We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Comparative analysis of Elkins historical interpretation of slavery with James McPhersons interpretation in Ordeal by Fire - Essay Example

Comments (0)
Two authors – Stanley Elkins and James McPherson – have both offered analyses of the subject, the former from the point of view of the effect of slavery on the individual, and the latter from the perspective of the…
Download full paper
Comparative analysis of Elkins historical interpretation of slavery with James McPhersons interpretation in Ordeal by Fire
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
Comparative analysis of Elkins historical interpretation of slavery with James McPhersons interpretation in Ordeal by Fire

Download file to see previous pages... ze the similarities and differences between the two authors, the relevance of their treatments – fact versus anecdote – and which of the two can be said – in the light of hindsight – to have most accurately described antebellum slavery.
Elkins’ and McPherson’s books represent two very differing accounts of slavery and are separated in time by almost a quarter of a century. Elkins discusses the subject in general terms, and advances two main arguments:-
It is now appropriate to expand the argument and discuss the points of agreement and disagreement between the two authors and to consider – in the light of history – whose arguments represent the most appropriate view of US slavery
Elkins believed that “the behavior you exhibit is who you are” (Elkins,1959); he maintained that slavery was ”so degrading and dehumanizing that slaves lost their identities and became “Sambos” [docile, child-like, content and striving for attention]
The different attitudes to slavery in the North and South of the country were profound; in the North slaves worked mainly as domestic servants, while those in the South were employed in agriculture – originally on three crops: tobacco, rice and indigo, and later on cotton as well. In the North, by the nineteenth century, strong feelings developed that it was not acceptable for one man to own another, and the abolitionists gained strength due to influence of the Quakers, Methodists and other factions. Elkins (1959) wrote “To the Northern reformer, every other concrete fact concerning slavery was dwarfed by its character as a moral evil – as an obscenity condemned by God and universally offensive to humanity” (Elkins, 1959). Many Northern church dignitaries believed that while one slave remained the whole populace was culpable [Cain and Abel – “his brother’s keeper”].
In the South, by contrast, it was held that slavery “was a positive moral good – a necessary arrangement sanctioned in ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Historical Interpretation of Hughess Poems
The social attitudes of the time about the back people in America were colored by racial attitudes. From this atmosphere of hatred and oppression arose the literature of protest. Harlem was the center of this renaissance movement and Langston Hughes gets his place in American Literature as a writer who stood for this awakening.
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
They describe that when Beckett was in France for seven years his absence was also good for them but once he is back they fear for him. The struggle of the characters in the play Murder in the Cathedral begins long before the plot opens .The plot opens explaining the estranged relation between King Henry II and Thomas Beckett.
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
Slavery a Comparative Analysis
However, due to the extent of the event and the varied consequences during and after the epoch, the happenings have been captured in diverse ways, often with some contradictions between authors. In this essay, I will give a comparative analysis of the construal of slavery in two books, James Macpherson’s ordeal by fire and Stanley Elkins’ slavery.
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Comparative Analysis of Slavery by Stanley Elkins and Ordeal by Fire by James McPherson

In a more analytical manner, the two authors have therefore immensely contributed to the abolition of the slave trade in America and as a result, restoring the almost lost good image of the united states of America as a liberal and democratic state whose good morals and high standing in dealing with the issues touching on humanity are admired worldwide.     

5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
Such trends are however established by collective impacts from individual members of the society. Political environments also identify collective positions that are sometimes so intense to determine people’s behaviors at personal levels. The greatest sense in the phrase is however noted in social set-ups in which culture and traditional beliefs are significant in people’s lives.
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Comparative Analysis of Slavery
A few scholars have dedicated their entire workings to the subjects of slavery and race relations within the Confederate States of America, moreover fewer still to the precise theme of their significance inside the mind of the rebel soldier. James McPherson, in disparity, has endeavored to enumerate soldier ideology.
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Source Essay analysis and interpretation
Trollope, all of who have visited New York at different times and brought out different aspects of the city in their works. All three authors have attempted to criticize the city’ lifestyles, culture and society in their own way
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Littering is a serious environmental issue in very many states because it has negative impacts (Hill, p. 97). The sound bite in this case is “Singapore: Litter free.” Here, we see a litter bin
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Cosmopolitanism, according to the reading, implies the idea that human beings, Japanese in this scenario, originated from a common
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
teractions have become on the rise thus prompting curiosity of people from all over the world to adopt and understand the culture of other people from other regions. Cultural aspects have been used to influence the field of economics through the production of commodities and
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Let us find you another Essay on topic Comparative analysis of Elkins historical interpretation of slavery with James McPhersons interpretation in Ordeal by Fire for FREE!
Contact us:
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us