Judith Jarvis Thomson's argument for limited abortion rights - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Include an explanation of the basis of her views, what she advocates as a position, and your reaction to that position.
Judith Jarvis Thomson’s essay titled A Defense of Abortion…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Judith Jarvis Thomsons argument for limited abortion rights
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Judith Jarvis Thomson's argument for limited abortion rights"

Judith Jarvis Thomsons argument for limited abortion rights: Please write an explication of Judith Jarvis Thomsons argument for limited abortion rights. Include an explanation of the basis of her views, what she advocates as a position, and your reaction to that position.
Judith Jarvis Thomson’s essay titled A Defense of Abortion serves as a polemic against some of the common objections made by pro-lifers. The first of her objections to the pro-life standpoint is regarding the status assigned to a human fetus. The pro-lifers argue that right from the moment of conception the fetus has to be assigned the same rights and respect that is granted to born individuals. Thomson takes issue with this assessment, arguing that a fetus cannot be equated with a born individual since the moment of conception, although she concedes that it is very difficult to exactly ascertain when a developing fetus deserves recognition as a human being.
The other point she makes is that on what grounds would pro-lifers oppose abortion when the pregnancy was the result of a rape. Judith Thomson is essentially trying to differentiate between cases of pregnancies that result due to negligence or indifference of either of the partners, and those which arise due to crime. It is on such grounds that the author expects special rights be granted for pregnant women to choose. She also thinks that it is unfair for anti-abortionists to expect a woman to invest so much of her physical and mental resources on a child that she does not want in the first place. The pregnant woman also carries the risk of complications during childbirth, which in some cases could even cost her life. She argues that those who talk about rights of unborn babies should also consider the risk of life to the woman who is carrying the baby. Here too, Thomson asks for special concessions to be made for pregnant woman who fall under high-risk category, namely those who have a history of complications, those who are physically weak or anemic, those who are too poor to take care of themselves, etc. Hence, the author is not in support of indiscriminate practice of abortion, but rather implores the readers to consider the vast gray areas in the issue and seeks a moderate approach from the lawmakers and the society at large.
Judith Thomson’s viewpoint on the issue of abortion is not fully compatible with the unique cultural values of our nation’s culture. In its 240 year history, the majority of American people have been religious. The foremost among religions practiced in the country is Christianity, the doctrine of which considers it a sin to abort a fetus at any stage of pregnancy. The argument against abortion is not so much a scientific one as it is based on moral values. Adherence to Christian practices is an important aspect of our cultural heritage and breaking away from it would jeopardize the foundation upon which the country thrives. This is a strong reason why abortion should not be encouraged. As for the legal angle, most states in America do not consider abortion as a crime. But some legislative changes are called for when we consider the fact that the existing liberal laws have encouraged indiscrete behavior among the country’s youth and have propagated such unsavory tendencies as promiscuous pre-marital sex.
Hence, I am quite convinced that abortion should be discouraged in our country for the reasons stated above. There a strong case against the practice from a moral and religious standpoint. Even on the legal front, granting legitimacy to the act of abortion would promote decadent tendencies in our society. This includes promiscuity, premarital sex, sexually transmitted diseases, lack of respect for the sanctity of life, etc. The act of abortion, moreover, puts the pregnant woman’s wellbeing in danger. I believe that there is only one reasonable condition under which a developing fetus could be aborted, namely when it puts the mother’s life in jeopardy. These rare cases of abortion should be carried out only after obtaining permission from authorized Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Apart from that, Judith Thomson’s liberal views on abortion do not appeal to me, for such concessions will undermine the cultural traditions of this country and also encourage irresponsible behavior in society. Hence the best approach to solving this issue would be to enact stringent laws against abortion, without many attached clauses of exceptions that could potentially be exploited. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Judith Jarvis Thomson's argument for limited abortion rights Essay”, n.d.)
Judith Jarvis Thomson's argument for limited abortion rights Essay. Retrieved from
(Judith Jarvis Thomson'S Argument for Limited Abortion Rights Essay)
Judith Jarvis Thomson'S Argument for Limited Abortion Rights Essay.
“Judith Jarvis Thomson'S Argument for Limited Abortion Rights Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Judith Jarvis Thomson's argument for limited abortion rights

Abortion and Womens Rights

...the decision regarding whether or not they would like to get their pregnancies aborted. This has led to a very heated argument because even though both men and women take part in sexual intercourse which may lead to pregnancy, only men are given the power to decide whether or not they want they child to be aborted. A woman, however, is a container for the foetus and without her the childbirth is not even possible (Shafak, n.p.). She needs to make the decision regarding whether or not she is capable of carrying the child in her womb for a period of 9 months. Every woman must have the right to make the decision regarding abortion depending upon a number of...
8 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Moral Obligation and Legal Duty

