Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

The Death of Humanity in The Overcoat and Bartleby the Scrivener - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Herman Melville's Bartleby the Scrivener and Nikolai Gogol's The Overcoat are, at first glance, very similar in terms of plot, characterization and ideology. Both protagonists are scriveners who are portrayed as the exploited laborers in a capitalistic society…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
The Death of Humanity in The Overcoat and Bartleby the Scrivener
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Death of Humanity in The Overcoat and Bartleby the Scrivener"

Download file to see previous pages The reader's reaction and emotive responses to the deaths of these gentlemen are different for each story because of the narrators.
Both stories, as discussed, are similar and these similarities will be dealt with swiftly. Akakievitch is described, in every way, as a second-class citizen, an exploited laborer at the mercy of an unjust society. "He was what is called a perpetual titular councilor, over which, as is well known, some writers make merry, and crack their jokes, obeying the praiseworthy custom of attacking those who cannot bite back" (Gogol, 1). His appearance matched his unfortunate status in life "-short of stature, somewhat pock-marked, red-haired, and short-sighted, with a bald forehead, wrinkled cheeks, and a complexion of the kind known as sanguine." (Gogol, 1)"His superiors treated him in coolly despotic fashion" (Gogol 2). Bartleby gives us the same impressions. The narrator saw him as "pallidly neat, pitiably respectable, and incurably forlorn!" (Melville, 5) and was also
employed as a scrivener for very little money. Both men die because they cannot function in a world in which they have no control, a world in which they feel isolated and mistreated. Akakievitch dies from a fever with which he is afflicted because his new overcoat is stolen, a coat for which he has sacrificed and obsessed over for many months. His obsession could very well be seen as the cause of his demise, but it was the one thing he could control. He picked the tailor, the fabric, and the style and even changed his demeanor when he wore the coat. Even though the St. Petersburg winters forced him to buy a new coat, he controlled the details. It was his biggest achievement in a life that was "littered" with obstacles and adversities. When his coat was taken from him, he was devastated, much like the lover who must endure unrequited love.
Bartleby died because he, too, was deprived of his only avenue of control. "I prefer not to" was a regular response to a boss who symbolizes the tyranny and exploitive behavior of the upper class proletariat of Melville and Gogol's time. From a Marxist's point of view, Bartleby's defiance can be interpreted as a resistance against capitalist oppression. Melville was a strong advocate of social justices and economic reform, a subject directly related to the social problems arising from industrialization in 19th century America. Although Gogol was a Russian, he too was a strong advocate for social justice. He wrote, however, under political censorship and that could explain why he needed to end his story with the fantastical element of a ghost. It would turn a rather didactic political statement into an Aesop's fable. The Americans had no such censorship.
Bartleby and Akakievitch both suffered from malnutrition, a significant factor in their deaths, since neither ate properly. Their reasons for such extreme actions were, however, quite different. Akakievitch sacrificed his evening meal for his new coat. "He even got used to being hungry in the evening, but he made up for it by treating himself, so to say, in spirit, by bearing ever in mind the idea of his future cloak" (Gogol 7). It was his decision to make. "He became more lively, and even his character grew firmer, like that of a man who has made up his mind, and set himself a goal" (Gogol ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Death of Humanity in The Overcoat and Bartleby the Scrivener Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The Death of Humanity in The Overcoat and Bartleby the Scrivener Essay)
“The Death of Humanity in The Overcoat and Bartleby the Scrivener Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 2 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Death of Humanity in The Overcoat and Bartleby the Scrivener

The overcoat

...?The Overcoat: The narrator of The Overcoat is anonymous and his/her voice in the story is digressing. The narrator’s attitude towards Akaky is compassionate and humorous, yet the narrator brings a condescending perspective to the story. His fellow workers persecute Akaky because they are very materialistic. They only respect people who possess material that they are impressed with. Akaky maintains a downtrodden and poor image. The coat he always keeps wearing before obtaining the overcoat becomes worn off to transparency. His fellow workers do not approve of his poverty and therefore, torture him. In reply to their witty statements, Akaky calmly retorts, “Leave me alone! Why do you insult me?” (Gogol, 2006, p. 5). Akaky maintains a very...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Compare and contrast The Great Gatsby to Bartleby the Scrivener

