Hiring a Bank Teller - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Although the decision framework that the boss made with regards to choosing whether or not to hire Anna was fundamentally flawed, her only grounds for a case are with regards to the fact that the boss clearly and definitively transgressed the law when he asked her if MS was a…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Hiring a Bank Teller
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Hiring a Bank Teller"

1. Does Anna have a case here – why or why not. Although the decision framework that the boss made with regards to choosing whether or not to hire Anna was fundamentally flawed, her only grounds for a case are with regards to the fact that the boss clearly and definitively transgressed the law when he asked her if MS was a genetic disease that ran in her family. Such personal questions with regards to disease or the prevalence of this in familial relations cannot and should not be asked as is specified by the ADA.
2. According to the ADA what is a qualified individual
According to the ADA, a qualified individual with a disability is “an individual who satisfies the requisite skill, experience, education and other job-related requirements of the employment position such individual holds or desires, and who, with or without reasonable accommodation, can perform the essential functions of such position. The ADA prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability against a qualified individual” (Manju Banerjee et al 144). If Anna were to file a suit, the burden of proof would be on her to prove that she was in fact a qualified individual who would be able to handle the job functions that the boss described to her in the interview process.
3. What critical terms related to the ADA must be considered in considering the legal implications of Dave’s decision? How do they apply in this case?
The crux of the issue with regards to the critical terms related to the ADA and their requisite consideration hinges upon the letter of the law with regards to whether Anna could ultimately represent the “skill” and “job related requirements” that the teller position required. Although Dave found himself in a difficult situation, and ultimately asked an illegal interview question, the fact of the matter was that he was ultimately unsure if she would be able to live up to the job related requirements that Dave required of all his bank tellers.
4. How can expense and cost be a variable when considering “reasonable accommodation”
In a word, Yes. If the employer is able to show that he/she cannot provide the accommodations that the individual requires because the cost of doing this would place an unreasonable burden on the company – it is possible that he/she may not have to do this.
5. What about Carl’s point the multiple sclerosis is a progressive disease and that Anna will almost certainly get worse, thus creating potential problems of absenteeism and health care costs. Can Dave consider this issue in his decision?
The answer to this is both yes and no; however the fact remains that these factors should not enter into the discussion due to the fact that they are future eventualities and not based on anything other than the employer’s interpretation of stated fact and conjecture.
6. Could Dave ask Anna about the nature or severity of her disability? Could he ask her about ability to perform certain job functions?
Ultimately, he is unable and bound by law NOT to ask Anna bout the severity or the nature of the disease. However, he is able to ask her questions relating to her ability to perform the job in question based upon her given condition.
7. Based on Carl’s comments regarding the probability of Anne’s MS worsening, could Dave require Anne to submit to and share genetic testing results as a condition of employment? Could Dave use such information?
No, this would serve as a blatant violation of HIPPA and ADA due to the fact that Anna is not required to provide such documentation to a prospective employer or even a current employer. Such a request would serve as a gross and direct violation of existing labor law and give Anna grounds for a lawsuit. Similarly, even should Anna provide the information to Dave, he would not be allowed to use it in making a determination with regards to her ability to work for the firm.
Work Cited
Manju Banerjee, et al. "Disability Documentation, The Americans With Disabilities Act Amendments Act, And The Summary Of Performance: How Are They Linked?." Journal Of Postsecondary Education And Disability 22.3 (2010): 142-150. ERIC. Web. 6 Feb. 2013. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Hiring a Bank Teller Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Hiring a Bank Teller Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“Hiring a Bank Teller Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document


Challenges in Hiring Talent

...? Challenges in Hiring Talent Question Why the Hiring Process is more Crucial than ever for Companies According to Yates (123), human resources are what drive business; without them a lack of normalcy in operations and profitability becomes apparent, resulting in low profitability and quality of goods. Every corporation or enterprise wishes that it had access to a highly skilled pool of human resources that can provide a template for current and future successes. Companies are realizing that talented workers and human resource personnel are very hard to come by. Prince (25), states that there has been a 10 % decline in the average quality of a worker since 2004. This has prompted companies to redouble...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Human Resource Case Studies

...or preceding year. The title allows employers to discriminate employees in special occasions where the trait is bona fide. Purple Cabs has over 200 employees, which is a requirement for Title VII to be applicable. During the second interview, a male panel member described Harrison as a skirt-wearing trouble maker. This means that Harrison was discriminated on the basis of sex. The company had enacted an affirmative action and women could apply for skilled positions in the company. This means that Harrison was discriminated against due to her gender and Jones was a victim of reverse discrimination. Hiring a Bank Teller 6. Does Anna have a case here? What are the critical variables? Anna...
5 Pages(1250 words)Case Study

