Nobody downloaded yet

Medical Malpractice in the Death of Mrs. Hoover - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
In the case of Trudy Hoover, an incident of medical malpractice has occurred that may have contributed to circumstances that brought her to her untimely death. To sum up the situation, Mary Smith, a Medical Assistant for Dr. Jones, ordered pain medications for Hoover as a Medical Assistant for Dr…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.2% of users find it useful
Medical Malpractice in the Death of Mrs. Hoover
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Medical Malpractice in the Death of Mrs. Hoover"

Download file to see previous pages In order for it to be considered a criminal case, the defendant's actions must be considered to be so grossly negligent that it was with willful and malicious intent that they committed the act that lead them to trial. Specifically, ""That degree of negligence or carelessness which is denominated as gross, and which constitutes such a departure from what would be the conduct of an ordinarily careful and prudent manas to furnish evidence of that indifference to consequences which in some offenses takes the place of criminal intent."24 or "Negligence, to be criminal, must be reckless and wanton (Monico 1)".
The type of tort that is appropriate for this case is malpractice. This is clearly a case of malpractice because the defendant acted outside her Scope of Practice. According to the Federation of State Medical Boards, "Scope of practice define s those health care services a physician or other health care practitioner is authorized to perform by virtue of professional license, registration, or certification. Health care professionals' scopes of practice sometimes overlap reflecting shared competencies (Federation of State Medical Boards, 2005)". As a Medical Assistant, Smith acted outside her scope of practice as a Medical Assistant as defined by her State's laws and medical direction. A Medical Assistant may only order, obtain and provide medications with a Doctor's Written Orders (Buppert 1).
In order to have avoided this situation completely, Smith could have chosen to remain within her scope of practice as a Medical Assistant. Smith could have advised Hoover to seek the care of another medical professional, or, if necessary, call for an ambulance or report to a hospital emergency room. Due to the fact that Hoover was in so much pain, Smith could have contacted an ambulance or a hospital for Hoover so that she could receive immediate medical care.
The Doctrine of Respondeat Superior dictates that Dr. Jones can be held liable in this situation. Specifically, Respondeat Superior can be used when "it is determined that the medical provider exercised control over the negligent provider's means and methods of work (Regan 1)". As Smith's superior, Dr. Jones worked closely with Smith close enough to the point where she knew the exact medication that his patients receive. Dr. Jones is explicitly responsible for the actions of his employees and the occurrences within his office, and probably has multiple forms of insurance for situations like this. However, Respondeat Superior can prevail in this case because Smith ordered the prescription as if Dr. Jones had ordered it, leading the patient to believe that she was truly being prescribed this medication by her doctor.
The Good Samaritan Law may not apply in this case. In general, the Good Samaritan Law's intent is to release the legal liability of an average person, including licensed medical professionals, who provide emergency care to a person experiencing a sudden medical emergency. The only exceptions to this case are actions that are considered to be criminal or grossly negligent. The Good Samaritan Law also does not change the scope of practice for those people who are performing as, or have identified themselves as, a medical professional while rendering emergency medical care. To cite the State of Georgia's Good Samaritan Law, "Nothing in this Code section shall be ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Medical Malpractice in the Death of Mrs. Hoover Case Study”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Medical Malpractice in the Death of Mrs. Hoover Case Study)
“Medical Malpractice in the Death of Mrs. Hoover Case Study”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Medical Malpractice in the Death of Mrs. Hoover

Medical Negligence and Malpractice because of any of the reasons stated above, but legally it can be called a case of malpractice this may be due to drugs not getting properly testing as stated by its standard testing procedure or if the drugs are released before time. Furthermore, it will be considered a case of negligence and malpractice on part of the pharmacy if the sales representative fails to provide the doctor proper warnings and effects of using the drugs. In the United Kingdom, laws against case of medical negligence and malpractice (Medical Negligence UK), in laymen terms states that if a physician is responsible for any injury or death to a patient, then...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Medical Malpractice Research Paper

...Medical Malpractice Introduction The relationship between a patient and a doctor has been outlined differently over the years. While patients often trust doctors and other medical practitioners to provide them with correct medication or to carefully perform the right procedures on them, sometimes this never happens in which case medical malpractice occurs. Professionally, medical malpractice is negligence by omission or act by a medical practitioner in which the practitioner provides care that is not in line with the acceptable standard of practice as defined by the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Malpractice in the Medical Field terms of the death of millions of people every year, lost productivity, overhead expenses, and also the suffering of people that bear the pressure but don’t sue. The cyclical insurance premiums of the medical malpractice are not driven by the runaway juries or perky litigation. Increased competition in the insurance industry and the financial trends are the real causes of increase in the insurance premiums for the medical malpractice during the 1970s, 1980s and the 21st century. A vast majority of the people that claim of having been the victim of malpractice actually sue just in an attempt to know what really happened. Even if they...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Federal Medical Malpractice Reform

