Prison vs. Mental Institutions - PowerPoint Presentation Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
prisoners by 2003 have been confirmed mentally ill according to the U.S. Bureau of Justice (Okasha, par.2). This figure, that has a relatively varied through decades, is…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Prison vs. Mental Institutions
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Prison vs. Mental Institutions"

Prison vs. Mental s/Community-based Mental Health Programs Lisa Ware Humanities 205, Fall 2009, Section November ( ), 2009
Lisa Ware
Prof. ( )
Humanities 205
( ) November 2009
Prison vs. Mental Institutions/Community-based Mental Health Programs
I. Background Information
It is such a biting consequence to have come to learn completely that roughly 16% of the two million U.S. prisoners by 2003 have been confirmed mentally ill according to the U.S. Bureau of Justice (Okasha, par.2). This figure, that has a relatively varied through decades, is allusive of the mid-century turning point in the history of the nation’s mental health sector with the aftermath of de-institutionalization which set some 100,000 (Yglesias) mentally unstable patients free of institutionalized treatment the state budget used to cover. It was realized however that these individuals, due to partial and uncooperative neighborhood, could barely find proper settlements so the authorities saw it fit to incarcerate them with the law offenders instead of placing them back in mental hospitals. The inappropriate coexistence of prison inmates, both state and federal, with the psychologically sick ones to add to their number hence aggravates the latter’s condition as revealed by case findings bearing statistical evidence.
II. Critical Evaluation
Joanne Mariner, the article’s author, is basically a lawyer and a human rights advocate whose main point of argument in this entry concentrates on expressing contempt against deliberate imprisonment of the mentally ill as well as her proposition of humane solutions which she necessitates for the legislators or justice officials to have reforms (Mariner) sought after. Inevitably, this presentation has meant to empathize with the situation of its subject all throughout and reflects on the author’s uplifting aim to grant it the highest, most favorable value possible it deserves.
Since the mentally ill have long suffered from not only having inadequate treatment, resources and poor facilities but also at getting worse due to unethical approach by prison staff whose custody fails to respectfully and dutifully address the major issue with their irrational dependents, J. Mariner signifies the need to divert solutions to a more resourceful and less expensive non-rigid community-based mental health treatment programs. Knowing that it is essential to give due recognition to every human being’s rights and welfare, such programs would be inclined to seek genuine attention from voluntary individuals in the general public who’d be sold out to look after their unreasoning counterparts and so impart diligent involvement that is far from negligence, discrimination and abuse.
The overall tone and methodology used by the author may be said to have withstood exaggerating demands or unnecessary elaborations. In the effort to unify every critical perspective in her presentation, she makes it a point to sound constantly headed towards the main objective with a consistent level of enthusiasm built around the core. With the employment of a mode that leads to persuasion her article obviously finds crucial to meet, J. Mariner begins with being informative by briefly discussing a comprehensive statistical account to show how appalling the trend is of the dramatic growth in numbers of the mentally ill people put under incarceration. Even as she skips the mention of concrete cases, the gravity of her mere emphasis on their existence through credible sources, suggests a population density of the untreated subjects that can no longer afford further neglect. As it places conditioning in the mind, the content is developed from declarative to persuasive work on shifting paradigm which is later to ignite its emotion with the intended perception that serves for the reader a driving force to cooperate with an active sense of commitment when capable.
In the process of breaking down particulars of her concern to explain why it makes all the more sense to remove the mentally ill from jail, she has enumerated factors which tend to reverse direction of treatment. Cited reports of assault, sexual abuse, exploitation, and extortion by fellow inmates and jail officers contribute to a rather worsening psychological deterioration than the benefit of recovery if at all likely. J. Mariner finds it unsuitable to obtain resolution with or prefer mental institution to prison considering impracticalities of state funding on the latter while the budget is moderately tight and that de-institutionalization has become a legally accepted, unbreakable habit. To conclude her essay therefore, she offers to vie for a whole new alternative of utilizing flexible communities to make treatment of the mentally erratic undoubtedly forward.
Except for the questions I could ponder to raise on the feasibility of her option for corrective measure, I’m with every side of her successful argument when it comes to moral issue underlying mental health. It has been enough told and confirmed that prison is not in any way conducive to treat the mentally ill for having unqualified staff who are deficient with psychiatric knowledge and skills and compassionate means to handle them. To think of a contradiction that qualifies to assess it with reasonable doubt is implausible especially with the presence of taunting inmates in an unpropitious environment that has limited influential elements to enable sound cerebral functioning.
While re-institutionalization could help in a lot of wiser ways, the current state of economy might not be able to promise stable financial appropriation for its sustenance. On the other hand, living in a nation which tolerates an application that equates to criminalizing the mentally ill citizens as J. Mariner puts it, is imaginably despicable. Nothing can be more effectual than to expose mentally disordered individuals to public service in a community or setting where they can access greater stimuli to broaden the range of their responsive, normalized behavior and nourish their intellectual capacity since it can well execute assistance under movable constraints. Without walls and bars to be enclosed by, unlike in prison, an appreciably open place allows endless possibilities to exploring certain potentials as they perceive real support, protection, and fair and equal acknowledgment of rights with others. Mental health programs of this sort may then be predicted to warrant progress, and not adversity, to treatment of the mentally ill.
Works Cited
Mariner, Joanne. “Prisons as Mental Institutions: The Mass Incarceration of the Mentally Ill.” FindLaw. 27 October 2003. Thomson Reuters. 3 November 2009. Okasha, Ahmed. “Mental patients in prisons: punishment versus treatment?” World Psychiatry. February 2004. PubMed Central. 3 November 2009. Yglesias, Matthew. “Prisons and Mental Institutions Revisited.” YGLESIAS. 23 February 2009. Think Progress. 3 November 2009. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Prison vs. Mental Institutions PowerPoint Presentation”, n.d.)
Prison vs. Mental Institutions PowerPoint Presentation. Retrieved from
(Prison Vs. Mental Institutions PowerPoint Presentation)
Prison Vs. Mental Institutions PowerPoint Presentation.
“Prison Vs. Mental Institutions PowerPoint Presentation”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Prison vs. Mental Institutions

