Does Billy receive a fair trial Herman Melville Billy Budd - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Much about the literary success of Herman Melville’s novella titled Billy Budd owes to the fact that it raises crucial questions about the moral aspects of justice. The ambiguous style of the narrative makes the story even more intriguing as the author leaves it to the…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
Does Billy receive a fair trial Herman Melville Billy Budd
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Does Billy receive a fair trial Herman Melville Billy Budd"

Does Billy Receive a Fair Trial? – Herman Melville’s Billy Budd Much about the literary success of Herman Melville’s novella d Billy Budd owes to the fact that it raises crucial questions about the moral aspects of justice. The ambiguous style of the narrative makes the story even more intriguing as the author leaves it to the penultimate chapter before revealing who actually killed John Claggart, the ship’s master-at-arms. The ensuing trial involves Captain Vere as the plaintiff and eye-witness to the murder. But this piece of information does not provide too much of literary scope to explore the unfathomable depth of Melville’s genius. The outcome of the trial goes to show how a composite plot, ably supported by ingenuity of narrative techniques, can be made analogous to a set of clandestine attributes of legal procedures. The thesis question to be resolved in this paper is whether Billy Budd receives a just trial or not, following the crime he commits after being charged with mutinous provocations.
Judgment on the fate of Billy is legitimized per se by a number of factors that are ingrained in the protagonist’s characteristic features as well as in some external stimuli. Minkowitz argues that while Billy embodies ‘moral goodness and grace’ and is well liked among his colleagues, the ship’s master-at-arms John Claggart is ‘sinister’ (4). This perplexes the readers for they know who the culprit is according to the law. But mere understanding of the legal righteousness fails to provide an accurate picture of the author’s intentions. Captain Vere, for instance, is portrayed as a person of contradictory dispositions. He is stuck between the loftier ethics of law, which he is supposed to adhere to out of his professional responsibilities, and the apparent leniency of divine justice. He is the only person who knows that Billy is both clean-handed and guilty (Parker 37) and yet, he must convict Billy for his crime.
It is apparent that the execution of Billy Budd symbolically represents a ‘justified animosity into a retributive righteousness’ (Melville 78). The question about whether Billy Budd receives justice or not is answered by Yannella:
…Vere prejudges the case against Billy, uses irregular proceedings to convict him, and then executes him in a gross miscarriage of justice…Vere’s conservative rationale for hanging Billy, of course, is that it will silence and tame the sailors, who otherwise will take the captain’s inaction as a sign of weakness and an excuse to rebel (27-8).
It is, therefore, quite clear that Billy Budd does not receive any providential clemency in the end, albeit his amicable demeanor made him a popular figure among the other shipmates. The external stimuli such as turbulence within the Royal Navy and the lurking threats of a rank mutiny condemn him more than anything else does.
Works Cited
Melville, Herman. Billy Budd. Babylon Dreams, 1966.
Minkowitz, Miriam. Herman Melville’s Billy Budd. Piscataway, New Jersey: Research &
Education Assoc., 1996.
Parker, Hershel. Reading Billy Budd. Evanston, Illinois: Northwestern University Press,
Yannella, Donald. New essays on Billy Budd. New York: Cambridge University Press,
2002. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Does Billy receive a fair trial Herman Melville Billy Budd Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Does Billy Receive a Fair Trial Herman Melville Billy Budd Essay)
“Does Billy Receive a Fair Trial Herman Melville Billy Budd Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Does Billy receive a fair trial Herman Melville Billy Budd

Herman Melvilles Billy Budd and Ralph Waldo Emersons Self Reliance

... Melville and Emerson: Kindred Ideologies Herman Melville, in his final work (and left unpublished until after his death), Billy Budd, is a novella that does much to exemplify the depravity of human nature and spiritual uncleanliness. More, after reading Ralph Waldo Emerson’s Self Reliance, there becomes a parallel between the two works that suggest similar ideologies about the human spirit and the functionality of self reliance. With that said, a close look will be taken into the character of Billy Budd to identify how he can be seen as the personification of Emerson’s theories, and more, to define the societal issues of the depravity of human nature. To begin with, Billy Budd is a unique story in that has often been interpreted... of...
3 Pages(750 words)Book Report/Review

Herman Melvilles Billy Budd

...?Herman Melville’sBilly Budd” Introduction “Billy Budd”, the unfinished novella by Herman Melville was started in the month of November in 1888 andwas continued till his death in the year of 1891. The book was not published till the year 1924. The novella, “Billy Budd” is regarded as the pivotal text in the career of Melville and contains a humiliating history pertaining to the editing of the novel which often exposes the misinterpretation of the notes forwarded by Melville under the poor transcription of the text. The plot of the novel...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Herman Melville's Billy Budd and Ralph Waldo Emerson's Self-Reliance

