Nobody downloaded yet

Comparison of Leo Tolstoys War and Peace and A Prisoner in the Caucasus - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The purpose of this paper is to analyze these two very important works by Leo N. Tolstoy, concentrating on two specific subject-matters to be compared, which are apparently intrinsic to both: the subject of war and the subject of national history.
Upon comparing Tolstoy's War and Peace and "A Prisoner in the Caucasus", the first thing that needs to be taken into account is the difference in format of the two works…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Comparison of Leo Tolstoys War and Peace and A Prisoner in the Caucasus
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Comparison of Leo Tolstoys War and Peace and A Prisoner in the Caucasus"

Download file to see previous pages In general and on a whole, it can be stated that there are more differences than similarities between the two. War and Peace provides ample background as to the war that is taking place, describing in detail the events leading up to the war, the reason for it, the points of view and particularities of both sides involved, and the historical context surrounding the characters and occurrences that are significant to the story. It is a standalone piece that a reader can approach without the need to be versed or even familiar with the history of the time period in which it unfolds, given the fact that all of this information is provided therein, whereas in "A Prisoner in the Caucasus", the only piece of information given as to historical context is that it is taking place amidst the war between the Russians and the Tartars, forcing the discerning and curious reader to research the circumstances of, and time in history when, said war was waged if he/she wishes to obtain some temporal reference or detailed contextual information that would serve as a basis for better understanding the tale's time and place.
Another general and very important difference between the novel and the short story consists of the fact that the latter was written by Tolstoy based on actual experiences. "A Prisoner in the Caucasus" fictionalizes Tolstoy's first-hand experience as a soldier in 1852 fighting in the war against the Chechenians, Tartars who rebelled against Russian rule. Evidence of actual occurrences that Tolstoy lived during his military career, which he either described in detail to instill realism into certain passages of his story or embellished upon to create memorable scenes, abounds in scholarly biographical works on the author. One such event is beautifully narrated in A Cadet in the Caucasus (Simmons, p. 23):
[Tolstoy] and Sado were in a convoy of stores from Fort Vozdvizhenskoe to Fort Groznoe. Although regulations strictly forbade anyone detaching himself from the convoy, because of the danger of being cut off by roving mountaineers, he, Sado and three mounted officers, impatient with the slow pace of the infantry, rode on ahead. Tolstoy and Sado ascended a ridge to see if any of the enemy were in sight. A large band suddenly appeared a short distance away. Shouting a warning to their three comrades below, Tolstoy and Sado galloped for the fort, less than three miles away. The Chechen band divided, seven taking up the pursuit of Tolstoy and Sado and the rest dashing after the other officers. These men had been slow to take the warning and two of them were severely wounded before reaching the convoy. Meanwhile Tolstoy, who had been trying out Sado's spirited new horse and hence might easily have escaped, refused to desert his friend, who was mounted on Tolstoy's slow ambler. The Chechens drew nearer and nearer, while Sado tried to keep them at a distance by threatening them with an unloaded gun. The enemy could have shot them down, but apparently they desired to take them alive, especially the renegade Sado, whom they no doubt wished to torture. Fortunately, a Cossack guard at the post saw their plight. A rescue party at once galloped out and the Chechens fled.
This close encounter ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparison of Leo Tolstoys War and Peace and A Prisoner in the Essay”, n.d.)
Comparison of Leo Tolstoys War and Peace and A Prisoner in the Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532073-comparison-of-leo-tolstoys-war-and-peace-and-a-prisoner-in-the-caucasus
(Comparison of Leo Tolstoys War and Peace and A Prisoner in the Essay)
Comparison of Leo Tolstoys War and Peace and A Prisoner in the Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532073-comparison-of-leo-tolstoys-war-and-peace-and-a-prisoner-in-the-caucasus.
“Comparison of Leo Tolstoys War and Peace and A Prisoner in the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1532073-comparison-of-leo-tolstoys-war-and-peace-and-a-prisoner-in-the-caucasus.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparison of Leo Tolstoys War and Peace and A Prisoner in the Caucasus

The Book: War and Peace

...English Literature 9 December War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy Leo Tolstoy’s novel “War and Peace” as the suggests is a tale of wartime and in-between times of tranquility and peace in Russia commencing from 1805 during the reign of Tsar Alexander I and leading up to 1812 when Napoleon invaded Russia. This novel can be perceived as a long chronicle of philosophical musings of Tolstoy about various aspects of life which includes family, romance, war and relationships as well as the author’s interpretation of history of Russia and in doing so he contradicts...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Prisoner Torture

