Nobody downloaded yet

EU Constitutional Law - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The EU's competence in respect of effective and democratic governance has been constantly under scrutiny. The main drawback to EU governance was its restricted decision making due to the Member States' veto powers, collective action problems for private interest groups and the regulatory competition triggered by the single market programme…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
EU Constitutional Law
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "EU Constitutional Law"

Download file to see previous pages The frustration with integration theories was due to, first, the scope of the study of integration, second, the participants who were effectively engendering integration and third, the process or mechanism of integration. This approach indicated the importance of certain factors, which had been omitted in the initial assessment. Despite, rejection by the intergovernmental conference, the proposed introduction showed that the Convention's aim was to vitalize the idea of democracy. The democratic constitution of the European Communities was considered unimportant and unnecessary by many scholars who felt that an internal market endorsed individual freedom1. In spite of this, the EU's transformation from purely economic to political cooperation has necessitated such thinking.
The Amsterdam Treaty2 has incorporated democracy as a fundamental value into the foundational treaties3. Article 2 of the Treaty Establishing a Constitution for Europe4 (CT) lists democracy as a central value of the Union and Articles 1- 47 buttresses this notion under the title "The Democratic Life of the Union" as representative5 and participatory6 democracy.
Although, the necessity of democratic governance is universally recognized its discourse, premises and content are frequently discussed7. The holistic approach is based on society and the assumption that there exists a common good which differs from the aggregate of all individual interests. The subject of legitimacy in the individualist position refers to the individual and hence, the aim of public policy is to promote individual interests. A state-centered collectivist approach deters further integration and limits decision-making to the national parliaments8. Hence, at the European level, the Council of Ministers have to play a vital role and from an individualistic perspective and the European Parliament, which represents the European citizenry is the main organ for obtaining democratic legitimacy9.
The holistic legitimacy concept justifies the state-centered democratic vision, which states that only national peoples are subjects of legitimacy. Since, minorities accept majority decisions only if the citizenry has a certain national homogeneity, legitimacy has to be derived from national parliaments. Hence, absence of a European demos is a hurdle to further integration. The legitimacy of the state-centered, collectivist approach is dubious as no relationship exists between society and the nation state10, which is independent of a national or homogenous group11 or a cultural, religious or social consensus.
Constitutional Treaty and Legitimacy.
Article 2 CT lists dignity and individual liberty in the Union's fundamental values with the individualistic concept of democracy being adopted theoretically and it accords center stage to the individual in the European legal order, which is further strengthened by the guarantee of equality prescribed in Articles 2 and 45 CT. These provisions grant European citizens equal rights, rendering mediation of citizen's rights by a state or nation unnecessary. Therefore, the guarantee of liberty and equality exemplify that the European Constitution is based on an individualistic concept of democracy12. Article 1 (1) CT, lists the will of the member states to build a common future beneath ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“EU Constitutional Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(EU Constitutional Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3250 Words)
“EU Constitutional Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3250 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document


Constitutional law

...Constitutional law Question l a In my opinion, based on the constant disruption tea partiers cause in congressional office buildings and capitol, it is unlawful for any individual within a hundred feet of any congressional office building in addition to the Capital Building to advance a representative within eight feet to pass any kind of pamphlet. This is based on probable difference in views between the Capital Building representative and the elected representative. In addition, restrictions are stipulated in regards to matters of security and safety. Moreover, it is unlawful for any person to wave a sign to or engage in oral protest during congressional hearing without consent from the chairperson....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The efficacy of the principle of supremacy of EU law depends on its reception in national constitutional courts. Discuss

...?The Efficacy of the Principle of Supremacy of EU Law Depends On Its Reception in National Constitutional Courts The principle of supremacy is the key element in the legal system of the European Community. It makes sure that the Community law is applied uniformly and in an effective manner. It is clearly stated in the European Court of Justice case law that the Community law is above the national laws of the member states, and this includes the fundamental standards of their state constitutions. It is important to note that the precise scope and basis of supremacy has been leading in both academic and...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Constitutional Law

