Economics Article Commentary - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
With the local industries facing tough times and the job scenario taking a downward turn, the political leadership in the…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Economics Article Commentary
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Economics Article Commentary"

Economics Commentary Number: __________ of Extract: Protectionism is not Self-Defense; it may be politically popular but promoting it would surely deepen the recession
Source of Extract: US Banker
Date of Extract: 1 June 2009
Word Count: 550
Date the Commentary was written: 5 November 2009
Section of the Syllabus to which the Commentary Relates: International Trade
Name: ________
Number: ________
International Trade and Protectionism
Since the onset of the current economic meltdown, protectionism seems to have once again grabbed the interest and attention of the developed nations. With the local industries facing tough times and the job scenario taking a downward turn, the political leadership in the developed nations of Europe and North America is finding it propitious and suitable to profess allegiance to protectionism. The bygone Bush administration immensely raised the tariffs in the pre-election scenario. The American Recovery and Reinvestment plan promulgated by the Congress successfully incorporated ‘buy-America’ provisions into the document. The Obama administration is visibly tough on outsourcing. The French President is blatantly threatening the Eastern Europe to repatriate car-manufacturing operations to France. The British Prime Minister is vying for reserving the British jobs for the locals. The residents of the developed world, pressed by the recession, think that protectionism will secure their interest. However, the fact is that it will only deepen the crises rampant in the international trade.
Protectionism is the policy of restricting trade between the nations by resorting to restrictive regulations by the government of a state to discourage imports and to prevent the entry of foreign players in the local markets. These restrictive regulations may be of various types. The governments may impose tariffs that are taxes on the imported goods, thereby discouraging the importers and making the foreign goods costlier in the local markets. The other way is to resort quotas that is to limit the quantity of foreign goods, thereby increasing their price. Administrative rules are one other way of curtailing imports. The nations may opt for anti-dumping laws to reduce the entry of cheap foreign imports. A direct subsidy or export subsidy that is extending monetary support to the local industries and exporters is one other way of supporting protectionism. As far as monetary measures are concerned, the developed nations can reduce the price of their currencies by exchange rate manipulations, thereby making the imports dearer.
All this protectionism is against the spirit of free trade, which allows the traders to carry on their business activities without any government interference or regulations. The policy of protectionism will not only weaken the local industries in the developed nations by making them less competitive, but will also jeopardize the economies of the developing nations by disabling them from taking advantage of their comparative advantages. Besides, counter-protectionist policies resorted to by the developing nations could further harm the interests of the industries hailing from the developed nations. In fact as per the WTO, most of the member states have practically realized the counter productiveness of giving up before the temptation of going for protectionism in the present recessionary situation defined by a general economic decline and a fall in the GDP of nations for two consecutive years. Vying for protectionism in such tough times could give way to a vicious spiral in the international trade in the form of retaliatory measures by the affected nations.
Hence, it will be wise for the politicians in the developed nations to restrain from protectionism in the face of popular pressure. This will unnecessarily sustain the non-competitive local industries and may give way to trade wars that will jeopardize the international trade.
Protectionism is not Self-Defense; It may be politically popular but promoting it would surely deepen the recession.
Article from:
US Banker
Article date:
June 1, 2009
Rosta, Joseph

