Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Refute an Argument regarding Immigration - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The presence of these ‘aliens’ increases the cost of health care and education. Jobs are lost because they will accept much less pay. Areas with high concentrations of…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Refute an Argument regarding Immigration
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Refute an Argument regarding Immigration"

Illegal Immigrants are the Real Losers The one-sided immigration debate is focused almost exclusively on the harms illegal immigrants perpetrate. The presence of these ‘aliens’ increases the cost of health care and education. Jobs are lost because they will accept much less pay. Areas with high concentrations of illegal immigrants are widely known to experience higher crime rates generally. Seemingly all we here about regarding this issue is the degree to which Americans are suffering due to illegal immigration. I submit it is the immigrants who are suffering to a much greater degree than legal residents. The scales of justice tip away from the illegal immigrant. It tips away from human and civil rights as well.
In the United States, overt discriminatory practices during all phases of the criminal justice system concerning ethnic minorities, especially those of African-American or Hispanic descent have been well-documented throughout the history of the country (Sampson & Lauritsen, 1997). In more recent years, various U.S. criminal agencies have increased their efforts to control a new type of minority group, namely illegal immigrants from Mexico and Central America. The U.S. passed the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994 which contains provisions that specifically target these groups by deterring employment opportunities for illegal immigrants and has provided a great deal of funding to the Immigration and Naturalization Service so it could increase efforts to diminish illegal immigration by stiffening border control tactics (McDonald, 1997).
The recent increased implementation of law enforcement measures which are exclusively aimed at minorities and immigrants has occurred not only in the U.S. but in European nations as well. A study that conducted research in both the U.S. and Europe showed that interactions between police agencies and interactions with immigrants are becoming increasingly tense as evidenced by a proliferation of physical and verbal abuse, a growing mutual distrust and an escalating threat of violence. In the U.S., “Discrimination against minorities occurs indirectly as a result of poor legal representation, language problems, high incidences of specific offenses (such as drug-related and immigration violations) and low level of employment status” (Marshall, 1997)
As compared to constituents of the socially dominant faction, illegal immigrants are much more liable to be detained, questioned, and searched by law enforcement officials. Once they have been arrested, minority members are also more likely to suffer police brutality and are more likely to be held in jail while waiting for their trial date instead of having an opportunity to post bond. When tried for a crime, they face a higher probability to be found guilty and are less apt to serve their sentences outside of prison such as serving community service. With the growing sentiment opposing immigration by non-white individuals and families, the discriminatory practices are unlikely to subside any time soon. (Marshall, 1997)
Immigrants built the country but are now an unwanted commodity. The federal government offers a type of amnesty to those already here but it and other governmental entities enacts laws that hamper the path to citizenship and restrict freedoms that are clearly outlined in the Constitution. It has been suggested that the U.S. could consider adopting similar immigration regulations as in the U.K. where a person cannot immigrate without first securing employment. Everybody wins, many jobs are awaiting immigrants who need them as have been evidenced by the number of those illegal aliens now working in the U.S. The U.S. economy also wins because of the higher tax base created by the new citizens the immigrants. Simple human compassion plus common sense minus prejudice is a sorely needed equation for the immigration debate.
Works Cited
Marshall, I. H. “Minorities, Migrants, and Crime: Diversity and Similarity across Europe and the United States” Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. (1997).
McDonald, W. F. “Crime and illegal immigration.” National Institute of Justice Journal. Vol. 232. (1997). pp. 2-10.
Sampson, R.J. & Lauritsen, J.L. “Racial and ethnic disparities in crime and criminal justice in the United States.” Ethnicity, Crime, and Immigration: Comparative and Cross-National Perspectives. M. Tonry (Ed.). Chicago, Chicago University Press. (1997). Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Refute an Argument regarding Immigration Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Refute an Argument Regarding Immigration Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“Refute an Argument Regarding Immigration Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Refute an Argument regarding Immigration