Alcatraz Prison

...Island, which is right outside San Francisco Bay. It earned its name from Juan Manuel de Ayala who named the island La Isla de los Alcatraces, which means island of the pelicans. Since its creation Alcatraz has served as an institution for multiple prisoners such as a military prison and then as a federal prison. The earliest history has the island serving as a prison for those in the Civil War. After serving as a military prison, it was turned over to the federal government in 1933. During this time it housed some of the most dangerous criminals of all time. It was closed in 1963 and now serves as a historical site, which can be toured...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Alcatraz Prison

...? Alcatraz Prison of the of the Concerned April 26, Alcatraz Prison Introduction Alcatraz is an island placed in the San Francisco Bay. It is located at a distance of 1.5 miles from San Francisco, California. People often do prefer to call this island ‘The Rock’. In the earlier days, this island used to serve as a light house. Later on, this island was used for a wide range of purposes like a military prison, a federal prison, and a military base. In the year 1976, Alcatraz was declared to be a national recreation area. In the current context, National Park Service operates Alcatraz as a historic site, lying within the domain of Golden Gate National Recreation Area...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

A Consideration of Prison Ethics: Punishment vs. Rehabilitation

...? A Consideration of Prison Ethics: Punishment vs. Rehabilitation The swing in Corrections ideology often moves between the idea of punishment (where one or society has been wronged against and should be able to get some form of retribution for his/their troubles) and rehabilitation – where an individual is not evil or wrong, but has acted in a manner that was the result of a string of consequences that were out of his control and therefore simply needs to be shown how to act as a decent human being. Although this is an extremely simplistic way of looking at the problem of punishment the fact is that over the centuries no-one has found an effective balance between the two ideals and that could be one of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Private Institutions vs. Public Institutions

