StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Devil in the White City - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Historical Analysis of The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson" presents an overview of post-Civil War American as the background to a recounting of the true story of America’s first serial killer, HH Holmes. The paper examines the events of history in a theoretical, obscure manner…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
The Devil in the White City
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Devil in the White City"

The Devil in the White An Historical Analysis History may be recounted in many different ways. There is the cold, calculating recounting of facts and often soporific analysis to be found in many textbooks; then there is scholarship that seeks to examine the events of history in a theoretical, often obscure manner. The Devil in the White City presents a different kind of history: Eric Larson places the history of post-Civil War American as the background to a recounting of the true story of America’s first serial killer, HH Holmes. The dichotomy between Holmes’s murders (at least 27 and maybe as many as 200) and the World Fair that was going on at the time in the same city produces a vivid picture of America that presents both its best and its worst sides. The two stories, of creation and destruction, come together to create a whole: Taken together, the stories of how Daniel Burnham built the fair and how D. Homes used it for murder formed an entirety that was far greater than the story of either man alone would have been. I found it extraordinary that during this period of nearly miraculous creativity there should exist a serial killer of such appetite and such industry.1 The so-called Gilded Age of American history was indeed a time of remarkable productivity. After the damage and chaos of the civil war a sudden spurt of energy occurred throughout America, but especially in Northern and mid-Western cities such as Chicago. An echo of the English Industrial Revolution that had transformed Britain a century before, American industry blossomed, and with it is cities. However, as Larson suggests, along with the growth of great cities with populations measured in the millions comes the anonymity, strangeness and loneliness associated with them. Holmes was both a product of these tendencies, and also took advantage of them. His comments regarding his own moral state, while melodramatic, may also encapsulate the great battle that was occurring between Labor (ie. individual human beings) and Capital (the great productive force) that was producing highly efficient, but somehow inhuman cities: I was born with the devil in me. I could not help the fact that I was a murderer, no more than the poet can help the inspiration to sing . . . I was born with the Evil One standing as my sponsor beside the bed where I was ushered into the world, and he has been with me since.2 While obviously self-serving, Holmes brings up an important factor – the sense of powerlessness within the modern cities as the battle between Labor and Capital played out. The idea of creation is vital within the book, in the sense of an industrial construction of various worlds that both clash with and yet strangely compliment one another. Thus, Daniel Burnham struggles against an unforgiving landscape (swamps) and government bureaucracy to see his dream rise above the city; and all the while Homes is building (and then secretly adapting) his torture and murder house. The fact that Holmes was a Doctor of Medicine adds a further layer of irony to the book. A person trained to help and cure people, who one might expect would be least likely to actually enjoy doing the opposite, enjoys doing just that. Industrialization, and the science and creativity that both creates it and which it nurtures, can be used for a variety of means. Thus Holmes was very particular about the exact temperature his crematorium would reach so that it would destroy any evidence of the bodies he put there. It needed to reach 3000 Centigrade, and it did. He provides an ironic contrast to the similarly careful struggles of Daniel Durnham, who is trying to produce a visible celebration of life and a country’s new vitality while Holmes is secretly creating a rather different edifice. Holmes uses the anonymity and isolation of modern cities, something that is often hidden behind the glamorous facades that people like Burnham produce, for his own ends. Thus, as Larson details, after the Civil War women started to come cities to find apartments, work and live on their own. The old structures of social life that had kept them protected but restricted were giving way to a new liberation that also placed them in a vulnerable position. Holmes, his education, good looks and charm at the ready, persuaded many of these young women to move into his “hotel”, and many were never seen again. At about the time that the events recounted in this book were taking place a whole new understanding of the human being was starting to emerge and dominate discourse. Darwin’s The Origin of Species3 suggested that men were animals, and thus subject to the harsh stricture of survival of the fittest. At the same time Freud was starting to argue that human beings are in fact dominated by a subconscious over which they have little control. Specifically, there is the ego (sense of self), the superego (social controls) and the id (will to destruction) that are constantly fighting for control.4 Burnham had a need to exhibit his own ego through the wish to outdo the recent Fair in Paris. Thus the 264-foot high Ferris Wheel, invented, designed and built by a man of the same name, was meant to dwarf the Eiffel Tower in the French Capital. The need to dominate, and be seen to dominate and conquer is central to both Darwin’s and Freud’s theses regarding nature. While Holmes’s need to dominate is perhaps more obvious, Burnham exhibited the same tendencies, albeit in a very different way. The contrasting story lines, with the two men juxtaposed against one another, suggest that in one way at least they are merely two sides of the same coin. The city is an extreme place that engenders many energies, and which rewards men who exhibit the same qualities. Both Burnham and Holmes were, at least for a while, very successful within their chosen activities. But these activities were more than just a way of passing the time, they were a raison d’etre to each man. What these two men did, on the cusp of the Twentieth Century, becomes symbolic of a whole time, both presently and what was about to come. Larson expresses it best himself: What better metaphor for the forces that would shape the Twentieth Century into a time of monumental technical achievement and unfathomable evil?5 It would be frankly difficult to think of a better one. So while the stories of Burnham and Holmes belong to a particular place and time: Chicago in 1893, and may thus be regarded as specific representatives of that Gilded Age, they are also representative of much more. They are representative of what Nietzsche would call “the will to power”, something which brought great good and yet monstrous evil to the world in the next century. ____________________________________________________ Works Cited Darwin, Charles. The Origin of Species. Signet, New York: 2003. Freud, Sigmund. The Basic Writings of Sigmund Freud. Modern Library, New York: 1995. Larson, Erik. The Devil in the White City. Vintage, New York: 2004. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Devil in the White City Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1183 words, n.d.)
The Devil in the White City Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1183 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1536748-the-devil-in-the-white-city
(The Devil in the White City Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1183 Words)
The Devil in the White City Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1183 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1536748-the-devil-in-the-white-city.
“The Devil in the White City Book Report/Review Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1183 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1536748-the-devil-in-the-white-city.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Devil in the White City

