StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Comparison of the movie Jane Eyre and the book Jane Eyre - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Jane Eyre" by English writer Charlotte Bronte is an autobiographical novel in many respects. It is devoted to the story about modest, but proud and independent girl-orphan. The heroine of book "Jane Eyre" struggles persistently with the set of obstacles standing on her way to the independent life and personal happiness…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Comparison of the movie Jane Eyre and the book Jane Eyre
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Comparison of the movie Jane Eyre and the book Jane Eyre"

Download file to see previous pages Jane Eyre is an ardent and strong personality, the carrier of the spontaneous protest against any oppression. In the childhood she openly rises against the rich and hypocritical aunt and her severe, spoilt son. In thw shelter, in conversation with mild and patient Helen Burns, she expresses an idea of necessity of resistance: When we are struck at
it again. I must dislike those who, whatever I do to please them, persist in disliking me; I must resist those who punish me unjustly (Bronte 1922). In the movie we see another picture: Jane wants to help her friend and let cut her hair to share her friend's fate. Here we see only Jane's high value of friendship, but we miss the real point the author of Jane Eyre wanted us to see: this is the difference between Jane and her friend Helen: Helen is mild, Jane is in contrast irreconcilable.
The spirit of the protest and independence is shown also in Jane's relations with her beloved. Rochester plays with Jane making her jealous; this is important moment showing Jane's feelings that is also missed in the movie. Jane is comparing her with beautiful rich lady and logically understands her imperfection. Here we see how strong and wise Jane is: she decides to forget her feelings, but than, after meeting Miss Ingram in the real life, she understands that not good-looking and poor she is much better than Blanch with all her perfection.
Exhausted by strange, freakish game conducted by her master, Jane is actually the first who speaks about the love - and that we see in the movie also. However, reading the book we feel stronger the difference of Jane and other women of her epoch. Jane's declaration ofy itthose who punish
666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666 love has the character of the courageous declaration of equality: "Do you think, because I am poor, obscure, plain, and little, I am soulless and heartlessYou think wrong!--I have as much soul as you,--and full as much heart!I am not talking to you now through the medium of custom,
conventionalities, nor even of mortal flesh" (Bronte 1922) Even in this scene the movie does not allow us to feel all the Jane's pride and independency.
Having become the bride of her beloved, at the top of happiness, Jane Eyre keeps self-control and sobriety. She is on guard of her independence; she is frightened with her possible transformation into the slave, into a toy of the husband. She continues to give lessons to his daughter, rejects luxurious gifts of the groom, persistently reminds him, that she is poor and not good-looking (yes, Jane Eyre is not beautiful, it is also was an innovation for the English Victorian novel). What do we see in the movie There is Jane's phrase that is understandable for those who read the book: "I am Jane Eyre" - the actress-Jane says to her beloved meaning that she is self-confident and independent. But the actress is too good-looking to express all the sense of this Jane's phrase. Here also there is no contrast between Jane and Blanch Ingram, because Jane seems to be not worse. To my mind, this was not right and the actress who played Jane must be not good-looking in order to show better ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparison of the movie Jane Eyre and the book Jane Eyre Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502415-comparison-of-the-movie-jane-eyre-and-the-book-jane-eyre
(Comparison of the Movie Jane Eyre and the Book Jane Eyre Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502415-comparison-of-the-movie-jane-eyre-and-the-book-jane-eyre.
“Comparison of the Movie Jane Eyre and the Book Jane Eyre Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502415-comparison-of-the-movie-jane-eyre-and-the-book-jane-eyre.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparison of the movie Jane Eyre and the book Jane Eyre

