Nobody downloaded yet

A Practical Discussion of Australias Role in Ethical Policy Formation: The debate regarding asylum seekers and refugees - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
For those in global and domestic society that aspire to sustaining human rights, the debate regarding the moral and ethical constructs associated with establishing policy to allow asylum seekers to be sheltered by Australian government is paramount…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
A Practical Discussion of Australias Role in Ethical Policy Formation: The debate regarding asylum seekers and refugees
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "A Practical Discussion of Australias Role in Ethical Policy Formation: The debate regarding asylum seekers and refugees"

Download file to see previous pages The rationale for seeking asylum or selecting Australia as a migrant destination differ widely depending on socio-demographics in a foreign country, personal needs for security against public sources or government, or generalized personal welfare for establishment of a lifestyle in a nation that promotes justice and liberty. Whatever the rationale for asylum seekers and refugees, the acceptability of establishing government-mandated permissions and tolerance for these activities have conflicting social, political and moral concerns. A 2011 Lowy Institute poll of Australian voters in a randomized sample identified that 86 percent of respondents believed that refugees arriving in Australia by boat represented a significant security threat to the nation (Soutphommasane 2011; Hanson 2011; Perera 2010). According to one critical academic: “secreted in the crevices and dark, invisible spaces of these illegalised bodies and intruding small craft lurk the invading germs and threatening microorganisms of the tropics” (Soutphommasane 2011, p.3). There are few that could legitimately argue against the practical rationale for suggesting that some individuals seeking protection in Australia pose legitimate health risks to Australian citizens and also serve to potentially strain political relationships with foreign governments by establishing policies that tolerate and consent to refugee placement in Australia. However, outside of the pragmatic view of potential security risks and the aforementioned majority opinion supporting security concerns, there are broader moral and ethical constructs that range far beyond simply public opinion which have global implications. It is necessary to engage in discussion about the different schools of thought in ethics and morality in order to determine the magnitude of international implications for establishing tolerant policies toward the refugee and asylum seeker. Utilitarianism, Rawls’ Theory of Justice, Kantian Deontology, ethical relativism, and an argument of human rights must be identified and deconstructed to add support or refute arguments that asylum seekers or refugees should be turned away from Australia as a form of self-protectionism. These theories of moral and ethical function lay the foundation toward determining the acceptability and best practice standards related to social, political, security, and cultural implications of tolerance. Theories of Ethics and Morality Believers in the utilitarianism doctrine define the moral value of an action only by achievement of the most desired outcome of the action (Hume 2002). Utilitarianism seeks to identify the most pleasurable and desired outcome, where the ends will justify the means if the greatest utility has been achieved through a decision process or action. Hume (2002, p.52) refers to the “consequence of public utility” that should be the fundamental principle that guides government policy formation concerned with utility as the ultimate “bounds of duty” in order to achieve the genuine interests of public constituency. Utilitarianism maintains practical reasoning similar to the concept of hedonism, seeking maximum pursuit of self-serving pleasure, an action or belief that trumps benevolence and egalitarianism to assure maximum self-welfare and utility (Mees and Schmitt 2008; Lemos 2004; Overskeid 2002; Edwards 1979). Thus, under this principle, the argument against tolerating and permitting asylum seeking and refugee placement in Australia as it ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Practical Discussion of Australias Role in Ethical Policy Formation: Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1401042-a-practical-discussion-of-australias-role-in-ethical-policy-formation-the-debate-regarding-asylum-seekers-and-refugees
(A Practical Discussion of Australias Role in Ethical Policy Formation: Essay)
https://studentshare.org/management/1401042-a-practical-discussion-of-australias-role-in-ethical-policy-formation-the-debate-regarding-asylum-seekers-and-refugees.
“A Practical Discussion of Australias Role in Ethical Policy Formation: Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1401042-a-practical-discussion-of-australias-role-in-ethical-policy-formation-the-debate-regarding-asylum-seekers-and-refugees.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
la
labadieadolph added comment 1 year ago
Student rated this paper as
I never thought 3250 words essay could be written in such a free manner. I loved the content of this essay. Will definitely use it for my own work!

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Practical Discussion of Australias Role in Ethical Policy Formation: The debate regarding asylum seekers and refugees

Refugees and Asylum Seekers

...Publication Foreign Policy Failed States' Index (2011) Available online at: http://www.foreignpolicy.com/failedstates Accessed: 4th July, 2011. Foreign Policy Failed States' Ranking (2011) Available online at: http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2011/06/17/2011_failed_states_index_interactive_map_and_rankings Accessed: 4th July, 2011. Gibney, Mark (2010) Global Refugee Crisis: A Reference Textbook California: ABC-CUOILC Great Britain Parliament Joint Committee on Human Rights (2008) The Treatment of Asylum Seekers: Tenth Report Session 2006 – 2007 The Stationary Office Hynes, Patricia (2011) The Dispersal & Social Exclusion of Asylum...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Refugees and Asylum seekers in the U.S

