StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Insanity defense : - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The insanity defense has been a relatively recent phenomena in court cases having first appeared in 1843 at the trial of Daniel M’Nagten, a woodworker Scotsman who killed the secretary to the British Prime Minister in a mistaken attempt to kill the man he believed was…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Insanity defense :
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Insanity defense :"

The insanity defense has been a relatively recent phenomena in court cases having first appeared in 1843 at the trial of Daniel M’Nagten, a woodworker Scotsman who killed the secretary to the British Prime Minister in a mistaken attempt to kill the man he believed was targeting him (Martin, 1998). As a result of this trial, judges determined the insanity defense might be invoked if the defendant was operating “under such defect of reason from disease of the mind” as to not realize that what they were doing was a crime (Martin, 1998). It is this right versus wrong idea that has formed the basis of most of the American laws regarding this defense argument. Yet, the insanity defense has come under attack numerous times since its inception because of its very malleable nature – some who are obviously insane, such as Charles Guiteau who shot President Garfield in 1881, are found incontrovertibly guilty while others, such as John Hinkley who shot President Reagan in 1981, are found not guilty by reason of insanity. “There is a very strong perception in America that defendants are abusing this defense to escape murder charges in the nation’s courts” (Gado, 2005). In terms of the defense actually being used, reports indicate that the insanity defense is “difficult to plead, seldom used and almost never successful” (Gado, 2005). Despite this, I do believe there are some instances in which the insanity defense is plausible and appropriate, such as in the case of Daniel Zwack.
In the case of Daniel Zwack, the defendant was convinced at the time of his crimes that he was being targeted by the CIA, the Masons and numerous other shadowy figures, forcing him to stock his vehicle up with weaponry and head back home to Minnesota in violation of his parole. What makes this case distinctive is that when his family started noticing strange behavior in their son – spraying mace in his mother’s face for refusing to hand over a negative letter regarding him, for instance – they tried to have him committed in an effort to obtain for him the medical attention they felt he obviously needed. However, the courts, deciding he wasn’t dangerous enough, refused to confine him to the hospital. It wasn’t until he was involved with a shootout with Texas police (and one federal officer, for whom he was given an additional 17 years) that Zwack was finally determined dangerous. His mother, though horrified, said she also felt some relief, believing her son would finally be found insane and be given the medical treatment he needed (Biewen, 2006). Instead, he received 62 years in maximum security prison. However, while there, he has received some medical attention that has demonstrated that insanity was a plausible reason for his rampage. While in prison, Zwack has been taking Risperdol, which has worked to stop hallucinations and reduce the voices Zwack claims to hear. He even reported receiving a phone call in his cell once to remind him to take his medicine. He, of course, does not have a phone in his cell.
When a person is demonstrably ill in his thinking, as in the case of Daniel Zwack, to such an extent that family and friends have worked to have this person committed at some time in the past, the insanity defense should be able to be used. In this particular case, the individual suffering the mental disease was not even aware of his wrong-thinking until after he was placed on medication and the medication had a chance to begin functioning. When he has been too long off of the medication, he now reports instances in which he is still thinking in strange ways. Other cases, in which the individual knows they are not thinking correctly, but are unable to obtain help for one reason or another, could just as easily be considered crimes committed while insane. While there is room for abuse in such cases, I believe if one is sick, mentally or otherwise, there should be methods in place for them to obtain the help they need before the crimes occur, and, in the absence of such, it is unethical for the rest of us to hold them responsible for what they do in the twisted reasoning of an injured mind.
References
Beiwen, John. (2006). “Not Sick Enough: The Insanity Defense.” American Public Media. Retrieved February 3 2006 from .
Gado, Mark. (2005). “You Must Die!” Court TV Crime Library. Retrieved February 3 2006 from .
Martin, John. (February 27 1998). “The Insanity Defense: A Closer Look.” Washington Post. Retrieved February 3 2006 from . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Insanity defense : Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Insanity defense : Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1535931-insanity-defense
(Insanity Defense : Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Insanity Defense : Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1535931-insanity-defense.
“Insanity Defense : Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1535931-insanity-defense.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Insanity defense :

