StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Conscious Obedience - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In a civilized world, we would like to believe that we are all generally well behaved and in being so, we are all obeying someone or something. It may be an authority figure or it may be a concept such as a law or morality. Young children will obey their parents and their parents will obey law enforcement…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
Conscious Obedience
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Conscious Obedience"

Download file to see previous pages In a very general sense, everyone obeys out of their own self-interest. However, this places the fear of punishment on an equal plane with the promise of a reward and does not shed much light on the underlying reasons. The question that needs to be answered is; what self-interest are we fulfilling when we obey Kelman and Hamilton argue that obedience comes from one of three rationalizations. Compliance for self-interest, acknowledgment of authority, or ethical concerns (Tyler 1090). A person may comply with the request to work overtime at no pay in hopes of getting a promotion. In their identification of authority model, a person may act against their better judgment if the boss orders them to take an illegal action. People also have the capacity to exercise free will and act according to their own value system.
Psychological theorists can help explain obedience by examining the motivation behind the reward we receive for compliance. Maslow would describe the humanist viewpoint as obeying to gain respect and recognition from authority. Skinner would see obedience as a natural conditioned reaction to doing what we are told. Bronfenbrenner describes a myriad of authorities that we obey on an individual or group level. The echological argument holds that patriotism is obedience to nationalism. Obedience can take many forms and the authority may be abstract.
Young children may obey their parents because they understand it is the right thing to do and is an ethical decision. It may be self-interest, as they will obey them to avoid their parent's punishment, or to gain a reward. However, a child's inner logic may not be apparent through their actions alone. Children who have been abused, neglected, or feel abandoned may withdraw and suffer from defeatism (Singer, Dornenbal, and Okma, 601). They will display obedience though it may not be for the self-interest that it appears.
In a study of children by Singer, Dornenbal, and Okma, the researchers found significantly more foster children offered little or no resistance to parental authority than their birthchildren counterparts (596). Birthchildren had a much higher incidence of offering fierce resistance in a disciplinary conflict than foster children (596). In the case of the foster children, the researchers noted that, "Their main goal is unilateral-self-saving [...] Their main interests are fear of punishment and a feeling of powerlessness" (601). The birthchildren that were offering intense rebellion were said to have, " [...] unilateral coercive goals to get their own way" (594). The birthchildren were acting in self-interest to exploit the parental authority's lack of resolve, while the foster children were obeying for self-preservation.
As children grow into adulthood, they will for the most part become more aware of the need for obedience. The cost of punishment by law enforcement will generally get most people to abide by acceptable customs. The need for a steady paycheck will insure that they will put their feelings aside when taken advantage of in the workplace. They may rationalize to themselves, and others, that they are being obedient in order to live up to a moral or ethical standard. Adults may allow ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Conscious Obedience Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506810-conscious-obedience
(Conscious Obedience Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506810-conscious-obedience.
“Conscious Obedience Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506810-conscious-obedience.
  • Cited: 1 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Conscious Obedience

Conformity and obedience

...?Conformity and Obedience: Conformity to social norms and obedience to higher ities are values that are instilled in people right from the day they are born. There are merits attached to this practice, for elderly people (who are also usually the authority figures) have more knowledge and experience than young people and it makes sense to heed their words. As alluded to in the textbook Social Psychology by authors Saul Kassin, et.al, there are evolutionary grounds for this tendency in humans. For example, from the evolutionary viewpoint children who obeyed and conformed to the instructions given by their parents survived to leave offspring of their own. To the contrary those who rebelled or disobeyed probably got eaten by a tiger or fell...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Stream of Conscious

...Stream of Conscious A refined piece of literature is undoubtedly the representative of the era in which it has been produced, and reflects the social and cultural aspects prevailing all around the author within his social structure. Consequently, such a superb literary piece vehemently points out towards the problems the people are undergoing as well as the activities they get involved into during their everyday life. Though hundreds of literary genres have quite unconsciously given birth to the variety of topics depicting the thoughts and actions of the members of society, there appeared a school, during the Modern Era of English Literature, which interlinked all human actions with some specific thoughtfulness. This sudden current...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Milgram and Destructive Obedience

...Milgram and Destructive Obedience Submitted by: Submitted Introduction The Holocaust is the term used to describe the planned and executed extermination of Jews from all German controlled and influenced territories. This tragic event in the history of mankind saw the death of a staggering six-million European Jews during World War II staged by the National Socialist party headed by Adolf Hitler. It was the "Final Solution to the Jewish Question" and ultimately saw the systematic execution and brutal treatment of the Jews which Germany saw as infecting the 'pure and superior' Aryan race which they imagined they belonged. Such event naturally gives rise to speculations on why the Nazi did it. Just how could an entire nation commit itself...
16 Pages(4000 words)Book Report/Review