...? Private s vs. Public s Public s vs. Private s Sociology of education is the in-depth scrutiny of the manner in which public institutions and personal or individual life experiences influence education and the general outcomes. The main concern of sociology of education is thus a close study of public school setups in the modernized and industrialized society. Sociology of education deals with what may unswervingly or indirectly have an impact on education. Here, the matters that may concern education should be sociological in nature. Primarily, sociology of education helps in understanding the entire education system, finding the strengths and weaknesses. In order to do proper...
11 Pages(2750 words)Research Paper

Prison Overcrowding

...of psychologists. Psychologists can help them to keep themselves away from further crimes and offences. Mentally ill prisonersPrisoners with mental illness can be identified at the very outset and it is better to divert them to mental asylum or hospitals where they will be better treated than inside the prison. For this, trained officers must be deployed so that mentally retarded offenders can be easily identified. Speed up the release procedure This is another area where the authorities pay less attention. Once the term of imprisonment is over, the inmate must be released with immediate effect. It should not take...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Prison Labour

... in 1930.17Although they are not binding, they provide guidance on minimal international standards concerning prison labour. They state that "all prisoners shall be required to work, subject to their physical and mental fitness".18They focus on the purpose of rehabilitation, 19 providing that "the organization and methods of work in the institutions shall resemble as closely as possible those of similar work outside institutions",20 and that "the interest of the prisoners and of their vocational training, however, must not be subordinated to the purpose of making financial profit from an industry in the institution".21 Finally, rule 73(1) provides that "preferably institutional industries and farms should not be operated directly... Running...
17 Pages(4250 words)Essay


...Running Head: PRISON; TREATMENT AND REHABILITATION OF OFFENDERS To What Extent Is Prison A Suitable Place For The Treatment And Rehabilitation Of Offenders [Writer's Name] [Name of Institution] To What Extent Is Prison A Suitable Place For The Treatment And Rehabilitation Of Offenders It is not clear that prisons, as institutions, have the competence to provide high quality rehabilitation services. Prisons are not at present designed to be schools or institutions; still less are they set up as places where trusted advisors can dispense either counseling or good counsel, or environments where family...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Prison Mental Health Services

... while they are incarcerated (Roskes et al., 1999). Mentally ill prisoners are more a risk for behavioral disturbances, acts of aggression, and disciplinary problems than non-mentally inmates (Rowen & Hayes, 1995). Untreated psychiatric symptoms are associated with assaults, self-injurious behavior, social withdrawal, and suicides within correctional facilities. (Hayes, 1995) The Supreme Court (Estelle vs. Gamble, 1976) established that it is unconstitutional under the eighth amendment to show indifference to the medical needs of prisoners. In Browning vs. Godwin (1977) it was determined that the right to medical treatment is not distinguishable from the right of mental health treatment. The American Psychiatric Association (2000... ....
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Prison Subculture

...the reasons for being raped in prison and the situation is aggravated by inept mental health practitioners whose assessment of the victim’s position is totally wrong. For instance, a male inmate in a state prison, told the Human Rights Watch that, I was put in a cell with a gang member who made me give him oral sex…I went to see a psychologist who told me that I’d caused that inmate to sexually abuse me…I can see that I was going through a brake down [sic] mentally.  Anyway, I’d made up my mind that I was taking my life….it is truly impossible to put into words what goes through one’s mind when becoming a victim of rape.  Being made into a person of no self worth,...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay


...Movie Review: The Longest Yard Affiliation: The movie, The Longest Yard, is set ina prison system that allows both inmates and prison guards to interact in more ways than just the normal prison routine. Using Adam Sandler as the main character, the movie presents ways and means through which prisoners can improve the quality of their life even after incarceration. The prison system within which the movie is set exhibits a number of major issues, all of which relate to the different stakeholders expected in a prison system. The prison management, security guards, inmates, and the external environment influence the manner...
3 Pages(750 words)Movie Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another PowerPoint Presentation on topic Prison vs. Mental Institutions for FREE!

Contact Us