Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

'Discuss with reference to academic sources, case law, the Law Commission's proposals in the Law Commission Consultation Paper 1 - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Harris Kamran Law Consultation Paper 7 July 2011 The Effectiveness Of a Screening Panel For Expert Evidence In Criminal Trials Criminal trials have been, of late, increasingly relying upon the presentation of expert evidence for decision making, especially in cases that involve complex technical, scientific or professional concepts or understanding1…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.4% of users find it useful
Discuss with reference to academic sources, case law, the Law Commissions proposals in the Law Commission Consultation Paper 1
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "'Discuss with reference to academic sources, case law, the Law Commission's proposals in the Law Commission Consultation Paper 1"

Download file to see previous pages This means that such evidence carries a considerable weight in jury decisions, especially if it goes in accordance with circumstantial evidence4. Indeed, the “aura of infallibility”5 regarding the scientific evidence is sometimes enough to polarise the court and sway it heavily in favour of one party6. Whereas the inclusion of expert evidence in criminal trials has proven to be very helpful in jury decisions, especially when it is as straightforward as DNA results7, there have been many disturbing miscarriages of justice in regard to either too much or very unreliable expert evidence, which has led to a growing skepticism8 among the legal bodies about the involvement of such information. This paper relays some of those problems and their causes, and proposes a solution in the form of a screening panel for the analysis of such evidence as a solution to these problems. Expert evidence, owing to its nature, is complex and technical, and is often beyond the intellectual capacity and understanding of the legal body, including the judge, jurors, and lawyers, because they have not been trained for such disciplines. This leads to the basic controversy that the judge and the jurors tend to side with the expert readily, given the “aura of infallibility”(No 5)9, as stated before. This trend alone can lead to grave miscarriages of justice, as it stems from two further issues. Firstly, it is not necessary that the expert opinion is based on reliable and authentic sources, and that the methodology of data collection and analysis is standardised and authentic. Often the scientific techniques for gathering evidence do not reach up to the mark10, or are not fully developed or researched in that region. This means that the legal body would be basing their decisions on unreliable and flawed information_ an inexcusable error in the legal discourse11. Secondly, the objectivity of the expert can be questionable. By law, the expert is expected to be an “independent” witness12, that is, unbiased and basing his statements only on the factual evidence. However, this might not be the case. The expert witness is, more often that not, also the expert adviser to one of the parties13, and as an adviser, by law, he is expected to abide by non-disclosure and loyalty to his party, aiming, at no time during the legal proceedings, to harm the image or motives of his party14. The same adviser, when presenting as a witness in court and submitting expert evidence, is expected, by law, to be impartial and adhere to complete disclosure of all the information on which he is basing his opinions, such that those facts should be the same on which the judge or the jurors would base their decisions15. As can be clearly seen, these two roles of the expert witness contradict each other and are paradoxical in nature, leading to many wrongful decisions by the court16, or at the least, eliciting a lot of controversies. Expert witnesses cost money, and the employment of multiple expert witnesses by the different parties means the legal proceedings become quite an expensive affair17. This problem exacerbates when the parties involved have different economic standings, leading to a disparity between the parties in relation to the accessibility of resources. This means that those who can afford it will be able to call more expert witnesses ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“'Discuss with reference to academic sources, case law, the Law Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
('Discuss With Reference to Academic Sources, Case Law, the Law Essay)
“'Discuss With Reference to Academic Sources, Case Law, the Law Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF 'Discuss with reference to academic sources, case law, the Law Commission's proposals in the Law Commission Consultation Paper 1

Organization and Functions of Federal Law Enforcement Agencies

Threats may either appear in the form of terrorism or from other intelligence groups or from the espionage. It may arise within the country, against the existing government or social systems. Though most of the federal law enforcement groups are investigative groups, they are not only focused on investigations but stand for the people. One can see that the importance of the federal agencies is growing day by day because the threats from militants and others have considerably increased. Such kinds of federal law enforcement agencies include Federal Air Marshalls, Secret Service, FBI, Untouchables, C.I.A and Federal Corrections etc. The organization and functions of these agencies vary in different fields and can be cited in the fol...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Contract Law

This expression of willingness can assume several forms, such as a facsimile, letter, electronic mail or a telephonic message. The intention is an objective consideration and in the case of Smith v, Hughes 4 relevant consideration was deemed to be the manner in which a reasonable person would view intention. Furthermore, the law distinguishes between an offer and an invitation to treat. The latter is not an offer but merely an indication of willingness to negotiate a contract.

An instance of this is provided by the case of Gibson v Manchester City Council5. In this case, the phrase may be prepared to sell was held to constitute an invitation to treat and not an offer. Indeed, the Gibson decision challenged the tradition...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Constitutional and Administrative Law

When examining the decision of previous court comments that are made obiter dicta will not be part of the precedent since often obiter dicta comments are speculative remarks on how the judge might have acted if the facts had been different.

