Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Critiques of Management Theories - Assignment Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Management theories involve the study and analysis of organizations for the promotion of ways and programs that enhance better administration, management, effectiveness and efficiency of organizations…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
Critiques of Management Theories
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critiques of Management Theories"

Download file to see previous pages This paper therefore gives an account of certain management theories by providing a detailed critique on each and how they affect organizational management. Additionally, the theories are going to be discussed in correspondence to the contributions of Frederick Taylor and Max Weber, and how they would have perceived each of these theories. Before getting into the main discussion of these management theories, foremost of all, Taylor’s and Weber’s contributions will thus be looked at briefly as discussed below. Frederick Taylor’s contributions to organizational management are considered very instrumental in changing the perceptions and approach to management. Taylor came up with what is known as scientific management. The theory is credited for the belief that it would improve the working environment by motivation employees through remuneration and maintaining that managers should concentrate on activities that promote worker’s cooperation. Weber on the other hand developed principles that came to be known as ideal bureaucracy which mostly insisted on the division of labor and specialization, positive relationship and competency as the key tools for effective management (Rainey, 2011). The Hawthorne Studies The Hawthorne studies were an analysis which was conducted between 1927 and 1932 at Western Electric’s Hawthorne Company in Cicero, Illinois. Several research teams engaged in the study including Elton Mayo and Fritz Roethlisberger from Harvard faculty members and William Dickson the head of Hawthorne’s employee relations research division. The study was focused on the effects of different levels of lighting on the productivity by controlling the lighting in the area in which the employees work. These were known as the physical and environmental influences of the workplace. The lighting or illumination studies also focused on the psychological aspects such as how lighting manipulates group pressure, leadership and teamwork. The employee’s group productivity was assessed and compared with that of another employee group whose lighting was left unaltered. The findings were that as illumination was increased in the experimental employee group, productivity also improved. This was suggested that it was due to the impact of the motivational effect on the workers as they were pleased by the attention from the researchers and as a result of the interests being shown in them during the study. Regardless of the experiment, one reasonable conclusion is that the productivity of the other group not exposed to lighting continued to increase considerably. The illumination studies after a while was therefore short-lived, but its evaluation effect is still practiced to date. These findings thus become the contributing factors to the strengths and weaknesses of the Hawthorne effect. The strength of this study is that it is surely a tool that gives a framework which can be used to increase the productivity of workers within an organizational set-up through the motivation of workers, appreciating their work input and output, and maintaining quality working environments. This can be applied in today’s hospitals and healthcare systems, by improving the working conditions and work environments of medical staff and other personnel. Additionally, it enhances motivation on medical workers when consistent positive changes are made in the working environment, thereby enhancing work behavior and quality service delivery from hospitals and the health care systems. On the contrary, the weaknesses of the study are that as much as it ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Critiques of Management Theories Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Critiques of Management Theories Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words)
“Critiques of Management Theories Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
darion57 added comment 1 year ago
Student rated this paper as
At first, I thought 10 of pages is too much for such a issue. But now I see it could not be done better. As the author starts you see the difficulty of the issue. I’ve read all at once. Terrific essay

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critiques of Management Theories

Management Theories

...? Management Theories Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Employee Empowerment Culture 3 Real Life Example 3 Conceptual Framework 4 Alternate Model4 Penetration Pricing 5 Real Life Example 5 Conceptual Framework 6 Alternate Model 6 References 7 Employee Empowerment Culture Employee empowerment concept has emerged as major breakthrough in the field of human resource management. The concept can be analyzed from four different points of view. Motivating employees to become creative in daily work environment and helping them to provide new ideas to organization. Organizations try to create an amicable environment of knowledge sharing, equal power sharing among employees. Top manage tries to create a flexible work force by empowering... ...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Literature Critiques

...?Literature Critiques Introduction The study ed by Blom et al sought to determine the levels of efficiency of Hoodia gordonii extracts HgPE on energy intake and body weight on a sample of healthy but overweight women. Hoodia gordonii is a plant species, which is present in the Southern parts of Africa and believed to contain some steroid glycosides that are known to decrease the appetite for food and control body weight in animals. The choice of this plant for the purposes of the study is suitable on account of past researches that have identified positive presence of some components that have the capacity to affect the diet and appetite of animals. Methodology In terms of methodology, the study by Blom et al (2012)...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Management theories