The Americans acquired its labor supply from; kidnap, misleading information and promises, some were a result of clan clashes and were sold by the labor brokers. In addition, the laborers from china sold themselves to offset the balances that they initially had from gamble. From the newspaper, the Chinese laborers called ‘coolie’ were shipped to America on vessels. The congress which the US president addressed majored on this aspect. This was passed from grant all the way up to pierce and the message was at an annual congress. The coolie trade was later prohibited and the American shippers were warned about the illicit enterprise they were engaged. The US government prohibited coolie trade and allowed only voluntary immigrants fr...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


... through which he presents the prevailing conflicts regarding immigration (Sampson 28-33). In his article, Rethinking Crime and Immigration, Robert Sampson reveals that immigration is indeed a social problem, and it greatly influences the society. The role played by immigration in the political discourse particularly in the political contests has been captured by the author in a very explicit manner capturing the real essence of immigration in America. Though the author specifically focuses on immigration as a social problem in the United States, it is evident that the predicament affects all countries without discrimination. Robert Sampson (29) asserts that cultural and social issues associated with immigration easily become subjects...
5 Pages(1250 words)Term Paper


...?Factors Affecting Integration of New Immigrants in the USA Literature Review There is a wide range of impacts of the immigration on society which includes the people of the host country as well as the immigrants. Impacts of immigration on society include but are not limited to culture shock, xenophobia, racism, bullying, constraints on the practice of religion, and different kinds of psychological and emotional problems. Immigration’s impact on the American society is profound because America has been the center of attraction of immigrants from the developing countries for centuries because of her extraordinary technological power and ever-growing opportunities. This can be estimated from the fact that with the total number of immigrants...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay


...?Immigrants and Immigration: DO ALL ILLEGAL ALIENS HAVE TO BE DEPORTED Immigration is the migration of individuals from one place to another which isusually done for a better future. United States is a developed country which faces the problem of illegal immigration from all over the world. Some however argue that illegal immigration is not a problem but rather a blessing in disguise. Immigrants from all over the world are entering United States illegally for a better prospect. Illegal immigration has been a deep rooted issue that has been subjected to many debates in the United States. The border which separates the United States and Mexico is an important ground which has led to speeding the process of this illegal immigration (Bowden...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Analyze the Conventional Wisdom Regarding the Iliegal Immigration Debate

...?Analyze the conventional wisdom regarding the illegal immigration debate The conventional wisdom regarding the illegal immigration debate is based upon the arguments in favor of and against illegal immigration. To be specific, the illegal immigrants, the human rights organizations and activists are in favor of illegal immigration. On the other side, politicians and others in America are against illegal immigration. From a different point of view, both sides have justifiable reasons to put forth their arguments because illegal immigration is an unresolved issue in the American society. Besides, the arguments on illegal immigration deeply influence the development of conventional wisdom on the same subject. Thesis statement...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Refute paper

... Section/# The Trouble with Statistics: An Article Refutation of Michelle Malkin’s “Obama’s Layoff Bomb” The problem with using statistics to prove a point is that many individuals, Michelle Malkin included, measure them over a period of time that best helps prove their central thesis, relies on odd measurement data, and seeks to draw inference where none would otherwise exist. This is very much demonstrated in Michelle Malkin’s piece “Obama’s Layoff Bomb”. This brief refutation piece will seek to lay out some of the reasons why Malkin’s piece falls short as well as specifically engage and refute key points that are salaciously put forward by her. It bears emphasis that the title of the piece as well as the timing in which it has come...
4 Pages(1000 words)Article

Confirm and refute

... about disastrous consequence is a pharmacist who refuses to add active ingredient needed to control the side effects of a piece of medicine. People who take the medicine can suffer dying consequence as a result of the omission. Refutation Regardless of the argument given earlier to confirm the wisdom in the maxim, there are core limitations in it that can be refuted using quotes and events. Generally, the refutation of the maxim seeks to claim that there is no merit in saying that the choices that people make, no matter how bad or wrong they may be should be a matter of concern for the larger society. In its most logical terms, it is understandable that all people are individual beings who come into this world alone and with their own...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay


