'Stalin blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Cold War Instructor Name Joseph Stalin has been, without doubt, one of the most impactful influences in the shaping of power relations in the contemporary world politics. A centrally crucial figure to the cold war, his personality and its impact on his politics is magnetic for historians, drawing them into a debate that has been raging for decades – was the enigmatic Stalin directly responsible for the Cold War or was he a victim of the sociopolitical context of the time…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
Stalin blundered into the Cold War. Discuss
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"'Stalin blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss"

Download file to see previous pages Indeed, there are facets of the Cold War debate over which many of the contemporary scholars are in agreement, particularly with reference to Stalin’s paranoid personality. The focus of this study, however, is a matter of contention amongst eminent Cold War historians. Whether Stalin blundered into the Cold War out of a confusion and misjudgment of his adversaries’ intentions that derived from his suspicious personality, or whether the reality of an aggressive US foreign policy nurtured Stalin’s existing paranoia, thus forcing him into an unavoidable conflict will be one of the central themes of discussion. Taking into account and critiquing the work of prominent Cold War historians, this essay will serve to evaluate the origins of the Cold War with particular reference to Stalin. The study aims to demonstrate that Stalin greatly overestimated the US desire for war, and blundered into the Cold War as a result of his paranoia and obsession with personal and domestic security. Looking at the Cold War through the lens of Gaddis, Matsny, Zubok and Pleshakov, a conclusion can be drawn towards how the Cold War originated from miscalculation and lack of judgment on part of Stalin. John Lewis Gaddis is one of the most influential post revisionist historians of the Cold War. In his book titled We Now Know, he clearly does not see Stalin as blundering into the Cold War. In fact, he is seen as a conscious initiator of the events that led to it, while the US is represented as merely reacting to the threatening desire Stalin held for world domination. Influenced by “Marxist Internationalism” and “Czarist Imperialism”1, Stalin had a personality that was conducive to paranoia and insecurity. It is this fusion of ideologies, coupled with an insecure personality that led to the Cold War. Gaddis therefore, sees Stalin’s ideology as a key figure in the Cold War. In its essence, Gaddis sees the Cold War as an ideological war between America and the Soviet Union, where American pluralist democracy and capitalism is argued as inherently superior to Soviet communism, and is the cure to the threat of a communist world. American historian Vojtech Matsny offers a distinct insight into the Cold War, and addresses one of the integral issues that Gaddis conveniently overlooks. In The Cold War and Soviet Insecurity, Matsny revolves around the figure and personality of Stalin, and his preoccupation with maintaining his autocratic rule. Stalin’s imperialistic approach towards rule deflects through his paranoia and insecurity that eventually led him into the Cold War. Aware of the lack of popular support his regime had, Stalin intelligently chose to cash in on the 2fundamental Bolshevik belief that “the outside world remained implacably hostile”. Carefully carving out a sense of “us” and “them” through help of the revolutionary communist ideology, Stalin’s prime objective was to preserving his regime and maintaining power within the Soviet Union rather than world domination. As Matsny argues, Stalin did not deliberately wish for a Cold War, but considering his Soviet ideology and insecure imperialism, could not avoid it. For Matsny therefore, “ ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“'Stalin blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1466134-ychstalin-blundered-into-the-cold-waryie-discuss
('Stalin Blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss Essay)
“'Stalin Blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1466134-ychstalin-blundered-into-the-cold-waryie-discuss.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
Cold war
...and diplomatic pressures. This was the period when the Soviet Union faced economic stagnation. According to researchers, the cold war was the first-ever war between the social and economic systems (Tyull & Enright, 2011). In this period, the prime minister of Britain, Winston Churchill felt that the Soviet leader; Joseph Stalin was quite untrustworthy. Stalin was viewed as distrustful after Truman informed him of a new weapon that he was to use against the Japanese. In addition, Stalin knew about the weapon’s power after reports of Hiroshima went back to Moscow. He also asserted that World War II was an inevitable case...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Cold war
...Cold War Several aspects of the American society had been impacted by the ‘Cold War’ for most part of the second half of the 20th century. As the ‘Cold War’ emerged out of the opposing values fought mostly through propaganda and secret tactics, the global battle for supremacy shifts the balance of power between the United States and democratic countries on one hand, and the Soviet Union and the allied communist nations on the other. This event provided stimulus for continuously sustaining and expanding the U.S. military capability after the end of WWII and to a higher end, remedied the ‘great depression’ by converging to resolve with...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Cold War