Has Advertising Helped to Make Men More Self Conscious about Their Appearance

...Has advertising helped to make men more self conscious about their appearance? Evaluate whether this might be a good or a bad thing. Advertising has become the greatest cultural instrument these days. Any person chooses all his daily requirements on the basis of advertisement. The toothbrush to sleeping mattress that we use is selected on the basis of advertisements. And it is better not to talk about the beauty industry. Previously, this was something exclusively for women. But now the situation has changed so much that even men go behind these temptations. “No battle or movement is fought or won without casualties. Men are beginning to lose what women have begun to gain in the war against the depiction and treatment of human bodies...
10 Pages(2500 words)Coursework

Stream of Conscious

... captures the mind of an individual and keeps it under its control for a long time. Such a whimsical but long-lasting thoughtfulness is, however, not the outcome of one sudden event or incident; on the contrary, it is actually the product of the uneven circumstances prevailing in the social and natural environment of the author, which he looks for drawing out in a realistic manner through the magic of his writing dexterity. The same is applied to stream of consciousness, which concentrates upon human psychology and extracts the reflection of the fluctuations existing in human mind in one way or the other. Our conscious mental life flows, James states, continuously like a stream in which “the transition between the thought of one object...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Self-Conscious Emotions

... Self-conscious Emotions Self-conscious emotions play a pivotal role in self-control of an individual. Emotions such as pride and guilt can enable us to learn how a child reacts to his or her short sighted or immediate desires. Apparently, a child can respond either well or poorly. Self-conscious expresses itself in different emotions such as guilt, pride, embarrassment, and shame. These emotions are responsible for one’s self-consciousness owing to their relationship with the self-sense and his or her reaction to others (Hofmann and Fisher 1). Studies show that children begin to develop self-conciseness at the age of two. At this age, a child begins to understand that she is an entity with distinct qualities. There is an underlying...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper

Mothers' Health Conscious

...). Aside from this, only the averages were reported and there was no way of computing other characteristics of the distribution – we cannot know the variances of the responses to the survey, and we have no way of checking whether groups were homogenous or not. In short, while the figures used in this survey were effective at supporting the claims of the article, one cannot know the accuracy of the interpretations made. It is possible that while the mean stated that mothers are becoming more health conscious, once the variance or standard deviation of the distribution is computed, it can reveal that responses were so far away from each other where some mothers are making healthy food choices, others have no idea what it is (Quick MBA, 2010...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Obedience

...Obedience Questions Question Children require directions in most of the issues that they face. They have no past experience or knowledge upon which they can rely on to make decisions. Accordingly, authority figures in the lives of children are the sources of guidance and knowledge. It is therefore very important that children are socialized to obey such figures for their (children’s) good. Question 2: Children are taught to obey authority figures without questioning such obedience - their total obedience is required. Therefore, it is true that, on a face value, children are set on the path to the kind of obedience that is displayed in the Stanley Milgram experiment (Blass, 2002) and the McDonald incident (abc, 2005). Question 3: By obeying...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Destructive obedience

... The phrase destructive obedience refers to the idea of a person following the orders considered to be immoral, which later on will cause them a lot of regret and distress. This usually occurs with conformity which basically is the adoption of behaviors and attitudes of others even though they are against a person’s own inclinations. Factors such as prestige or the appearance of authority or power have a direct influence on destructive obedience. Obedience could also occur for instance to a superior officer such as in the military. 2. The following are strategies that may help resist destructive obedience-educating the public about dangers of the same, publicly promote and encourage dissension and lastly inoculation which is early...
2 Pages(500 words)Coursework

Conformity and Obedience

... Lecturer Philosophy, conformity and Obedience in HealthCare A nurse should act in accordance with the highest standard of ethics, competence, responsibility, efficacy as well as honesty. This is because the aim of a nurse is to provide a secure as well as caring surrounding that advances the health as well as well being of the patient. philosophy in nursing refers to attitudes to life and reality that progress from the beliefs of a nurse. This means that nurses should make their own decision on what they believe is good instead of others such as physician deciding on what should be done (Hofling et all, 1966). By administering the drug, the nurse would have broken health care rules such as; accepting the instructions through phone...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Obedience to Authority

...Obedience has been incorporated into the human sociology to transform humans from savagery to civilization. In a few cultures, obedience to certain values, religion, parents, or other authority figure is considered to be the yardstick for measuring behavioral patterns. Still in some cases and situation, obedience to authority deems desirable social behavior, for instance, when teachers or parent intend on civilizing their children and teaching them basic manners. Similarly, hierarchy and obedience of authority figures in an organization is also deemed necessary for achieving the targets and keeping the human resource at an optimum efficiency level. However, extreme cases predicate that unconditional obedience to authority figures, i.e...
4 Pages(1000 words)Admission/Application Essay

