Original need for the Commerce Clause - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The Commerce Clause is a power listed in the US constitution describing the powers of the federal government to regulate commerce between the US and foreign countries, among the several States and trade with Indian tribes. The commerce clause draws its meaning and original…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.4% of users find it useful
Original need for the Commerce Clause
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Original need for the Commerce Clause"

Original need for the Commerce Clause The Commerce Clause is a power listed in the US constitution describing the powers of the federal government to regulate commerce between the US and foreign countries, among the several States and trade with Indian tribes. The commerce clause draws its meaning and original intend/need from the preceding mercantilist tradition. Johnson (2004) states that the original debates over the adoption of the constitution, termed as ‘regulation of commerce’ was almost purely as a cover of words for particular mercantilist proposals that were related to foreign trade and deep-water shipping.
The original concrete programs that were targeted by the clause by giving Congress the authority to regulate commerce were, giving protection or subsidy to favored domestic merchants, restrictions on international trade and punishing foreign producers or imports. The cause was therefore adapted because of the need to nationalize tariffs on imports or state imposts (Gould, 1980). From this, it is evident that neither interstate commerce and trade with Indians was a significant issue in the clause’s original intend/debate.
The often claims regarding the purpose of the clause is that it was meant to avert protectionist economic policies among all the US States and to launch common market characterized by free trade across the borders of all states. However, barriers on interstate commerce were not an issue in the original debates. As Johnson (2004) explains, the constitution was put down before Adam Smith with its meaning originating from the mercantilist tradition that existed then but free trade and laissez fair came to dominate the dominate economic thinking later on. Looking at the current description of the clause, it is clear that the Commerce Clause are not the proper descriptions of the original meaning and need of the clause.
Gould, S. (1980). The Panda’s Thumb: More Reflections in Natural History. New York. W.W Norton & Company.
Johnson, C. (2004). “The Panda’s Thumb: The Modest and Mercantilist Original Meaning of the Commerce Clause.” William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal. (10) pp 1-54. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Original need for the Commerce Clause Research Paper”, n.d.)
Original need for the Commerce Clause Research Paper. Retrieved from
(Original Need for the Commerce Clause Research Paper)
Original Need for the Commerce Clause Research Paper.
“Original Need for the Commerce Clause Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Original need for the Commerce Clause

Commerce Clause WIckard v. Filburn and Affordable Care Act

...Task Commerce Clause Wickard Filburn and Affordable Care Act Introduction We do not need another book for the constitutional revolution of the 1930s. The history of that happening has been invested a couple of times from different perspectives, and there is so much that is universally agreed that it is unlikely that new things and ideas will emerge. Fortunately, it seems that the least we can expect for some minimal disparity on the following reasons: After the elapse of approximately sixty years of constitutional reading so as to defend private belongings, the market economy and the regime, the ultimate court suddenly altered its decision in 1937, neglecting guide and giving the central...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

The Federal Government's Power through Application of the Commerce Clause

...commerce? Regulating commerce according to Chief Justice Marshall regarding the case of Gibbons .v. Ogden2 means having the power to control the manner in which commerce is to be governed. Chief Justice Melville Fuller also gave a similar definition by stating regulation of commerce to mean the authority to prescribe the set of rules outlining the way the governing of commerce should take place. The federal government is formed out of a union between states and the sovereign power and this power is divided is therefore split between the national government and the various states (Bork & Troy, 2002). Discussion The original...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Original topic

...the equality between Whites and Blacks. Both parties were to access public services equally rather this is not the case since divisions are permeating. Accompanying these divisions is the American Identity paradox. The society has two avenues of foundation, one is on the principles of justice, and equality and the other are on the traditional racism and popular slavery traditions. Although this situation may somehow reflect original cultural and political events, the psychological factors that determine this challenge are pervasive and enduring. Both within and beyond America, the undetermined globalization brings in new psychological, social and economical challenges for the host. With reference to the recently observed...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Original topic

...friends and talking to them throughout the day. But in reality she is not a talker at all and never likes going out. She feels more confident when she’s online. Yes, the internet may help people interact with people in the digital world but will never help them develop inter-personal communication skills that they truly need in this real world. Another valid point that Stoll presents is that internet is only used for day-to-day communication and will not replace physical communication. He provides us with an example where a participant “appreciated the e-mail correspondence she had with her college age daughter, yet noted when her daughter was homesick or depressed, she reverted to telephone calls to provide support.”My...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Original Cases position. On the other hand, the government is left with no other choice but to recruit foreigners. This is because of the lack of skills and expertise of the local people. Hence, it is important to formulate suitable strategies which satisfy both conditions. The Problems and Need for Decision Every organization has to deal with some kind of issues, whether internal or external. Similarly, the Abu Dhabi Police Institution and Training Center is facing some internal as well as external issues. The issue that the establishment is currently dealing with is related to the way of achieving the organizational goals. As identified, the Abu Dhabi Police Institution and Training Center is facing problems related to the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Exclusion clause

...The ways an exclusion clause could enter into a contractual agreement General overview Contracts are essential documents for all commercial relationship between two or more parties that are willing and ready to go into an agreement with the hope of enjoying some certain levels of relationship as indicated in the contracts. These relationships could be in business, employment, education and other service-related transactions. Normally, there are some exclusion clauses in the contracts that state clearly what the stronger party (in this case, an employer) would not undertake for the weaker party (in this case, an employee) if certain unforeseen problems suddenly happened to the weaker party. In...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Early interpretation of the commerce clause have a congressional power that controlled agriculture with Indian Tribes and manufacturing with foreign nations. Under the constitution convention, it was agreed that the term commerce be used as a substitute for trade and exchange. Contextual analysis of the clause gives a strong support to a conclusion that the phrase “among several states” was initially used to refer to mean between persons of different states. However, this interpretation would render the term ‘among several states superfluous or excessive. According to Grant and Pushaw (1999), the reason for adding the term among several states ,and foreign nations, was to exclude some forms of commerce from the power of the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

The current extended interpretation of the Commerce Clause

...Interpretations of the Commerce Clause Interpretations of the Commerce Clause The Commerce Clause raises several interpretive and normative questions. How, for example, is commerce to be defined? What constitutes commerce among the several states? What are the proper functions and powers of the respective state and federal governments under the commerce clause? What weight should original intent, current values or modern conditions of trade have in construing the commerce clause? During the constituting era, the...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper

Exclusion clause

...Regulations 1999. Ineffectiveness of exclusion clause Firstly, under the UCTA, a party cannot excuse himself or herself from negligence under section 2(1) of UCTA 1977 when the breach of duty results in death or personal injury (Hughes-Jennett and Anslow, 2009). Secondly, under section 5(a), a company cannot exempt itself from liability caused by faulty goods or distributor negligence, particularly where commodities are meant for consumption (Stone, 2013). The doctrine that cushions the consumer is referred to as manufacturer liability. Thirdly, in light of the need to protect the consumer, sections 12-15 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 outlaw the exclusion of implied terms or terms which provide details...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Commerce Clause

... The Commerce Clause Every in America operates autonomously with their government systems not entirely answerable to the federal government. In several instances, the states have their independent bylaws governing their operations independent of other states. However, the US as a nation has constitutional provisions that regulate socio-economic, political, and legal perspectives of its states. Furthermore, in several instances, states enact laws in line with the national constitution; some of the laws, however, conflict sharply with the provisions of the constitution. Georgia is no difference from other states pursuing conflicting laws to those of the federal government. The state’s statute establishes that all trucks and trailers... that...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Original need for the Commerce Clause for FREE!

Contact Us