The repercussion is dealt with in turn with a strong-willed defense of immigration. As time goes by, the debate becomes more intense; immigration will perhaps be a foremost issue in the politics of the near future and the next generation.
Some contestants in the debate dispute that immigration is an economic advantage to the nation but a catastrophe in cultural implications, that the latter dimension is more essential than the former; hence immigration should be trimmed down (Loveless, 1996). I have a different assessment. Persistent soaring immigration is likely to generate economic problems for the nation but as well provide key social opportunities, and because of this, immigration will contribute constructively to the nati...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay


...Refute to “Raise Wages Not Walls” Trainer’s Affiliation The agenda of illegal immigration has raised sensitivity in the economic world as well as in the economic arenas. While those in the government contend about applying walls versus imposing strict rules of identification in the employment industry, author to the “Raise Wages, Not Walls” assert that raising minimum wages will solve the issue (Dukaki & Mitchel, 2006). This paper refutes the assertion of the authors on eliminating illegal immigration by raising wages. Raising the minimum wage will cost the economys considerable number of jobs as the employers are likely to reduce the number of employees. Even with the possibilities of encouraging the American citizens to take the lowly...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay


... Immigration Introduction Immigration is one of the most important yet contentious social issue in the United States. The Obama administration has received immense criticism from both the elected leaders and the public owing to its controversial approach to the issue. Immigration is the migration of people from different countries to another country. Such is a major source of population growth and cultural diversity in the country. Despite such, the complex demographic phenomenon gives rise to a number of social problems such as identity theft, increasing crime rate and drug abuse among others. Peter Mathews argues in his book, Dollar Democracy, that the cause of every social ill in the country is legalized bribery of the elected leaders...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Security System In Reference To Immigration

 When James Hollifield delivered this paper at the 1989 Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association barely three months before the descend of the Berlin Wall he seemed to foretell the crisis situation which the member states of the European Union (at that time the European Community) and the United States would visage when coming to terms with the unprecedented international migration flows they experienced in the early 1990s. With the collapse of communism in Europe and the subsequent rise of irredentist and nationalist tendencies on a global scale, both Western Europe and the United States were faced with the challenge of sustained wide-scale migration flows into their territory throughout the early half of...
11 Pages(2750 words)Report

Canadian Immigration Policy

The differentiation of the local and global norms imposed a similar development on the country’s immigration policies and practices in order to successfully meet the requirements of the modern socio-cultural environment protecting both its residents but also the immigrants from any potential violations of their rights. However, the failure of cutting back the number of immigrants during the 1990s (which was characterized by significant difficulties in the labor market) proved the country’s inefficiency to restructure its immigration policies according to the needs and the strength of the Canadian market. Under these terms, current immigration policy appears to be based on the idea that ‘immigration generates econ...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Argument for Increased Prison Sentences in British Criminal Justice

The addition of prison time, while effective for keeping habitual criminals off the street, serves to further overcrowd prisons. This situation creates a ‘revolving door’ effect which releases violent criminals early and adds to an environment that is hardly conducive to rehabilitation.

A strong argument for increased prison sentences is the positive consequences of deterrence. However, the significant increase in the prison population has not correlated with a similar reduction in violent crime. The evidence showing whether an increase in prisoners is cost-effective in regards to a reduction of crime is mixed. Research demonstrates that “prison may have cost beneficial for violent crimes, but it also...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

The Human Rights Act 1998 and Immigration Control

As stated by O’Donnell (2004): “a truly democratic rule of law ensures political rights, civil liberties, and mechanisms of accountability which in turn affirms the political equality of all citizens and constrain political abuses of state power.” (p.32)

Various laws and policies have been designed to restrict entry for a variety of reasons. The reasons may be economic, as when foreign immigrants could take jobs that should have gone to citizens of the country. It can also be for reasons of security, quite relevant in this present time, considering the surfeit of terrorist bombings brought about by religious fundamentalism.