...and political tensions (Arne, 2007). In the 1980s, the Western bloc increased their military, economic and diplomatic pressures, a time when the Soviet Union faced economic stagnation. The cold war was the first-ever war between the social and economic systems (Bahm, Enright, and van Tuyll, 2011). In this period, Britain’s Prime Minister, Winston Churchill, felt that the Soviet leader; Joseph Stalin was untrustworthy. Stalin got viewed as distrustful after Truman informed him of a new weapon that he was to use against the Japanese. In addition, Stalin knew about the weapon’s power after reports of Hiroshima went back to Moscow. He also...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
Cold War
...Prof’s The Cold War had many causes, but the fundamental causes were the fact that the United s and the Soviet Unions were by far the two most powerful countries in the world during the Cold War years (Chafe 2009: 117), and the fact that the two believed each other’s existence to be anathema to the other: that either capitalism or communism would need to be a new world order. The United State’s strategy during the Cold War shifted slightly, but also remained surprisingly constant. One of the pillars of this strategy was not ever involving the United States in direct confrontation with the Soviet Union: there was a very real fear that any...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Cold war
...?After the Second World War, the unification between America Britain and the USSR came to an end world was replaced by a bitter rivalry between the two countries that came to be the major world powers for the duration of the cold war and these were America and the USSR. Essentially, the notion of the cold war is enigmatic since the major counties in the center of it never actually took up arms against each other in “hot wars”. American and The USSR were embroiled in an ideological contention; American was democratic and capitalistic, whereas Russia was a communist country, this meant that it was led by a single dictator who exercised control all the economic aspects therein. Each tried to spread their ideologies to many countries... America...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
Cold War
...recovered from the recession, the increased military expenditure in the following years was the reflection of Kennedy’s policy to deter any possible offensive role of the Soviet Union. The dissidents of the United States’ cold-war policy complain that the US policy of containment was, indeed, the trigger of the Cold War. They believed that in the name of democracy Truman was essentially a war-monger. If he really believed in the democratic values, he would endeavor to bring the soviet leaders back the roundtable discussion. Instead, he inflicted the war in the name of supporting democracy. In a ‘Speech on the Truman...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Cold War
...? Cold War COLD WAR Beginning in 1947 and lasting until 1991, the Cold War can be defined as the sustained of military, as well as political, tensions that existed between western hemisphere countries and their NATO allies and the Eastern hemisphere that was dominated by countries in the Warsaw Pact dominated by the USSR1. Following the success of the wartime alliance formed temporarily against Hitler’s Nazi Germany, the only two superpowers in global affairs were the United States and the Soviet Union. However, these two countries had profound differences in their political and economic ideologies, and this led to the beginning of the Cold War. The Second World War had a profound effect on global politics, with the early efforts... of...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper
Cold War
...The Cold War came up because of the competition on a global scale of the world’s two superpowers, the United s and the Soviet Union. There was a great fear in the United States of the Soviet Union’s ambition to spread the ideology of communism, which it followed, worldwide and this was not acceptable to the American government. In response, the American government chose to shore up those regimes, which were allied to it all over the world not only financially but also militarily to ensure that they combated the potential communist forces and parties which were to come up against them (Mueller 172). Moreover, the Soviet Union was very fearful of the American acquisition of atomic weapons, this led to its...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Cold war
...Causes and consequences of cold war Cold war was a silent war between the US and the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union wanted to spread communism in the Eastern Europe and the US saw that this spread from Soviet Union was most likely to spread and very quickly to Eastern Europe, Asia and even Africa in a domino effect and it therefore tried to contain it using different strategies and policies. Soviet Union was on the other hand afraid of US and what it could do and hence put in place its own strategies to prevent US affecting its communism spread plan. This distrust and suspicion was the basis of cold war and it led to...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Cold War
...Cold War was a unique phenomenon of post WW2 international relations when the two nations, especially the two superpowers: USA; and USSR had developed hostile relations defined by sharp conflicts within political diplomacy and Economic areas. According to Murrin et al. (2011) cold war was not only confined to international relations but it had encompassed myriad aspects of domestic and international conditions which had huge impact on the people at large. He affirms that in international relations, Cold War affects social conditions at the national and local level and may also remain in background and serve as catalyst that may adversely...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic 'Stalin blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss for FREE!
logo footer
Contact us:
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • StudentShare App Store
  • StudentShare Google play
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • Miscellaneous
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us