StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

EU Law: Direct Effect, Indirect Effect and State Liability - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The author examines the issue which relates to the doctrine of direct effect, indirect effect, and state liability. Each of these is discussed at length and evaluation of whether Jean can enforce her rights in accordance with the said principles against the employer is made…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
EU Law: Direct Effect, Indirect Effect and State Liability
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "EU Law: Direct Effect, Indirect Effect and State Liability"

Download file to see previous pages The doctrine of direct effect is a principle that has been by the European Court of Justice and not is the EC Treaty. The development of the doctrine was done in a series of judgments. The doctrine is simple terms means that subject to satisfaction of certain conditions, rights and obligations which are created by EC law, may be relied upon by individuals and can be enforced in their national courts.

The doctrine developed in Case 26/62 Van Gend en Loos v. Nederlandse Administratie der Belastingen2, the Court found that the Treaty was more than an international agreement; it introduced a ‘new legal order’, which had its own institutions as well as legislative powers, thereby granting rights and obligations on individuals as well as governments. The courts went on to lay down the conditions that need to be satisfied in order to enforce a Treaty in the national courts, these were that the provision must be clear and precise; it must be unconditional, and its operations must not be dependent upon further action by national or EC authorities. A fourth condition requiring negative prohibition was also introduced in Van Gend but was dropped in later judgments (57/65 Alfons Lutticke GmbH3). Even the conditions that were laid down so as to utilize the doctrine of direct effect as an exception rather than a rule had been carved away. For a provision to be conditional, it must confer discretionary powers upon a third party (e.g. Member State) and thus cannot have a direct effect. Furthermore, the requirement that action must not be dependent on any further action can be done away with when the time limit within which such action should be taken has expired, thus allowing the direct effect to be used. (Case 43/75 Defrenne v. SABENA4). Finally, lack of clarity can be circumvented by national courts, by way of seeking clarity from ECJ through Article 234 preliminary reference procedure. Thus the doctrine of direct effect operates as a norm rather than as an exception. ...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(EU Law: Direct Effect, Indirect Effect and State Liability Assignment, n.d.)
EU Law: Direct Effect, Indirect Effect and State Liability Assignment. https://studentshare.org/law/1744235-eu-law
(EU Law: Direct Effect, Indirect Effect and State Liability Assignment)
EU Law: Direct Effect, Indirect Effect and State Liability Assignment. https://studentshare.org/law/1744235-eu-law.
“EU Law: Direct Effect, Indirect Effect and State Liability Assignment”. https://studentshare.org/law/1744235-eu-law.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF EU Law: Direct Effect, Indirect Effect and State Liability

Direct effect in the EU Law

... organizations or bodies which were subject to the authority or control of the State or had special powers beyond those which result from the normal rules applicable to relations between individuals.”25 Secondly, the principle of indirect effect was developed which calls for the interpretation of national laws that are in harmony and in consonance with EU directives. The leading jurisprudence for this principle is the Von Colson case where the Court ruled that the national court of member-states have the discretion and power to interpret national legislation in such a way that it conforms with the EU directive.26 Lastly, the incidental horizontal effect argues that although non-implemented directives cannot impose obligation on individuals...
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

EU Law - Incidental Direct effect and indirect effect

... effect if the directive time limit has not expired. 6 In Von Colson and Kamann v Land Nordhein- Westfalen, 7 the ECJ ruled that national courts of member states should interpret their national law in respect to the directive in as far as it has the ability to make that decision under national law. Von Colson was a case where the member state had failed to implement the directive in the correct manner. In Marleasing v La Commercial Internacional de Alimentacion 8 the indirect effect was used where a member state had completely not implemented the directive. Under EU law, any law or a regulation applies to all member states of the EU and becomes a national law for all the states. A regulation in EU law is similar to an act of Parliament...
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Direct Vs. Indirect Taxation

...Direct Vs. Indirect Taxation Taxes are an important source of revenue for the government. A government thrives on collecting revenue from taxes and uses it for the developmental and welfare expenditure. The money received through taxes is also considered as a source of transfer payment, where money is collected from the rich and spent for the welfare of poor. However, it is very difficult for any government to decide on the optimal level of taxation and the medium used to collect these taxes. All the economies in the world are faced with a dilemma either to charge direct or indirect taxes. There’s no consensus yet, but both sides of the arguments have been able to muster some support (Bamford). Certain economists support the point of view...
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

