StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Case against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs - Coursework Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
"The Case against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs" paper demonstrates in the following sections, women suffer more physical injuries than men, they often suffer more serious psychological ailments, they resort to substance abuse as a means for coping with the psychological strains. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
The Case against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Case against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs"

Download file to see previous pages The point is not that women are incapable of serving in the military. The point most certainly is not that women cannot be good leaders and good soldiers. The thesis of this essay is that women should not be placed in direct combat roles because (1) their presence may very well result in more serious physical and psychological costs than those experienced by male soldiers, and (2) that their presence causes the military to become preoccupied with peripheral issues such as sexual harassment, dating, and disharmony to the exclusion of military readiness and missions.

As the data will demonstrate, this ought to be viewed and treated as much more than a political or a social issue. The military occupies a special place within the larger political and social framework, its combat functions result in serious injuries and mental strains, and women ought to consider the medical findings and the military realities before demanding increased combat roles. This research paper will define what is meant by combat and, as illustrated in Iraq with messy urban warfare, how traditional notions of combat versus non-combat personnel have become increasingly difficult to define. This blurring of the traditional distinction is of particular relevance in this case because women serving in traditionally non-combat roles have, in fact, been directly exposed to combat nonetheless. After examining the meaning of combat, this essay will analyze a number of recent studies that demonstrate that women suffer greater burdens than their male counterparts. Some of these burdens are biologically-rooted and cannot be remedied by simple shifts in policy.

In the final analysis, there is no good scientific or military argument for including women in combat roles. The humane result would be a wholesale exclusion of women from combat. Only a sadist would use women as martyrs to make a point of gender equality, which has been and can continue to be made in less damaging situations and contexts.
Combat Versus Non-Combat

Combat was traditionally defined as taking place in a specific place with specific people (Skaine, 26); however, Skaine also goes on to note that combat today is more spread out, warring parties often hide and fight among civilians, and that defining a woman as serving in a combat or non-combat role is somewhat disingenuous. This is because, even though most women are theoretically shielded from combat by legislation and by non-combat designations and deployments, the combat reaches and affects women. Indeed, it is an open secret that women operate in combat roles even though they are technically barred or prohibited. Recent events in Iraq illustrate this blurring of the role between combatants and non-combatants all too starkly; as reported by CNN, “The Pentagon's policy banning women in combat is being tested in Iraq, where the lack of a defined front line and insurgents' guerrilla tactics expose female troops to deadly situations” (2005: np). The report, which was confirmed, went on to note that eleven female marines were killed in a single bombing, the largest loss of female soldiers in a single incident since the Second World War.  ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Case against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs Coursework, n.d.)
The Case against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs Coursework. https://studentshare.org/military/1501314-argumentative-research-paper-women-in-combat
(The Case Against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs Coursework)
The Case Against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs Coursework. https://studentshare.org/military/1501314-argumentative-research-paper-women-in-combat.
“The Case Against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs Coursework”. https://studentshare.org/military/1501314-argumentative-research-paper-women-in-combat.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Case against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs

Violence Against Women

...The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... against women: This paper is based on a very serious issue related to male violence against women that is increasing at a fast pace day by day. This horrendous issue is among the most brutal violations of human rights and its victims are spread all over the globe. It is reported that violence against women by an intimate partner is one of the most common forms of sexual violence. A wide range of psychological, physical, and reproductive health problems result from sexual abuse and it can be practiced either by family members or authority figures. It is also a fact that young girls are more prone to sexual abuse...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Women in Combat

...The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... Bans on women in combat continue to be a pressing issue among the military, specifically because of regulations and reinforcements which are placed on women. The continuous debates are now moving into issues directed at the ability for women to assist in combat. This debate is one which is now showing in current news, as women in the air force are restricted from flight and don’t have the ability to be trained to fly. The change in this occurred on March 30th, when the first woman flew in the Air Force while on combat duty; however, according to Defense Department Policies, women don’t have the option of flying in...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Violence against women

