StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Rationale for Banning The Outsiders - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This essay will examine why The Outsiders, a popular novel by S.E. Hinton, was criticized and banned in some schools. The original novel was published by the teenage author in 1967, and it incorporated a number of themes and topics which some people found extraordinarily objectionable…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
The Rationale for Banning The Outsiders
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Rationale for Banning The Outsiders"

Download file to see previous pages As an initial matter, before addressing why the book was banned in certain schools, it is useful to summarize the plot generally. The protagonist in this story was Pony Curtis. Pony was a young boy whose parents had died in a car accident; as a result, he was cared for by his twenty year old brother, Darry. Pony was poor, though clever and a good student, and he did what all boys in this neighborhood did. He joined a gang, named the Greasers, and hung out with his gang as if they were an extended family. There was a rival gang, the Socs, made up of rich boys from a another neighborhood. A gang rivalry existed between the two, and one day a fight ensued in which Pony's good friend killed a member of the Socs gang in self-defense. Pony's friend later died, and another friend was shot by the police after going crazy and trying to rob a store with a gun. Pony, however, did not suffer the same fate as his friends; rather, after being inspired by a letter from Johnny, he decided to reconcile with his older brother and to try and improve his life. In short, Pony decided to reject the outsider lifestyle and to participate more productively in his society and community. Given the hopeful ending, the transcending of obstacles, it seems odd that the book was so heavily criticized.
The first The first basis for criticism was that the novel promoted gangs. More specifically, this line of reasoning argued that the novel, by including both rich and poor children in gangs, glamorized and encouraged young readers to pursue similar affiliations. In this way, the novel's critics believed that the novel was divisive, socially destructive, and immoral. It was socially divisive because it pitted rich boys against poor boys; it was socially destructive because violence was used as a conflict resolution tool for disputes; and, finally, it was immoral because the gang lifestyle promoted laziness, substance use, and revenge. Indeed, the central role of gangs in the novel was a central foundation for the criticism which ensued.
A second criticism was the use of violence by young boys. One can distinguish between clubs with mild-mannered rivalries and gangs with deeper notions of rivalry and revenge. It is one thing to portray youthful pranks; in the minds of the novel's critics, however, it was quite another thing to portray children and adolescents intending to cause serious physical harm and genuine emotional trauma on their rivals. A particular example was the use of weapons in the novel. These gang members, for instance, carried knives, bats, and guns. Rivals weren't simply embarrassed. Quite the contrary, as in the case of Johnny's conflict with Bob, some people were killed. Thus, in addition to the portrayal of gangs, the vivid depiction of violence also furnished a strong basis for the subsequent criticism.
A third criticism was the prevalence of substance use and abuse by underage boys. The references to cigarettes and alcohol were also found objectionable. These boys were underage. By associating public figures, in this case fictional characters from a popular novel, with substance abuse, many people argued that schoolchildren would be influenced to behave similarly. Today's cigarette-smoking adolescents will become tomorrow's marijuana users was the fundamental criticism. These ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Rationale for Banning The Outsiders Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
The Rationale for Banning The Outsiders Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525741-the-rationale-for-banning-the-outsiders
(The Rationale for Banning The Outsiders Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
The Rationale for Banning The Outsiders Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525741-the-rationale-for-banning-the-outsiders.
“The Rationale for Banning The Outsiders Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1525741-the-rationale-for-banning-the-outsiders.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Rationale for Banning The Outsiders

Banning packed lunches

...Banning Packed Lunches Serving children with proper nutrition is an important role that parents must do. Regardless of their work or other preoccupations in life, parents should always ensure that their kids are receiving the nutrition they need. However, many parents fail in their responsibility to provide proper diet to their children because most of them work more than 12 hours a day. The failure of parents to satisfy the nutritional needs of their children has become a concern among school officials. According to the article on the website of Mother Nature Network (MNN) which first appeared on April 12 this year, the principal of Little Village Academy in Chicago has made a move to ban packed lunches...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

Banning texting while driving

...Banning texting while driving Introduction: Impaired driving after taking substances that might intoxicate the driver is a social malady that attracts substantial hatred and notice from all spheres of the population. Ironically an activity like texting while driving that deserves equal if not more hatred and importance goes by almost unnoticed. Alcohol rides the blood and reaches our brain to make us think and act in an erratic way. Considering the fact that driving involves significant expertise and hand eye coordination; driving under alcohol invariably leads the driver below his optimum efficiency level and hence punishable. Ironically the same happens when the driver indulges in texting while driving. The similarity comes... precision....
18 Pages(4500 words)Research Paper

