healthcare within the United...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Controversy

...of the world with a Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of $181.3 billion, as on April, 2013 (OECD, 2013). Background Analysis Taxation in New Zealand is a vast and complex phenomenon. Since 1980, the country is going through significant tax reform programs for the purpose of restructuring its marginal tax rate system. In 2010, the marginal income tax rate was reduced from 66% to 33%, corporate tax rate was also diminished from 48% to 33%. GST (Goods and Service Tax) was introduced at a rate of 10% initially. However, imposition of Capital Gain Tax in New Zealand still remains a controversial issue. A Capital Gain Tax may be defined as the tax levied on realization of assets such as shares, bonds and properties or capital...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic African Athena Controversy for FREE!

Contact Us