...Herman Melville’s Billy Budd and Ralph Waldo Emerson’s Self-Reliance Billy Budd was the last novel written by Herman Melville. One of his most famous works is Moby-Dick. There had been critics who stated that Billy Budd has quite a distinct relationship with Ralph Waldo Emerson’s Self-Reliance. As a matter of fact, it is not just those 2 literary works but a couple more works by the said two authors. However, there are also distinctions found in their works especially after the publication of Melville’s Moby-Dick. As McLoughlin quoted Charles Feidelson’s...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Billy Budd by Herman Melville and Self-Reliance by Ralph Waldo Emerson

...Billy Budd by Herman Melville and Self-Reliance by Ralph Waldo Emerson Introduction The narration Billy Budd portrays numerous personalities, but the focal personality is Billy. Additionally, Billy depicts most of the lessons from the narration. In the vessel Rights of Man, Billy is a moderator among his vessel affiliates. He is a leader, not through control, but by modelling. All the affiliates of the ship admire him and love him. Moreover, Billy possesses strength and splendour which might be symbolizing America at the epoch of the recording the narration. The writer...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Character Sketch of Billy Budd evil. With his stuttering he is tongue-tied and in such a grim situation he is rendered helpless by the speech impediment. His ignorance and innocence is linked to his physical deformity of stutter. Objectively, Budd breaks a major provision of the law; a crewman has slain an officer. He must die. Melville writes, “Billy Budd was formally convicted and sentenced to be hung at the yardarm in the early morn…” (88) As compared to the tall and divine character of Billy Budd, others look like pigmies. As he is lead to the gallows, he cries out, “God bless Captain Vere!” The novella concludes with a song composed by one of the sailors from...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Was justice served on Billy Why //read BILLY BUDD by

...Billy Budd The plot of Herman Melville’sBilly Budd” is simple. A young sailor Billy Budd, is falsely accused of sedition by the ship’s Master-at-Arms, John Claggart. Beside himself with resentment and indignation, he kills the slanderer with a strong blow during questioning. Under pressure from the Captain of HMS Bellipotent, the Hon. Edward Fairfax “Starry” Vere, who suspects the innocence of Budd, but cares primarily about maintaining discipline on the warship, the young sailor is court-martialled and executed as a warning to the crew. A moment before the execution, standing with a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Journal for Herman Melville, Billy Budd, the Sailor

...Task Billy Budd, the Sailor by Herman Melville Introduction Billy Budd, the Sailor by Herman Melville depicts an area of war aboard a war ship. Melville writes the story at the time when French uprising and insurgency had centered in the seas (Melville, 15). The emerging issues in the story are the emerging issues in the modern society (Snodgrass, 80). Summary Budd who was caught in the midst of jealousy and abhorrence garners the support from the ship crew even to those thought to be resolute. Budd is fallaciously accused of planning a...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Billy Budd by Herman Melville

...Billy Budd by Herman Melville In this case, it is undeniable the cause of Claggart’s death resulted from Billy’s action though he inadvertently meant to kill him (Melville 74). This was just a retaliation, which any other ordinary person would have result to especially if confronted with falsehoods meant to fix him or her and coerced to consent. This is because victim’s societal status is very low compared to the person who is compelling him or her. Since, the latter had malicious intentions meant to torture him more despite all along subjecting him (Billy) to untold sufferings based on unconfirmed hearsays. Based on...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Billy Budd

... individual whose popularity among the different workers in the ship attracts problems. For example, the antagonism and popularity make Claggart accuse him falsely. However, the provocation of his innocence does not stop until he strikes Claggart against the wrong accusations. In resolving the paradox, Melville guides readers by shifting attention from captain Vere and bringing into light the fact that evil fights the good. Furthermore, he puts into perspective military code responsible for Billy’s death. Works Cited Melville, Herman. Billy Budd, Sailor. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster, 2014. Print... Task: Billy Budd Presumption of innocence in Billy Budd’s...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Herman Melville

...episode Marriage bed and an entire chapter in Squeeze of the Hand taking about sailors tring to extract spermaceti fro whale that was dead. The theme of law and literature has also been explored in his works to a large extent especially in Billy Budd. Death and Legacy of Herman Melville. Herman Melville succumbed to heart attack in dying on morning of the 28th day of September, 1891 in his birth city of New York. The death occurred at his home, at the age of 72 years and no his death certificate the doctor indicate cardiac dilation as cause for his death. His remains were interred at the Woodlawn Cemetery of New York’s The Bronx...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Does Billy receive a fair trial Herman Melville Billy Budd for FREE!

Contact Us