State Liability and Direct Effect

...Doctrine of Liability and Direct Effect: Introduction: In the European Union, high importance and value has been placed on the enforcement of European Union laws. In order to ensure proper implementation of laws and to guarantee complete rights to all EU citizens, a number of protective laws have been developed. One of such laws is the law of State liability, in which a European Union member makes up for the losses suffered by a EU citizen as a result of breach of EU laws. This law is developed to ensure that complete rights are granted to individuals especially in the areas of industrial relations and employment. The implementation of law of state liability is the responsibility of national courts of EU states1. Body: Certain incidents...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Effect of Direct Effect on Directives

... authorities is being subjected to the control of the EU, thereby creating an untenable position. It is forcing national law enforcers and judicial authorities to re-evaluate the prosecution of State authorities under national law, which would normally not be possible but are mandated under the enhanced proviso of the Direct effect on the EU Directives which pertain to domestic policies that are to be adopted by all member states. The case of Francovich and Bonifaci has introduced the principle of State liability18, however the Direct Effect has created a situaiton where the degree of state liability is associated with the provisions of the Directive in question. For example in Brasserie du Pêcheur SA v Germany19 and RV exparte20...
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

REFER TO OTHER INSTRUCTIONS FOR PROBLEM QUESTION WHICH NEEDS TO BE ANSWERED CONCERNING EU LAW-Principles of Direct Effect, Indirect Effect, State Liability and

... and adhere to the terms of the Regulation. EU regulations are in general very detailed and unless any specific remedies are available to individuals under the terms of the regulation, it is unlikely that eastern Interiors or the other company can successfully seek remedy under EU law. In the case of Scenario 2, both the Direct and indirect effect can apply, since this concerns a Directive. A member State is bound to enforce a Directive, therefore UK has to enforce the terms of the EU Directive which seek to impose controls on furniture quality through inspection checks. A Directive can be directly effective in a Member State if it meets the conditions laid out in the Directive, but a Directive has also been said to have indirect effect...
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Taxation Direct and Indirect taxes

... be used to maintain the condition of the passageway. What is important to keep in mind is that any particular jurisdiction may have any number of direct, indirect or specialized tax used in any combination to suit the needs of the local citizenry. In this regard taxation can be tailored to meet the specialized needs of a particular area. According to Smith (1776) it is the case that every state ought to contribute towards supporting the government in proportion to their respective abilities. One could translate this as meaning the proportion of the revenue which entities actually are able to gain as a result of protection provided by the state. It is the case that in most modern societies many different government entities are charged...
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Opportunity, direct and indirect costs

...Opportunity, direct and indirect costs Opportunity cost is a broad term which is used in different circumstances. Any activity which involves value, money or material can generate an opportunity cost. Opportunity cost of an activity is usually calculated based on the next best alternative of that activity. Suppose, two world cup football matches; one between Brazil and Argentina and another with England and Germany, are going on simultaneously. I am a football fan and a strong supporter of Argentina team. At the same time, I always like to see tough fights between different teams. Suppose I decided to watch the Brazil – Argentina match at the expense of watching England-Germany match. Using modern technologies, I can definitely record...
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Direct and Indirect Instruction Model

...Direct and Indirect Instruction Model Learning is a continuous process known to be all through anyone’s life. The dynamism of the world’s content necessitates adventuring and corresponding simplification through introduction of learning centers such as schools. People pay for learning services comprising individuals in different levels of learning. Regardless of level and learning institution hierarchy, two prominent models have been applied to teach including direct and indirect models. The choice of a model to be used depends largely on the lesson, system policies, and academicians administering the lesson. Question 1 Direct instruction model has been applicable in teaching for an unspecified duration. In this model, instructor...
2 Pages (500 words) Coursework

Direct and indirect messages

...Direct and indirect messages SUBJECT: Guide to your retreat package I would like to inquire for your rates on a retreat package for our staff on either of the following periods; December 15-19 or January 12-16. We are a team of 55 marketing and media professionals who are interested in conference/retreat/vacation facilities for four days. We will be accompanied with our partners or significant others and thus I would like to find out if you can provide us with approximately 50 rooms. I would also like to find out if you can provide 2 conference rooms that can accommodate above 25 participants for one and a half days. I would also like to know if we can host a banquet for about 85 people on one evening during our possible stay. Kindly...
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic EU Law: Direct Effect, Indirect Effect and State Liability for FREE!

Contact Us