.... According to Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) statement by UN, everyone has the right to ‘life, liberty, and security of the person’. The statement clearly mentions that no one can be subjected to torture, or to cruel and unjust punishment (Orend, 107). Also, torture in a way of putting someone’s privacy under threat is not acceptable. The purpose of any criminal investigation is to unearth the truth behind crime. However, the process of finding truth should not be cruel or inhuman. Torture, being an act of cruelty, defies use in any circumstance. The purpose of implementation of human rights in prison and war imply that someone might have committed a wrong against a threat. Naturally such...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

War and peace

...War and Peace The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has been in existence for more than sixty years. The conflict has a basic idea, which both sides believe: for the Israeli, they believe that they have the entitlement to the land they call Israel, while the Palestinians are of the believe that they have the entitlement to the land that they call Palestine. Both sides fight for the same land and call it by different names. Both parties are of the opinion that God blessed them with the land and giving it away to other people is a sin and an insult to God. Many factors have been attributed to the existence of the war, but opposition mobilization has been the steering factor to the existence of...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Research Paper - War and Peace

...?Research paper - War and peace How do People Justify War? War is one of the main s in the international history and it provides us a clear-cut view that war has been part and parcel of our political society. There are different analysis and perspectives given to war. One dimension of the war provides that war is inevitable for the mankind and that it is becomes one of the essential part of the society. While one section of the global society believes that peace is the means to achieve things, there are also views that support warfare. This paper will bring out the views and opinions of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

War and Peace

...War and Peace This essay on war and peace explores the moral and legal of when and how to achieve the political objective. The paper analyses the ethics of war and peace on its legal and moral perspective with respect to the religious teaching. It surveys the historical development of the war of reasoning and its incorporation in the international religious concern. The conflicting moral and legal obligations of the state in the peacekeeping and peacemaking have found concern in the religious rhyme. This paper studies the official catholic teachings on peace and war in the broader...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

LEO Program

...? LEO Program Essay. My life has had more than its fair share of upheavals and hardships. My childhood was spent on a small farm in Ecuador under thecare of my maternal grandparents. My mother, a single parent, worked long hours in the city in order to financially support us: although this necessitated a painful separation. At the age of twelve, I was devastated by the death of my grandmother who had been a second mother to me. This was closely followed by my mother’s departure for America, in search of a better life for herself and her family. It would be seven long years before we could be reunited. My younger sister and I joined our mother in America in 1996. From the time of this arrival, this would be the pattern of...
3 Pages(750 words)Admission/Application Essay

Comparison: Iraq war & Vietnam war

...man has to suffer for no reason. The common man wants peace, prosperity and a security. Innumerable human loss is not affordable either for the winner or for the looser. America as a mightest nation should know its accountability. If America is really willing to establish democracy in the whole world it should know that war and aggressive policy is not the solution. Because this is not the democracy that was dreamt by Abraham Linchon. Democracy is the most ideal form of the government but it can be spread through the peaceful way also. References: 1. News Service - Foreign Policy in Focus 2. Commondreams.org – News-center and USA Today 3. “Iraq and Vietnam”: Differences, Similarities,...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy

... War and Peace by Leo TolstoyWar and Peace is considered to be one of the greatest novels ever written (Moser 1992). It is based in Russia and dates back to the times of the Napoleonic wars. The novel is stretched from the period of 1805 to 1812: drawing up a clear picture of the effect Napoleon’s wars had on Russian lives. It is based on the histories of five aristocratic families: Bezukhovs, the Bolkonskys, and the Rostovs and how their personal lives were affected by Napoleon’s invasion of Russia. Though the book has a vast medley of characters, some are fictional while accurate displays have been...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Caucasus Region2

...CAUCASUS REGION2 The shattering pieces of former USSR are yet to fall in place and re-integrate. The Caucasus region is a troubled place full of political tension and insecurity (web; Waal). Key players Georgia, Russia, Armenia and Azerbaijan tense relations. Borders are closed and ceasefire lines drawn. Problems with Iran and Turkey makes things still worse. The region is a flashpoint and is heading towards a collective suicide in the event of a full scale war. Economies are weak and have to support large number of refugees from neighborhood. A three pronged strategy; political-economic-military, by UN forces and USA is required to settle down things and bring peace...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Islamic peace and war

...Islamic peace and war Within the context of world peace, the 9/11 incident raised questions on the Islamic point of view on peace and war. First of all, one must not misunderstand that the terrorist attack is based on the Islamic ideas on peace and war. To be specific, the terrorists misinterpreted the Islamic point of view on peace and war and made use of the same to create violence in the international context. One can see that the Islamic ideas/concepts on war are strictly limited to the medieval age, when holy wars and jihad was fought to reduce the scope of internal and external aggressions, or to restore peace. Thesis statement: The Islamic point of view on peace is based on restoration of peace, and war is based on internal... be...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Comparison of Leo Tolstoys War and Peace and A Prisoner in the Caucasus for FREE!

Contact Us