Plato and Butler Arguments - Essay Example

According to him, the difference between man and woman is merely biological whereby both sexes play specific roles in procreation. Consequently, this thought and understanding of gender as irrelevant, prompted numerous intellectuals to conclude Plato was a feminist. Primarily, this is because of his argument regarding the inclusion of both sexes to assume the same roles concerning nation-building without considering humanity’s biological differences, which is beyond human intervention. Women ought to have equal say as their male counterparts as per Platonic arguments because they are capable of delivering as necessitated and even exceed society’s expectations. Hence, this prompts Plato among all other philosophers to emerge as the modern day’s democratic ancestor due to his perspective regarding gender. However, in the execution of the same duties or roles by both sexes, Plato seems to have a soft understanding concerning jobs’ allocation without giving a clear explanation. Since, women and men guardians cannot tolerate similar severity of their respective jobs, whereby the latter environment or jobbing setting is a bit tougher than the females’. Probably, this is due to the biological differences between the two sexes where the males’ physique is more muscular than that of females. Therefore, Plato presumes expounding more concerning these differences and after terming the issue of gender as irrelevant in the allocation of duties.                   

Are there roles in the city that are particular to women and men because they are women or men?

Besides Plato’s strong stand regarding gender irrelevance in the allocation of jobs and undertaking diverse roles the society, he admits each sex has a responsibility to undertake. Mainly, the basis of the two sexes encompasses biological differences where women according to Plato’s arguments embrace the role of mothers and being wives. These roles are irrefutable, and nature dictates them to assume that course, which is being human intervention. However, theine roles especially those which encompassing diverse city’s undertakings, Plato emphasizes consideration of gender equality. However, Plato’s argument did not imply he had in mind the position of women and whom society; instead, his intention was strictly to involve them in the city affairs. Plato’s perspective entailed women’s capability and not their liberation as it is with numerous contemporary feminists. This is evident in frittatas’ deprecating attitude towards women, which is comprised of a hipper son. Plato’s advocating of gender equality was a way of ensuring justice prevails in all sectors where women will be able to contribute constructively.                

Why does Plato make the argument that he does?

Plato’s main concern is to ensure justice in the city with the involvement of both the s. This is because he deemed the authorities would prove to be fair via accommodating every person. Since each person will be able to undertake an occupation, which he or she is capable of performing as necessitated.      

What is the logic of his claim about family life (for example) given his goal in creating the Gallipolis Compare Plato’s claims about the idea of gender to those in Octavia Butler’s short story “Blood child?” Life for Gan on the preserve is far from an ideal city. But Butler is playing with the idea of gender. How is she questioning contemporary gender roles?