... of the treatment procedures for the patients. Bibliography: Boonin-Vail, David, ‘A Defense of “A Defense of Abortion”: On the Responsibility Objection to Thomson’s Argument’ (1997) 107(2) Ethics 286, 313 Cline, Austin, ‘Ethics of Abortion: Is it Moral or Immoral to Have an Abortion?’ (, 2012) accessed 12 February 2012 Gardner, John, ‘Law and Morality’ (nd) accessed 12 February 2012 Thomson, Judith Jarvis, ‘Judith Jarvis Thomson: A Defense of Abortion’ (1971) 1(1) Philosophy & Public Affairs accessed 12 February 2012 ‘Termination... medical laws other than the law of clinical negligence with an intent to evaluate whether the extent to which the enforcers of these laws see a moral obligation to their duties. For this, the issues...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Abortion and the Rogerian Argument

..., J. (2004). The Problem of Abortion: Essentially Contested Concepts and Moral Autonomy. Bioethics, 18(3): pp. 221-233. Jesudason, S. & Epstein, J. (2011). The paradox of disability in abortion debates: bringing the pro-choice and disability rights communities together. Contraception, 84: pp. 541-543. Jones, K. & Chaloner, C. (2007). Ethics of abortion: the arguments for and against. Nursing Standard, 21(37): pp. 45-48. Kaposy, C. (2012). Two Stalemates in the Philosophical Debate about Abortion and Why They Cannot be Resolved Using Analogical Arguments. Bioethics, 26(2): pp. 84-92. Lipp, A. (2008)....
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Ethical argument-Abortion

...argument is that at what point it is morally wise to charge fetal life as human life. Too much stress on the fetus can lead to an abstracting from the important role the woman's body plays in the development of a child. In speaking of the view of convinced critics that the status of the child is the most important issue to resolve in the abortion controversy, Marquis gives examples of pain on animals (Stetson 101). The second controversy is that Marques states: "Presumably abortion could be justified in some circumstances, only of the loss consequent on failing to abort would be at least as great" (Marquis). He does not take into account that women should have a...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Judith Thomsons' Defense of Abortion

...the mother chooses to have a child, in other situations – most prominently rape – this happens without her will. This argument is effective in demonstrating the absurdity of forcing an individual to go through the nine-month pregnancy procedure entirely against their will. While many people would support the recognition that it is a good practice to help other individuals, particularly famous violinists, the notion that individuals should be forced to aid another person against their will crosses an ethical line. I believe that in situations where the individual was impregnated against their will, the ultimate decision as to what should occur with their bodies should be the individual’s. Although it’s upsetting that...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Abortion Argument - Ethics class

...cell research and abortion will be eliminated. I think the overall argument is faulty, to me it is no different than asking the question does organ donation increase suicide rates in order to donate more organs to those who need them? It is, in my mind, a biased attempt to gain support from those people who already have feelings against abortion to associate stem cell research with something that they already find disagreeable, forcing them to marry the two concepts in their minds; if one is “bad” then they both must be. In fact, stem cell research has nothing directly to do with abortions that are performed. The idea that this proposed increase in...
1 Pages(250 words)Personal Statement


...Abortion Judith Jarvis Thomson makes a strong argument on the permissibility and impermissibility of abortion by pursuing more limited conclusions, which indicate that abortion can be permitted under different circumstances while other circumstances make it impermissible. She develops her argument on the fundamental right to life of humans a point used by groups opposed to abortion. The argument follows that life begins at conception, and this empowers a fetus to be considered a living being on conception and as such should be accorded...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Argument about abortion

...Abortion Debate Abortion The issue of abortion has generated huge debates in various societies around the world. Such debate has also been witnessed among politicians. An example of such debate took place between Gyan and Biden. The paper seeks to focus on analyzing this debate and take a stand on the issue. Abortion is the intentional termination of pregnancy, and the exercise is usually conducted in the first 28 weeks after conception (Grisanti, 2000). Consequently, there are many arguments regarding abortion, and the topic has caused debate that has led to two groups of people. Some of the people believe in abortion while others are against abortion. From the video discussion between Gyan and Biden shows how people differ... in their...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Judith Thomsons Responsibility Argument

...Judith Thomson’s Responsibility Argument. Introduction If one examines the public dis one can not find an issue that has been more controversial than the issue of abortion. Unlike other problems that mostly deal with the abstract concepts, this one engages the most fundamental ones such as life and death. Indeed, the questions that abortion raises do not only concern right and wrong, they also focuse on the value of life of a person. While some people prefer to think that fetus is not a human being, others point out that it should not be treated as a mechanical aggregation of cell, but an individual that has rights. That...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Thomson's paper" A Defense of Abortion"

..., but none of them was clearly defined. That makes all article rather not solid, randomly answering a bunch of contradicting questions bound by one topic but still too different to mix them this way. These mistakes result in an article, which main goal was to counteract idealistic thoughts by means of harsh examples of real life, where person is not obliged to anyone to be good, whether it is human or inhuman - until so-called inhumanity is limited by her survival – turning into a propaganda of abortion. Overly emotional unbalanced answer, that addressed only one side of a conflict, was automatically counted as a support of the other side of it. The article that limits the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Judith Jarvis Thomson's argument for limited abortion rights for FREE!

Contact Us