StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Judicial Resolutions to State School Financing - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Four cases, Serrano v. Priest, San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez, Edgewood Independent School District v. Kirby, and Coalition for Equitable School Funding v. State of Oregon, are examples of historic judicial resolutions on the issue of state school financing which have greatly impacted the significant social issue of educational equalization.
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
Judicial Resolutions to State School Financing
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Judicial Resolutions to State School Financing"

Download file to see previous pages In its ruling, the Court found that poor communities had to have a high tax rates to generate relatively low per-pupil revenue whereas wealthy communities could have low tax rates and yet still generate relatively high per-pupil revenue (Merrow, 2004). The Court opined that "affluent districts can have their cake and eat it too; they can provide a high quality education for their children while paying lower taxes. Poor districts, by contrast, have no cake at all" (Coon, 1999, citing Serrano).
In an attempt to address such a complex social issue, the Court applied the equal-protection analysis of wealth as a suspect classification by extending it for the first time to school districts and ultimately ordered the state legislature to change school financing laws (Coon, 1999). Subsequent legislation was passed that was designed to equalize school funding by increasing state funds for poor communities while putting a cap on per-pupil revenues in wealthy districts and redistributing some of their local property taxes to poor districts (Merrow, 2004). However, the Court had failed to consider that 75% of poor children lived in high spending districts, and it effectively led to low school spending for most poor children (Merrow, 2004). In addition, the public was disconcerted in paying property taxes and in supporting any increase in property taxes that were not helping their local schools (Merrow, 2004).
Judicial Resolutions 4
Because of the existing and continuing disparities in school funding and educational disparities, it is doubtful that the Serrano decision can be credited with defining and bringing about the educational equality that its original supporters were hoping for in their praise following the Court's ruling. However, the case can concretely be credited with bringing about massive revision in school financing in California and it spurred an immediate wave of similar rulings and legislative action in other states (Brimley, 2003). The effects of those revisions, even in light of subsequent cases that seemed to rule to the contrary, have lasted through the last several decades and continue to impact education today.
San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez (1973)
In San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez, 411 U.S. 1 (1973), issues very similar to those in Serrano were before the Supreme Court of the United States. The San Antonio Independent School District (SAISD), acting on behalf of students whose families resided in poor districts, challenged the Texas state funding scheme by arguing that it violated the Fourteenth Amendment's Equal Protection Clause by underprivileging such students because their schools lacked the vast property ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Judicial Resolutions to State School Financing Case Study”, n.d.)
Judicial Resolutions to State School Financing Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501252-judicial-resolutions-to-state-school-financing
(Judicial Resolutions to State School Financing Case Study)
Judicial Resolutions to State School Financing Case Study. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501252-judicial-resolutions-to-state-school-financing.
“Judicial Resolutions to State School Financing Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501252-judicial-resolutions-to-state-school-financing.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Judicial Resolutions to State School Financing

Judicial Restraint and Judicial Activism

..., the schemes were not narrowly tailored, and the Parents court found that other methods would be preferable to meet the stated goal of racial balance, and further found that these school districts did not consider other methods to achieve their ends that were racially neutral. Conclusion Judicial activism is something that supposedly is anathema, as judges should not interfere with individual and organizational decisions. However, at the same time, that really is what judges do. It is their jobs to examine decisions and laws by constitutional precepts and apply them. If applying these constitutional precepts means that a law or a decision is overturned, then this is a case of the justices doing their jobs. Without “judicial activism...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

State judicial system

...Running Head: THE US JUDICIAL SYSTEM The US Judicial System The US Judicial System I The Courts Generally, state courts can be classified into trial courts and appellate courts. Trial courts can be classified as follows: the lowest level courts which include the small claims courts, municipal courts, city courts, justice courts or traffic courts; the superior courts which has jurisdiction over larger civil cases, serious criminal cases, most divorce and other domestic cases; special trial courts with jurisdiction over juvenile or domestic cases. There are usually two appellate courts: the court of appeal which reviews cases decided by lower courts, and; the state supreme court which is the highest state court. Jurisdiction is conferred...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions

When the United s Constitution was established and the various s entered into a union that included a federal structure with a national government and the various state governments, there was a period of some uncertainty regarding which level of government was the ultimate authority as the people’s representatives. The question would be resolved over the course of US history through such events as Supreme Court decisions that established the supremacy clause (McCulloch v. Maryland, and others), the slavery and nullification crisis, and finally the Civil War. However this evolution came with a struggle that was marked by numerous constitutional crises. Perhaps the most important early constitutional crisis that dealt with this i...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Capital Financing for the state of Arizona

...CAPITAL FINANCING FOR THE OF ARIZONA Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 System of Capital Financing Used 3 Availability of Project FinancingFunding 3 Funding Resources for Financing Capital Projects 3 Authorized Debt 4 Alternative Financing of Capital Projects 4 Autonomous State Authorities having major Capital Spending 5 Other Public Capital Spending 5 References 6 System of Capital Financing Used The State of Arizona in United States uses a mixed system of financing which is based on the purpose of financing. Like with regards to higher education, the State of Arizona requires the colleges and universities in Arizona to have a funding structure that will be performance based. Soft Capital funding is used for K-12 schools. Rollover...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Judicial restraint and judicial activism