...Management Theories Management Theories There is always a new management style that is coming along and is tested in one company or another and shows great promise. Management theory changes rapidly but so does the need for the change. In today's business world of rapid change, one cannot manage their employees the way they have in the past. It is a responsibility of management to stay well involved in their craft and assure that they are using techniques that will provide success for their employees as well as themselves. This paper will discuss some of the older theories as well as the new. With new management theory so readily available, it seems that few if any of the historical theories meet our expectations today. However... . As...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


...Running Head: HAZARDOUS MATERIALS Article Critique: Hazardous Materials Introduction of Article The article on hazardous materials covers important information about the subject matter. It serves as an eye opener for readers who are not familiar with hazardous materials, as well as provide vital information for those who may be involved with potentially hazardous materials. It serves well as a starting point for further information gathering or research into hazardous materials. It provides a definition of materials considered as hazardous and introduces the reader to various laws and the related regulating bodies concerned with hazardous materials. Another aspect covered by the article is sources of information for the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...SEEKING CONSENT FROM PRIOR TO TREATMENT Seeking Consent from Prior to Treatment All medical practitioners are required to seek consent from a client before they carry on any form of treatment and recording of the client’s details. However, saying that the patient must first be informed of all matters that they are participating in is quite illogical. There are those patients that are brought in for treatment when they are in an extremely critical state. They are in no way capable of holding any discussion and in so doing; a doctor will be wasting precious time in saving the patient’s life. The doctor is thus force to make a wise judgment and proceed with treatment. Also, one may not know the limit of how much information... CONSENT FROM PRIOR ...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Debate Critiques

...first Debate critique The argument on the need for ethical obligations for multinational companies is better explained by Team A considering relevance to the subject, content presented, presentation, link to experimental studies and flow of information. This presentation clearly articulates why multinational companies should have ethical obligations by linking the reasoning with their goals. Further, this presentation identifies five most important reasons for multinational companies to adhere to ethical obligations. Team A’s argument in support of ethical obligations for multinationals is strongly backed by information obtained from previous researches. For instance, the advantages of ethical obligations such as...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Article Critiques

...A critique on the study, ‘The Effects of Depression on the Progression of HIV; Direct and Indirect Effects’ A critique on the study, ‘The Depression Effects on the HIV Progression Direct and Indirect Effects’ The study focuses on the above document with intent of illuminating the strength of its findings and consequently criticizing the articles main failures and focuses. The article is also concerned on the critical subject discussed by the article through offering other instances that have been omitted by the paper under discussion (Eli, 2012). The study is based on a study on progression of the HIV virus in the society. The article also describes other factors that precede the acquisition of the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Management theories

...Management Theories Number Introduction This behavioral theory shows the findings of a research study that was carried out by the behavioral scientists such as Chester Bernard, Chris Argyris, Douglas McGregor, Herzberg and A.H Maslow. Most of the conclusions of the Hawthorne research have been confirmed by the research that followed. In addition, certain thoughts have been refined, added and behavioral scientists have stressed other vital thoughts. The centre of management action is the human behavior in an organization (Plunkett, Warren, & Attner, 2013). Behavioral theory is concerned with the psychological and social elements of human behavior in an...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Event Critiques

... Spring Exhibitions Opening Reception. America has one of the most sophisticated art industries with very different genres for audience to enjoy. Concerts and events are held almost on weekly basis in different parts of America celebrating our heritage, our artists our styles and entertainment. I attended the spring 2014 exhibitions opening reception and no doubt this was a great event show casing and celebrating our artists. Americans had turned up in large numbers to enjoy and support the artists. The event featured three visual artworks namely Uncertain Beauty by Darren Waterston, The Dying of the Light: Film as Medium and Metaphor done by a group of six American artists and In Transit: Between Image and Object by Dike Blair... Spring...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Documentary Critiques

... of Teacher 29th June, “Which Way Home” “Which Way Home” is a documentary about immigrant children, and the difficulties which they face in their attempt to the United States. The main three characters of the documentary are Kevin, a 14 year old boy who wants to go to America, so that he can support his mother living in Honduras, Fito, a thirteen year old boy, who wants to leave his grandmother and mother, because they don’t take care of him anymore. The third character is Yurico, who is seventeen year old and wants to go to America, hoping that someone would adopt him because he doesnt have a family and back in Chiapas, he has to beg for money. These three boys and the other children on the top of the freight train, tell... of Teacher 29th ...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Critiques of Management Theories for FREE!

Contact Us