Famous Insanity Defense Cases

..., also known as the “Product test”), the drafting of the American Law Institute Test (1953), the Hinckley case3, which led to the adoption of Insanity Defense Reform Act in 1984 and the well known Andrea Yates case. In the first part of this paper, the author will provide a brief analysis to some of the most famous insanity defense cases, whilst in the second part – the author will describe in more details the sad case of Andrea Yates, a case which has given birth to controversies and nobody is able to completely understand if Andrea Yates was or was not aware of the cruelty and illegality of her actions. 1. Famous insanity defense cases...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Andrea Yates: The Difficulty of the Insanity Defense, Despite the Evidence of Mental Illness

..., and then reported what she had done, the idea of insanity as it was defined by the state was not established. The insanity defense is a difficult defense to use and is rarely successful. According to Denno (2004) “the defense rankles social and community tensions over two conflicting goals: the desire to punish the horrendous, highly publicized crimes that the public typically hears about versus the need to understand that some mentally ill people should not be held responsible for what they do”. The standard by which the defense of insanity is measured is usually through the M’Naghten case which came from the House of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Insanity defense

...– Contrary to the criminal law which seeks to punish the criminal; the insanity defense seeks to excuse the criminal of responsibility (Fersch, 2005). Affirming the crucial importance of criminal intent in defining a crime, this term paper contends that insanity defense is morally justified and necessary because without this justice may be unwittingly denied. Insanity Defenses The recognition and standard of insanity defense vary across states and have changed through the years: From the M’Naghten rule (1841) to the introduction of Diminished Responsibility (1866) and to the Insanity...
4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper

Insanity

...? Insanity People do not just become insane without any reason. There are a whole lot of reasons that bring about insanity in someone. At the same time, insanity has multiple effects, although all of them are destructive either of one’s sanity or even of one’s life. Nevertheless, through the various pieces of American literature one learns that insanity is a part of human nature whose cause is a great desire to express something and whose result is always destruction. In the story “The Most Dangerous Game,” one can see that General Zaroff is insane as he is so engrossed at the idea of hunting people as he would animals, and that such a desire is somehow based on his need to fulfill his wish of hunting a rational animal. It could also...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Insanity Defense

...The insanity defence directly speaks to mens rea because its primary focus is the mental capa or intent of the perpetrator upon the commission ofthe offense. In other words, as determination of criminal culpability is inextricably linked to intent and, importantly, awareness, a guilty finding is predicated on the establishment of intent and awareness, on mens rea. Within its legal context, insanity specifically focuses on mens rea or intentional and mental capacity. As regards the stated, there are three approaches to the insanity defence, all of which may be defined as standards. These are the M'Naughten, Durham, and ALI defences/standards/models. Following a brief comparative definition and discussion of each, this essay will argue...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

How Has the Insanity Defense Been Used in the Films Primal Fear and Nuts

... that she is mentally competent to face trial. While these two films have a different orientation to the subject of legal insanity, both of them deal with the courtroom proceedings surrounding the establishment of this legal defense. In both these films, the defendants admit to their criminal acts, but it is the defense that puts forth the insanity plea in “Primal Fear”, while it is the prosecution that advances the insanity defense in challenging the defendant’s competence to stand trial. The film “Nuts” revolves around a call girl, Claudia, who has killed a client and has been declared to be insane by the resident jail psychiatrist. She comes from a respectable, middle class white family and her mother, a timid woman together with her...
8 Pages(2000 words)Movie Review