...summarily searched and harassed, the entire fabric an understanding of why the freedom of speech was important and should be appreciated would necessarily evaporate (Harr, 2012). Similarly, the right to own and bear arms would have little if any merit if any and all non-owners worsen merely harassed and searched by law enforcement officials at each and every juncture. The same can of course be applied with regards to the rights of African-Americans or women to vote, the same could be applied with regards to freedom of assembly and/or freedom of religion. In fact, each and every amendment the United States Constitution is predicated upon the belief that the United States government will not retaliate...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Constitutional Law

...Running Head: Constitutional law Constitutional Law s Constitutional Law A constitution is a system of rules which describes the structure and powers of government, the relationship between different parts of the government and citizen. When talking about a constitutional government, we really mean whether or not the United Kingdom has a constitution. This is a discussion which has been argued over many years. The sources of the constitution are also important, statue law, common law, royal prerogative, conventions, works of authority,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Constitutional Law of the EU the purposive reasoning employed by the ECJ as a means of furthering its own aims for the Community. Section 3 of the European Communities Act 1972 makes it obligatory for all the courts to interpret EC law according to the rulings of the ECJ. The UK courts though unreluctant to apply directly effective provisions have nevertheless been clearly unwillingness to apply the Von Colson principle.18 In United Kingdom v Council,19 the Article 118a of the EC's time procedure under which the employee is supposed to work was established. The UK disagreed to accept this proposal with a contention that the legislative competence was not taken into account. Whilst acknowledging EU's competence in that area, it...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

Constitutional Law

...and Masterman observe: “…at the same time they were proud of their long-established common law and constitutional traditions, including deference to parliament and to the executive in judicial review cases, as manifested in the Wednesbury doctrine.”5 The Wednesbury doctrine is the approach adapted by the courts in respect of judicial review in Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v.Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223. In this case it was held that the applicant for judicial review is required to satisfy the court that no reasonable public official would have reached the conclusion that the official under review came to.6 Moreover, the court went on to state that it will not stand in an appellate...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Constitutional Law of the EU

...Constitutional Law of the European Union (EU) Introduction It has been found, after a study of the facts pertaining to the case, that Directive 2006/114/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of European Union (12.12.2006) banning the use of misleading information in advertisements, which was to be implemented by the UK Government, has been disregarded, by questioning its legal validity. A directive is a mandatory compliance instrument issued to the country to which it has been addressed and cannot be invalidated under normal circumstances. “Directives only apply in those member states to which they are directed and they usually need implementing legislatures to become...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Constitutional Law of the EU

...Law of the European Community Q A The European Commission’s fundamental duty, as the guardian of the EC Treaty, is to ensure the proper implementation of EC law, throughout the EU by the Member States. The Commission monitors and supervises the implementation process. It is the regulatory authority and provides guidelines to the Member States, whenever required. The Member States must incorporate the Directives issued by the Commission into their national law completely, correctly and within the stipulated time1. Furthermore, they have to apprise the Commission about the steps and measures taken, in order to implement Directives. If they fail to do so, the Commission can initiate action under the provisions of Article 169 EC... the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

LL2012C/N Constitutional Law of the EU

...EU Constitutional Law Question One Although Adil’s claim is against his security guard company, he may take action against the UK for consequential loss. The right of action arises under the doctrine of direct effect as interpreted and applied by the European Courts.1 The doctrine of direct effect functions to ensure that Member States observe and comply with their respective obligations under the Treaty of Rome, 1957. By virtue of this tenet of EU law, parties to “legal proceedings” are at liberty to invoke and rely on EU law in domestic courts.2 In fulfilling its obligations under the Treaty of Rome, the UK enacted...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Constitutional Law of the EU

...Press Trevor Hartley., (2004). European Law in a Global Context: Text Cases and Materials. Cambridge University Press. Norbert Reich., (2003). Understanding EU Law: Objectives, Principles and Methods of Community Law. Intersentia. Hanlon, J., (2003). European Community Law. 3rd Edition Sweet & Maxwell. Lasok, D., & Bridge, J.W (1994). Law and Institutions of the European Communities. Butterworths. Franz C. Mayer (2006). Supremacy –Lost WHI Paper 2/06 German Law Journal Vol 6 No 11 pp1497-1507. GF Mancini and T Keeling, (1991) From CILFIT to ERT: The Constitutional Challenge Facing the European...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic EU Constitutional Law for FREE!

Contact Us