StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

William Muir, Police: Streetcorner Politicians - Book Report/Review Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
Muir. The book serves multiple purposes at once – it is part sociological research, part collection of interesting anecdotes and part informed commentary. The author…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.7% of users find it useful
William Muir, Police: Streetcorner Politicians
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "William Muir, Police: Streetcorner Politicians"

Book Report/Review Police: Streetcorner Politicians by William K. Muir Jr. The complex and challenging role of the policeman in society is given a rigorous treatment by author William K. Muir. The book serves multiple purposes at once – it is part sociological research, part collection of interesting anecdotes and part informed commentary. The author excels in meeting each of these three objectives with élan. One of the attractive features of the book is how it combines armchair analysis with on-field documentation. With regard to the latter, the author seems to adopt a hands-on, spontaneous documentary style, where he walks in to situations of interest with a recorder/scribbling pad at hand.
Muir acknowledges the propensities of policemen for stereotyping victims and resorting to easy violence. Yet, he constructs his narrative in a manner empathetic towards them. He highlights how highly stressful the daily duties of police are and how their poise can consequently sometimes snap. A policeman’s professional life is mostly filled with tragic or emergency situations. These situations demand an elevated degree of resourcefulness, alertness and decisiveness. Needless to say, such great demands on the body and mind take a toll on their health and wellbeing. It is mostly as a result of such adverse conditioning that a policeman comes across as having an aggressive and rigid personality. It is interesting to note that these same apparently negative qualities turn virtuous in situations demanding valor and fortitude. By highlighting these nuances of the psychodynamics of policemen-on-duty, Muir has crafted a well-rounded personality profile of a police officer.
Muir treats the phenomenon of corruption among policemen without getting judgmental. He illustrates how even honest and forthright police officers face peer pressure to play along with the system. An isolated well meaning policeman simply gets ostracized by his peers if he does not conform to the general culture of the corruption prevalent in most police departments.
In terms of style of scholarship, breaking away from conventions and decorum expected of academic research, Muir builds personal camaraderie with his interviewees. He makes them feel comfortable by projecting that he is one among them. They then give answers in an uninhibited fashion. This atmosphere also allows Muir to elicit answers that are not colored by psychological defenses mechanisms or protective rationalizations. Muir is thus able to get a composite portrait of policemen, with both the professional and personal facets included. He is able to show how many policemen struggle to separate their personal and professional lives. The high volatile environment of police duty incurs a personal cost. Oftentimes, their interpersonal relations with close family members suffer due to this imbalance. Muir attempts to thus portray policemen with humanitarian understanding. All things considered, police personnel play a crucial judicial function (law enforcement) that no democratic civil society can do without. However, they often get a bad rap as greedy and ruthless – a perception that melts away under Muir’s scrutinizing scholarship.
The other underappreciated facet to a police officer is his blind subjugation to existing laws. Even when a policeman personally disagrees with a law and perceives it to be unjust, he is bound to enforce it with an attitude of detached solemnity. Despite overcoming several such moments of conflict in the course of his duty, the policeman yet remains negatively stereotyped. Muir endeavors to correct this general misunderstanding.
In sum, the book is deeply humanistic. Although Muir brings to the table a degree of distanced objectivity fitting a research scholar, one cannot but help feel his sympathies with the police profession. The composite picture of policemen that he paints is one showing them as decent human beings by and large.
Reference:
Muir Jr., William K. Police: Streetcorner Politicians, Published by University of Chicago Press, 1977, pp. 313 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“William Muir, Police: Streetcorner Politicians Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1661232-william-muir-police-streetcorner-politicians
(William Muir, Police: Streetcorner Politicians Book Report/Review)
https://studentshare.org/management/1661232-william-muir-police-streetcorner-politicians.
“William Muir, Police: Streetcorner Politicians Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1661232-william-muir-police-streetcorner-politicians.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
ca
candicejacobi added comment 1 month ago
Student rated this paper as
I didn’t know how to start my text. "William Muir, Police: Streetcorner Politicians" helped me out a lot! Especially the list of ideas was valuable.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF William Muir, Police: Streetcorner Politicians

Politicians and Elections

...?Politicians and Elections of the Number Grade of the 14th March, Politicians and Elections In American politics, the success of political plans immensely depends on the perception held by the electorate regarding the personality and character of the contesting individual. The construction of a political character constitutes a combination of various elements making the individual’s personality. While some may be attributes of being associated with other people, the most image damaging characteristics in American politics remain to be, personal traits of political personalities. The expectations of the electorate regarding personal conduct and characteristics of politicians, immensely...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

