StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Issue of Gender Reaction to Workplace Diversity - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Issue of Gender Reaction to Workplace Diversity" describes that the authors suggest that the information presented will help managers be to provide women support in male-dominated workgroups and ease levels of stereotyping for both genders. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
The Issue of Gender Reaction to Workplace Diversity
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Issue of Gender Reaction to Workplace Diversity"

A summarizing critique of Asymmetric reactions to work group sex diversity among men and women by Jennifer A. Chatman and Charles A. O’Reilly (2004),Academy of Management Journal, 47(2), 193-208. The article explores the issue of gender reaction to workplace diversity and the sex’s response to groupings of those with similar, or different, sexes. Previous research has explored how men and women respond to gender dominance in the workplace (Tsui, Egan, and O’Reilly, 1992). Prior studies have focused on the similarity-attraction hypothesis only. Chatman and O’Reilly find this hypothesis to be too straightforward to fully capture the variable of gender in work groups. Specifically, various studies have found that men may react negatively to a male dominated work environment, while women were more likely to be democratic toward men when the work group was female dominated (Konrad, Winter, and Gutek, 1992). The authors note that previous studies have relied on information that was gathered in environments where there were very few instances of female presence (p. 194). The issue of female underrepresentation in the work groups has also been a concern for feminists and researchers for a number of years (Syed and Murray, 2008) (Francoeur et al. 2008). The authors extend this hypothesis to include environments that are male dominated, female dominated, exclusively male or female, and a balanced number of men and women. By adding these other factors the study has not only separated itself from previous research, but enabled the examination of the issue of group sex diversity from various angles while avoiding a focus on similarity-attraction predictions. Chatman and O’Reilly put forth a study using deductive reasoning and a set of hypotheses that examine the relationship of men and women to the gender proportion of their work groups. The authors begin the study by examining general observations about gender in the work groups and go on to narrow their observations and previous research into a set of hypotheses. The first, hypothesis 1, is concerned with male and female preference for inclusion in higher status work groups and secondly, hypothesis 2a proposes that men and women in groups that are dominated by their own gender will be more committed to the organization. In addition those in groups that are dominated by their own gender will express a higher positive affect as proposed in hypothesis 2b. Lastly hypothesis 2c suggests that those in groups where their own gender is dominate will believe those groups are more cooperating than groups dominated by the opposite sex (p. 196). The authors conducted a quantitative study examining 189 professionals of both genders who were surveyed about their beliefs and attitudes concerning the issue of gender diversity in the workplace. Subsequently 11 participants were dropped from the study because they did not complete their responses, or their overall data was incomplete leaving a total of 178 that were fully surveyed (p. 196). The individuals selected comprised a clothing manufacturer and retailer and were professionals as opposed to production workers. The independent variables included questions on gender and work group sex composition (which were ascertained from company records). The dependant variables were the employees likelihood to transfer from their current work group and their normative commitment to the organization (by which the authors used a preexisting eight-item scale ranging from 1= “strongly disagree, 5 = “strongly agree” (p. 197). Also among the dependant variables were positive affects, and work group cooperation. In addition the control variables include a description of how the participants felt about aspects of their employment, their age, race, and group size. There were also a number of dummy variables including some that were subsequently dropped from the study. The results of the findings were very interesting in that some hypotheses are more adequately supported than others. The authors found “that women reported a significantly higher likelihood of transferring out of homogeneous same-sex groups than did men (p. 198). This evidence supports the first hypothesis that women overall would display a propensity or want to leave a work group because of the same sex domination. Next the research indicated evidence that women expressed a higher level of normative commitment and men that worked in homogeneous groups were not as normatively committed to the organization when compared to men working in male dominated groups or balanced work groups which only partially supports hypothesis 2a (p. 199). The authors also discovered that women in male dominated group settings