Response Paper on On Being an Atheist, by H. J. McCloskey From a Christian Viewpoint - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
McCloskey (1968) takes the position that atheism represents a more reasonable and comfortable belief than that forwarded by belief systems associated with Christianity.  McCloskey argues his point by…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Response Paper on On Being an Atheist, by H. J. McCloskey From a Christian Viewpoint
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Response Paper on On Being an Atheist, by H. J. McCloskey From a Christian Viewpoint"

Download file to see previous pages While to some this position on face value may seem to have credibility, a careful analysis of the theories from a Christian perspective shows his arguments lacking.
The first thing that strikes is McCloskey’s choice of beginning his discourse with a usual and chronically pleading argument that would appear to make sense and put the entire onus of “believing” or of “faith” on a human need to want to believe, rather than a spiritual analysis of why we do. McCloskey puts forth that many theists take the position that “atheism is a cold, comfortless position,”1, and quotes one Christian as saying, “It’s harder if you don’t believe in God.” 2 McCloskey’s argument, which he extracts totally from this position, is a tired one at best, tied to a humanistic era [the 1960s] that overly promoted, at the exclusion of the spiritual founded in the intellectual, the concept of science, be it the science of human psychology or otherwise. “Proof” is the buzzword, a strange choice since proof of this overriding human need to feel comfortable in an uncomfortable world has never been proven, but is itself founded on the “discoveries” suggested by psychologists and sociologists and hardly based in solid scientific irrefutable fact. Much of McCloskey’s so called scientific approach falls far short of anything resembling proof.
Consider McCloskey’s cosmological argument as examined by Privette (2009). “McCloskey argued that the cosmological argument was an argument from the existence of the world, as we know it.   He stated that believing in an uncaused first cause of the universe is a problem because nothing about our universe forces us to that conclusion.”3 I agree with Privette and would use the following argument, as she has, with a few of my own thoughts added on the concept of contingencies. If ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Response Paper on On Being an Atheist, by H. J. McCloskey From a Essay”, n.d.)
Response Paper on On Being an Atheist, by H. J. McCloskey From a Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562849-response-paper-on-on-being-an-atheist-by-h-j-mccloskey-from-a-christian-viewpoint
(Response Paper on On Being an Atheist, by H. J. McCloskey From a Essay)
Response Paper on On Being an Atheist, by H. J. McCloskey From a Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562849-response-paper-on-on-being-an-atheist-by-h-j-mccloskey-from-a-christian-viewpoint.
“Response Paper on On Being an Atheist, by H. J. McCloskey From a Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1562849-response-paper-on-on-being-an-atheist-by-h-j-mccloskey-from-a-christian-viewpoint.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
CHRISTIAN SERVICE PAPER
...? The Heart of Christian Service Word Count: 805 I. Introduction The service which I have performed, the impact which myself and my God-given talentshave on others, and the impact which the people with whom and for whom I minister have on me has furnished me with many useful insights--when I take the time to reflect upon them in order to thank Jesus Christ. In this essay, I will comment by writing: 1) what elements of Christian ministry are highlighted in the chosen readings of Luke 4:16-21 and James 2:14-17; 2) how I can comment on today’s society from the perspective of Luke 16:19-25 and take an actionable response; 3) how my service relates to the elements of ministry in these...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
J&J
...? of the of the J&J Company The J&J Company manufactures the drug Tylenol which is used to cure flue and fever. However since it was first commercially released in the market, it has been in the limelight for various controversies. The reputation of the Company has greatly been tarnished by the stories of deaths which the drug had caused The J&J Company is faced with a dilemma because it cannot give direct warnings regarding specific organs as this would only cause confusion about the use of drug. Also they cannot mention about the risk of death on the warning label because people with suicidal tendencies may start using it. The drug...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
Response to McCloskey's Article On Being an Atheist
...?Response to McCloskey’s Article “On Being an Atheist” Introduction The philosophy of existence is arguably one of the most difficult, challenging and most widely contested branches of philosophy. No deep understanding of existence seems to provide absolute proof to all philosophers. One philosopher, theorist, or thinker comes up with an argument only to be contested by other lines of thought. McCloskey is perhaps one of the philosophers who have given the issue of existence of God a deep thought. His arguments on the article “On Being an Atheist” present a wide dimension of thought, discussion, and critique. In this...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Personal Viewpoint Paper