Byline: Joseph Rosta
Former President George W. Bush increased 300 tariffs in the final days of his administration; Congress successfully inserted "buy-America" provisions into the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act; French President Nicolas Sarkozy threatened to repatriate auto manufacturing from Eastern Europe; and UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown promised "British jobs for British workers." Desperate times often bring damaging measures. But protectionist acts will only further stifle world trade, thus lengthening and deepening the recession.
In Book IV, Chapter 2 of "The Wealth of Nations", Adam Smith makes clear his distaste for what the modern world calls protectionism: "To give the monopoly of the home-market to the produce of domestic industry...must, in almost all cases, be either a useless or a hurtful regulation." While G-20 nations and most other free-trading countries strive to meet the letter of international trade law, some appear to be skirting its spirit.
Indeed, the World Trade Organization regularly tracks "trade and trade-related measures," country by country. Its latest survey covered the September 2008 to March 2009 period, and pointed to more than 200 measures, often with multiple effects. Some of the actions are no doubt acceptable under WTO rules - and the organization says its listing "implies no judgment by the WTO Secretariat on whether or not such measure, or its intent, is protectionist in nature." But it is clear that, in many cases, the measures could limit imports.
Argentina, for example, introduced reference prices for "around 1,000 imported products considered sensitive," the WTO report states. State-sponsored reference pricing allows domestic companies to sell their goods at just below market prices, and is considered one of the basic non-tariff trade barriers.
The allure of protectionism is growing, the WTO says. "At the start of this year, most WTO members appeared to have successfully kept these pressures under control," according to most recent report from the director-general to the organizations Trade Policy Review Body. Now the barricades are going up, with higher tariffs, other restrictions, and anti-dumping actions on the rise. Although most stimulus bills "clearly favor the restoration of trade growth globally," several include trade-limiting government aid and subsidies, and various buying and hiring restrictions.
And as anti-trade measures pile up, "this will worsen the contraction of world trade and undermine confidence in an early and sustained recovery in global economic activity," the WTO says.
The world has experienced the misfortune of protectionism before. High tariffs didnt create the Great Depression, but they made it greater, making the downward spiral uncontrollable and unstoppable. Smoot-Hawley was a craven concession to the perceived public will, a pure play for votes. The law passed despite the failure of the Fordney-McCumber Tariff, enacted in 1922 to protect the American farmer. Fordney-McCumber greatly limited European agricultural imports. But overproduction eroded prices, and American farmers continued to suffer. So newly elected President Herbert Hoover raised tariffs even more. In no time other industries sought and were granted similar "protection," which was solidified by Smoot-Hawley in 1930.
An escalating imposition of retaliatory measures ensued amid already weakened economies, a self-destructive virus that strangled trade and was only wiped out by a world war.
"Clearly theres enough understanding that extreme trade wars can be destructive, and thats better than starting without that underlying belief," says David Levy, chairman and director of the Levy Forecasting Center. But the public grows impatient as the pain of recession intensifies. "Its difficult for politicians who want to stay in office - or alive, depending on their situation - too ignore the temptation," Levy observes. The G-20s defense of free trade is laudable. But when survival of key domestic industries is in doubt "its natural to say we cant have all those cars coming into the U.S. The nature of the debate changes."
Levy calls the U.S. the "800-pound gorilla because the importer has more clout in this situation." Protectionism could "push a particular player to default," leading to a panicked, downward spiral. The global economy is in a delicate state: "Rattle it and it can break," he warns.
The 300 tariff hikes signed by President Bush complied with WTO rules, and the "buy-America" provisions in the stimulus bill were altered to the same effect. But Brown still stands behind his "British jobs for British workers" cry, and Sarkozy has not withdrawn his repatriation remarks. This protectionist stance may win them votes, but it will harm their economies.
R. "Protectionism is not Self-Defense; It may be politically popular but promoting it would surely deepen the recession." US Banker. SourceMedia, Inc. 2009. HighBeam Research. 5 Nov. 2009 . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Economics Article Commentary Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Economics Article Commentary Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“Economics Article Commentary Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Economics Article Commentary

Moving Towards an Open World Economy

...Many misconceptions surround the move toward trade liberalization In "Moving towards an Open World Economy: the Next Phase," Robert Litan discusses the future of the World Trade Organization (WTO) after the round of talks and demonstration in Seattle. Major issues shape both the perceptions and reality of trade liberalization. In order to achieve its objectives of enhanced global commerce and competition through trade liberalization the WTO must help improve the political atmosphere for further liberalization. Governments should be engaging in less promise of job increases as a result of trade liberalization but should inform the public about the lasting increase in the global standard of living. They should also change... misconceptions...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Economics Incentivizing Thrift

...A Summary of the article incentivizing thrift by Ronald Wilcox: Introduction: The article incentivizing thrift by Ronald Wilcox highlights how savings can be encouraged in the economy, he states that consumers in the US have insufficient savings which may result into problems in the future, when there is higher savings then the individuals will be better off and at the same time the economy. The following is a discussion of some of the economic concepts in the article. Economic concepts: Savings: The article discusses the problem of savings in the US economy, consumers are consuming more and saving less and this may result into problems in the future. A consumer will consume a portion of his or her...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

International Economics many professions, for example in secretarial, and some customer services areas like call centers, and even in highly skilled professions like radiology and accountancy. The effect of this will be to relocate many millions of jobs away from richer countries and towards poorer countries like India which has an educated, English speaking workforce with lower wage costs. Binder recommends that America should resist the temptation to engage in protectionist activities, because these shifts are inevitable, but to promote instead workforce flexibility, aids to transition towards personal and local services, and better safety nets for displaced workers. The current transformational initiative of US economic reform is...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