The Insanity Defense of Andrea Yates

... committing this horrifying crime, she called the police as well as her husband for disclosing the crime she had committed. (McLellan; Keram) There is no doubt that no crime could be more heinous than killing one’s own children. However, looking at the nature of crime committed by a mother, questions are bound to arise regarding the mental status of Yates at the time of the crime. It was her psychological disorder which prompted her to commit such crime and considering her psychological problem her defendant demanded insanity defense in the first trial. She was under treatment and was taking drugs even two days before the incident occurred. She claimed of having odd visions and hearing sounds which was not real. She believed...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Among the strategies used by the defense to absolve their clients of criminal intent and nullify prosecution arguments that suggest their clients have committed crimes, defense counsels may argue that their client suffers from insanity or temporary insani

...Affirmative Defense Task: Affirmative Defense Attorneys may employ affirmative defense, in an attempt to exempt their client of crimes of which they are charged. In affirmative defense, the attorney fails to decline the crime committed by the client. However, the attorney will provide adequate proof to demonstrate that it was not the clients’ rightful will to commit the alleged crime. For instance, the attorney may argue that the client was suffering from impermanent or total mental illness (Champion, Rabe & Hartley, 2008). This provides one instance of affirmative defense. Another category of affirmative defense is the entrapment. In this, the attorney argues that their clients could have engaged in a crime, owing to the situation...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

The Definition and Criticism of an Insanity Defense

...few people plead insanity though and among those who plead it, a very minor part wins the plea. An important point here is people acquitted under insanity defense are seldom allowed to walk free. In almost all cases, the acquitted people are allowed to go to treatment centers and kept there until mental health officials determine they do not pose a danger to anyone. Criticism to insanity defense is a common phenomenon. Critics argue that some defendants misuse insanity defense, effectively faking insanity to win acquittals or less severe convictions. And often the trials involving an...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The European Defense Community

...The European Defense Community Introduction The European Defense Community (EDC) was an excellent but aborted plan to counter the planned rearmament of West Germany. Its plan was proposed in 1950 René Pleven, the French President of the Council (known as Prime Minister after 1958). The impetus for the creation of the EDC is to provide a pan-European defense force which will serve as an alternative to the proposed accession to NATO “meant to harness its military potential in case of conflict with the Soviet bloc” (Wikimedia Foundation, Inc). It was established by the Treaty of Paris on 27 May 1952 by the six members of the ECSC (Palmowski). The European Defense Community is considered by many as the most ambitious project...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

The Coroners & Justice Act 2009 and the Defense of Provocation

At last, the areas so desperately in need of reform would be given the due attention deserved, and the web of case law upon which they were perched would be dusted. However, as is usually the case with proposed reformations of the law, the tentative steps taken were a far cry from the envisaged upheavals. And so the age-old question resounds in courtrooms around the country – is the situation any better now than it was previously? This paper will explore the new stance of the law in relation to the defense of provocation under the Justice and Coroners Act 2009, and assess what changes were made, as well as the reasoning behind the changes. Overall, it will argue that there have been no major changes made by the new legislati...
34 Pages(8500 words)Essay

Defense of Human Civil and Natural Rights

...Natural and Civil Rights: A World Community Issue Introduction When the topic of rights are considered, the responsibility of defending of those rights comes into mind. Natural and civil rights can easily be stripped from those without their own sources of defense. Therefore, it is important for the courts, interested organizations, and even civilian awareness to work together to provide protection for all people. In a discussion of the defense of civil and natural rights, it is important to define what these terms mean. As well, defining where those given rights end and the responsibility of the individual begins must be determined. A discussion of consumerism will also shed light on the extent for which the global community has both...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Natural Rights And Fundamental Defense Of Liberty

...Natural Rights And Fundamental Defense Of Liberty The question of whether natural rights can be justified is paradoxical as natural rights need no justification otherwise they would not be universal and unable to stand as a fundamental defense of liberty for the individual as proposed in the context of Enlightenment. In positing natural rights as foundational, their basis is in “existence” or life as experienced through the autonomous individual. The categorical imperative as outlined by Kant is expressed through the 'a priori' of moral consciousness which can be seen in examples of later declarations of human rights that seek to articulate or delineate “the universal rights of man” as an expression of the moral sentiment...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Operations Research in Military/Defense