Jacque-Louis David Compared to Sandow Birk

?New York: Phaidon; Distributed by Garden city, 1952.... ?New York: Phaidon; Distributed by Garden city, 1952.... Jaques-Louis David and Sandow Birk appear, at first blush, to be nearly as unrelated as it is possible for artists to be.... Jaques-Louis David was a French painter who was active from the end of the eighteenth to the first quarter of the nineteenth centuries (Louis-Antoine), while Sandow Birk is an American artist who has been active only in the twenty-first century (Birk)....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

3 Major Events that Led to the 1963 March on Washington

The law required the African American to yield their seats to the white men if there was no vacant seat available for the white men.... Montgomery's Women Political council was an organization which was founded to work against segregation on the city buses before they started the boycott.... The Supreme court in the United States of America said that, segregation of the black and white children had detrimental effects especially on the children....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Satan and Dr. Faustus, overreachers in their own different ways

It is seen that Faustus makes a decision of selling his soul to the devil in exchange for knowledge and earthly power as well as 24 years as an additional life (Sachs and Ariel, 31).... He is the devil who appears at the summoning of Faustus', as well as the devil that has the role of serving Faustus for a period of 24 years.... Their characters as well reflect the belief of Christian that humans have been assigned guardian angels, and in this context, the devil has the capacity of influencing the human thoughts....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Devil in the White City

The book (devil in the white city) is about two men namely Daniel Burnham and Henry Holmes and describes the American history of 1893; Daniel Burnham was an architect of the white city and Henry Holmes was a serial killer, this book talks about American history in the gilded age both the good and the worst moments. … Burnham built the white city by bringing together other architects such as Richard Hunt, George Post and Charles mc Kim.... Burnham overcame various obstacles and convinced them on the importance of the fair, Henry on the other hand set up his own world's fair hotel; Holmes took advantage of young women arriving in Chicago from other towns by luring them to his hotel and committing a series of murders. Larson tries to combine the story of the 1893 Columbia exposition with a tale of an urban serial killer; he contrasts the white city which was painted white all over with the Holmes world's fair hotel which was dark which portrays good and bad....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

New Urbanism

That is the central thesis of New Urbanism, which is at its heart an attempt to move back to the city planning of an earlier time.... New Urban ideas run through the essays of Kunstler, Davis and Ryan, but despite this the three essays are… Kunstler argues that the problem is one of zoning, and that Americas real problem is consumerism replacing the traditional American dream....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

War on the Silver Screen: (Your Phrase) in Film Title (s)

Inspired by the novel survival, it is set in an impoverished farming village in North Hebei Province in Northern China near the high wall during… This area was under Japanese occupation since year 1930's, due to a long period of being ruled the villagers in the area had adapted to tolerate the occupying devils who demanded tax inform of percentage The film traces the growing and ironic amity between Chinese villagers and two prisoners of war who by luck were deposited into their care....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The City of Brass

Tarmazin Compare and Contrast Essay - The of Brass When considering the story line on both articles, the articles are explaining a similar issue, which comprise occurrences in the city of Brass.... This is because the author of the former article talks about events that are currently taking place such as awakening of the city while the latter mostly concentrates on telling the events as a story from a perspective of the past.... Here, the newer one appears to have been explaining the fate of the city while the older one explains the earliest days of the city....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

The Conditions Prior to the Storm

According to Garrow, the average income of African Americans in Birmingham was less than half of the white salary-earners; a fact that could be observed at the local steel mills (1989, p.... Such cultural or ideological concept was further strengthened with the formulation and implementation of certain ordinances in the city.... Two particular ordinances that highlight segregationist policies are Section 369 and Section 597 of the city ordinances (Birmingham's Racial Segregation Ordinances, May 1951)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us