Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Philosophical Analogy - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Philosophy is all-encompassing. The very nature of it makes it possible to make an impression on every aspect of life. It does then, becomes a daunting task to discuss in totality all principles, theories, assertions, arguments and standpoints of the four theorists in which this paper concerns of: Plato and Derrida, Aristotle and Foucault…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Philosophical Analogy
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Philosophical Analogy"

Download file to see previous pages While Plato was Aristotle's mentor, Foucault was once Derrida's teacher. Derrida and Foucault are both French philosophers who are part of 20th-Century-Western Philosophy. As would be expected, the latter philosophers would have a considerable amount of study on the works or references of the earlier theorists. Derrida's work Plato's Pharmacy is an attack to Plato's famous work Phaedrus. While Foucault counters Aristotle's "enduring substances" with his claim that everything is "historically contingent".
Plato's Phaedrus "is a rich and enigmatic text that treats a range of important philosophical issues, including metaphysics, the philosophy of love, and the relation of language to reality, especially in regard to the practices of rhetoric and writing" (Zuern par. 1). In this particular dialogue, Plato through the character Socrates (with his conversation with Phaedrus) shows explicit criticisms on the art of rhetoric and writing. He argues that rhetoric is not based on truth but that rhetoric practitioners can and will "make small things appear great and great things small", and adds that these people "have discovered how to argue concisely and at infinite length about any subject" and use "words' magic spell" (267). His stance is that, rhetoric is misleading and only aims to be persuasive to achieve its goal in whatever means, without being truthful. It is, as far as he is concerned, only dependent on language and words and not on truth.
What Plato favors and promotes is the use of his dialectical method, the method which is "capable of helping itself as well as the (person) who planted it" and "produces a seed from which more discourse grows in the character of others" (277). The idea is that, compared to rhetoric (writing), the dialectical method (speech), can construe clearer definitions by means of producing further discussions, which would validate or not the claim of truth, and thus, would achieve value, with the truth it is affirming and not merely by the rhetoric of writing.
This argument is deconstructed by Derrida in his work Plato's Pharmacy, where he centralizes his analogy on Plato's use of the term pharmakon in his works. With that analogy, Derrida highlights the ambiguity of Plato's distinction of the sophist's rhetoric from the philosopher's dialectical method. Derrida questions Plato's preference of "living" speech over "dead" writing.
To understand the way Derrida deconstructed Plato's Phaedrus, it is important to go back to the latter's work and analyze the way pharmakon was used. First off though, we have to establish what the term means prior to Plato's context. Pharmakon is "from a Greek word meaning both poison and cure" (Maslin par. 8). Thus, it has a neutral stance, it does not have a negative or a positive connotation attached to it. It can either be a harmful poison or a helpful medicine, making the word ambiguous and would only take its meaning depending on the context of its use.
The term is first encountered on Phaedrus, taking on a different form pharmacia. On their way to leave Athens, Phaedrus and Socrates came across the place where it was said that the mythic Oreithuia was taken away by Boreas. Socrates then goes to assume that perhaps "a gust of the North Wind blew (Oreithuia) over the rocks where she was playing with Pharmacia; and once she was killed that way people ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Philosophical Analogy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Philosophical Analogy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from
(Philosophical Analogy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Philosophical Analogy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words.
“Philosophical Analogy Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Philosophical Analogy

Modern Architecture and Modernity

...landscape. Even today, contemporary high-tech design aesthetics are based on Fuller’s designs and engineering principles. The architect’s philosophical analogy of being a Trim Tab or mover of big ships, for improving the way the world works is a unique one. A trim tab is “a small rudder used to turn the larger rudder of big ships, offering tremendous leverage in terms of steering and changing the direction of the ship” (Gabel & Walker 2006). Thus, the trim tab, according to Buckminster Fuller is a powerful metaphor for effective individual leadership, denoting that small and appropriate interventions are capable of leading to large-scale and profound progress. Fuller followed the principle of the trim...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Philosophical Thought

...Philosophical Thought 22 July Final Paper for Philosophical Thought In the discussion of the studied module for this course, there lies the concept between the saint and the hero, two kinds of archetypes that represent the best qualities of the human spirit from different spectrums. The saint is the archetype that focuses on the spiritual well-being of an individual in light of the divine and the universe, while the hero portrays the qualities found best in human endeavors and efforts. In my opinion, I believe that the value of human existence is best found in balancing the saint and hero qualities, putting them in harmony with each other. While explaining my position, discussion will be made with regard...
8 Pages(2000 words)Thesis