... Task Compare and contrast The Great Gatsby to Bartleby the Scrivener Bartleby the Scrivener is a short story inscribed by Herman Melville. In this short story, an elderly lawyer hires Bartleby to work in his business, which deals with“bonds, mortgages and title deed” (Melville 3). The elder lawyer employs Bartleby to proofread the office work, but Bartleby ends up refusing to conduct the assigned responsibilities. With time, the elder lawyer fires Bartleby, but he refuses to leave his premise. Throughout the story, Bartleby encounters physical and psychological problems that later culminates to death (Melville 7). Secondly, the Great Gatsby is a novel written in 1925 by Scott Fitzgerald, which represents an American classic work...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Overcoat

...?Mini research paper Summary The literature, ‘Gogol’s “perfectly true” tale: “The overcoat” and its true mode of closure’, as was ed by Proffitt Edward, reviews the ending of the story, ‘The Overcoat’ and analyses people’s misconception of its literacy. According to the writer, the Overcoat literature is an excellent work that is perceived by many to be elusive to the reader’s imagination that considers the ending fantastic. The literature ends with news of Akaky’s death that is followed by existence of a being, understood by many as Akaky’s ghost. This perception is a development of the fact that the ghost appears just after the news of Akaky’s death. The ghost is described to have taken the form of Akaky’s professional position...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Bartleby the Scrivener and Young Goodman Brown

... “Bartleby the Scrivener” and “Young Goodman Brown Character and Community At first reading, Herman Melville’s “Bartleby the Scrivener” and Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman Brown” appear to share no common ground. Melville’s story is set in early Wall Street, peopled with lawyers. The protagonist is an enigmatic copywriter, who is completely alone in the world. The isolation of the scrivener is the focus of the story. On the other hand, Hawthorne narrates a tale of Puritan New England and a protagonist who is a young, family man. Melville’s story is a tragedy which ends in the death of Bartleby. Young Goodman Brown lives to a very old age, fathering many children and grandchildren. Melville’s narrator is Bartleby’s employer who...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Bartleby the Scrivener -the Sympathetic Narrator

The narrator is profoundly affected by his encounter with Bartleby and is moved to tell his story. The reader sees the scrivener exclusively from the narrator’s point of view. The lawyer is the interpreter of Bartleby’s actions and motives and the development of the plot rests on his interaction with the Scrivener. He is the first-hand witness who is with Bartleby as the scrivener moves into an increasingly rigid denial of work and finally, of life itself. In this context, the narrator occupies the pre-eminent position in the story, and may even arguably be considered to be its hero. The character and actions of the narrator demonstrate a deep sympathy for Bartleby which persists throughout the story. The narrator&rsqu...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Herman Melvilles Bartleby the Scrivener

... function in a modern capitalist society and the humanity of which Bartleby reminds him.' (Castle 265). The irony of Bartleby's death remains when the capitalist does not understand the true nature of Bartleby and what causes him to kill himself. This essay uses the formalist approach to examine the structure of the text using various critical theories to analyze Bartleby the Scrivener. Bartleby is an abstract and this confronts his boss as the boss himself is guilty of abstract behavior, being absorbed by the cold, materialistic world of Wall Street and legal affairs. The narrator and boss is somewhat successfully converted by Bartleby and this makes Bartleby a hero because he has sacrificed himself for the sake of another man...
5 Pages(1250 words)Book Report/Review

Bartleby the scrivener

... The Necessities of Life: Parental Guidance and Food There is an old adage that says we are what we eat. There is another old familiar haunt that reminds us that we will become our parents. The influence of food in our life is no less important than the attitudes and values instilled by our parents at an early age. We exemplify these sayings by the way we interact in our relationships as well as the type of food we eat. By looking at either one, we can predict the other. In Herman Melvilles fictional short story "Bartleby the Scrivener: A Story of Wall Street", the author entwines both until they become inseparable. Melvilles 1853 story employs food and nourishment as visual imagery to portray the ability to relate to others that we have...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Bartleby the Scrivener