...to encounter numerous experiences, which significantly affect my perception and understanding of the occurrences in life. Through these experiences I have learnt numerous things which have enriched my life immensely. Though some occurred subconsciously, others were instigated discussions held between myself and friends. While discussing various lifetime experiences with my friends, something I had always ignored occurred. My friend informed me of the inherent discrepancies present between environments where people grow up. The friend informed me of how he grew in a Muslim dominated society, and the difficult experiences he underwent as a Christian. With a majority of the people being Muslims, the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Christian Service Paper
...always looked so sad. On my first day she would not talk to me. By the end of my service, she spoke to me every day. Some days she would not stop talking! Before my service ended, she said she was glad I cam to work at the Children’s Welfare Institute and that she hoped I would come back to visit. It made me feel very good. All of the children were great, but Maya was special because I felt like she really needed someone to look up to. Being away from her parents was scary for her and I feel like I made her life a little bit happier. The one thing I wished I could have done at the Children’s Welfare Institute was to connect with more children the way I connected with Maya. I realize that this was not possible, but the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Christian Service Paper
...?Christian Service Paper Table of Contents Thesis ment 3 Role at the Service Site 3 Initial Expectations and Alterations in the Viewpoints 3 Benefits of Christian Work 5 Surprises in the Christian Service Involvement 5 Change in the Understanding of the Community 6 Continuing Involvement 6 Raise Awareness about the Group 7 Most Difficult or Satisfying Aspects of My Work 7 Successes of the Project 8 Reflecting Values through Community Work 8 Uncomfortable Feelings 9 The Prayer 9 Work Cited 10 Thesis Statement This paper aims at providing a personal account of my experiences after participating in the Christian Services...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
This article, titled On Being an Atheist, was written by H. J. McCloskey
... the concerned people. This goes a long way in teaming up the positive spirits and constructive advice and thoughts. References McCloskey, H.J. (1962), “The Problem of Evil,” The Journal of Bible and Religion, 30:187-197, July McCloskey, H.J. (1968), “On Being an Atheist,” Question, 1:62-69. David L. L. (n.d.). The Problem of Evil, Pain and Suffering,[Online]. Available at: www.apologeticspress.org/pdfs/research_pdf/Problem-of-Evil-Pain-and-Suffer.pdf Accessed on 25 Nov 2010. Evans, C.S. (1985). Philosophy of religion: thinking about faith. Downers Grove, IL: Inter Varsity Press... On Being an Atheist On Being an Atheist The capabilities of an atheist would...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
7-2 Response to J. Brickner
...Response to J. Brickner’s Work on Accuracy, Reliability and Usefulness of Genetic Testing The issue of precision and reliability of the results of genetic tests results does not seem to arise in many cases where such results are used to determine materiality of an event or occurrence. However, the lack for competing ideas in genetic testing is worrying and scientists are already working to this end. In this paper, the views of one J. Brickner into the accuracy, reliability and usefulness of genetic testing are reviewed. Response In their work, Brickner points to some serious aspects regarding the issue of accuracy, reliability and usefulness of genetic...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Response: Importance of being hated
...Response: Important of being hated This article talks about the importance of having a few enemies for a person to makeachievements in life. The author develops his argument by expressing his negative attitude towards having a bunch of friends in his corner who end up betraying the trust bestowed on them. In his argument, he categorizes the people around a particular person into two: nemesis and archenemy. In this context, nemesis characters are those people that you despise. They are the characters that you cannot ignore but they are not pleasant to hang around them. You will help nemesis characters but you will always be careful in their presence. In my own analysis, nemesis characters are critiques...
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework
Atheist Manifesto
...it was not his intention. Twain’s work can be viewed as an atheist manifesto due to how it negatively paints God. It depicts God as uncaring Lord, one who enjoys the human suffering and failure. For example, Twains fourth and fifth letters talk about the story of Noah (Twain 7). However, it does not cover the pessimistic view that the Christians used to view it but a more pessimistic side. In specific, the fifth letter shows that Gods impacts in nature through the flood during Noahs time have continued to impact the world until today. It argues that even though the large animals had no fault, they were destroyed by a ruthless God. The two letters message to the Christians is the God...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic Response Paper on On Being an Atheist, by H. J. McCloskey From a Christian Viewpoint for FREE!
Contact Us