Nobody downloaded yet

Eminent Domain and the Taking of Private Land by Governmental Entity - Term Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Eminent Domain Part I: Discuss the rights of citizens in Florida under the Florida Constitution when their property is taken by a governmental entity, and explain why and how the property owner is entitled to be made whole.  In doing so, distinguish when property is taken by police power, and when it is taken by eminent domain…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
Eminent Domain and the Taking of Private Land by Governmental Entity
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Eminent Domain and the Taking of Private Land by Governmental Entity"

Download file to see previous pages Brigham, that the right to own property and to possess it is a valuable and protected right. It is within this context that the right to made whole is interpreted. In making the owner whole under eminent domain, the courts must not confine quantification of damages to mere compensation for the value of the property. The courts must also take account of the expense that the proceedings will undoubtedly put on an unwilling private owner. It therefore follows that in making the owner whole, the government must take responsibility for all costs incurred by the owner in challenging the proceedings and proving damages.3 Therefore the significance of the right to own property is reflected in substantive and procedural laws that accompany eminent domain. As demonstrated in the Dade County ruling, the mere taking of property with compensation for the value of the property will not amount to just compensation. Compensation understandably must put the owner in the position that he or she would have been in but for the takings. This means the expenses that the owner is forced to undertake pursuant to the takings’ proceedings must be accounted for. Thus the constitutional basis of property rights is supported by the property owner’s right not to be deprived of his or her property without due process. Specifically, Article 1, Section 2 of Florida’s Constitution provides that “no person shall be deprived of life, liberty or property without due process of law”.4 Due process has been established to mean that the individual in question shall be accorded the opportunity to be heard and to challenge any intended action to deprive the individual of his or her private property.5 Thus procedural fairness is required in the deprivation of private property under Florida’s Constitution. Therefore reasonable notice and the administration of justice via a fair hearing are prerequisites for the taking of private property by the state in Florida pursuant to Florida’s constitution. Procedural due process however, can have different implications depending on the legal context. This is because procedural due process is tied to substantive due process.6 The connection between procedural fairness and substantive fairness lies in the general imposition of the right to challenge governmental taking of private property.7 Procedural fairness refers to the process that official must follow in depriving a citizen of his or her property. In this regard, the degree of procedural fairness typically corresponds with the severity of the proprietary right at risk. Substantive fairness proceeds on the basis that the law permitting deprivation of property is constitutional and presumes that any law that encroaches upon human rights is unconstitutional and therefore not valid.8 Deprivation of property conceivably invokes two different legal contexts, both of which can be deemed serious proprietary rights: police powers and eminent domain. Police powers refer to the right of states to legislate for the protection of safety, health and morals.9 Thus police powers do not technically deprive the individual of his or her property, but rather deprives the individual of the right to use his or her property as he or she sees fit.10 Police powers are typically associated with ordinances and regulatory frameworks relative to zoning, building codes, health/safety standards, rent controls and city planning.11 These police powers are ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Eminent Domain and the Taking of Private Land by Governmental Entity Term Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved de
(Eminent Domain and the Taking of Private Land by Governmental Entity Term Paper)
“Eminent Domain and the Taking of Private Land by Governmental Entity Term Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Eminent Domain and the Taking of Private Land by Governmental Entity

Eminent Domain Assignment

...Eminent Domain Epstein A. Richard. Takings: Private Property and the Power of Eminent Domain. Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. 1985. Richard Epstein is a legal scholar. In this book, Epstein makes a detailed analysis of the eminent domain or takings clause of the constitution which states that any private property taken by the government for public use shall be compensated justly. He argues that in contrast to other clauses in the bill of rights, the eminent domain has been interpreted narrowly, that is, it has been narrowly...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Constitutional Law: Eminent Domain

...from a landowner which he/she cannot refuse. Though the U.S. constitution has no provision for eminent domain power, its invoking by any government has never been seriously resisted. Constitution’s silence about the eminent domain does not mean that the government has no power but rather it signifies the implied existence of that power. The constitutional limits to exercise this power have however been the subject of interpretation by the courts and debate. Courts have always supported the legislatures taking the private property for public good. In 2005, the U.S. Supreme Court held in Kelo v City of New London that it was...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Eminent Domain