Charlotte Bronte Jane Eyre

...?Is Bertha (Mr Rochester's wife) the only crazy woman in the house? In what way Jane is insane? Besides Bertha, Jane can also be considered as an insane person for reasons that can be well understood from a philosophical point of view. When somebody passionately wants to stay isolated, this is insanity. We see in Jane’s personality that she is most of the time feeling comfortable in solitude. When she comes to know about Bertha, she leaves Rochester even she was madly in love with him. Bertha can be considered as a metaphorical character representing Jane’s rage towards the society that has been controlling her and making her quiet down her emotions. In the start of the novel, Jane has often told people, like her cousin, to stay away...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Jane Eyre

...?Analyse the role of childhood in Jane Eyre. The novel Jane Eyre tells the story of a young woman from the age of about ten until her marriage in adult life to Mr Rochester. There are two contrasting views of childhood in the book, and they are the childhood of orphaned and impoverished Jane herself, along with the children in Lowood school on the one hand and the childhood of her cousins, the Reeds, and of her own pupil, Adele, on the other hand, who all come from an upper class background. The book explores the pros and cons of growing up in both of these social classes and this is one of the main themes of the novel. This paper considers the representation of working class childhood and then upper class childhood, and then compares...
4 Pages(1000 words)Coursework

Jane Eyre: Gender Roles

...? 2 November Jane Eyre: Gender Roles Gender roles can be defined as “shared culturalexpectations that are placed on individuals on the basis of their socially de?ned gender” (Williams et al 702). The history of the world provides innumerable evidences for the undermined gender role of women and subjugation of women’s rights by men (Ifegbesa 29). Jane Eyre is one of many books that speak of violence displayed by men against women. Violence is conventionally understood as a practice that causes physical offence, whereas it actually constitutes several types of offensive behaviors that may not necessarily be physical. The definition of violence according to The UN Declaration on the Elimination of Violence Against Women is “Any act...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Jane eyre

...; and no net ensnares me; I am a free human being, with an independent will; which I now exert to leave you ” (Bronte 78). Jane always wanted to break herself loose from the oppression she felt to become autonomous. Jane used the character Bertha Mason to present the anger she had to the society. From the critic book by Sandra Gilbert, Mad Woman in the attic, Bertha Mason is represented as an angered, violent woman ready who had the capability of burning Thornfield on any slight opportunity she got (Gilbert 234). Sandra criticized that Bertha Mason representation of anger, is what all women, including Jane Eyre felt towards that society that continuously oppressed them. In regard to charlotte’s writing, Jane was angered at how other women...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Jane Eyre

... English Literature: Jane Eyre There is genre fluidity in Charlotte Bronte’s narrative “Jane Eyre”. As we can see; the author portrayed a number of genres for instance, autobiography, romance, mystery, gothic invention and childhood to adulthood. The title of the narrative itself illustrates the autobiography genre. The narrative is about a woman called Jane Eyre yet at the same time the title is “Jane Eyre.” In my perception, Bronte does this deliberately as in a literary work; it implies some form of heroism or hero in the central narrator. The narrative is not the author’s autobiography but the narrator’s. The narrative is in the first person. The central character who is Jane Eyre gives a description of her as if telling the reader her...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Jane Eyre

...Jane Eyre Jane Eyre tries to preserve her self-respect, independence and self-sufficiency at every stage of her life, both in struggling with socialpressure and in resisting the temptation of passion. This statement was innovation in the literally world of the 19th century. The novel "Jane Eyre" written by Charlotte Bronte greatly influences the reader and gives another vision of society and world in the whole. The novel was published in 1847. And it is a matter of fact that this novel made the author famous all over the world. The main reason for this is that this novel became an innovation in world literature. It was unusual for that time and created another vision of women and relations in society. The book showed all the difficulties...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Script for Jane Eyre

Script for Jane Eyre

Mason and a lawyer – stand up. They dispute Mr. Rochester’s freedom to marry, stating that he is already married to Mr. Mason’s sister. The secret is then revealed; the woman who attacked Jane was Mrs. Rochester, a madwoman who is locked up in one part of Thornfield manor. Mr. Rochester breaks down and confesses that he is indeed married, but it has not been a normal marriage because of her mental illness. Mr Rochester asks Jane to run away with him to France despite the fact that they cannot get married, but she refuses on principle.
St. John’s reserved interactions with Jane until his sisters leave. Then he asks her to marry him and go to India, because he says his observations have shown him th...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Jane Eyre

