Nobody downloaded yet

The Negative Effects of the Grading System - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The traditional grading scale, A through F, is a time-honored standard for measuring student performance. It is utilized in the vast majority of schools, from kindergarten through graduate school. Letter grades represent an intuitive and convenient way to judge the caliber of work product that results from the efforts of any given student…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
The Negative Effects of the Grading System
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Negative Effects of the Grading System"

Download file to see previous pages While each individual has perceptions of what an A or a C or an F should mean with regard to student achievement, the reality is that these measures are often applied inconsistently and arbitrarily. Letter grades often become efforts to shoehorn subjective learning assessments into an objective measurement system that does not necessarily lend itself to being applied in that way. Further, such grades can be applied with relativism, such as in the context of a bell curve whereby students are given a grade that may not truly reflect their mastery of the subject matter, simply because of their juxtaposition to other students in the class.
Ultimately, there are several potentially negative effects of the traditional letter grading scale that warrant a wholesale review of how student performance should be appropriately measured under various circumstances. To be sure, the traditional system may be the best system for some situations, namely where students are objectively tested and scored on the material. However, education is largely becoming a more complex, subjective and nuanced endeavor in a world that is rarely black and white. This paper will assess the appropriateness of the traditional letter grade system for measuring student success in various types of learning environments, and evaluate some of its alternatives. It will also discuss the potential negative consequences of applying the traditional objective letter grade system where it may not be appropriate to do so.
The Meaning of Letter Grades
A's and B's no longer mean what they used to, largely because they have become the predominant grade given. For example, a recent analysis of grades in Indiana public schools shows 75% of all grades given were either A's or B's, with only 10% being D's or F's (Stockman, 2007, para. 3). That leaves 15% of grades being C, which intuitively would be the median grade. Such an uneven grade distribution begs the question of whether grade inflation is at play, or whether the vast majority of students are really earning these high grades. According to Matthew Hartley, assistant professor of education at the University of Pennsylvania's Graduate School of Education, "It's important to remember that grade inflation is a shift in grades without a corresponding improvement in performance. . . If your institutions are becoming more competitive and selective, it may be that they are admitting better prepared students who are earning A's, which means there is no inflation" (para. 7).
Largely due to this uncertainty about how well deserved a grade actually is, letter grades are becoming increasingly irrelevant as students move toward the transition from school to the workforce. As George Kuh of Indiana University asserts, "If you talk with business and industry leaders, they'll tell you grades don't matter . . . What you really want to know is if they're flexible, adaptable, can they work with other people" (para. 30). Thus, it seems a different, more subjective measurement of student performance may be in order if the goal is to help students succeed as working professionals. An approach that evaluates students on their ability to apply what is learned in a way that makes them functional contributors to society would likely be more valuable to ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Negative Effects of the Grading System Essay”, n.d.)
The Negative Effects of the Grading System Essay. Retrieved from
(The Negative Effects of the Grading System Essay)
The Negative Effects of the Grading System Essay.
“The Negative Effects of the Grading System Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Negative Effects of the Grading System

Negative Effects of Climate

...? Negative Effects of Climate The abrupt fluctuations in climate highlight the various economic and ecological forums and massive campaigns for awareness of harsh climate changes to the humankind. The global climatically changes have result in various un imaginable temperature changes, catastrophic events, abrupt seasonal variations that had not only affected the lifecycle and human activities but resulted in disastrous effect to the aromatic plants and wildlife. The intensity of the threat to the dissolution of vegetation, aromatic plants, or life cycle of human kind and wildlife is unpredictable and the vulnerability of the climate has become a big challenge as an outcome. The future...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Negative effects brought by technology

...?Negative effects brought by technology College Negative effects brought by technology Since the industrial revolution, society has become more reliant on technology. It has become so much to an extent that we sometimes do not have the will to think before we act. Sometimes we ran out of patient if it takes more than a few minutes to download information we are in need of from the internet (Carr, 2008). We look forward to instant responses to our messages, and we expect someone to answer their cell phone whenever and wherever we call. Industrialization led to quick and sustained economic growth and a huge increase in consumer goods. But to the contrary, it meant a...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Negative Effects Behind Marijuana