Hypnotherapy - Understanding of Conscious and Sub Conscious Processing

...Hypnotherapy - Understanding of Conscious and Subconscious Processing Affiliation: Introduction This is a therapy that employs the technique of hypnosis. The therapy leads to deep relaxations and the patient enters into an altered state of consciousness whereby the subconscious and the unconscious are assessed without any inhibitions of defences. The subconscious is the key to an effective hypnosis. The hypnotherapist is able to analytically communicate with the sub conscious without any compliance (Hamill, 2012, p.27). The patient undergoing hypnosis is under a visualization trance and the person’s mind is at free will and hence is responsive to images or even ideas which the hypnotists explores to learn about the person. Even though...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Behavioral Study of Obedience

...Research Problem The main reason as to why Milgram came up with this sort of research was in a move to determine how obedience actually worked. In the study, Milgram attempts to find out the rate at which humans obey orders; this is because according to him, many people are forced into complying orders even if they are not willing (Milgram, 1963). During the study, Milgram focuses on the Nazi regime because numerous deaths marred this era. Hence, according to him, although Nazis caused these deaths, most of them had to commit these atrocities by exhibiting utter compliance against their will (Milgram, 1963). This was due to the fear they experienced whereby in failing to execute what the leaders advocated would face similar incidences...
4 Pages(1000 words)Admission/Application Essay

The Weight and the Health Conscious

...CALORIE CALCULATOR 1. Business Concept Emerging technologies have enabled the weight and the health conscious achieve their objectives as far as their food intake and physique is concerned. Over the years, gym equipments have been created to meet the needs of those who want to build their bodies and of course, those who wish to manage their weight. It is probably now more than ever that gym operators and manufacturers of gym equipments are raking it in terms of subscription and sales. Various weight-management programs have also been introduced, and this includes the south beach diet, the Glycemic Impact Diet, among others. There are also alternative ways to manage weight, which include yoga, pilates, street jazz, and many other...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

The Evolution of the Duty of Obedience in Charitable Organizations

...The Evolution of the Duty of Obedience in Charitable Organizations from the Trust Model to the Corporate Model of Regulation Introduction Today nonprofit organizations suffer from the lack of people’s trust. Even in case if the organization’s activity is successful, people usually do not believe in its competence and reliability. Restricted gifts, which impose special conditions, become widespread and philanthropists received a right to apply for breaking off. Unpleasant situations and scandals spoiled the reputation of nonprofit organizations. For example, graduates do not want to maintain relations with their educational institutions because of abuses. It is difficult to assess the increasing influence of this dishonor, however...
12 Pages(3000 words)Research Paper

The Functions of the Unconscious and Conscious State of Mind against Perception

... Perception: Does the location of spatial attention affect the performance of rapid, goal-directed movements? The paper relates the functions of an unconscious and conscious states of mind against perception. For this purpose, a literature review has been elaborated over and some experimental observations of young kids/adults have also been reflected upon. Perception: Does the location of spatial attention affect the performance of rapid, goal-directed movements? Perception and the conscious-unconscious nature of mind are directly related to each other. Perception is driven by the unconscious and conscious observance. For decades, all human processes were thought to be of conscious nature; only recently have scientists begun...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

The Obedience to Authority

...Obedience to Authority and How It is Evil Two short stories tend to shock people with their endings and implications: Jackson's “The Lottery” and LeGuin's “The Ones Who Walked Away from Omelas.” These stories underlie the darkness present in humanity, a darkness that has been too “old” to be completely removed. This essay analyzes how following authority produces evil. Obedience to authority results in evil in the stories “The Lottery” and “The Ones Who Walked Away from Omelas,” because of appearance of convention, cowardice, and ordinariness of violence. Convention and law are common sources of authority, which many people can follow mindlessly, however evil their outcomes may be. In “The Lottery,” Old Man Warner stresses...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Are Animals Conscious

...Are Animals Conscious? The debate about animal consciousness is not a new one. It is one of the areas of science that have never been resolved. Behavioral psychologists and cognitive scientists have had and continue to have their views on the matter, but still there is no common ground. It has been a subject of philosophical thought too. There are those who insist that animals are conscious and others that oppose such an assertion. It is difficult to study and really understand animal consciousness because animals lack the ability to express human language and cannot talk about their experiences. This essay asserts that much as animals do not possess the intelligence of a human being, they are conscious and may express behaviors...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Conscious Obedience for FREE!

Contact Us