Book Banning

...Book Banning of the of the Concerned Professor November 11, 2009 Book Banning In the modern Western civilization, if the freedom of expression is gaining grounds on the one hand, there have been ample incidents where some sections of the society and the state machinery tend to support censorship and banning of books at one pretext or other. The point that needs to be understood is that every idea carries in its fold multiple ramifications and it is always easy and feasible to justify the suppression of an idea or a piece of literature by alluding to the possibly...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Rationale Paper on 'The Outsiders' by S. E. Hinton

...1. Rationale Paper on 'The Outsiders' by S. E. Hinton Audience and Rationale This novel is suitable across a wide range of grades, from 7 and 8 in middle school, right through all high school grades. Described as Young Adult Literature and aimed at ages from 12 years to 17plus, it contains many elements which would immediately engage students. Some educators have suggested that less academically minded students would relate easily to the book, and in so doing, may be motivated to pursue further literary examples.(Wilder and Teasley, 1998) It has enough material to encourage discussion, study, report writing and to work well as a whole class study. By involving themselves in these...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Challenging Banning Boxing

...Charley Mitchell 5. Glorioso 19 March 2007 Boxing: Should it be Banned or Not Centuries have passed and boxing is still considered as one of the most followed sports today. According to history, boxing originated when a person first lifted a fist against another in play" ("Boxing History"). The boxers used to play bare-fist; it was only in 1866 when the Marquess of Queensberry supported a new set of rules that includes the mandatory use of gloves ("Boxing History"). It was in the 18th century when professional boxing started booming. It even found a permanent place in the Olympics. Apart from being a sport, boxing is used as a self-defense. As in any other physical games and martial arts, boxing instills discipline...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Band of Outsiders

...Band of Outsiders Introduction: Band of Outsiders was the film which was rotating around the three wretched mates in 1964, directed by Jean-Luc Godard. The film was known as Bande A Part in its French version. The film pitched the hymn of youthful folly and playful homage to American pulp fiction. This film tracked the trio of unfortunate classmates, formulating a small-time heist one poetically unwelcoming Paris winter. The movie was based on the novel Fool's Gold by Dolores Hitchens. The movie was one of the finest ever work by Jean-Luc Godard. It was a lyrical tragic comedy, perhaps was one of the Godard's most charming ...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Labeling Theory

... and views them as different from the mainstream society". It is also the case that deviant outsiders consider those rule-making or rule-abiding members of society as being the outsiders of their social group. Becker identifies the primary deviance as the first step which may take place either intentionally or unintentionally. The second step or the secondary deviance leading to a career in crime results from the acceptance of the deviant label by the rule breaking people. "The final step in the creation of a career delinquent involves the movement of a rule breaker into a deviant subculture." (Crime Theory) An individual who is a labeled deviant derives moral support and self-justifying rationale when he/she gets affiliated... of...
28 Pages(7000 words)Essay

Banning Flag Burning

...Banning Flag Burning Flag desecration is a term used to de any insult or damage to the official flag of a nation. Acts of desecration may include flag burning, or using the flag for inappropriate commercial purposes. Over the years, flag burning has been used as a means of protest against certain government policies. This has evoked some rather sharp and intense reactions from all over the country, reactions that have stirred up the widespread debate regarding the issue. The national flag of a country is one of its most revered and respected symbols. And thus, flag burning is seen as a huge insult to the very integrity of the nation. Not only has the issue invoked strong opposition from the masses, it has also found...
5 Pages(1250 words)Thesis Proposal

Use of drugs in Sports

... in Sport, Waddington emphasizes the issue in which drug-users and non-drug users in a community have a relationship in which the former group is considered to have behaviours not conforming to accepted standards (Dunning & Waddington, 2003). Hence, sportsmen such as bodybuilders who are often associated with drug use are considered outsiders (Dunning & Waddington, 2003). That is, society associates sportsmen such as bodybuilders with drug/steroid abusers. Waddington and Malcolm thus feel that sports has often been associated with drugs and such an association could be exploited to help curb drug use by sportsmen and the youth who look up to sportsmen and women as role models. Rationale and Problem Statement The sporting world... to...
6 Pages(1500 words)Dissertation

Books Banning

... Banning books Books have always been one of the most important educational resources for teachers, and other members of the academia. The learning community has heavily relied on books for the advancement of their knowledge and ongoing learning. Even after the arrival of the internet, a large portion of students, teachers, and other learners rely on the availability of books for acquiring knowledge and understanding. Not all books are informational, yet they still provide essential information on many aspects of life that may not be otherwise communicated well through other channels. Books act as central means of imparting knowledge and communicating diverse thoughts, ideas, and viewpoints. As such, they act as useful instruments... for...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Rationale for Banning The Outsiders for FREE!

Contact Us