StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Division between the Scottish Highlands and Lowlands - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Division between the Scottish Highlands and Lowlands" it is clear that despite the widely spread opinion that the Highland Scots were Catholic, in fact, they were mostly Protestants and attempts of Reformation to turn them into Catholic religion have failed…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
Division between the Scottish Highlands and Lowlands
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Division between the Scottish Highlands and Lowlands"

How significant was the division between the Scottish Highlands and Lowlands The of the present work is history of Scotland, and will discuss the significance of the division between the Highlands and the Lowlands. It is not under argument, that this division, though being not physical, but more cultural and attitudinal, has created serious impact on the whole Scottish history and attitudes between people. However, it is necessary to describe the situation through the prism of history, making closer look at the events which took place at that time, and then to define the impact of those events on the Scottish history. Introduction The division between the Scottish Highlands and Lowlands was not an unexpected event, and has become the cause of the major impact on the Scottish history and the human attitudes. It is interesting to note, that the topic of Highlands-Lowlands division is closely connected with the discussion of the British imperialism and its impact on the development of Scottish nationalism (or national identity), as it is a historical fact, that the development of imperialism had already reached rather significant level, but its spreading onto the Highlands territory was prevented by the division between Highlands and Lowlands; although the connection between the division and the Scottish nationalism is seen, the work will not make special accent on this topic, but we will here look at the general impact on people, their culture and the whole future history of Scotland which was made by this division. The division of the Highlands and Lowlands has created a major impact on the fact that Scottish people didn't feel like entire nation and the notion of nation has ceased to exist for them. However, this impact was created through the number of factors, which are to be considered separately in this work. Highlands and Lowlands The feudal movement, which existed in Scotland, was one of the major engines, making the division of the Scotland closer. The roots of the division lay in the fact, that King David, being active supporter of the feudalism and making everything possible to spread it over the country, has unconsciously divided Scotland into two parts: the estates, which he often granted to his lords, were mainly situated in the southern part of the country, making it more bourgeois and developed, and thus closer to Britain - not physically, but in economic development and culture. It is already by that time, that Scottish nation was characterized by two different languages spoken, and two different political preferences - while the Highlands was closer to Ireland, the Lowlands at the moment tended to speak Teutonic (modern English) and thus culturally to be closer to England. The manners and customs of the Scots vary with the diversity of their speech. For two languages spoken amongst them, the Scottish and Teutonic, the latter of which is the language of those who occupy the seaboard and plains, while the race of Scottish speech inhabits the Highlands and outlying islands. The people of the coast are of domestic civilized habits; the Highlanders and people of the islands, on the other hand, are savage and untamed race, rude and independent, given to rapine, ease-loving, hostile to English people and language - and exceedingly cruel.'1 This extract makes it evident, that though the division between Highlands and Lowlands is mostly discussed through the period, starting with the 17th century, the roots of the problems were already apparent in the 14th century. Knowledge and understanding of these roots is essential for defining the significance of this division both for the history and for the people. Though the later period became a mark of more equal feudal development of both Scottish parts, but the discrepancies, planted earlier, remained to grow into more serious forms, which later turned into huge cultural, religious and attitudinal division between the people of one state. Closer to the beginning of the 18th century, it has become apparent that the division between the two parts of the same country had become too large. With this period of Scottish history being integral to the history of Britain as a whole, and assuming this division brought serious influence on Scotland becoming the stateless nation, or a nation without nation, it is of course necessary to define its significance through separate factors. The significance of the division between the Scottish highlands and Lowlands 'The Highlanders regarded the Lowlanders as a very inferior mongrel race of intruders, sons of little men, without heroism, without ancestry, or genius, who could neither sleep upon the snow, compose extempore songs, recite long tales of wonder or of woe, or live without bread and without shelter for weeks together, following the chace. Whatever was mean of effeminate, whatever was dull, slow, mechanical or torpid, was in the Highlands imputed to the Lowlanders, and exemplified by allusions to them'.2 This was the situation at the beginning of the 18th century. Though the Lowlands were feudally more developed, there was no significant difference between the Highlands and the Lowlands in their economic development. Instead, the cultures developed by the two parts of nation, caused constant suspicion, with which each of the two cultures considered another one. The significance of this division could probably be smoother, if not for the hostility and hatred, which at the time were usual between the representatives of these two country's parts. Some authors state the roots for such hatred lay in the development of clans, which was characteristic of that period3, but in fact I may also agree with Davidson4, who wrote that different religions, languages and attitudes towards law were the real causes for the situation described. The significance of the division has first of all influenced the attitudes towards law between these two parts of the Scottish society. While the Highlanders had been previously characterized as savage and cruel people, the division put a tint of permissiveness on them. The period of the 17th century was characterized by the disregard to order and law, and frequent attacks on the Lowlanders and their property. Which is more interesting, that in this hunting for profits, even other Highland communities became the victims of such marauding. However, this impact is not the major one in the division between the Highlands and the Lowlands - the middle of the 18th century has witnessed the decrease of criminality among Highlanders.5 This impact should be viewed from these points of view - the attitudes towards disorder and the following criminality decrease; though knowing that the Lowlanders were hardly opposing to such state of affairs, it may be concluded that they hardly gave the fact of their herds driven off, much consideration. The significance of the division in this aspect is seen not only through the disorders, but also through the forming attitudes between people - while Highlanders have acquired an opportunity to maraud the Lowlanders as the 'inferior' nation, they have only supported their image as 'savage and cruel' in the eyes of those who inhabited the Lowland part of the country. Thus, the country being divided geographically has also become divided by attitudes. 