...Judicial Restraint and Judicial Activism The doctrine of judicial activism is based on the belief that the federal judiciary is supposed to take an active function by utilizing its powers to examine the activities of the state legislatures, administrative agencies, and the Congress (this is in the case where the aforementioned government bodies go beyond their authority). The Supreme Court acted in an activist manner in the period between 1953 and 1969, and this is in an era when Chief Justice Earl Warren headed the Court. The Warren Court instigated the civil rights onward by suggesting that the laws allowing racial segregation were in violation of the equal protection clause (Bardes, Schmidt, and Shelley 459). On the other hand...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Introduction to School Finance Systems and State School Aid Programs

... to office supplies; tax payment; vehicle acquisition, registration, repair and maintenance; field trips; medical bills; vacation; extra-curricular activities; boarding facilities; food; membership fees; newspaper, magazine and TV subscriptions; and charitable contributions (Vickrey,.1996). This is a clear proof that these institutions are overburdened with expenses. They are all crucial and can not be forgone at all costs. However, with the reduced state funding, many schools find it so difficult to cater for all their expenditure. Meaning, they have a little finances which can not fully support them. Thus, their effective operations are hindered (Steve S., 2008). Meanwhile, the tough economic crises have made the well-wishers to limit...
4 Pages(1000 words)Admission/Application Essay

The Kentucky Resolutions

...The Kentucky Resolutions Question The thesis of the article is a remonstration against the Alien and Sedation Act that was passed by Congress (Federal government). The article majors on the proposed resolutions to the Kentucky Legislature as a protest against the act. Question 2 The audience of the article was the Kentucky legislature. The article was also directed to all the citizens of the United States of America. Question 3 The authors use the constitution of the United States of America as evidence to make their points. They refer to several provisions of the constitution....
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

State Judicial Systems

... Judicial Systems Judicial System The laws of a nation are composed of bills that are passed by legislators. Most of these bills are passed because of the benefits the benefits that they have to citizen of a particular nation. However, before the bills are passed into law, the legislators have to scrutinize them carefully to avoid passing undesired laws. Both the positive and negative sides of these bills have to be looked into carefully (Gallo, 2004). There are increasing death cases resulting from motorcycle accidents. A bill requiring persons who ride motorcycles to wear protective helmets should be passed into law. This is because helmets are said to reduce the number of brain injuries, lower the risks of cervical spine injury...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The State Judicial Selection Process

... or is involved in gross misconduct in Texas, the state commission on judicial conduct would investigate and sanction removal as a punitive measure. The Supreme Court would then appoint a tribunal which would conduct an inquiry into the matter and front a possible removal from office. Similarly, a judge may be suspended or removed from office on the opinion of the governor after a recommendation of the two thirds advice from the senate and house (Schmidt, Shelley, Bardes & Ford, 2013). Tentatively, a judge may be impeached or removed by the Supreme Court. The same reasons such as gross misconduct or violation of the constitution thus the Supreme Court or the by a two thirds resolution of the senate and House of Representatives. 4. Opinion...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

The State and the Impact That Homelessness Has on Children in Miami-Dade

Miami-Dade County has the highest homeless rate in the State of Florida. It ranks first in ‘families living in poverty’ among 25 major US cities (JLM, n.d.). Poverty and high rate of rentals have been considered the two main causes of homelessness. As much as 83% of people experience homelessness for a short period and usually require assistance in finding housing or rent subsidy. About 17% of the people in Miami-Dade are homeless for longer periods and require permanent supportive housing. The total number of homeless persons on the street in January 2006 was 4709 (Camillus.org). Fluctuations in the homeless count can occur depending upon the weather, time of the year and the methodology.

Florida accounts f...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Maigret Goes to School by Georges Simenon

The pipe-smoking Maigret went on to feature in 75 novels and 28 short stories and about 850 million copies featuring him were sold worldwide. Inspector Maigret is certainly one of the best-known characters in detective fiction

Maigret goes to school is an entertaining book in the Maigret series. All Georges Simenons books have gripping stories and the characters in them are believable, considerate human beings. Maigret goes to school is one such book with an intriguing story. The postmistress, Leonie Birard of Saint Andre, a small village in France near La Rochelle is hit by a bullet in the eye and is killed. The whole village is happy that she is dead. Everyone in the village hated her because she was inquisitive and p...
7 Pages(1750 words)Book Report/Review

Evolution of the Law and Judicial Activism

In some instances, such fault had been the consequence of the inattention of the defendant. Accordingly, the courts associate fault with intentional offenses or carelessness of the parties involved. Moreover, courts determine the application of fault on wrongdoings or torts. Civil law determines fault in actions of parties where they had exercised less than reasonable care. This insufficient reasonable care would be sufficient to establish a prima facie fault. Previously, the courts had adhered to the principle of there being no liability without fault. Accordingly, a person could be held liable, only if he had committed some fault. This made it essential for a fault to exist. However, the commitment of a fault was not always suff...
14 Pages(3500 words)Case Study

School Bullying: an Educational Problem

School bullying is a serious educational problem that is receiving increased attention. While anti-bullying programs are mandatory in Australian and American schools, they are not in Singapore (Forss, 2006). In Singapore, 95% of students in primary and secondary schools have experienced bullying (Forss, 2006).