...Bartleby the Scrivener Part The main character in the story is Bartleby, a scrivener a law copier or clerk working for a Wall Street lawyer in London in 1850. He was hired after answering the ad posted by the lawyer .At the beginning, he is enthusiastic in doing his work but after some time, he rejects the task given to him by politely saying “I prefer not to”. Surprisingly, the lawyer finds it hard to dismiss Bartleby since he pity this forlorn-looking man. Later, Bartleby starts living in the office and eats only ginger nut cakes brought to him by an associate. The symbolism of the food had important meaning in the story. Bartleby was not attracted to food, which could symbolize greed. This was subtly shown in the story...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Individuality in Bartleby the Scrivener

Ralph Waldo Emerson in his text ‘self reliance’ argues that an individual should not conform to the standards that have been imposed on him by the society. An individual should however seek to follow his own wishes, desires, and convictions. According to the essay, the society often has negative impacts on the individual, and often makes the individual give up his values and convictions. Instead of conforming to the society, the individual should trust himself and realize his self worth. Emerson argues that each person is a unique genius and if he (the individual) can trust himself against what the society dictates, he will realize the genius in him. An individual should think for himself and value himself against the society. Em...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Bartleby, the scrivener

...Bartleby the Scrivener The in this paragraph explains about the sadness that is taking over him. He said the sadness is due to the bond humanfeel and could have been directed towards his colleagues and office environment. He was getting a sadness which was due to brotherhood and he was feeling a closeness with Bartley because they were both human created by Adam. The narrator remembers the faces he has seen that day and remembers how happy world looks. The author is telling us that misery in the world stays away from the outside world like Bartley in a corner. The narrator is pointing out that because we do not see sadness outside we think there is no misery in world. He says that when people smile we think there is no misery in this world...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

D.H. Lawrence and Other Views on Death - How They May Help Us Deal with Death in Context to Healthcare

Lawrence graduated from University College, Nottingham in 1908, devoted himself for a time to teaching at a boy’s school, but not long after, decided to quit teaching and spend his time at freelance writing instead. In March of 1912, he met and fell in love with a married woman, Frieda Weekley, nee Richthofen; then six weeks later eloped with her to the Continent.

Frieda was a sister of the famous German World War I flying ace and wife of Lawrence’s French professor at Nottingham. This elopement marked the start of Lawrence’s lifetime war with existent moral standards as well as the beginning of a continuous wanderlust prompted by Tuberculosis which induced him to seek warmer and more healthful climes....
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Dreams in Arthur Millers Death of a Salesman

From the play’s dialogues and descriptions, the reader sees that the Loman knows the weakness of believing in half-truths about the circumstances but they choose to continue on the wrong paths. Willy, the head of the family, is not a good leader as he leads his family into believing that the road to success is based on a set of ideas that do not work in his American society. For example, he thinks that Biff should not be made to study because having spirit and personality is more important than being a ‘worm’ (bookworm). He condones his sons’ theft of property, cheating at examinations and other wrongs. The Loman sons, Biff and Happy, discuss how Willy has had a few car accidents because he had difficulty c...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Controversies in the Death Penalty in the US

In 2003 Amnesty reported 1,146 executions in 28 countries, 88% of them in just 5 countries: The People’s Republic of China 726, Iran 108, the U.S. 65, Vietnam 64, and Saudi Arabia 52 (, 2006). The U.S. went on to carry out 59 executions in 2004, 60 in 2005, 53 in 2006 and 11 until March 2007 (Death Penalty Information Center, 2007). Today, the death penalty has been abolished in the vast majority of democracies in Europe and Latin America, while it is still retained in most democracies in Asia and Africa, the U.S., Guatemala, and the countries of the Caribbean (, 2006).

As on April 2, 2007, there were 38 states in the U.S. with the death penalty and 12 without. Between 1976 and 2007 there...
14 Pages(3500 words)Case Study

Contentment and Materialism in The Overcoat and The Necklace

The stories have qualities that are reminiscent of fairy tales. Both messages are similar to those ones might find in tales designed to support a moral message. The Overcoat and The Necklace each use opposing ideas to help support the same moral message about the materialistic world.