Economics Article Analysis achieve the relative comparative advantage in international market due to the quality of the wine. The above graph shows the composition of how the total production in the country is sold. It clearly indicates that most of the wine produced in the country is exported to countries like UK, US, China and Hong Kong thus suggesting that the production of wine is mostly done for the purpose of exporting it. It is critical to note tha the article does not provide figures for the total local demand in order to assess the impact of the high exports on the local prices. Economic theory suggest that when the international prices are higher as compared to the local prices, suppliers tend to export more thus creating shortages...
5 Pages(1250 words)Article

Economics of Sports

... Economics of Sports An economic evaluation of the Moneyball Hypothesis by Jahn K. Hakes and Raymond D. Sauer is a journal analyzing Micheal Lewis’ book, Moneyball. The book faced criticism from economists and baseball insiders (Rosner & Kenneth, 361). The research question authors want to address is whether the assessment of skills for baseball players’ market was revoltingly ineffective as stated by Lewis in his book (Hakes & Sauer, 173). The methods used in examining the research question include theoretical and empirical approaches. The theoretical approach is used since the method involves a theoretical system that analyzed reasons why baseball players’ market failed to be productive. On the...
1 Pages(250 words)Article


... US President Obama and Fiscal Cliff US President Obama has declared in his first news conference, subsequent to victory after re-elections, in his call for high salaried persons in the US to reimburse additional money in excise and taxations in his first news conference since winning re-election. He ordered for rapid proceedings to chalk out tax increase on the initial $250,000 (£158,000) of earnings, but rejected to elevate tax rates for the richest to 2%. The year of 2012 serves as "fiscal cliff" for US by cost-cuts and taxes mounting. The year of fiscal cliff will also observe that George W Bush-period tax cuts ended up in amalgamation of repeated, across-the-panel decrease in armed forces and household spending. Loophole... US President...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

Communication in Economics

...Communication in Economics The realities of the banking sector in the U.S The banking industry in the U.S has recently been plagued by incessant backdoor deals that many economic analysts have criticized raucously, especially in the Wall Street journal. Banking is a vast industry that controls a significant portion of the U.S economy through lending, foreign exchange as well as creating the most convenient programs for companies and individuals to save. However, the reality behind the perceived success of banking in the U.S is concealing some illicit deals that are perpetuated by the very bigwigs at the helm in the industry. The most masked illegal covenant that takes place in deep secrecy in the U.S...
2 Pages(500 words)Article


...Commentaries The Political Bargain of Mr. Potus Potus was an outstanding president during his first tenure in office. He intensively invested in agriculture and financial services that doubled the economy. During his presidency, Potus was successful in ending civil strife by defense force camps in war-prone area. The president also unveiled a constitution that ensured equal distribution of national income. The major problem of Potus presidency, however, was nepotism. Critics questioned whether would manage to his seat. Opposition against Potus’ administration formed an all-inclusive-coalition that shows the face of diversity in the country. Whether Potus would be victorious following the allegations of corruption and...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Labor Economics

...Topic: Unemployment Article: Fed Should Push Unemployment Well Below 5%, Paper Says Introduction This paper reviews the article written by Pedro Nicolaci Da Costa on The Wall Street Journal about unemployment. The article “Fed Should Push Unemployment Well Below 5%, Paper Says” was published on March 25, 2015. This paper is organised as follow. First, a summary of the article is presented then I present my personal commentary on the issues in the article before concluding the paper. Summary of the Article The article reports of the study by Lawrence Ball, an economics professor and monetary expert at John Hopkins University. In the paper, Mr. Ball recommends that in order to keep unemployment levels...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

Economics of Geder

...Articles Citation Bagues, Manuel F., and Berta Esteve-Volart. Can Gender Parity Break The Glass Ceiling? Evidence from aRepeated Randomized Experiment. Review of Economic Studies 77.4 (2010): 1301-1328. Web. Jackson, Jerlando F. L., and Elizabeth M. O’Callaghan. What Do We Know About Glass Ceiling Effects? A Taxonomy and Critical Review to Inform Higher Education Research. Res High Educ 50.5 (2009): 460-482. Web. 11 June 2015. Weinberger, Catherine J. In Search Of The Glass Ceiling: Gender and Earnings Growth Among U.S. College...
1 Pages(250 words)Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Economics Article Commentary for FREE!

Contact Us