Nobody downloaded yet

Dog Bite Law - The Diane Whipple Case - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Donna Purcell Order 542893 02 June 2011 Dog Bite Law: The Diane Whipple Case The Case: On January 26, 2001, around 4:00 p.m. San Francisco paramedics and police were called to the Pacific Heights apartment building. They shockingly found a naked woman in a pool of blood, clinging to life, and her body bitten everywhere…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
Dog Bite Law - The Diane Whipple Case
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Dog Bite Law - The Diane Whipple Case"

Download file to see previous pages No one else was seen in the immediate area. The victim was Diane Whipple, a lacrosse coach, who lived in an apartment a short distance from the apartment where the dogs lived. San Francisco General Hospital pronounced Diane Whipple dead at 8:55 p.m. that night. Bane and Hera, the Presa Canario dogs that savagely killed Whipple were originally bred for fighting, guarding and herding in the Canary Islands. The breed, being almost extinct in the 1950s, was mixed with mastiffs and others and reintroduced in the US in the 90s. The dogs were obtained through a website called “Dog-o’-War.” The dogs lived inside the apartment of Robert Edward Noel, Attorney-at-law and Marjorie F. Knoller, Attorney-at-Law, his wife. The Suit: Sharon Smith, Diane Whipple’s life partner, filed a wrongful death suite against the dogs’ owners on March 12, 2001. The criminal law applicable to the case against Noel was Death caused by a mischievous animal and involuntary manslaughter. And the criminal law applicable to Knoller was death caused by mischievous animal, involuntary manslaughter, and second-degree murder. The basis for the charges and recovery against Noel and Knoller were formed from three theories of California law. In the state of California the owner of the dog is liable for dog bit injuries unless the victim was a trespasser on the property or provoked the dog. Noel and Knoller claimed that they were not owners of the dogs but “trustees.” This indicated they intended to defend themselves against a civil suit on the grounds that they were not the owners. They were also subject to either one or both of the defendants being negligent in handling of the dogs. The final basis of recovery was common law and liability for keeping a dog that has dangerous tendencies. If Noel and Knoller had known that the dogs Bane and Hera had dangerous traits to kill and attack a person, then both could be held accountable. In any dog bite case, possible civil defendants can include owners and caretakers of the dog, the landlord and property manager where the dogs resided, the breeder, trainers and even others. The legal basis for all civil claims is negligence. In order for landlords and property managers to be held accountable, they would need to have actual knowledge that the dogs had bitten another person or exhibited dangerous tendencies. Since Whipple died the legal coarse of action is for “wrongful death.” Whoever can inherit your property if you die without a will can also sue for your wrongful death. Sharon Smith and Edythe Pamela Whipple-Kelly filed wrongful death suits against the dog’s owners and against the owner and property manager of the apartment building where the dogs lived. The value of the case is based on the value of the person’s life and their relation to the person suing. Therefore, it is very hard to establish a rule on potential damages. The Prosecutor’s Case: The belief that the breed Presa Canario dogs are dangerous was the basis for the prosecutions case. Noel and Knoller were fully aware that these particular dogs had bitten people and animals, but neither took precautions to protect someone like Whipple. A witness, Neil Bardack, testified that Knoller knew she could not control the dogs, as he had seen the dogs dragging her down the street in the past. There were other witnesses that testified the dogs had previously attacked them or shown extreme aggression. It was determined that Noel and Knoller ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Dog Bite Law - The Diane Whipple Case Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Dog Bite Law - The Diane Whipple Case Research Paper)
“Dog Bite Law - The Diane Whipple Case Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Dog Bite Law - The Diane Whipple Case

Dog Pound

...Film Review: Dog Pound The film Dog Pound is centered on three teenagers serving sentence in a Canadian juvenile correction center. The actors are three teenage boys jailed for drug possession (Davis), assault and car theft (Angel), and sociopathic behavior (Butch). Davis and Butch become targets of bullies in the facility having command over the inmates. Banks is the leader of the prison bullies and has the ability to torture and abuse the new convicts. The bullying acts go undetected by the prison guards, which gives them the ability to engage in any form of torture. The brutal acts leveled against the inmates force them to plot a revenge attack against Banks. Butch beats Banks and inflicts serious on...
4 Pages(1000 words)Movie Review

Dog Training

.... Behaviour modification training programs are successful if they are able to lessen the motivation for the undesirable trait engendered by the undesirable natural instincts or to strengthen the motivation to engage in an alternate, desirable behaviour or to remove the reinforcement for the objectionable behaviour . These programs are effective if they include desensitisation and counter-conditioning and counter-commanding programs (Case 2005, pp.206,211). A specific example is when dogs are stopped from believing that they are pack leaders and instead are taught to be submissive members of the pack. They are conditioned to believe that their owners are the leaders of the pack. A complete...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Case Law