In the story of The Overcoat, we find a man who is content in his life. His contentment is based on not needing anything but the satisfaction of his work. The life we see in Akakii Akakievich does not need the approval of others and does not need the acquisition of things in order to achieve anything more within his self-awareness. He leads a simple life that does not need, in his estimation, anything more. His attempt to repair his old ove...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Law Studies: Disposition after the Death

One of the first things that Abelard needs to do is to make sure his wishes are expressed in his will. He may also want to name a close and trustworthy friend to be the executor of his will such that that individual may interview the children of Abelard at the time of his death in order to make a subjective judgment as to whether the children are in fact followers of the Christian faith or if they are only claiming to be. In the event that the children have deceased, then Abelard’s furniture is to go to a museum that may also be executed by Abelard’s chosen executor. In addition to naming the executor, it is critical that Abelard ensure that communication regarding his exact intentions is in detail, within the will and...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Death Penalty: Does it Serve as a Deterrent to Future Crime

Animal instincts are directed towards self-preservation and it is the law of nature that a stronger and healthier individual has more chances of living than his weaker counterpart. The survival of the fittest has now been established as a ground reality according to Darwinian philosophy. If we eliminate our civilized thought process, it emerges as a stark reality that we would not desist from attacking another living person or animal when we are overcome by the basic needs of food, shelter, and clothing. In times of natural disasters like earthquakes, wars and floods, and manmade disasters like war, it is not uncommon to witness ravaged populations shedding the façade of civilization and resorting to violence in order to fu...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

Death of a Salesmen: Tragedy or Not

The diversity of the issues that have been subtly raised in his work and the way each of them has been treated in his various works have helped the author achieve the literary acclaim that he rightly deserves. The author has succinctly shown through the protagonist of the novel, Willy Loman, that the life is not a bed of roses but fraught with tragedies that force one to realize that mortality and pain are part and parcel of life It is a sensitively written play that depicts the dual nature of the life of a common man. While the play can be treated as a tragedy in the context of modern literature, some critics have contested the same under Aristotle’s interpretation of tragedy. 

Aristotle in 330BC had defined...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Shawshank Redemption:A Place Where Humanity Is Put to Test

...The Shawshank Redemption – a place where humanity is put to test. While a prison is normally taken as a restraint on one’s freedom, it is also supposed as the first step to correction of one’s offenses or crimes. The movie Shawshank Redemption directed by Frank Darabont, and released in 1994 reveals the brutal reality and corruption within the four walls of the Shawshank State Penitentiary operated by Warden Samuel Norton. The movie is based upon the work Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption by Stephen King. Despite being a place for resurrection, the prisoners often find them facing harsh situation which are unjust. the movie centers around Tim Robbins enacting as Andy Dufrense, a banker accused for killing his wife and her lover...
6 Pages(1500 words)Movie Review

The Theme of Death in Shakespeares Hamlet

The play goes ahead to question whether kings do possess a heaven’s free pass. The theme of death in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, therefore, has an influence on the lives of living human beings (Bloom 45).
In Hamlet’s mind, the idea of death did not seem awful. However, despite the fact that he became obsessed with the notion, the afterlife uncertainty frightened Hamlet from committing suicide. Hamlet’s turning point took place at the scene of the graveyard in the fifth act of the play. It was before Hamlet became revolted and shocked by the living’s moral corruption. However, when he saw the skull of Yorick whom he loved and respected propelling, he realized that death does eliminate the differences th...
8 Pages(2000 words)Literature review

The Life and Death of Alaska

The protagonist called Miles Halt who is later nicknamed Pudge by his closest friend Chip –a name that strikes us as ironical considering that he was skinny and very tall is caught in his own web of the labyrinth(HapperCollins:2014). The story sets off as brought to us in the prologue at a lonely scene in his small town. The author paints a desolate and lonely picture of the character as he plans to move from his hometown school to Culver Creek Preparatory high school in Alabama (Greene: 2007). Many people are puzzled by his move to the latter as he was all along known for his academic preoccupation at his former school. His mother perhaps more intrigued by the surprising turn of events seeks to find out the motivation behin...
7 Pages(1750 words)Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Death of Humanity in The Overcoat and Bartleby the Scrivener for FREE!

Contact Us