...ability. Active ingredient in marijuana is Tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) which meddles with the ability of the brain to think, develop coordination between different systems of the body, and control emotions “Marijuana and Teens”). Use of marijuana early in life and its continued use can affect students’ memory and their clarity of thinking. Smoking marijuana makes it difficult for the students to concentrate upon concepts, pay attention in the class, and learn new things. Smoking marijuana has a negative effect on the decision making ability of the students. When the students are intoxicated, they cannot properly maintain their balance in their movements. A moderate decrease in the level...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Class Grading System

... Grading System and Section # of Grading System This is the grading system plan that deals with the system of work allocation, management and recording. Following is the suggested grading plan: 30% Mid term Examination 10% Assignments 10% Class Quizzes 10% Term Project 40% Final Examination 100% Semester total Mid term Examination: The term examination is given a major chunk of 30% as it gives the half point progress of the semester. More weight-age could have been assigned; however, it has been kept relatively lower to ensure that one bad day doesn't spoil the semester/term on the whole. Assignments: Assignments shall be given through out the semester/term, and graded out of 10. For each 5 assignments, best 4 shall be chosen... for...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Negative Effects of Outsourcing

.... It is also evidenced that outsourcing has negative consequences for the overall American economy. Even though free trade is often cited as a reason for outsourcing, Dobbs suspects that eminent economists such as Adam Smith and David Ricardo, who regularly advocated free trade, would take a different opinion if they realized that decisions like outsourcing were made at the expense of national self-interest that will have far reaching consequences. Dobbs states that "they also could not have imagined that one nation would effectively risk bankrupting itself by transferring its comparative advantage of knowledge base, expertise, and capital to its trading partners, and then ship its jobs overseas as...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Grading System 2

...Running Head: GRADING SYSTEM 2 Grading System 2 Grading System 2 In creating a grading system there are several components to consider. While it would be easy to create a system particularly tailored to the teachers needs, the system must also conform to the overall schools system of grading for it to be utilized. In other words, what happens in the classroom as far as grading student performance and achievement is one thing, but translating those grades effectively into the "report cart"...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Changing the teaching/ grading System

...Writing Response 6: CW 3 Brainstorming Changing the Teaching/ Grading System (5 minute speech) October 7, (Speaker’s catching the audience’s attention phase) Are your happy when your friends and relatives know that you got an F or failed grade in your class? (Speaker looks from to audience for a response, pauses for 10 second.). In your K – 12 years, what is the normal reaction of your parents when they see that you got several failed grades? Will they be happy? In the same way, as parents, how will you feel happy to see your child’s failed grade? (Speaker pauses 10 seconds to await the audience response). Well let me answer for you… a...
2 Pages(500 words)Speech or Presentation

Negative effects of fast food

...Negative Effects of Fast Food Introduction Eating habits in developed and developing nations have metamorphosed over the years; healthy nutritious foods are being replaced by low-cost and convenient junk food. These foods differ from traditional meals because they do not require immense preparation and structure; it is from this fact that they derive their names. The phenomenon had taken over all age groups, ethnicities and races, and raised serious concerns about the sustainability of the practice. People’s eating practices have a direct impact on their health, the sustainability of the food cycle and hence the environment as well as the quality of their relationships. How fast food affects...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Negative Effects of a Monopoly

...Negative Effects of a Monopoly A monopoly can be described as a phenomenon in which a big firm becomes the sole provider of a service or product, orwhen a certain company becomes so dominant in the market that it gets hard for other companies to compete with it. Several socioeconomic and political circumstances are responsible for the creation of a monopoly. Often, corrupt governments in a bureaucratic system take hold of the industries and own big companies, thus driving other competitors out of business. A monopoly is detrimental for the economy of a country in that it reduces purchasing power of the consumers, paves way for lower quality services or products, and creates...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Negative Effects of Social Networking

... Negative Effects of Social Networking Social networking is at the top of the most popular things in the world today. Both the young and the old spend hours on their computer screens and other technological devices posting, chatting, commenting, and engaging in other forms of socializing. As a matter of fact, nowadays people spend so much time in the social networking sites than they do in real world socialization activities. The use of these sites for socializing among other purposes has, however, gave way for a controversy questioning whether it is good or not. While others believe that this revolutionary technology has several benefits to human beings, some people claim that social media causes...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Negative Effects of the Grading System for FREE!

Contact Us