A bully is someone who repeatedly attacks another individual who does not resist (Berger, 2006) and constantly harasses somebody else either physically or psychologically (Bosworth, Espelage, Simon, 1999). Bullying is manifested in many different ways such as physical, verbal and relational bullying (Berger, 2006). As a result of bullying, victims may experience anger, sadness, and depression which can lead to lo...
11 Pages(2750 words)Literature review

Element of the Columbine High School Shooting

The morning of Tuesday, April 20, 1999, was a beautiful spring day and it seemed to be a regular day for Columbine High School as far as anyone knew. Students were coming to school as usual and no one suspected that it would be the longest day in the history of this high school. The parking lot was filled with the usual BMWs and Hummers of the football players and those students who were on the outside of the popular kids were being teased just like any other day. No one noticed anything different in the beginnings of that morning and no one really worried about anything. It is assumed that students had breakfast before they came to school and many were standing around waiting for classes to start and maybe smoking cigarettes as t...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

Public Relations and School Administration: The Jena Six Story

The infamous Juvenile Correctional Centre for Youth is located in Jena, with the institution closing after merely 2 years of its opening. The closing of the institution was owed to prevalent brutality and racism. One of the scandals they were involved in was the choking of black juveniles during a meeting with a lawyer. The guards also paid inmates for them to wrestle and fight with each other for their entertainment and also laughed at teenagers who are trying to commit suicide inside the jails (Witt, 2007).
At one time, district boundaries lines had been drawn to establish or maintain white-non white separation. It was in the last 20 or so years that nonwhites had begun to move into several areas; Jena for one, previously p...
11 Pages(2750 words)Term Paper

Self-Defence against Non-State Actors

Prior to 1945, there was no unified international prohibition on a unilateral resort to force and the UN Charter sought to radicalize international politics through a general prohibition on the use of unilateral force by member states. The prohibition was officially enshrined in Article 2(4) of the Charter, which provides that:
“All member states shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations”(UN Charter Article 2(4) 1945).
Despite the purported ban on the unilateral use of force, the parameters of Article 2(4)’s applicabili...
15 Pages(3750 words)Assignment

School Social Worker in Special Education

Social workers are required to understand the diversity of families and help individuals and families cope with the implications and impacts of learning disabilities, physical or cognitive problems. Individual treatment may be required in a safe environment and relationship in which to deal with issues. The work of the school social worker in special education is related to a diverse number of areas, in which he/ she is required to fulfill various roles and responsibilities (Turner, 2005).

Approximately one-half of school social workers are found to be practicing with elementary school children. School social workers support and help to prevent future problems by intervening with at-risk children during elementary schoo...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study

Health Needs Assessment among Internally Displaced People in Southern Darfur State

In the recent past, Sudan has gone through a very serious humanitarian crisis, rated by as among the worst in the world. This crisis has led to thousands of Sudanese being displaced from their homes. The crisis was a series of civil wars that have characterized the Southern Sudan regions, and quite recently the Darfur region. The conflict in the Darfur region is among the most recent crises in Sudan and has as a result drawn global attention. According to the UN, the Darfur conflict emerged as the worst crisis in the year 2003 as far as humanitarian aspects are concerned (UNEP/OCHA, 2004 pp 6).

So far, the Darfur crisis has led to the internal displacement of more than two million citizens. In the year 2008, the UN esti...
11 Pages(2750 words)Term Paper

What Are the Most Important Factors in Explaining the Rise of the Modern State

Though the existence of the state can be felt in different walks of everyday life, yet it is an intangible whose nature is impossible to grasp. As a political institution, state embodies the concept of sovereignty. Devetak (2007) describes it as a political unit or a country that possesses sovereignty. State can thus be described as a single, unified whole confined within territorial borders. The state is built in a core geographical area with allowances to a certain extent on the boundaries. According to Strayer (1970), a state exists in the hearts and minds of the people. The collective personality of the state renders it immortal. The state is a multi-faced concept that is fuzzy around its edges. Consequently, we cannot develop...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Developing Countries and Dispute Resolutions

... vocal (Iwasawa, 291). The disputes settlement body (DSB) is one of the integral parts of the agreement establishing the WTO. The World Trade Organization is based on the principle of single undertaking as opposed to the old system of dispute settlement under the generalized system of Tariff and trade (GATT) which advocated for positive consensus before any decision by the panel of adjudicators was adopted (Iwasawa, 295). The GATT system has in the past led to blockage of the settlement procedure by the member countries either at establishment of the panel stage or the adoption of the panel report stage. Such a case was in1988 when the United States of America imposed sanctions against Brazil imports under the Super 301 trade Act of 1974...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Judicial Resolutions to State School Financing for FREE!

Contact Us