...Jane Eyre In the novel Jane Eyre, Jane the main character goes through several people and experiences that help to establish her passion. To start with, the devotion and confidence of St. John Rivers intrigue Jane virtually enough to silence the passionate spirit in her. She also adheres to the morality of Victorian woman that was dominated by the church of Anglican. The religion has no faith in passion and emotion. The instinct of Jane to assert herself stifled at her very tender age and could be expressed via defiance. It is Mrs. Reed's defiant announcement of independence that gives the power of freedom to Jane's life. In Lowood, Jane learns how to be thoughtful and patient. Rochester also introduces her to emotions of the spirit...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Comparison of Constructive Trust with the Remedy of Restitution under the Common Law

When trying to locate the property loss because of a transfer made under a breach of trust, there are certain issues that need to be taken into account. At the first level, the remedies available by the relevant legal texts tend to differentiate not only regarding their requirements but also their level of protection provided. On the other hand, the application of the rules of common law instead of the ones of equity has to be considered thoroughly and the party that suffered the damage has to evaluate all the parameters regarding his choice as each of the above legal paths has its own advantages. From a general point of view, it has been stated that ‘a person who confers a benefit, normally a money payment, under a mistake,...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

Faith and Works - Comparison of James 2:14 and Romans 4

While the apostles James and Paul agree that Faith connotes belief in God and Works connotes good actions, James contends that faith and works are both essential for salvation, while Paul asserts that faith is the only requisite.

James is unequivocal in his declaration that “faith by itself if it has no works, is dead” (2:17). However, he does not discount the importance of faith. His contention is that both are essential and one, without the other, is futile. He is addressing Christians, who, we may assume, are already among the congregation of the faithful, by virtue of their professed belief “that God is one” (2:19). Therefore, James accepts that faith is a precondition for salvation but asser...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Towards the Comparison of Specialized Courts in USA and India

Without specialized courts, resolution of complex matters would have been stalled and progress dampened.

Both countries have high educational standards and believe in an informed judiciary who are experts in their fields and these courts are presided by such persons. Justice is speedy in both cases and both give their judges penal and punitive powers.

Although there are many similarities, yet there are some differences both in content and in approach. Whereas the US believes in a more liberal outlook, giving greater emphasis to Human Rights, India lags behind due to its colonial and cultural legacies. The redeeming feature is that lead by its own global status as a growing economic power, it is trying to shed...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

Comparison of the Cold War International System to the Current International System

An example is that of the Korean War (1950-53) which is said to transform the nature of the Cold War, while its initial impact was to solidify the division of the world into political, military, and economic spheres. Take Germany for instance where imperialism was a victim challenged by the historians for the destruction of the German Government along with its supporters used to conduct (Keylor, 2001, p. 44). That indicates economic expansion and territorial acquisition has always been a problem promoted since the First World War. Even in the 1920s, it was fashionable to declare the German empire on the threshold of the ‘Great War’ (Keylor, 2001, p. 44).

Europe in the global context remained tense and divide...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article

Analysis of the Book of Job

The job was a man of God who possessed insurmountable faith, so much so that God systematically relinquished from Job all that is good and important, to render a more cleansed and righteous Job with renewed faith. Job discusses many plague-like incidents that all seemed to happen to Job and his family. One of the most powerfully portrayed issues in Job was divine justice.

In the case of the severity of Job’s trials, it is beyond the term understatement to say that what Job went through simply for a test, was supreme overkill. The stipulation placed by God was that he was to be turned over to Satan but just not killed. It seems that God should already know if Job is truly a faithful follower as opposed to putting h...
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review

Stop Animation and the Comparison to Newer Techniques in CGI

As with many films, a great creative license is taken with the story, although it retains the original thrills and spectacle.