The primary Human Rights document in the United Kingdom is the Human...
11 Pages(2750 words)Term Paper

The Major Issues in the Debate Regarding the Existence of an Optimal Capital Structure

The level of capital has been used as a criterion for the classification of a company within its market. Regarding this issue it is noticed by Penrose (1952, 810 in Cooper, 1997, 750) that ‘positive profits can be treated as the criterion of natural selection -- the firms that make profits are selected or 'adopted' by the environment, others are rejected and disappear’On the other hand, Ruhnka (1985, 45) supported that ‘the primary source of capital for most start-up and development stage companies is equity capital raised through limited stock offerings that are exempt from expensive federal and state registration requirements’. In other words, the capital of the firm can be formulated through a series of...
13 Pages(3250 words)Term Paper

Social Support and Immigration

Social support from within the immigrant's own ethnic social network and from host social networks offers a means to address the issue of stress in the acculturation process. Social support gives the relevant support needs for the immigrant to cope with the stress factors of acculturation and have a more happy and peaceful in the new environment.
Immigration has been a part of human developmental history, with people trying to find better means of living or moving from areas of violent turmoil to more peaceful environments. In recent times most of the exodus has occurred from the less developed world to the developed world. The United States of America is exceptionally suited for any study related to immigration, as immigrati...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

British Involvement in Jewish Immigration to Palestine 1919-1939

Britain held close its cards on its motivation for throwing its support in one direction or another in the years between 1919 and 1939. Even though they were the force behind laying the foundation for the rise of Israel as an independent state, they also sent mixed messages making it difficult to say where, if anywhere, the British stood on Middle East relations and Israel.
While Britain’s role in the Middle East would change over the post World War I years, Britain acquired additional Middle Eastern territory following the war. Some Middle Eastern leaders sided with Germany during the war, and, as a result, in the aftermath of the war Britain’s Middle Eastern territories were increased (Kedourie, Elie, [Dann, Uri...
13 Pages(3250 words)Article

Immigration and Its Impact on the United Kingdom

For example, for farming communities, fertile and well-watered land has been a pull factor in migration. Business opportunities and political stability are also examples of pull factors.
Since the turn of the 20th century, Great Britain and Northern Ireland have experienced a great influx of foreigners migrating into the country due to pull or push factors. There have been different waves of migrations to the United Kingdom, which has had different impacts. Because of this, the United Kingdom has had to respond in several ways, which includes coming up with new acts on immigration, nationality, and providing asylum to refugees.1 However, the topic of migration to the United Kingdom has attracted different political views and...
23 Pages(5750 words)Assignment

The Immigration System in America

The higher education system of the United States is roughly comprised of 4,200 postsecondary institutions that have been accredited, attended by sixteen million learners, of which 565,321 are international students (Institute of International Education). These international students play a key role in the American higher education system. This is because they contribute over 13 billion U.S dollars to the American economy every year. Furthermore, most academic programs depend on them to carry out research and act as teaching assistants in important areas dealing with technology and research. Additionally, their diverse standpoints help to internationalize American classes and also enhance the value of discussion, teaching, and rese...
13 Pages(3250 words)Case Study

An Objective Argument that Justifies Globalization

The development and proper framework on globalization came out clearly through the establishment of international monetary funds that came up with four categorizations of globalization concepts. These included investments and capital movement, the transaction of trades, people’s migration and transfers of knowledge. It helped push the agenda of globalization of moving goods, capital and services across national boundaries into other territories (Bakari, n.d).
This paper aims to discuss globalization with a critical evaluation of its benefits and demerits across the various sectors of global operations. It aims to give an objective argument that justifies globalization and its processes as well as offers a gloom scenario...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Refute an Argument regarding Immigration for FREE!

Contact Us