...of eminent domain. You are flustered, angry, dumbfounded, and at your wits' end! Why me! Don't I have the right to do what I like with my own property No, you don't! Not when you are up against eminent domain. The state government has enough powers under eminent domain to take over your property, pay you a 'just compensation' and raze your house to the ground and start with their redevelopment plans. (Karen Sudol) What is Eminent Domain If for even any one single reason out of several such as: building a bigger structure a l condominium, bigger business, hotel or retailer by which the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Eminent Domain Law in California

... to "take" property from its owner for the purpose of transferring it to a private developer (California). However, as noted above, the issues brought into the voting arena were oversimplified by the media. Because of public concern about the possibility of rent control being phased out and the fact that both propositions were efforts to amend Article I, Section 19, of the California State Constitution, the California voters made the decision to reject the proposition that they thought might do them the most harm, namely Proposition 98. Instead of informed debate leading to eminent domain reforms, each political campaign waged in this battle focused on one issue only. Therefore, it is highly likely that further study of this issue... will be...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Eminent Domain Case Study

...well heeled people enjoying "disproportionate influence and power". Applying this decision to the activist justice, means that the justices have no power to make a fair and impartial decision - the very thing that they are elected to do! Anyone can bring a temporary restraining order against the local city or town, but their burden is tremendous, and all that the city need do is demonstrate that the person seeking to keep their home is not overly burdened. What is the judicial threshold What constitutes "overly burdened" remains to be seen, one can only hope that there are activist judges out there who will make the burden a light one for the home owner. Further, perhaps the judge in his/her discretion will find that the home owner...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Eminent Domain (Real Estate Analysis)

..., there are question on how some real estate projects benefit the public. Additionally, ways of calculating of the just compensation is questionable. Therefore, it is important that the government exercise eminent domain carefully since it affect the constitutional rights of the property owners (Cook Web). Transfer of property land to real estate agents entails transfer of property from one private owner to another private owner. There is need for courts to define when it is appropriate for eminent domain to be applied especially if the property is being transferred to private owners. Transfer of...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Eminent domain

...Philosophy, Essay Topic: Eminent Domain The right of a government to acquire private property for public use is known as eminent domain. The owner is compensated for parting with the property. Dennis J. Coyle, in his book “Property Rights and the Constitution: Shaping Society through Land Use Regulation,” argues, “Regulation is sometimes benign, sometimes oppressive, absurd at times, and at least occasionally sensible.”(6) When political powers join hands with vested interests, eminent domain abuse goes wild. Constitutional provisions in the U.S. (in the 5th Amendment to the Constitution) have made it...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Zoning and Eminent Domain

...College: Zoning and Eminent Domain Introduction It is a major assumption that private property belongs to an individual and the rights to develop the property remain exclusive with the registered owner. Further, people assume that the private property owner has rights to admit or expunge away any encroachment of the property by any party. These exclusive rights seen to be enjoyed by individual property owners are bestowed on them by the local or regional governing body. The governing bodies like municipalities, local, state and federal governments are responsible for allocating, issuing private property ownership documents and authorizing the uses of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Eminent Domain

...Eminent Domain The city plan did not violate the constitutional taking clause. The plan was aimed at benefiting the public in New London economically by providing jobs to the unemployed and increasing the tax receipts that would ultimately boost the city's public finance and by so doing boost the economy necessary for the city's development. The takings clause protects the private property from conversion by the state for public use without just compensation. Although the eminent domain gives the state the right to acquire private land for public use, this 5th Amendment provision of the takings clause subjects such conversion to be legitimate, that is be for public use and the compensation be just what is viewed as be fair as per... such...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

Private and Public Entity Risk Management

...Private and Public Entity Risk Management al Affiliation) Chapter The texts commence in laying out the basics of risk management. First the text expound on the various categories of risk which are: personal risk which impact individuals on a personal level such as life and health issues. Then it divulges in to property risks which affect the owner but directly affect the property. Finally it expounds on liability risks which imply mainly institutional risks in their operation s example finances. I t further offers and explains clarity between material and people assets which largely assist in explaining intricacies of risk management. Key words: Risk analysis management, people asset, security liability,...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Term Paper on topic Eminent Domain and the Taking of Private Land by Governmental Entity for FREE!

Contact Us