Diversity Hiring

...Diversity Hiring "The diversity debate has shifted from the moral obligation of affirmative action to a business imperative. CEOs, faced with intensecompetition in global markets, record numbers of mergers and acquisitions, and the global war for talent, are focusing on how to leverage diversity as their competitive differentiator. The challenge for many CEOs is to directly infuse their diversity belief systems into the organization. The test for diversity practitioners in many organizations is to overcome diversity resistors and to leverage the power of the CEO's vision to make diversity happen. " --Dr. Vanessa Weaver Introduction It is irrefutable that current business operations have evolved over time, confounding...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Automatic Teller Machine

...input is done through ATM card – a plastic card having a magnetic stripe that holds the customer’s information like name etc. ATMs have special card readers installed as part of the system that accept and read the card. The second input is done through keypad or touch screen that is integrated part of the ATM machine. It is used to enter PIN (Personal Identification Number) to authorize the transaction. In addition, it is used to take inputs like transaction type, amount and other information from the users. Processing Function The processing of the ATM initiates when both card and PIN are entered into the machine. The core processor that controls the operations of the system sends this data to the central computer of the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Automatic teller machine

...Assignment This assignment is based around the use of an automatic teller machine. The objective of the assignment is to answer a series of questions regarding the ATM machine. Herein, the questions and answers and opportunities for improvement are listed. The first question asks how much money one is allowed to take out. This, of course, depends upon the limit set forth by the bank and is often set up when the account is first established by the cardholder. Typically, it is $500 or so. That seems to be the most popular figure. The second question deals with, if you were to take the $500 out of one machine and then go to another, what would happen? You would most likely get a message that your...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Hiring for Success

...Hiring for success Task: Hiring for success The hiring process is vital in organizations; however, it is one of the most difficult managers’ responsibilities. When making decisions throughout the hiring processes, some managers rely on the analysis of computers or their perceptions, which lead to biases. The process can be influenced by some challenges like overconfidence of some managers (Draft & Marcic, 2006). During the hiring process, most people overestimate their abilities to foretell the hiring results. For instance, some managers hire some people because they know them, and they believe that they will work...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper


... College I visited Ms. Thompson a human resource manager at Alameda healthcare facility to examine the hiring process and what laws and regulations were in place to ensure that the whole process was smooth. My main aim was to find out how the hiring team was able to select an individual from the long list of shortlisted candidates and make one candidate their choice. With 20 years experience in the hiring field, Thompson is an experienced human resource manager. The first thing that they do is post an advertisement for application. One has to be qualified for the position of a nurse and only shortlisted candidates are shortlisted for interview. Being a registered member of the nursing board is one of the major qualifications... College I...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Hiring Process

...Hiring Process Conclusion of It is true therefore that hiring process is the same despite the varying recruiting processes that are supposed to fill departments and companies. This is because it is obvious that only one person receives the job for which the interview is conducted at the end of it. So it s highly imperative that the four basics of hiring procedure be well understood by the hiring manager so as to help him or her get the best qualified person for the job. To ensure that the four basics work, it would be advisable for the hiring manager to ensure that he or she tries as much as possible to get applicants whose qualifications, skills, work...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay


...that enables the clients seeking the transactions of a financial institution to perform financial transactions (Cummings et al., 2004). It achieves this without the need for human cashier, clerk or bank teller. According to Anand (2006), ATM is a banking terminal capable of linking customers with 24 hours deposit and withdrawal services for the clients at any time (Anand, 2006). The ATMs or cash dispenser devices are installed in the bank halls and spread across the city or specific locations for convenience of the customer. They mechanically accept deposits; give withdrawals, transfer funds between varied accounts and issue bills. The very vital factor that makes...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Hiring Employees

...Hiring Employees for a new office Grade (Feb. 3rd, Hiring Employees for a new office The recruitment of new staff to fill existing or new job positions require that adequate planning and strategizing is done. The recruitment process follows a series of steps, which are relevant for ensuring that the recruited staffs are well qualified for the job position, while at the same time ensuring to adhere to all the legal requirements guiding staff recruitment. Thus, for the Chief Human Resource Officer (CHRO) to be able to recruit the best and brightest employees to fill key roles at the new office, the following steps are necessary: Identifying the existing vacancies and evaluating their needs The proper...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Hiring a Bank Teller for FREE!

Contact Us