'The seventeenth century, from the Scottish entry into the War of the Three Kingdoms, was the watershed during which attitudes on the Lowland side of the Highland Line hardened into a hostility whose full and terrible consequence would only become apparent at the climax of the revolution in 1746. Two events in particular were crucial in consolidating this hostility.' 6 One of the events mentioned was the battle of Aberdeen in 1644, when the Lowland Scots came under attack of the Irish and Highland inhabitants. The second one took place during the period of Restoration, when the population of the Scottish southwest was quartered in attempt to impose the order - the bigger part of those, who performed these actions were coming of Highlanders. These events, as a part of the Highland/ Lowland division have created major impact on the general history of the country - the two populations were by the time supposed not to belong to one nation. The significance of this division is even more evident if looking at the situation with languages and religion. While the bigger portion of Scottish inhabitants used to speak Gaelic (Scottish) with the simultaneous use of other dialects (as Bythronic, which was in fact Welsh ancestor), the division of Highlands and Lowlands has become the driver of the major division between the English and the Scottish language, with the former 'the language of those who occupy the seaboard and plains, while the race of Scottish speech inhabits the highlands and outlying islands'.7 The end of the fifteenth century was marked by the development of the 'Scots' language among the Lowlanders, which was dictated by the need and desire for the ruling class to have a separate language. Highlands have kept their Gaelic language, which was at the time supposed to be closer to Irish. Thus, through the division between the Highlands and the Lowlands the two distinctive impacts may be traced: first, they disregarded the laws adopted by the central state; second, they appeared to be unable to speak the language which was by the end of the seventeenth century spoken by most Scots. It was another contribution into the situation, when the Lowlanders supposed Highlanders not to be their natives, but rather to be close to Irish settlers. The division has caused the incomprehensibility of the two languages spoken by one nation, and has created even great discrepancies between the two cultures. Despite the widely spread opinion that the Highland Scots were Catholic, in fact they were mostly Protestants and attempts of Reformation to turn them into Catholic religion have failed. Moreover, speaking other language, incomprehensible for Lowlanders, this task was almost impossible. Highlanders hardly recognized the Scottish Catholic Church. For this reason Highlanders were mostly perceived by the Lowlanders as 'Irish'. This has only contributed into disagreement, which had already existed between the representatives of both parts of the state by that time. 'Lowland Kirk ministers constantly complained of the failure of the Reformation to make permanent inroads beyond the Highland line. One of their key preoccupations was that the perpetuation of the Gaelic language was preventing the Highlanders from being converted to the Calvinist version of Christianity practised by the Church of Scotland. We are dealing here with the effect of perceptions, not their relationship to reality.'8 Conclusion: Scotland the stateless nation The division between the Highlands and the Lowlands may be seen in general as a serious contribution into the fact that the nation was in fact divided into two different societies, which in its turn has become the cause of the situation, when both parts of society didn't view the notion of 'nation' as central and necessary for them to be united. The division started from the economic factors, being heated by the discrepancies on cultural, religious and ideological grounds. The Lowlanders got accustomed to perceiving the Highlanders as 'Irish' for their close links with Ulster. The stateless nation - or, better, the nation without nation - this is how Scotland could be called at that period, and the division between the Highlands and the Lowlands was the principal driver of these changes in the life of Scottish society; the society, which has been divided into two different parts, having nothing in common and regarding each other with hostility and even cruelty. This division has prevented the creation of the solid basis for the Scottish nation as a whole, and made it possible only centuries later. Bibliography Davidson, Neil. The Origins of Scottish Nationhood. Edinburgh: Pluto press, 2004 Dickinson, William Croft. Scotland from the Earliest Times to 1603. London: Thomas Nelson and Sons, 1961 Ferguson, William. The Identity of the Scottish Nation: An Historic Quest. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University press, 1998 Fry, Fiona Somerset. The History of Scotland. London: Routledge, 1992 Grant, Anne. Essays on Superstitions of the Highlanders of Scotland. London, 1811. Harvie, Christopher. Scotland and Nationalism: Scottish Society and Politics, 1707 to the Present. London: Routledge, 1998. Mackenzie, W.C. The Highlands and Isles of Scotland. A Historical Review. London, 1924. Mitchinson, Rosalind. Why Scottish History Matters. Edinburgh: Saltire Society, 1991. Mitchinson, Rosalind. A History of Scotland. London: Routledge, 2002 Williamson, A. Scottish National Consciousness in the Age of James I. Edinburgh, 1973 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“How significant was the division between the Scottish Highlands and Essay”, n.d.)
How significant was the division between the Scottish Highlands and Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506887-how-significant-was-the-division-between-the-scottish-highlands-and-lowlands
(How Significant Was the Division Between the Scottish Highlands and Essay)
How Significant Was the Division Between the Scottish Highlands and Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506887-how-significant-was-the-division-between-the-scottish-highlands-and-lowlands.
“How Significant Was the Division Between the Scottish Highlands and Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506887-how-significant-was-the-division-between-the-scottish-highlands-and-lowlands.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Division between the Scottish Highlands and Lowlands