expressed a lower level of positive affect in comparison to those in homogeneous groups and in contradiction to hypothesis 2b, men involved in homogenous atmospheres expressed the lowest levels of positive affect (p. 200). Lastly when examining hypothesis 2c “women viewed their female-dominated work groups as more cooperative than men viewed their male-dominated work groups as being” (p. 200). As a whole the result of the study leads to some very interesting conclusions about gender in work groups and how both sexes respond to domination or balance by either gender. As a whole the authors were able to discover some credible conclusions using quantitative research and numerical calculations of that research as evidenced by the graphs and statistical data. The authors were successful at taking the similarity-attraction theory and making it malleable enough to create extensions of the theory itself (Ibarra, 1992). The researchers recognize limitations explaining that the business they studied possessed an atypical makeup of both minorities and women. This makeup does not affect the overall outcome of the study and is a statistic that has increased overtime, especially in the business (Campbell and Minguez-Vera, 2008). The authors note that they do not actually measure job performance in the study or consider how gender diversity could possibly play a role when considering performance. This is definitely an area that needs to be explored in the future because in the workplace the most important factor is actual job performance. This certainly could have been an area, if addressed, the researchers might have used to bolster the significance of the overall study and the result gathered. So what are the benefits of possessing the information derived from this study? This is a possible question the readers may be left to ask themselves. The authors suggest that the information presented will help managers be to provide women support in male-dominated work groups and ease levels of stereotyping for both genders. While this observation makes since the authors fail to acknowledge exactly what actions managers could take to do this, and how their research alludes to those action. They have adequately placed the research in a feasible context, while not providing a usability element for the research itself. Bibliography Campbell, K., Minguez-Vera, A. (2008). ‘Gender diversity in the boardroom and firm financial support, Journal of Business Ethics’. Vol. 83, 435-451. Chatman, J.A. and O’Reilly C.A. (2004), ‘Asymmetric reactions to work group sex diversity among men and women’. Academy of Management Journal, Vol. 47, No. 2, 193-208. D’Intino, R.S., Goldsby, M.G., Houghton, J.D., and Neck, C.P. (2007). ‘Self-Leadership: A process for entrepreneurial success’. Journal of Leadership and Organizational Studies. Vol. 13, No. 4, 105-120. Francoeur, C., Labelle, R., Sinclair-Desgagne, B. (2008) ‘Gender diversity in corporate governance and top management.’ Vol. 81, 83-95. Ibarra, H. (1992). Homophily and differential returns: Sex differences in network structure and access in an advertising firm. Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol. 37, 442-447. Karakowsky, L., & Siegel, J. (1999). The effects of proportional representation and gender orientation of the task on emergent leadership behavior in mixed-gender work groups. Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 84, 339-348. Konrad, A., & Cannings, K. (1997) The effects of gender role congruence and statistical discrimination on managerial advancement. Human Relations, Vol. 50, 1305-1328. Konrad, A., Winter, S., & Gutek, B. (1992). Diversity in work group sex composition. Research in the sociology of organizations.Vol. 10, 115-140. Syed, J., Murray, P.A. (2008). ‘A cultural feminist approach towards managing diversity in top management teams’. Vol. 27, No. 5, 413-432. Tsui, A., Egan, T., & O’Reilly, C (1992), ‘Being different: Relational demography and organizational attachment’. Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol. 3, 549-579. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A brief critical analysis of Asymmetric reactions to work group sex Article”, n.d.)
A brief critical analysis of Asymmetric reactions to work group sex Article. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1555958-a-brief-critical-analysis-of-asymmetric-reactions-to-work-group-sex-diversity-among-men-and-women-by-chatman-oreilly-2004-academy-of-management-journal-vol47-no2-193-208
(A Brief Critical Analysis of Asymmetric Reactions to Work Group Sex Article)
A Brief Critical Analysis of Asymmetric Reactions to Work Group Sex Article. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1555958-a-brief-critical-analysis-of-asymmetric-reactions-to-work-group-sex-diversity-among-men-and-women-by-chatman-oreilly-2004-academy-of-management-journal-vol47-no2-193-208.
“A Brief Critical Analysis of Asymmetric Reactions to Work Group Sex Article”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1555958-a-brief-critical-analysis-of-asymmetric-reactions-to-work-group-sex-diversity-among-men-and-women-by-chatman-oreilly-2004-academy-of-management-journal-vol47-no2-193-208.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Issue of Gender Reaction to Workplace Diversity

