Manager/ Employee Comparison - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
I used to work at a motor-vehicle assembly line at General Motors Ltd plant situated at Detroit, Michigan in a factory composed of about five hundred workers. More than two hundred workers have been fired, retired or transferred due to debilitating on-the-job injuries or for…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.6% of users find it useful
Manager/ Employee Comparison
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Manager/ Employee Comparison"

EMPLOYEE COMPARISON Employee Comparison I used to work at a motor-vehicle assembly line at General Motors Ltd plant situated at Detroit, Michigan in a factory composed of about five hundred workers. More than two hundred workers have been fired, retired or transferred due to debilitating on-the-job injuries or for complaining over issues of work not related on issues. The employees are also complaining that the work-related stress and non-payment of dues emanating from airtime have made them poorer as compared to their colleagues from similar plants elsewhere. The employees in the plant are not enough to meet the number of vehicles that are assembled through the line and the workers are forced to work extra hours than the stipulated timeline. This means that the workers have to work longer hours and this makes them susceptible to make error as well as putting their lives at risks of the machines and equipment within the factory.
The workers in this plant want alternative work schedules other than the normal forty hours for the whole week (University of Washington). While the employer want a reduction on these in order to cut on their wage bill, the workers insist that the hours remain so in order to shore up their earnings. Further, the workers want the union to put in place a framework for the payment of any overtime hours and a leeway for employees to refuse more than the specified number of overtime hours per week. The employers on the other hand want to restrict employees to a specified number of overtime per week and those who do not meet this are liable for punishment. The workers in this plant also want the shifts to rotate in a manner that allows all the workers in the plant to have free times with their families. The workers also want to be paid time off including when on vacations, holidays and defined leaves (Catlin-Legutko and Stacy 36) while the management of the factory are opposed to the idea and may at times restrict the entitlement or use. While the factory does not consider seniority as a criterion for the transfer of employees instead of layoffs, the workers prefer that there should be consultations in line with a Collective Bargaining Agreement before an employee is transferred (Berkowitz, Phillip and Thomas, 17). The workers and the management should sit down and have flexible work schedules that looks at the interest of both the worker and the employer and the overtimes paid commensurate with work done.
A major non-wage related issue that brings about the debate between General Motors Ltd employees and their employer is the matter of work conditions and safety. This includes clauses that deal with the provision of safety equipment and non-hazardous work environment. The workers demand that their rights should be higher than those set by the Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA) as they feel that that they are exposed to dangerous machines at the work place. The management on the other hand feels that they have less influence on the work place and it is upon the worker to take an initiative that the health and safety area of the work place is guaranteed. This has brought about frequent complaints and litigation between the workers and the employer on who should bear the burden of securing the health of the employees and protecting them from harm. Both the worker and the employer should sit down and come up with an amicable way of ensuring the safety and health of the employees.
Works Cited
Berkowitz, Philip M, and Thomas Müller-Bonanni. International Labor and Employment Law.
Chicago, Ill: Section of International Law, American Bar Association, 2006. Print.
Catlin-Legutko, Cinnamon, and Stacy Klingler. Organizational Management. Lanham, Md:
AltaMira Press, 2012. Internet resource.
University of Washington Examples for Overtime Exempt Classified Staff & Professional
Staff. 2007. (Web). (Accessed February 27, 2014). Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Manager/ Employee Comparison Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Manager/ Employee Comparison Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from
(Manager/ Employee Comparison Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Manager/ Employee Comparison Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words.
“Manager/ Employee Comparison Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Manager/ Employee Comparison

Project Manager Being an effective project manager

...will be involved in such a project. People often view the same thing in different ways and their opinions differ as a result of various factors. However, I realised that in order to become an effective project manager, there is need to involve all members who will execute the project so that they can be in a position to express their views and ideas freely. Mutual understanding can be created if all members of the team share the same ideas towards something. In our case, we only managed to reach consensus when we discussed the idea as a team given that some of the employees were against the idea in the first place. An idea that is shared by the majority of people in a group is likely to...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Manager Interviews

