We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Nobody downloaded yet

Sens Explanation of the Great Bengal Famine - Book Report/Review Example

Comments (0)
Summary
Several authors have contested Sen's claim that some of the major famines he has examined were of non-FAD origin. The argument has raged mostly over the great Bengal famine of 1943 and the African famines of the 1970s. Who has had the better of the argument, though an important issue in its own right is not something we shall be concerned with in this paper What concerns us here is the claim of several of these critics that, by refuting Sen's empirical analysis, they have discredited the entitlement approach.
Download full paper
GRAB THE BEST PAPER
Sens Explanation of the Great Bengal Famine
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
Sens Explanation of the Great Bengal Famine

Download file to see previous pages... Although his empirical arguments relate to this particular famine, he goes on to draw a general analytical conclusion, which is our main concern here. He argues that ' Sen's theory of famine will lead to the wrong diagnosis and the wrong remedies for famine and will therefore worsen the situation'. (Eric Markusen, David Kopf, 1995).
This conclusion has two parts. There is first the claim that it was no accident that Sen misdiagnosed the Bengal famine, because his theory was such that it could not but lead to the wrong diagnosis. Secondly, such misdiagnosis will worsen the situation further by suggesting the wrong remedies. We shall see that both of these analytical conclusions are false, even if one grants for the sake of argument that Sen did actually misdiagnose the Bengal famine.
The first part of the claim, asserting the inevitability of misdiagnosis, is based on two premisses. The first premiss holds that 'one cannot discuss famines without constantly taking into account aggregate food supply', the implication being that reduction in food supply necessarily plays a part in all famines. Bowbrick, however, simply asserts this proposition, because he nowhere establishes the necessity of food shortage as a precondition of famine. He does however make a case for its sufficiency, in the following manner. He defines three different degrees of food shortage: the first-degree shortage is defined as the situation in which, despite food shortage, widespread starvation can be avoided by redistributing food in the appropriate way, but the second- and third-degree shortages are such that not even a perfect distribution can avoid famine. Thus, famines will inevitably occur in the event of second- and third-degree shortages, and may very well occur even in the case of first-degree shortage owing to practical constraints on redistribution, especially if the population is already living close to the level of bare subsistence. It therefore follows that food shortage of whatever degree will often be sufficient to spark off a famine in a barely subsisting economy.
The second premiss lies in Bowbrick's interpretation of Sen's theory as a specific hypothesis that stands in opposition to the FAD hypothesis. He suggests that the entitlement theory proposes a 'redistribution hypothesis', according to which famines are caused simply by redistribution of command over food (away from the poor and the vulnerable), unaccompanied by any reduction in aggregate food availability. (Jean Dreze, Amartya Sen, 1990).
He then goes on to argue that an approach that explains famines in purely distributional terms will inevitably misdiagnose cases involving second- and third-degree shortage. For, even if these cases are accompanied by adverse redistribution of food, such redistribution in itself cannot be blamed for the famine because even in the absence of any redistribution famine would still have occurred. The situation is slightly different for first-degree shor ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Great work great career
It is mentioned that ‘great career’ has to be defined by the individual himself or herself. The book initiates focusing that great career has to be well-framed in order to have a direction. In broad sense, the book revolves around the set of characteristics that are not bound to be external but internal importantly; to have a clear idea about what a great career means to oneself; to accept that great career can be achieved by anyone as it is more related to perceptual acceptance and achievement than belonging to certain powerful professions.
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review
Scott Fitzgerald's Great Gatsby
We learn about various characters through his perceptions. Nick being very honest has described the characters in an unbiased way and has put them forth as they are. He has done justice to Gatsby by making him a hero and by calling him 'The Great Gatsby'.
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review
Charles Dickens Great Expectations
Between Arthur Conan Doyle's stories of Sherlock Holmes pursing criminals through the back alleys of London and Dickens' stories of poor orphans struggling to survive, the image of Victorian England that is perhaps forever burned into the public consciousness is one of filth and unfairness.
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review
Sen's Explanation of the Great Bengal Famine
Born just north of Calcutta in 1933, on the campus of a university founded by poet Rabindranath Tagore, Sen went to study at Trinity College, Cambridge, in 1953, returning a little more than a decade later to teach at the Delhi School of Economics. His serious scholarly attention in those days was given to social choice, the abstruse, mathematically oriented field opened up by RAND Corporation economist Kenneth Arrow in a 1951 essay showing how hard it could be for democratic mechanisms to reflect a majority's true preferences.
14 Pages(3500 words)Book Report/Review
The Great Gasby
The Great Gatsby is a very popular novel, and today nearly all critics agree that it is a great one. But what makes it great What does the greatness of Gatsby and Fitzgerald's novel consist of Probably no one is able to give a complete answer to that question.
5 Pages(1250 words)Book Report/Review
Great Expectations
Pip's journey is thus a highly 'individual' journey, and is in certain way a tale of alienation. It is a journey where he Pip goes through a diverse range of experiences that continually challenge his understanding of class, family and individuals at large to finally come to a better understanding of himself.
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review
The Nightrunners of Bengal
The unrest between the Indian and British began as a result of the disobedience of Indian religious rights by their British Officers. The Nightrunners of Bengal reads like a fiction, the story revolves mostly around the revolt of 1857. Rodney Savage is the main character of the novel; he is an army officer who lives with his wife and son in the cantonments, Savage is represented as an officer who is deeply involved and committed to his British troops and its Indian soldiers, as a result he fails to recognize the up- rising and pays a deaf ear to all the conspiracies against the British rule.
3 Pages(750 words)Book Report/Review
The Great Influenza
The essay "The Great Influenza" gives a referential record of the magnitude of a disease that spreads the storm of death on the surface of the land it passed. Science, politics and the pestilence are enveloped with the background of a great war.
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review
The great deformatin
the assumption of monetarism and Keynesians too, showing how both neo conservative and liberal interface in the market has ascertained dangerous and damaging. Stockman reveals how America recently has faced fiscal cliffs and financial crisis. It counters conservative
2 Pages(500 words)Book Report/Review
The great deformatin
FDR together with brain trust did not understand that the United States had purged into a depression due to the collapse of its export markets. US had to take immediate action to save its foreign customers but its potentials to do so
2 Pages(500 words)Book Report/Review
Let us find you another Book Report/Review on topic Sens Explanation of the Great Bengal Famine for FREE!
Contact us:
+16312120006
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us