The Benefits of Gender Diversity in the Workplace

Gender diversity with regard to workplace has been defined as the comprehension and recognition of employees of both the genders.... Gender Diversity in Workplace The idea of gender is primarily based on the dissimilarities of features amid the individuals of different sex.... The notion of gender diversity relates to the actuality of the existence of variation in terms of the genes with regard to a species.... The major guiding forces of gender diversity within the workplace are the women employees....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Rethinking the policies : motivation and managing diversity

In diversity management, the issue of inequality plays a fundamental role in the success of an organization.... the issue of equality in workplaces is supported by Legislation structured to address issues of discrimination on employees.... Name: Tutor: Course: Date: University: Rethinking the policies – motivation and managing diversity Introduction Over the last several decades, the UK has experienced rapid changes within the work environment....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The American Gay Rights Movement

This society is also known to be the earliest known gay rights organization.... Since then, many other events have taken place in order for the gay community.... ... ... In 1958, Caffe Cino opened and six years later, it began hosting its first gay plays.... In 1969, the Stonewall incident turned the gay rights movement into a massive protest for acceptance and equal rights....
39 Pages (9750 words) Research Paper

Managing Diversity Awareness Campaign

Employees in an organization are identified to vary on the basis of gender and demographic characteristics for which the employees are identified to be having their own personal and professional goals.... Gender management is important, as it increases the scope of gender diversity and enables the employees to focus upon their respective goals.... Furthermore, a leader helps in the establishment of gender equality through focusing upon the formulation of gender equality initiatives (AHRI, 2012)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

Mediating Gender Inequality in the Workplace

the issue of equality of the sexes has often been taken as a diversity issue and that stance is a good starting point since women remain a minority in many professional fields.... Social interaction and networking within a company can certainly help decrease the amount of gender discrimination faced by women but to expect it to totally eliminate the discrimination would be unrealistic.... The paper "Mediating Gender Inequality in the workplace" states that interactions between genders in social settings and even general interaction between the sexes at the workplace must be coupled with awareness and a guided discussion concerning gender inequality issues....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Gender Discrimination in Workplace

This report "Gender Discrimination in workplace" presents discrimination that has been a major problem at home and even in governmental structures especially against women.... Individual performance at the workplace is enhanced by a stress-free mind an employee possesses.... The essay thus highlights various types and forms of women discrimination in the workplace due to their gender, empowering of women at the workplace, and how disadvantageous it is to discriminate against women at workA situation whereby an employee or a job seeker is denied an opportunity to be employed or is treated as of less qualified because of the person belonging to a particular gender or sex....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report

Gender Discrimination in the Workplace

This work called "Gender Discrimination in the Workplace" reflects upon the existence of gender inequalities in the workplace and how campaigning facilitates in inducing greater awareness in the minds of female employees to resist such practices actively.... If all commercial institutions begin discriminating on the grounds of gender, many employees would be rendered jobless.... ender inequality in the workplace has become a rising issue and a concern for many female employees....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review

Overcoming Gender Discrimination in Fire Departments

This situation is causing a dearth of problems for the service and the fire department needs to tackle the issue of gender discrimination so that it can be able to provide its services competently.... The paper "Overcoming gender Discrimination in Fire Departments" focuses on the critical analysis of the main issues concerning overcoming gender discrimination in fire departments in the US.... iscrimination refers to a situation where people receive unequal treatment and benefits that are determined by a range of issues such as race, religion, gender, age, ethnicity, or even nationality regardless of merit, personal abilities, and qualifications....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us