William Shakespeare

...?Topic:  William Shakespeare Part I Shakespeare is an English who lived in England during 16th century He has been acknowledged to be the greatest writer and dramatist history has ever seen. The birthday of Shakespeare is unknown to the world; still the records date it to be April 23 rd of 1564.As a part of his education, he joined the local school of grammar to enhance his English language skills and fluency. The parents of William were John and Mary, in whom father belonged to a merchant class, and mother land gentry. During his teenage years, William’s dad faced with much financial difficulties and it continued till the success and fame of his son. It is not very easy to track the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

William Faulkner

...and period; a product of hard work and much practice through research and analysis, and trying to connect these phenomenon by putting them down in a simple language that is clear and comprehensive to meet the readers’ expectations. It should be noted that being a writer is different from being a technical writer in that, an effective writer can be smart English student who can construct English sentences for the teacher alone; technical writers process information and disseminate it to a large crowd of readers with diverse expectations and perspectives about the subject matter and thus the need to dig deep into the brain of their subject matter expertise. William Faulkner was the best writer with incorporation of various...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

William Carey

...William Carey, born in Paulerspurg, England, in 1761 and apprenticed as a shoemaker, died in Serampore, India, in 1834, a renown Baptist missionary and, indeed, the "father of modern missions." His life and his legacy beg the questions of how and why one born into the Anglican faith and whose career training was very far from the Church could grow to become one of the most influential Baptist ministers in history. Carey's life work, which includes the translation of the Bible into variant languages, among which was Sanskrit, lies in his effective redefining of the strategies by which missionaries should spread the Christian, the Baptist, faith and in the resultant formation of the modern Baptist missionary. Indeed, as...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

William Harvey

...R.Preeti 12/4/2008 WILLIAM HARVEY William Harvey is one of the greatest s in the history of medicine. He is credited with the laying out fo the details of the circulation system and how the circulation fo blood works in the body. William Harvey was born on April 1, 1578, in Kent and was educated in Canterbury. Later, he was a Fellow of the Royal College of Physicians. He married the daughter of a prominent London physician. Harvey was also known for his yeoman service, and the Harvey Grammar School is still a reality today. He left the world on June 12, 1657. Harvey is most famous for observing and ...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Police

...1. Discuss the main characteristics associated with the patrol and investigative police functions. Compare and contrast the activities as well as thepurposes associated with each function. According to the Police Operation Rules, police boxes are principle established in urban areas, usually operated in shift services. Residential police boxes, on the other hand, are in princip le established in non-urban areas (rural or semi-rural areas) and manned by a single officer, who lives his family in the residential section attached to the office. With these differences, the police box and residential police box have the ir own strengths....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Politicians, Corruption and the Police

...Politicians, Corruption and the Police Corruption: Corruption can be described as deviation from a standard practice to achieve a particular goal orobjective. Corruption can be defined as illegal practice to achieve a particular goal. These illegal practices can be different in different field. The goal or objective achieved by corruption may be useful to some one or harmful to another one. The different types of corruptions are as follows: 1) Political Corruption, 2) Informational corruption, and language related corruption. The major contribution in corruption is made by political corruption. The person involve in political corruption are generally government officials. Government official misuse...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

William Wordsworth

...William Wordsworth William Wordsworth was born on April 7, 1770 to John Wordsworth and Ann Cookson in Cockermouth, Cumberland, northwest of England (Gill, 1990). William was the second of five children. His sister, Dorothy, was a poet and diarist, and was very close with William. She became one of William’s greatest influences in his own writing. William had an older brother and two younger brothers. William and his siblings had no relationship with their father. Even though William’s father was hardly present, it was he who taught William poetry. His father also allowed him complete...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Police Chief William Bratton and his Transformational police leadership style

...Introduction William Bratton was born on 6 October 1947 in Boston. He attended Boston technical high school and served in United States as a military during Vietnam War. He swiftly rose to lieutenant rank after returning to Boston to begin a career in police. Bratton was appointed as the chief of the police in 1983 for the Massachusetts Bay transportation authority and later he became metropolitan district commission of police superintendent. William Bratton holds the highest award for valor for being the New York City 34th police commissioner. He soon after left the job following supposed personal difference with Giuliani and later in...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

William Wordsworth

... The Things They Carried In his book, The Things They Carried , Tim O’Brien has presented a collection of short, inter-related stories from his memoirs of the Vietnam War and an autobiography that aims to construct a reflection of his own experiences through the fictional character who shares O’Brien’s name. Although O’Brien emphasizes that the work is pure fictional rather than a true, historical account, it is quite evident that O’Brien’s own feelings are reflected through his portrayal of the war in which he personally participated. Rather than being chronologically arranged, the story by O’Brien is stretched along many stories which O’Brien reminisces as he remembers about them. The characterization of Tim O’Brien in the book...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Book Report/Review on topic William Muir, Police: Streetcorner Politicians for FREE!

Contact Us