The Management Team in Scotland

Rainfall varies widely from 3, 000 mm per year to 800 mm in the Western highlands and the East Cost respectively.... Most of the other population lives in the north-eastern lowlands in Dundee and Aberdeen.... This essay discusses Scotland that has attractive benefits to attract good investment....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Alternative Existence System for Scotland

This was mainly due to the high political consensus of the scottish people.... The Marquis of Montrose's brutal attempts at repression with an army of Irish Catholic mercenaries were also to feed into the scottish consciousness.... the scottish political system.... However it was the scottish agricultural revelotuion, which changed the low land area and the traditional farming methods were replaced by efficient and stable agricultural syste....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Scotland, the Stateless Nation

Many attempted to settle in Central America through the scottish sponsored Darien project with a hope of establishing the same success as the English.... There they were fated to die, abandoned by both the scottish and English government.... the scottish government and investors lost huge amounts of capital that contributed to the later depression of the 17th Century3.... Herein, the English turned the scottish laird and chieftain to their purposes and ultimately through them destroyed the scottish nation....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Buses in Scotland as Aspects of Sustainable Transport Mode

The bus is an essential means of transport in Scotland; because of its importance for the local social needs but also for the environment, the scottish government has developed a framework of rules regulating the bus operators across the country.... the scottish government has developed a series of sustainable policies applicable to the bus industry.... The success of this effort is examined in this study; the support of the scottish Government towards these efforts seems to be important; it should be updated, though, in order to meet the needs of these firms in the terms of sustainability....
34 Pages (8500 words) Thesis

The Idea of Being British

the scottish people are an ethnic group native to Scotland, an amalgamation of the Picts and the Gaels.... he notion of Britishness was shamed during the Napoleonic Wars between Britain and the First French Empire that later developed further during the Victorian era....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Music World Culture

The discussion here commences with the historical, sociological, and geographical information of Scotland regarding its people, culture, and society; and particularly focuses on the music world culture that includes cultural information about the country's unique music, dance, and instruments of the scottish people.... However, there are myriad things that make scottish culture unrecognizably unique from the rest.... Scotland's population is estimated to be more than 5 million, as per the census 2011, with a population of 62 percent identified as being purely scottish, 18 percent as scottish and British, 8 percent as British only, and 4 percent as other national identities....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Highland Clothes - a Medieval Tartan Fashion

The report 'Highland Clothes – a Medieval Tartan Fashion' presents a brief introduction about a symbolic dress style considered by historians as turnout representing social status in Scotland, associating with Jacobitism and the scottish people and restrained by Parliament in 1746.... The Act of Parliament on the part of the British hoped to make the scottish people become more subservient and the law wanted to abolish the dissimilitude of appearance between the Highlanders and the other inhabitants....
6 Pages (1500 words) Article

Cultural Beliefs of Scotland

The writer will explain the culture and beliefs of the scottish people.... the scottish kilt is coming back on the catwalk.... he heroes who fought for Scotland's freedom made the scottish proud of their sovereignty.... National symbols such as the scottish thistle, the iron rampant, and the St Andrews cross (Saltire) on the national flag have origins in that period.... scottish culture is not stagnant.... scottish culture is not stagnant....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us