StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Immigration Myths - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Immigration Myths" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the immigration myths. In David Cole’s article for The Nation, “The New Know-Nothingism: Five Myths about Immigration”, he condemns the ‘fear-mongering’ language of those who support laws…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
Immigration Myths
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Immigration Myths"

However, no politician has offered a strategy that is suitable to the majority of Americans because the issues are complex as are the answers. There are reasonable counterarguments that can be made contradicting these viewpoints concerning the immigration debate, an aspect the article does not acknowledge.

The first ‘myth’ Cole points to is that ‘America is being overrun with immigrants’. “Much of the anti-immigrant fervour is directed against the undocumented but they make up only 13 per cent of all immigrants residing in the United States and only one per cent of the American population” (Cole, 1994). This number appears small and consequently insignificant but even if this number is taken as an irrefutable fact, it is somewhat dated. This percentage should be significantly increased since the article’s publication. In addition, due to the massive numbers of illegal aliens coming across primarily the southern border each year, this percentage has grown. Cole did not consider projections to, for instance, 2020, which would undeniably cause concern for those on both sides of the immigration debate. The deluge of illegal immigrants has and still yet causes substantial social, economic, and physical difficulties for legal residents. Numerous polls show that most American citizens, including Mexican Americans, want the government to put a stop to the surge of illegal aliens spilling over the border.

The second ‘myth’ is that illegal immigrants are taking Americans' jobs. Cole claims, “There is virtually no evidence to support this view, probably the most widespread misunderstanding about immigrants” (Cole, 1994). In his article, Cole reminds us that when the Europeans immigrated to America, the industrial revolution was in full swing.  These immigrants were needed to fill the industrial jobs which served a financial need in the country. These immigrants were employed therefore could successfully make their new life while America benefited due to the seemingly endless supply of labor coming into Ellis Island making it the most mechanized and economically prosperous nation in the world. The industrial revolution is over and has been for many generations. Today many American jobs are being shipped overseas. Employment is not as abundant but the number of immigrants sure is.

The third ‘myth,’ “immigrants are not a drain on society’s resources” may be the most obviously misleading of Cole’s statements. In years past, immigrants to America were less likely to collect welfare than persons born in America. This arrangement has changed drastically over the past several decades. Welfare use is three times higher among illegal immigrants who were granted amnesty compared to the rate for US-born citizens. Today, immigrant families are about 50 per cent more likely to collect federal benefits than persons born in the US. Additionally, “immigrants are more likely to adapt their lives to rely on the welfare system and studies have shown the longer immi­grants stay in the US, the more likely they are to be on welfare” (Rector, 2006). Illegal immigrants exhaust social services, $2 billion in hospital care, $2 billion from food aid programs and $2.5 billion from Medicaid. “States along the southern border pay out hundreds of millions of dollars every year providing social services for illegal aliens” (Hess, 2007).

Cole’s fourth ‘myth’ that the “aliens refuse to assimilate” (Cole, 1994) is true but is not a new phenomenon. Italian and Polish immigrants that settled in neighbourhoods labelled ‘Little Italy’ or ‘Little Warsaw’ during the period of European immigration that occurred a century ago are prime examples. Jewish immigrants also grouped in tight-knit communities (Hirschman, 2005). It takes a few generations for those foreign cultures to completely assimilate.

In Cole’s final ‘myth,’ that “non-citizen immigrants are not entitled to constitutional rights” he counters by stating, “Our government has long declined to treat immigrants as full human beings, and nowhere is that more clear than in the realm of constitutional rights” (Cole, 1994). This may be his most convincing argument but it seems counterintuitive to make a case for the rule of law in defence of those illegal immigrants who have already broken the law when they came into the country. Additionally, a significant number break more laws while in the country including murder, theft, selling drugs, rape, etc. “No system depending on a strict regard for the rule of law can treat law-breaking so casually” (Erler, 2004).

Cole’s viewpoint is neither necessarily right nor wrong but this article represents his opinion and the majority of other citizens. It should not be mistaken for responsible journalism.  Both sides of the issue must be honestly debated using facts not fear and emotion to have an intelligent public conversation regarding the best way to resolve an issue as complex, controversial and important as illegal immigration. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Immigration Myths Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1429088-immigration
(Immigration Myths Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1)
https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1429088-immigration.
“Immigration Myths Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1429088-immigration.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Immigration Myths

Chinese Immigration to the USA

hellip; With Chinese immigration to the U.... By offering better economy of scale than the United States immigration of Chinese to the U.... Impact of Chinese immigration to U.... This phenomenon is called as immigration.... Looking at the map of immigration trend in the world, it is obvious that most of the immigration in last few decades have been from the most densely populated region of the world to the world's most economically stable region....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Migration: Population Trends and Policies

The human resettlement in new region is mainly in terms of diversity and economic development of self and region.... Most importantly, migration of people… Hence, migration becomes a critical issue if the skill and knowledge are either being added or region is being deprived of it when In the recent times, it has emerged as a highly sensitive issue for socio-economic development of nations, especially for developing and under developed economies....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Should immigration rights be stricter

This has spurred a debate as to whether stricter immigration rights should be imposed or not.... For example, when a country has a predominantly Christian population, people might encourage the enforcement of stricter immigrant rights particularly for the illegal immigrants; “Illegal immigration is the antithesis of Christianity…It's a gross mischaracterization of Christianity to apply it to tolerating the mass lawlessness, death and damages involved in illegal immigration” (Gheen cited in Piccalo) whereas film industry would have the opposite stance because the greater the variety of cultures in the society, the more vibrant the ideas and the more rampant the resources....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

International Relations: Migration Myths

According to the seven myths presented by Hein De Haass about migration, they distort our understanding of the relationship between migration and development.... International Relations: Migration myths According to the seven myths presented by Hein De Haass about migration, they distort our understanding of the relationship between migration and development.... In receiving societies, migration and development policies tend to be seen as separate policy domains, and the former distorted by some migration myths....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The History of the Asian Community in Britain

The migrations occurred in phases due to conformity with immigration laws that have Marjory controlled the immigration trends.... This paper "The History of the Asian Community in Britain" focuses on the fact that the history of Britain is marked by a continued presence and increasing trends of Asian community migration....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

So mexicans are taking jobs from americans

“They take our jobs” – Debunking Immigration Myths.... “They take our jobs” – Debunking Immigration Myths.... The writer acknowledges the fact that there are numerous myths and convicted notions held by Americans about Mexicans in their country.... Chomsky believes that… In the 20 myths, the writer irons out certain misinformation about the immigrants.... The Take Our Jobs And 20 other myths about Immigration....
2 Pages (500 words) Annotated Bibliography

Myths about Immigration and Education

The paper "myths about Immigration and Education" emerges the attainment of quality education for immigrants has been a contentious issue.... However, there is no myth in the academic success of the immigrants, except for the fact that the success was derived from the upholding of native language,… Multi-cultural education is a key concept in the understanding of the socio-political context of a country, an area of socio-political literary writing that has been adopted by Nieto & Bode in their assessment of the effect of migration on education levels....
5 Pages (1250 words) Literature review

Impact of Undocumented Immigration on Canadian Economy and Labor Market

"Impact of Undocumented immigration on Canadian Economy and Labor Market" paper explores the concept of illegal immigration in Canada.... Issues of illegal immigration and its undocumentedness will be discussed; government policies and issues such as GDP will be looked at.... Although illegal immigration has a huge international relevance, it has not been exhaustively studied in Canada, especially with regard to its impact on the economy and market labor....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us