Philosophical Reconstruction

...? 28 April Argument Reconstruction of Descartes’ Meditations (Second Meditation) The Second Meditation of Descartes' Meditations on First Philosophy: Concerning the Nature of Human Mind: That is Better Known than the Body, is rather testing and complicated, and sometimes it is not "trouble-free" to follow what he intends to carry out. While Descartes' claim is not solely and completely clear-cut and well-defined - he does not openly create the relationships that I will formulate, instead, indirectly draws attention to those relationships – the claim is adept of reconstruction. Firstly, observe that Descartes presents two leading issues in the second meditation: (1) the cognito (the idea on thinking); (2) the wax argument... 28 April Argument...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Philosophical reasoning

...Two women have built profound philosophies on the of feminism. They have both taken a journey into reasoning and logic that few people ever truly go on in search of the realities of life. Simone de Beauvoir and Christina Sommers both raise interesting points and arguments, both making clear what equity really refers to and the differences that exist between men and women. Comparing and contrasting Beauvoir's "The Second Sex" and Sommers' "Who Stole Feminism" on their philosophical reasoning on the subject at hand has the ability to enlighten the philosophical mind joining them on their journeys. Both Beauvoir and Sommers address the issue of feminism from a systematic or topical method in which they...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Analogy between Science and Religion

...The basis for the dominance that science gained compared to religion was the power of reason and the support of empirical data that science commanded. Realizing this, theologians have always tried to prove that religion was as scientific as science is. From this attempt, grew an effort to correlate scientific models with religious myths. The ambiguities that still remained in the field of science were cited by these scholars to prove that science also depends on analogies and metaphors as religion does. This crucial attempt of analogy between science and religion, though commanding not much significance in modern times, has of course made the cohabitation of science and religion an easier exercise. The...
11 Pages(2750 words)Literature review

Philosophical debates

...such as enhanced interrogation techniques. Both philosophers, however, were very clever men who would be able to cogently argue both positions of the argument. A good example of 18th century terrorism was the French Revolution, which had the aim of overthrowing the aristocracy and declaring the independence of the other classes. The event was historically very significant and caused huge political ripples at the time. This was one of the first times Republicanism had reared its head on the European continent. Burke strongly opposed the Revolution, believing that violent revolution was not acceptable and would in the end change nothing. It is important to note that these Revolutionaries did not attack London or...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Historical analogy

...Running Head: Historical Analogy Historical Analogy Historical Analogy The paper is aimed to present an analogy of the different events in history. One of the most discussed events in the 20th century is the Great Depression. The period of Great Depression can be considered as one of the most economically devastating event in history. It had presented lessons on the society and economy that can help in facing subsequent similar events. The focus of the study is to specifically present the parallelism of the Great Depression to the present economic situation referred to as the economic meltdown. The Great Depression is similar to the global economic meltdown of 2008...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Thomas Donovan Lesson Assignment 5: Analogy Exercise

... Thomas Donovan Lesson Assignment 5: Analogy Exercise From the article en d “Should the Stand Your Ground law for gun owners be repealed?” written by Gary Stein, the author’s thesis explored the support of advocates of gun lovers for the ‘Stand Your Ground’ law in Florida (Stein par. 4). The author is comparing the gun lovers’ support for this new law with their hating any gun law in general. Stein averred that gun lovers “are strongly behind the “Stand Your Ground” law in Florida, which basically lets people who claim to have used their gun in self-defense to turn themselves into the victims” (Stein par. 4). The two things being compared by the author are support for a particular enactment involving restricting the use of guns... . The...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Criticizing an Argument by Analogy

... TV is a drug. Just say, No. Imagine that foraging ants are compelled to live a life where they would sit around the whole day without doing anything at all. What if they had to do this for a whole month or even more? What if the foraging ants, which are accountable for finding food, as well as bringing food that they find back to the colony never did their work at all? Appears impractical? Not for human beings. Human beings have the capability of watching television as if they were hooked to a drug, and they cannot do without it. People addicted to television, go through depression, articulating that they feel as if a friend has been lost, and demonstrate the signs of opiate-withdrawal, augmented anxiety, aggravation... TV is a drug. Just...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Western Philosophical View v. Eastern Philosophical View

...Western Philosophical View versus Eastern Philosophical View One of the fundamental differences between Christianity and Buddhist is that while the former is centered on the religious teachings of Gatuama, the latter is centered on the teachings and life of Jesus Christ. Likewise, Buddhism can be described as being non-theistic because there is no believe in a supreme creator. On the contrary, Christianity is a monotheistic religion that believes in the supreme creator of the universe, who is also the father of Jesus Christ. Buddhism seems to be an offshoot religion of Hinduism while Christianity draws its teachings and beliefs from the Abrahamic religion and Judaism. The two religions are, however,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Philosophical Analogy for FREE!

Contact Us