...Report on Operations Research In Military/Defense TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Summary p.3 II. Introduction p.4 III. History p.4 IV. Theories and Applications p. 6 Decision Theory p.7 Research and Development p.8 Computing Cost p.9 Military Operations p.10 V. Problems p.11 VI. Operations Research Today p.12 VII. Conclusion p.12 VIII. References p.13 IX. Index p.14 Summary Due to the rapid development in technology today, the US military has been faced with the need to innovate and reform existing capabilities, systems, policies and tactics. This is made more complex by the impact of this same technology on other states as well...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

The Rules Governing the Insanity Defense

.... This led to the formation of strictures whereby it was avowed that a defendant was required to have a mental condition or illness and even retardation that was required to be severe to an extent that the defendant had no insight as to the quality and nature of the act committed without the knowledge that the act was wrong. English law has reviewed the concept of insanity defense and is an area rich in evidence especially with reference to decided cases evaluating this defense. In this regard, this paper will critically analyze the insanity defense according to English law. Changes that have been made to the insanity...
18 Pages(4500 words)Coursework

Prosecutorial and Judicial Misconduct along with Ineffective assistance by criminal defense counsel

...Prosecutorial, Judicial Misconduct and Ineffective Assistance by Criminal Defense Counsel Prosecutorial Misconduct The perfect example of a case of prosecutorial misconduct involves abuse of the prosecutorial power of discretion, where failure is witnessed in exercising authority to determine which offenses to be brought before the justice system. A prosecutor decides which offenses are weighty enough to appear before the court and which to be disbanded on grounds of evidence. An illustration of such abuse was witnessed when Durham County Prosecutor Michael B. Nifong brought a case of rape before the court without investigating and North Carolina Attorney General moved in, dismissing rape charges leveled against members of Duke University...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Insanity of the Narrator: The Descent of Madness

One intriguing trait portrayed by the character involves his persistence about being sane, yet his wrongful action coupled with the motivation behind his action suggests otherwise. From a reader’s perspective, it is undeniable that the narrator suffers from peculiar psychological problems. However, the narrator remains confident regarding his mental status. He claims that the particular state of his mind makes him sharp and enlightened. Succeeding parts of this essay evaluate the main elements of Poe’s writing together with the true motivation behind the narrator’s crime.

At this juncture, I am personally fascinated by the narrator’s mentality and his state of sanity. His mental construct and su...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

Felony Defense in the U.S

...Felony Defense in the U.S The United States as a leading democracy, anchors its rule of law on the supremacy of its Constitution, through various laws, rules, regulations and statutes. All these are core to the day-to-day running of American affairs, as well as enabling a peaceful social order. In the U.S., while federal laws hold supreme, as anchored in the constitution, state law is also important in both its distinction and role-function. Thus, in each state, crime and criminal activities are distinguished into specific categories, as influenced by their seriousness, cause-effects and social implications, amongst others. In each state, crimes are hence distinguished into three distinct categories, which are inclusive of infractions...
11 Pages(2750 words)Research Paper

Insanity in Edgar Allen Poe's Works

... s Insanity in Edgar Allen Poes works Introduction The human mind will always generate and will be “mined” with various thoughts. Individuals would constantly or irregularly develop those thoughts based on the external situations. When it is the right time, he/she will try to “translate” or actualize those thoughts into actions and reality. When that actualization happens in a smooth and expected manner, it will provide optimal happiness and contentment to the individuals. However, if those thoughts could not be aptly actualized or erroneously ‘translated’ into action or reality because of the negative or dubious nature of those thoughts, it will lead to negative reactions in the individuals’ minds. If these reactions reach extreme ends...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Insanity defense : for FREE!

Contact Us