The great Ray Harryhausen created some of the most advanced special effects of the time within this film. The scenes are exciting and thrilling, although by today’s standards it is easy to spot the differences between what is created and what is filmed from life. Still, the special effects in Jason and the Argonauts are some of the best examples of Ray Harryhausen’s stop-motion animation available. The movie is a mythological creature that is the eighth collaboration between producer Charles Schneer and Harryhausen. Ray Harryhausen’s contributions included those of co-producer,...
13 Pages(3250 words)Term Paper

Quality Use of Medicines - Pharmacy Comparison

The pharmacist is also the justice of the peace.

Comparing this pharmacy with the Campbell pharmacy, the Chandler pharmacy is located in a much busier area, hence there are more shops and more people in the vicinity. There are more medically related establishments in the Chandler pharmacy than in the Campbell pharmacy, hence there are more patients buying their medicines in the Chandler pharmacy. Both pharmacies have similar conveniences for their customers. They are located near a bus stop and taxi ranks, and a car park is available within the vicinity of both pharmacies.

The Chandler Kamart pharmacy is a very busy pharmacy with three full-time pharmacists and 8 pharmacy assistants working in one shift. With...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Comparison of Leading Womens Role in Portrait of Teresa and Salt of Sea

... Number] Comparison of leading Women’s role in Portrait of Teresa and Salt of Sea Every society has different values,traditions and perceptions regarding the role of women that fit within their historical, cultural and social contexts. The cinema being an important cultural institution and reflector of social values tends to depict the role of women in movies to refer their current status as well as to motivate them playing a non traditional role for some specified purposes. In the movies “Portrait of Teresa” and “Salt of the earth” also, the directors Pastor Vega and Herbert Biberman have presented the roles of women in quite encouraging manner to show the women’s potential of playing a revolutionary and defining role in setting up trends...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Juvenile Delinquency and Education: A Comparison of Public and Private Education

...Juvenile Delinquency and Education Introduction and ment of the Problem The question of juvenile misbehaviour and crime was not taken seriously until modern times. It was till the eighteenth century that children were regarded as non persons. They were neither recognized nor received any special treatment from either the state or society. The concept of discipline was at most a violent treatment of reinforcing specific norms acceptable in society. Perhaps a reason for that was that child mortality rates were high. It was not considered feasible to form attachments with children. They were left up to nature and the survival of the fittest approach. However, at the end of the eighteenth century, the age of “The Enlightenment... Delinquency and ...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Proposal

Jane Eyre and Rebecca

The adaptation does draw attention to the changes because they are evident in the visualization as depicted in the scenes between the two protagonists. One scene, in particular, is notable in this respect. Jane is shown at Moor House, after having been separated from Mr. Rochester for several months and in a flashback, she remembers all her times with him. As the flashback ends, Jane bursts into tears and this visualization reveals more poignantly than words could, the intensity and depth of her feelings for Mr. Rochester. The interaction and dialogues between Jane and the madwoman Bertha have been adapted to imply a spiritual connection between them that is intended to overthrow the patriarchy existing in the 1800s when the novel...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Comparison of the Political Orientation of Trade Unions

Austria or you may call is the Republic of Austria in official terminology is located in Central Europe. Although the population figures do not touch the danger limit but the talent and resources are worthwhile there. Germany and Hungry are also near this region. Italy is in the south of Austria. Switzerland will be seen in the west. So, now you can realize the importance of this region clearly.
The GDP is also impressive here. You can say the economy is strong and it has much depth. The strong social market economy is the result of development and proper management by the government (DArt & Turner 2008). Traders find flexibility in business operations. Labor has a positive approach to work and jobs.
There was a tren...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Comparison of the movie Jane Eyre and the book Jane Eyre for FREE!

Contact Us