Binding precedents come from earlier case law and, as suggested in the wording, must be followed even if the judge in the present case does not agree with the legal reasoning of the judge in the earlier case. In order for a precedent to be binding the facts of the present case to have to be sufficiently similar to the earlier case. Decisions given in a lower court to the one in which the present case is being heard will not be binding. For a decision to set a precedent it must have b...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

The Idea of Liberty in Sam Slime Case

... the tax. Block also presents an interesting scenarios regarding money and its source and use and presents the following suppositions from a Libertarian viewpoint: 1. Say XYZ gets $50m from the State. You say giving money to XYZ is donating money to the state. 2. Suppose XYZ were a private college but received $50m in state subsidy. Is donating money to it also donating money to the state? 3. If so, what is the dollar threshold of state funding? If a private college receives even $1 in government funding, is giving money to the college illegitimate? (Block 22) So in the case of “giving” money in both scenarios, is the first wrong because Sam Slime is a criminal and the second right because the government has the taxing authority...
8 Pages(2000 words)Coursework

Analysis of OReilly v Mackman Case

Judicial review is a concept which is constitutionally undecided as it on one side, it shores up the rule of law, democracy, and pre-eminence of parliament by facilitating the courts to check the boundaries of government authority and on another side, the courts are open to the decision on the plants based on the fact of separation of authorities that are intimating with the verdicts of democratically elected institutions. Judicial review is not apprehended with the virtues of government assessment but deals with whether the deciding authority has remained within the legal boundaries and whether broad principles of rationality and fairness adhere. The constitutional basis of judicial review is debated as one view holds that it is...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

The Law on Physical Punishment of Children Fails to give Sufficient Respect to Childrens Rights

Under the English criminal law, several past and current legislations were made in order to protect the children from corporal punishment or becoming a victim of physical abuse. Despite our effort to prevent parents from using physical force in disciplining their children, the British Government remains unconvinced that the law which protects the children from physical punishment is sufficient (Keating, 2008). Physical punishment such as ‘smacking’, ‘slapping’, ‘kicking’, or ‘spanking’ is referring to the act of causing a degree of pain or discomfort to the child. (Niland, 2009, p. 6) With regard to the legal issues behind child protection against physical abuse, this study aims to d...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

Analysis of Tourism and Hospitality Law Case

 The main issue that needs to be tackled first is whether there is a valid contract between Richard Brat, carrying on trade as Brighton Greens, (buyer) and Molly and Kelly trading in First Grade Granny Smith apples as Holy Farm.

Apparently, there was, when considering their verbal and written mail sent by Richard to Holy Farm on August 1 reading as follows –“Please deliver 20 boxes –Granny Smith ‘Brighton Greens’. Cheque mailed.“

It may be seen that the mail order does not specify the category or grade of apples to be supplied, but one of the implied conditions of sale could be that the goods ordered need to correspond with the goods inspected and tested.

In th...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

International Law: Child Soldiers

Using children to fight wars is not only morally abhorrent but very bad very the physical and mental health of the children in question. That is in part why a series of international laws and treaties have come into effect to try to deal with this scourge. But the issue is more complicated than that. While child soldiers are victims of war crimes, they too can also perpetrate serious breaches of the law of armed conflict. Under normal circumstances, individuals who commit such acts, be they combatants or not,2 would be vulnerable to prosecution. However, because children in such situations are victims as well as perpetrators and because of the special protections afforded to children under international law, many have questioned w...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

The Law and the Media

New and complex issues have arisen which demanded fresh understanding and handling of cases involved them. This has resulted in the enhanced development of specialized laws e.g. cyber laws and interpretation of those laws. The same is true with Media Laws. Media has developed much in the last half-century. As it evolved as a profession and more people started to join it, there arose the levels of money involved in it. With this grew the contractual obligations on the parts of parties and concerned laws e.g. patent laws, privacy laws, and copyrights laws, etc. also started to play their parts. With these issues, the role of law in the media industry also reached a new height.
Mathew Fisher, the appellant, joined a band with Mr...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Global Employee Information and Consultation: Replicating the European Model

.... Print. Rǘb, Stefan. “World Works Council and Other Forms of Global Employee Representation in Transnational Undertakings.” Trans. Pete Burgess. Arbeitspapier 55 (2002): 1-61. Web. 22 Feb. 2010. . Seifert, Achim. “Global Employee Information and Consultation Procedures in Worldwide Enterprises.” The International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations 24.3 (2008): 327-348. Print....
9 Pages(2250 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic 'Discuss with reference to academic sources, case law, the Law Commission's proposals in the Law Commission Consultation Paper 1 for FREE!

Contact Us