.... Researchers require equipment such as computers, tablets, and calculators. People who could undertake some research could have some difficulty in using some of these tools to either input information or search information (Esty, 2006). A well-established spa should not only focus on the comfort and well-being of its clients, but with that of its employees as well. To keep any conflict at bay, a manager should maintain professional relationship with the employees as well. This translates to fair treatment and wage payment too. One way to achieve this is by holding regular staff meetings that help keep members of staff up to date with all aspects of the spa’s day-to-day operation....
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Comparison of a leader and a manager

...Comparison of a leader and a manager “Leadership is a process by which a person influences others to accomplish an objective and directs the organization in a way that makes it more cohesive and coherent” (Northouse) whereas management can be defined as “the process of getting activities completed efficiently and effectively with and through other people” (Gulick & Urwick). This essay will explain the differences and similarities between a leader and a manager. One obvious difference is the focus of discussion here. The leaders focus on people but the managers focus on structures and systems. According to (Chase), leaders work with people to achieve a...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Plant Manager

...PLANT MANAGER (ERGONOMICS OF OFFICE) As the workers will be spending all of their time in front of computers, the most important aspect here is to reduce the risk factors associated with work-related musculo-skeletal disorders (WMSD’s), which is the primary element in reducing efficiency and productivity of employees. Workers will be provided with appropriate desks and adjustable task chairs for their workstation so they can adjust their posture as desired. Posture is very important for workers who spend considerable amount of seated in front of computers as a number of awkward postures have been observed such as typing with bent wrist, leaning over to type in data from Papers laying flat on the desktop,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Reflective Manager

...environment, the managers have to ensure that the way in which business activities are being conducted in the organisation gets changed simply from responding to changes, the managers need to focus on developing a learning organisation (Solomon, 2008 and Vince, 2005). Everyone in the organisation needs to understand that collectively they can bring change in the business operations and by their support to the management they will be able to enhance the productivity of the organisation. In order to make a learning organisation, it is the responsibility of management and employees of the organisation to divert their focus from reflective practitioner at...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

General Manager

...GENERAL MANAGER General Manager As the general manager, I handle various projects of the company this one notwithstanding. For the success of any project proper project planning, management and evaluation is required. In project planning we have a network or graphical representation of a project showing the flow and sequence of activities and events and their timeline. The network model is always known as: -Project evaluation and Review Techniques (PERT) In the graphical presentation (PERT) a network known as Critical path method (CPM) also exists this network is an analysis that entails a group of techniques and activities whose completion are key to the success of...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Project Manager

...Project Management: An Article Review of Project Management: An Article Review The article entitled a model of project knowledge management written by Stanislaw Gasik is an in-depth analysis of project knowledge cycle and its significance in project management. The article pronounces the most important aspect of project management i.e. usage of model to regulate operations. The author has divided the theme of this article in specific areas such as micro level knowledge for project management. This is followed by macro knowledge of project management in the article. The issues that have been highlighted in the article are...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review


..., in clinical settings, autocratic leadership styles lead to heightened stress, strain, and less job satisfaction. On the other hand, transformational leadership will help develop an increased level of commitment in the staff. Also, it is found that this will heighten morale among the employees and will empower nurses in management positions. The mere fact is that managers should have enough knowledge and consistency, and at the same time, should be able to empower the subordinates through delegation. According to Campbell and Sinclair (2004), it is highly necessary for the supervisor in an emergency department to develop close working relationship with the ED staff. This is so because...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Developing Manager

...) operating on a global context. The company has employed over 9,000 skilled employees ensuring better job security. The management of the company seek that the operations of the company are conducted in an ethical manner in compliance with the rules along with the regulations of the countries where the company is operational. The management and the leaders further seek that employees are motivated to conduct their operations in accordance with the goals of the company. Moreover, the company provides better job opportunities as well as security with the intention of retaining skilled employees (Ryanair Ltd., 2012). In this respect, it can be recognised...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment


..., from an organizational perspective, it is not advisable to create huge disparities between the two groups because there is a high possibility of breaching employment laws. Antidiscrimination laws are one of the most important components of employment law. As with other components, compliance with these laws require sound internal mechanisms that support the company’s efforts to remain within the law when hiring and managing employees. Concerning antidiscrimination, the first mechanism involves the institution of in-house antidiscrimination rules that stipulate the company’s expectations on the issue (Rowley and Warner 35). These rules will be incorporated in the company’s charter and mission statement...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Manager/ Employee Comparison for FREE!

Contact Us