...The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... Violence against Women Domestic violence is an issue of international concern and has been in the public realm for a very long time. A majority of those affected are women, both married and single women as well as divorced and those separated from their partners (Peter et al, 445). Domestic violence can either be psychological or physical and affects women of all races, and social classes. Several countries developed various policies, rules and regulations in order to overcome this serious social problem or challenge (Peter et al, 445). Domestic violence against women reaches all the socioeconomic levels. Poverty,...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Women in Combat

...The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... in Combat 2008 Women in Combat Nowadays the US Army represents a diverse body composed of male and female soldiers of different ages, ethnic, social and cultural backgrounds. Naturally, gender diversity is a very essential aspect in military studies nowadays. The growth of interest toward this topic seems to be absolutely justified and up to date. In the past, the role of women in military affairs was minor and insignificant: they performed functions of nurses or worked for national defense. As feminist movement grew stronger, the voices for equal military opportunities for both sexes grew louder. As a result, in...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Article Critique: Women in Combat

...The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... Article Critique: Women in Combat Introduction James W. Revels is a retired U.S. Army colonel and a contributing editor of DefenseWatch, the official magazine for Soldiers For The Truth (SFTT), an educational organization started by a group of concerned veterans and citizens to inform the public, the Congress, and the media on the decline in readiness of the U.S. armed forces (SFTT 2008). In Revel's article, "Time to Rethink Women in Combat", published March 9, 2004, he writes about why women should not be put on combat duty. His purpose is to influence the people concerned with making decisions to reconsider such...
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review

Violence against Women

...The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... I Violence against women is considered an important social dilemma because about quarter of all women in the United States continuously “experience rape, physical assault and stalking” (Tjaden & Thoennes, 2000:1). From Mills’ perspective deconstructing every phenomenon on “personal trouble” and “public issue,” violence against women constitutes simultaneously a tragedy of an individual and family (personal trouble) and a tragedy of whole society (public issue). From the critical perspective, the majority of sociological studies recognizes that violence against women is not a singular phenomenon but, rather, a term...
10 Pages(2500 words)Case Study

Violence Against Women (CASE)

...The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... AGAINST WOMEN Violence against Women Violence against women is a current issue in various countries worldwide anddifferent measures have been taken to curb the issue. Among the measures that have been adopted across many nations is the bystander program. The bystander program focuses on increasing awareness and promoting empathy among the victims of violence against women. The program is based on advocating for prosocial attitudes and behavior and condemning behaviors that lead violence against women. Women in the society are prone to violence and hence there need to be implemented an effective program that will be ...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Violence against Women

...The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... against Women Introduction The violence channeled towards women was first viewed as a serious problem in the society during the 1970s, following the return of the women’s rights movement; the movements probed the area, and uncovered the issue as a pressing one in society (Johnson 25). Following the establishment that violence against women was a real social menace, scholars in various areas engaged in the exploration of the area, including those taking a feminist ideology explored it under the disciplines of sociology, philosophy, law and literature (National Research Council 40). Irrespective of the wide array o...
10 Pages(2500 words)Dissertation

Violence against women

...The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... against women Violence against women Introduction As much as the world has made significant strides in terms of globalization, civilization and advancement in technology, women continue to be trivialized through violence perpetrated against them. In essence, violence against women abbreviated as VAW is a collective term that denotes all the forms of violent acts against women across the globe. Mostly, this tends to be gender based, which normally targets women because of their gender attributes and also because of the simple fact that they are women. Some of the categories that violence against women fall under...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Should women be allowed in combat(arguing against the issue)

...The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... The Case against Women in Combat An Objective Analysis of Costs... Women Should Not Be Allowed in Combat In the fight for the equality of genders, the society reached the point when the issue of allowing women in combat has become the highly debated one. More specifically, quite a significant number of people, both men and women, argue that women should be allowed in the frontline combat roles and be allowed to serve side by side with men. However, this idea seems to be improper due to a range of factors that influence women abilities as soldiers. First of all, women should not be allowed in combat due to the fact that as a rule, women are physically weaker than men. The differe...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Coursework on topic The Case against Women in Combat: An Objective Analysis of Costs for FREE!

Contact Us