...INCONSISTENT SUPREME COURT CASE LAW IN CRIMINAL CASES OF SODOMY Inconsistencies In Supreme Court case law in two cases involving criminal prosecution for consensual sodomy Introduction: In 1986, the Supreme Court of the United States issued a judgment in the case of Bowers v. Hardwick supporting a Georgia statute that criminalized consensual sodomy.1 The issue at stake was whether or not the statute was constitutional in so far as it infringed upon a person’s sexual privacy. However, in a recent decision in the case of Lawrence v Texas2, the Supreme Court was presented with the same issue – the criminality of consensual sodomy - but in this case, it reversed its decision and deemed it unconstitutional to deem consensual sodomy... in the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

My Dog

...Introduction: They say, ‘God condemns for life, by giving those a broken heart!’—Ask me, how to live with a broken heart. I am not a defeated lover, but a defeated dog lover. I loved my Labrador Retriever immensely. “Amicable and sociable, [my] Labrador Retriever is a playful companion and a calm house dog.” (Labrador….) Right from the day I acquired her, I was always seized with a feeling that why the lifespan of this breed of dogs should be 10-12 years only. I complain to God about His scheme of things that such a lovely pet should live only for 12 years. My dog was already 7 years old and I remain anxiety-filled, what would happen to her in the next few years?...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


...Dog Dogs are the best friends of human from the animal family. Even though, cats, birds etc are some other pet animals, dogs have a special place in the animal lover’s book. There are many stories the dog lovers have to say about the loyalty, honesty, intelligence and the bravery of their most loved pet animal. “Dogs vary greatly from breed to breed. The smallest breed is the Chihuahua. It weighs only 4 pounds and is 5 inches high at the shoulders. The tallest breed is the Irish wolfhound. It is about thirty-nine inches tall at the shoulder”(Dog facts). Why the dog’s exhibit friendships with human when all the other...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Case Law

... [Manager] Employment Law September CASE LAW As a matter of right, Miss Clark can file a complaint against her employer before the federal courts, based on the ground of violations under American Disability Act (ADA), The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), Age Discrimination in Employment Act 1967 (ADEA), later replaced by Older Worker Benefits Package Act (OWPBA) and the Civil Rights Act of 1991, for the grave and intentional acts tainted with evident bad faith committed by her employer against her person. The foregoing violations shall be discussed individually. First, the American Disability Act (ADA) “applies to disabilities that affect a major life activity, and those areas of coverage are vision, mental... and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study


.... Of course thus far this analysis has simply focused upon the key areas of difference and divergence that humans and dogs would have. However, the more important factor is if one were trapped in the body of a dog they would necessarily be highly interested in the way in which humans viewed them as living and worthy of life. Whereas many places around the world treat animals and dogs with a high degree of respect, this is very much not the case in many regions around the world. As such, the life of a dog in a region that does not value its life would be miserable and hardly worth living at all.... Section/# Life as a Dog Although animal rights activists often ask us to place ourselves in the position of the animals that...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Treatment of a patient with dog-bite wounds

...Reflective Essay on Consultation Relating to a 30-Year old Patient with A Dog-Bite Contents Introduction 3 of Event 3 Feelings 3 Evaluation 4 Analysis 4 Action Plan 6 Conclusion 7 Bibliography 8 Introduction Dog-bites are serious and can always open up room for various kinds of infections that could be carried by the dog or through other secondary contacts with bacteria and other micro-organisms (Thomas & Brook, 2011). This paper is a reflective essay that presents the essential and important aspects of the examination of core elements of the treatment of a patient with dog-bite wounds. To this end, the paper...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Diane Mathis CS5

...Medical Interpretation for Cultural Competence Full s of Affiliation Medical Interpretation for Cultural Competence Comparison and contrast: needs of language interpretation, “best practice”. In the light of language barriers, numerous medical interpretation issues such as social and cultural influences emerge as potential obstacles in offering equitable healthcare access (Dreachslin, Weech-Maldonado, & Whelan, 2008). Common language barrier considerations include classification such as English Language Learners (ELL), Primary Language Is Not English (PLINE) and Limited English Proficiency (LEP). In these classes of interpretation needs, healthcare practitioners must appreciate potential sociocultural implications... Interpretation for...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Arrest by Force: K-9 Bite & Hold

...Bite and hold vs find and bark affiliation Bite and hold vs find and bark All over the domain of police force K9 training, each individual involved seems to have different opinions on the right, or proper, way to deploy a police force dog in the constraints of an illegal apprehension situation, in case it is on the street or in training. For a long period, the discussion among trainers of the police dogs and other participants has concentrated on two procedures of apprehension of criminals. This methods are the bite and hold and find and bark techniques. Therefore, the dissimilarities in this field are based on the trainers themselves,...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Dog Bite Law - The Diane Whipple Case for FREE!

Contact Us