...or periodic payments. Another is the patients. In the current malpractice framework patients with medical conditions requiring risky medical procedures will be high-risk to practitioners thus defensive medicine will make doctors avoid such procedures. Reform will make such defensive medicine unnecessary. At its heart, malpractice reform seeks to protect patients. Accidental deaths would be significantly reduced. The losers Insurers are the primary losers. With malpractice reform the big business is significantly reduced and with such reforms being aimed at the root of rising premium costs the insurance industry is sure to shoulder the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Analysis of Medical Malpractice

... Analysis of Medical Malpractice I. Introduction The following is the scenario that was presented. In March, Dr Foster (of Muncaster NHS Hospital) performed tear drainage surgery on Mr Smith in order to correct his watery eyes. Dr Foster was a junior doctor who had not performed the operation before. His superior, Mrs Smith (a consultant ophthalmologist and Mr Smith’s wife) was in attendance. Prior to the operation, Dr Foster had told Mr Smith that the operation carried a small risk of blindness, but that any other side effects were rare and/or minor. Mr Smith signed a consent form, but only agreed to the operation because Mrs Smith had privately threatened to divorce him if he did not. 
As a result of the operation... chance of...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study

Medical Malpractice

...administrations. All of these errors had resulted in an overdose and eventually led to the death of Jackson. Dr. Murray could have opted for a different approach of treating Jackson. He consulted other doctors and kept proper records of the medications provided to Jackson. Also, he could have used other drugs which did not require strict monitoring. These measures could have saved him from conviction (Medina; Ryan & Kim). Dr. Mark Weinberger serves as another example and multiple malpractice medical law suits were filed against him. Weinberger claimed that he was “The Nose Doctor” and he carried out surgical procedures that were not required by the patients. These...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Medical Malpractice

... case. Medical Malpractice Case Law - An Analysis The selected case The litigation ruling under review pertains to the case of SHEILA WEBB versus TULANE MEDICAL CENTER HOSPITAL AND ABE ANDES, M.D. which underwent a full-blown trial. The decision of the trial court was raised on appeal to the COURT OF APPEAL OF LOUISIANA, FOURTH CIRCUIT. The identity of the plaintiff and of the defendants and the jurisdictional matters The plaintiff, Sheila Webb, instituted the action in connection with the death of her son, Rodney Comeaux, the alleged victim of the medical malpractice. The main ground of the suit she filed was the negligence of the attending medical doctors and of the hospital appurtenant to the duty of the latter... Running...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Medical Negligence and Malpractice

..., and so on. Morbidity costs include the value of goods and services a person would have produced if that person were not injured. Mortality costs are the net present value of the future earnings lost due to death. Differing perceptions about the medical malpractice compensation system among various groups has led to a variety of proposed resolutions to the problems (Rosenthal, 1988). Uncertainties about the claims and premiums have led physicians to blame lawyers for initiating spurious claims. Physicians consider the contingent fee arrangement between lawyers and patients to be an incentive to bring claims against physicians. The slow judicial system and juries are blamed for...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

Medical Negligence & Malpractice

..., but Lord Goff held it to be an omission in Airedale NHS Trust v. Bland.26 Such a stand also raises the question of ethics and morality. Would it not be more ethical to allow a person to die peacefully by means of an act rather than let him suffer with pain in his last hour by means of an omission? An injection that allows a person to die peacefully, in a dignified manner, should be more acceptable than torturing him to death by leaving him gasping for his last few breaths. According to this position, the law would not have a problem if Mrs. Pretty would have been left alone in a room by her husband, with no one to attend her and feed her, thereby allowing her to die painfully as a result of non-medication and hunger... and family assisted...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Medical Malpractice

...court’s determination that his medical malpractice claims against Ziana Liese, M.D., are barred by the statute of limitations because Dr. Liese was not timely served with process. Because Mr. Davis never received or filed an executed waiver of service and did not formally serve Dr. Liese before the statutory deadline, we affirm.1 E. Locate a US Supreme Court (Federal court of appeals) decision & copy the 1st page of the case & summarize the facts, issues and holdings of the court. Date: 11-13-2009 Case Style: Doris Penrod v. David R. Schecter, M.D., Individually and d/b/a Schecter and Blumenfeld, P.A. Case Number: 08-07-00121-CV Judge: McClure Court: Texas Court of Appeals, Eighth...
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Medical Malpractice in the Death of Mrs. Hoover for FREE!

Contact Us