...Refugees and Asylum seekers in the U.S Immigration has been a common practice within the human culture and has been evidenced by the frameworks that have been crafted within government structures of different countries to deal with the feature. Governments acknowledge that there exists immigration into or out of these countries either legally or even illegally and thus the need for regulatory frameworks. However, there are international human rights that influence government decisions surrounding immigration and which are generally accepted within the international context. Nevertheless, every nation has her foreign policies as decisions that point to...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Public Services to Asylum Seekers and Refugees

...and researches on the problems confronting asylum seekers and refugees in Britain, the importance of integration and the role which both the education and mental healthcare systems should play therein. The fourth chapter, or `Analysis,’ shall expound upon the findings arrived at through both the secondary and primary data, present a set of recommendations and conclude the study. 2.0 Literature Review Asylum seekers and refugees, in more cases than not, cannot be categorised as transient visitors to, or temporary residents in the United Kingdom. Williams (2006) contends that consequent to statistics which indicate that...
31 Pages(7750 words)Coursework

European Practice Towards Asylum Seekers

...To what extent does current European practice towards asylum seekers concur with the image of a Fortress Europe Fortress Europe Role in providing Asylum Applications Academia Research Writer Farzeela Fortress Europe Fortress Europe is the term given to the working of the European Union to keep non-EU goods and nationals out of the Union's 25 member states. A classic example of a Fortress Europe policy is the development of a common asylum and immigration policy as a sign of Fortress Europe at work. (Wikipedia) Asylum Applications Annual and Per Capita UK, considered to be one of the richest countries in the world, hosts less than 2 per cent of the world's total refugee population. Global share: If we consider global refugee... (2.8)...
18 Pages(4500 words)Essay

Protecting asylum seekers

...PROTECTING ASYLUM SEEKERS The European Convention on Human Rights 1950 Versus UN Convention on Status of Refugees 1951". Introduction The provisions of European Conventions on Human Rights, 1950 vis-'-vis those in UN Convention on Status of Refugees, 1951 have been found to be more effective in providing protection for the asylum seekers within European countries. In most countries, an individual appeal to an international tribunal can only be done under provisions of European convention on Human Rights, 1950. This is the most effective safeguard for asylum seekers and refugees despite it giving priority to individuals over the state. Many principles laid down by the Court have played a significant role in securing the rights... of...
10 Pages(2500 words)Article

Mental Illness in Refugees and Asylum Seekers

...to other kinds of psychiatric disorders. Another important aspect that arises is the question of funding health care for these refugees and asylum seekers out of public resources that are already strained. Hargreaves et al (2005) have discussed how new proposals by Government are targeting asylum seekers in their bid to reduce what is viewed as an abuse of the UK’s health related services. Regulations are being introduced into the NHS to regulate in a much tighter fashion, the funds that are being dispersed to individuals for health services and the nature of the services that are being provided. All free secondary care services to...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Poverty and Social Exclusion of Refugees and Asylum Seekers

...Almost every developed country from the world is facing the problem of refugees. The rehabilitation of refugees and the asylum seekers has become the necessity as well as it is a great challenge before these developed nations. Poverty and Social Exclusion are the two different terms inter related to each other but they are not at all synonymous. So it is required to study them differently. Both are the social phenomenon and exist in every part of the world and in every period, right from the ancient civilization. Both of these concepts have a dark shade and it is the stigma to the human culture and civilization, yet they still exist in every society in different forms. Our actual discussion is on the poverty and social exclusion... of...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

The Situation of African Refugees and Asylum Seekers in Israel

...that remained, specially the Eritreans. However, in 2007, the Ministry of Interior implemented measures took away the rights of the refugees and asylum seekers in getting employment. Many were still tracked for ‘hot return’ and were temporarily detained while waiting to be sent forcibly to the Egyptian border. Despite protests from the UNHCR and pleas from local and international NGOs and humanitarian groups, the Israeli government continued to impose stringent policies on the refugees and asylum seekers. In 2008, the UNHCR reported the existence of asylum seekers numbering about...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Social policy & housing. refugees, asylum seekers and the homeless

...efforts on the homelessness problem. Social workers engaging in housing issues and homelessness receive guidance from the social policy and legislation in a number of ways. The policy provides a strategy for prioritisation of needs of the various categories of homeless people, which in turn greatly helps social practice. Further, the policy enables social workers to discern issues of responsibility for the homeless people, including the local authority and other arms of the government. However, as Stewart and Stewart (1992, p. 79) argue, intervention for the problem of homelessness has historically been housing oriented, with little regard to the social...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Possible solutions/suggestions for the problem of refugees/asylum seekers

...rejected, but have not yet left. Those who have been rejected, but still remain in the UK are difficult to assess in terms of statistics (Blinder). Systems such as vouchers and compulsory dispersal isolate asylum-seekers from the community, creating intense social exclusion. Policies that have been designed to create inclusion of those who have been recognized as refugees are very limited and are mostly based on voluntary initiative. The purpose of Asylum policies is to maintain control over the settlement of refugees. However, the systems often become more punitive which causes difficulties for the individuals who are...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic A Practical Discussion of Australias Role in Ethical Policy Formation: The debate regarding asylum seekers and refugees for FREE!

Contact Us